The Two Tongues Podcast
S1E60 · Oct 6, 2021 · 161 min
YouTube: Coming soon
In this episode Chris finally takes on the 300 pound gorilla in the Philosophical room–Postmodernism. Will it be an epic showdown? Will the forces of good defeat the Postmodernist boogieman? Or will our hero be persuaded to the dark side? Chris vs. Foucault…round one…fight.
Enjoy 🙂
Machine-generated transcript; names and terms may contain errors.
0:00:03 Welcome, everyone, to the Two Tungs Podcast.
0:00:09 Consider this your invitation to join Kyle and Chris
0:00:13 on a journey through our minds,
0:00:16 where we explore the questions that have fascinated us
0:00:22 for as long as we can remember.
0:00:24 Could anarchy actually work? Does God exist?
0:00:28 And just how did the cosmos get here anyway?
0:00:32 Let me be the Virgil to your Dante, the Sacagawea to your Lewis and Clark.
0:00:39 Let's take the guided tour through the dark chambers of our unconscious,
0:00:44 seeking answers to the most important and unsettled questions of our shared existence.
0:00:52 Ready or not, here we go.
0:00:55 Here we go.
0:01:01 What's up?
0:01:02 What's up, Tutang's World?
0:01:04 Chris coming at you again with another solo episode today.
0:01:09 I'm taking the day I've worked today so I'm going to spend a little bit of time recording.
0:01:14 I'm glad I am off because this is a this is a doozy. This one is a doozy I think. So today
0:01:24 today we're going to do the first of a three-part series on postmodernism. Why? Because I don't
0:01:31 understand it because it keeps coming up and I don't understand it. So I'm doing the hard thing,
0:01:37 which is something that I continue to suggest that's good for all of us, do the hard thing.
0:01:45 So I'm getting into it. I am getting into it. A couple of things. So we talked about post-modernism
0:01:53 before it's type of a kind of a well a modern form of philosophy that started in the oh boy
0:02:03 probably like the 40s but mostly it was at its height in the 60s and 70s and a lot of the philosophers
0:02:10 that come up when we talk about post-modernism are French. Pretty much all of them French.
0:02:17 A bunch of French philosophers writing in the 60s and 70s, I don't have to tell you guys
0:02:23 what the world was like in the 60s and 70s.
0:02:27 It was obviously a really important transitionary period in American history.
0:02:33 That's the birth of the psychedelic revolution, rock and roll, all the best cars that were
0:02:40 built there in the 60s and 70s.
0:02:41 This was an interesting time, interesting politically, interesting socially.
0:02:46 And postmodernism came out of this time, so when we talked about it before, it came up
0:02:52 in the context of Jordan Peterson being, well, against it, for lack of a better word, against
0:03:00 it.
0:03:03 So just to refresh your memory, what Jordan would say about postmodernism is that it's
0:03:07 tied to communism really closely.
0:03:12 And it supposes a view of the world
0:03:17 that's all about power and power struggles.
0:03:20 And the power struggles are being carried out
0:03:23 between groups of people rather than between individuals.
0:03:27 And so the kind of overarching narrative
0:03:29 that Jordan takes such a critique of
0:03:33 is the idea that this philosophy asks you
0:03:36 to see everything that happens in the world
0:03:38 as groups struggles, as a dynamic of power
0:03:43 between multiple groups.
0:03:46 And that is the driving force and the answer
0:03:50 to all of life's questions.
0:03:52 It's like everything somehow becomes political,
0:03:55 everything somehow becomes focused on the group
0:04:00 and the individual gets lost in the mix.
0:04:03 So that was a big sticking point for Jordan.
0:04:05 It's like, look, we all know what happens
0:04:08 When we get into a crowd, Kyle and I talked about this thought experiment, I don't know
0:04:14 that it's ever happened, but it probably has, that you could be, let's say, at a concert
0:04:19 venue with thousands and thousands of people.
0:04:24 Somebody can see somebody, let's say, slip and fall and fall into a pond or a lake or
0:04:29 something, and they're drowning.
0:04:31 Because you've got 1,000 or thousands of people standing around watching, there's this
0:04:37 thing that happens with responsibility where people just kind of think, oh, somebody will
0:04:42 help. And so you just sort of pass the responsibility psychologically from yourself, even though
0:04:46 you feel like you should do something, because you know somebody else is going to do it.
0:04:50 But everybody thinks that way. So nobody helps the drowning person and they just drown
0:04:54 and die. While everybody stands around looking at them, waiting for someone to do something.
0:04:58 So this is an example of when we act as a group, unusual things happen, things that
0:05:05 we wouldn't want to happen.
0:05:07 It's like, nobody's driving the car exactly.
0:05:10 The car's driving, but nobody's in charge of it.
0:05:13 Like, this is what happens when we think as a group.
0:05:19 This is the kind of risk we run.
0:05:20 I'm not saying that that always happens,
0:05:22 but this is the sort of risk we run.
0:05:24 Kyle and I also have brought up an example before
0:05:28 where collectivism seems to have some kind of a value
0:05:30 that's hard to pen down and the example has to do
0:05:33 with a jar full of jelly beans.
0:05:36 And you go around and you ask 1,000 people
0:05:39 to guess how many jelly beans are in the jar.
0:05:42 And everybody has different answers
0:05:43 and they're wildly different.
0:05:44 Some people say a couple hundred,
0:05:45 some people say tens of thousands.
0:05:47 And the thing is, if you go and you ask enough
0:05:50 individual people the average of the guesses,
0:05:54 it gets narrower and narrower honing in
0:05:57 on the actual number of jelly beans.
0:06:00 So I think they asked 100 people in this example
0:06:02 I'm referring to, or maybe something like that.
0:06:05 And they were within a couple, literally, within 10 of the correct number of jelly beans
0:06:10 by the average number of guesses.
0:06:12 So that's amazing.
0:06:14 It's really hard to understand.
0:06:16 It's borderline magical that that happens, but there's the other side of the coin that
0:06:22 as a group, somehow we're more accurate, right, somehow as a group, we're more accurate than
0:06:28 then we are individually, to an eerie degree.
0:06:32 So it's like, you can make an argument
0:06:35 that working together as a group
0:06:39 and subduing the individual,
0:06:41 that that's actually where the important things happen.
0:06:46 History kind of paints that picture.
0:06:48 We pretend like all the most important things
0:06:50 that happen in the world are large scale,
0:06:52 grand, political, and social changes.
0:06:56 And that sort of disregards the fact that those changes
0:06:59 that kind of happen on the large scale,
0:07:02 they started with individuals.
0:07:04 There just was enough individuals doing it
0:07:06 that it became a large scale movement.
0:07:08 So there's definitely arguments on both sides of the coin
0:07:13 about whether a group identity is,
0:07:16 should be paramount, should be the level
0:07:18 that we're concerned about.
0:07:20 But here in America, we have a history.
0:07:23 We have a tradition of honoring the individual,
0:07:26 individual rights, the thinking about the soul is sacred and the individual is sacred.
0:07:32 And so it makes it very difficult to put that aside in favor of a group identity.
0:07:39 And then you can think about all of the things that Jordan will bring up about where a group
0:07:43 identity has gone wrong in the 20th century to the nth degree, where things have gone
0:07:48 wrong so bad that we can't risk ever allowing that to happen again.
0:07:53 Jordan will pin that down on group identity just the same. These are things like you know
0:07:59 what happened in Nazi Germany, what happened in the cultural revolution in communist China,
0:08:03 what happened in the in communist Soviet Union under Stalin let's say.
0:08:09 So this is all about group identity. It's all about hitting groups against one another.
0:08:16 And in those examples you basically have a manipulation going on where the dictator is
0:08:21 sort of pinning its people against one another to sustain his own position and power.
0:08:28 And you can see that sort of thing happening in American politics, maybe that's been going
0:08:33 on for a very long time, but it's certainly going on now.
0:08:36 So here's the argument.
0:08:37 This is where the postmodern argument comes in.
0:08:41 And if we're going to take this part of the postmodern argument as our starting point,
0:08:46 we're basically going to be starting with a guy named Michelle Foucault.
0:08:51 So that was a name that I heard tossed around before.
0:08:56 I just never understood what the postmodernist exactly
0:08:59 believed, that summary that I've provided to you already
0:09:02 is basically the gist of what I had.
0:09:06 Now, when Kyle and I talked about this,
0:09:08 we tried a little bit, but we hadn't really
0:09:10 got into the philosophy, so how far are you going to get?
0:09:13 We didn't get very far.
0:09:14 But we definitely talked about some things
0:09:16 that the postmodernists talk about.
0:09:18 They talk about things like structuralism,
0:09:21 post-structuralism, deconstruction.
0:09:25 These are words that come out of post-modernism.
0:09:28 And we'll talk about them a little bit today.
0:09:32 And so what those concepts boil down to
0:09:39 is the ways in which power,
0:09:42 the ways in which we can see power working in society,
0:09:47 where that power comes from,
0:09:48 who's pulling the strings?
0:09:50 And it gets really muddy and interesting,
0:09:53 especially when we start talking about language.
0:09:55 Because what Foucault was gonna say
0:09:58 is that culture is also a power dynamic.
0:10:01 And it's working on us all the time.
0:10:04 And we don't, it's like invisible to us
0:10:08 because we're born into it.
0:10:09 It's like a foregone conclusion.
0:10:11 We never think about the culture,
0:10:13 but that there are ways in which the culture
0:10:14 is holding certain people down, let's say,
0:10:17 and raising certain people up.
0:10:19 So you can see how when we start talking about that,
0:10:22 that you can see like the seeds of the social justice
0:10:26 movement and things that we're seeing today
0:10:28 that are there ready to come out of this postmodernism.
0:10:32 But the point that Foucault is making
0:10:34 is in a more interesting one.
0:10:35 And this is one, like I said, that Kyle and I talked about
0:10:37 to do with language.
0:10:39 It's like, look, we're sort of born into this language as well.
0:10:43 And this is the only way that we can communicate.
0:10:45 It's the only way we can get the thoughts out
0:10:46 of our unconscious and into the world because we have these restrictions with words and
0:10:53 meaning that we didn't come up with, we inherited it.
0:10:57 It's like there's a lot of things, baggage that comes along with language that we're
0:11:02 sort of, it's sort of invisible to us and that there are things that come about and
0:11:09 how we communicate with each other and the meaning that we kind of mutually agree on
0:11:14 that's influenced by the limitations of language
0:11:19 and the assumptions in language.
0:11:22 So it's like, this is something that Kyle and I talk about
0:11:26 when we're talking about Jordan Peterson
0:11:28 and lots of other things that I actually sort of agree with.
0:11:31 And it has to do with, when I come up with a word
0:11:34 and I'm trying to convince you, let's say,
0:11:38 that that word reflects something in the world,
0:11:41 like a table or a dog or something.
0:11:43 I have the first person to come up with this word and I want you to believe that it's referencing
0:11:47 this thing out there in reality.
0:11:50 And what I don't take into consideration when I do that is the fact that this other conscious
0:11:55 creature who's looking at this reference, this object, a table or a dog, let's say,
0:12:00 that their perception is not the same as mine, that their history is not the same as mine,
0:12:04 the connotations that they have to a dog are not the same as mine.
0:12:08 So arbitrarily using this word dog that we both sort of agree means this thing.
0:12:15 It actually doesn't mean the same thing to me as it does to him or her.
0:12:19 So we're assuming that we're communicating, that we're on the same page using these symbols
0:12:24 for language.
0:12:25 But maybe we're not, maybe we're full in ourselves that that's what we're doing.
0:12:29 And maybe we're living in some sort of fake illusory type of world that way in ways that
0:12:36 we don't understand.
0:12:37 And I think that's interesting, I think there might be something to that because it's connected
0:12:42 to this idea that Kyle and I talk about sometimes, that we don't know anything beyond our subjective
0:12:48 experience of the world.
0:12:50 We don't know anything beyond our perceptions.
0:12:52 So when we look out at the world, we see the things we see, we have no choice but to believe
0:12:56 that that's what they are, or pretty close to what they are.
0:13:01 But we have no way of knowing really how much of an illusion our perceptions are, and if
0:13:06 when we look out at the world, what we're seeing is really nothing at all like what's
0:13:09 really there. And this is the idea about objective reality. We have no idea what that
0:13:14 is. We only ever experience it through our subjective experience. We only ever experience
0:13:19 it through our, you know, through our senses and that they're not perfect. So there's
0:13:26 a mystery there. And this seems to be what Foucault's pointing out. It's like, look,
0:13:30 I can use a word, but does it really describe the thing behind the word? If that thing is
0:13:35 objective reality, and you want to put a wrench in the cogs just a little bit deeper, going
0:13:42 down the mystic route that I like to go down.
0:13:45 You can say that what's behind every perception is the sort of the supreme mystery.
0:13:50 What's behind every perception, whether it's a dog or a table or the cosmos, doesn't matter.
0:13:56 What's behind every one of those things is the same thing.
0:14:00 It's the Terminator 2 liquid metal substance that I keep referring to in metaphor.
0:14:04 pure potentiality and it's the same thing. It's the potential to become anything. It's
0:14:10 the substance of God, whatever that is. And behind every perception is that. Well, if
0:14:15 that's the case, then every word I come up with is false. Every perception I have is
0:14:21 false, right? So, when Jordan's talking about our perceptions being false and shining some
0:14:28 light on the mystery of matter and the mystery of existence, I think Foucault is doing the
0:14:34 same thing when he's examining language. He's shining a light on the same thing. This weird,
0:14:43 hard to define, you know, substance behind our ideas, our notions, our words, that might actually
0:14:52 be some mystery like that, like I was just describing, some Terminator 2 substance, like behind every
0:14:57 idea or every concept is God somehow. It's potential somehow. Like a word has the potential
0:15:04 to have a meaning. And if we agree that it does, but in reality that word is meaningless,
0:15:10 or perhaps it means everything, because what it references is some mystery behind our perceptions
0:15:15 that's infinite. Something like that. So I really do think that Foucault and Jordan
0:15:23 are talking kind of on the same on the same along the same lines here, which is interesting.
0:15:30 Okay, so let's put that mine along the side for a second. I want to talk a little bit about
0:15:35 Foucault now that we've got there. So Foucault was born in 1926. That was a really nice time in
0:15:46 kind of the Western world right before it was the calm before the storm though. So the
0:15:50 Roaring 20s you guys may remember. That's what we call them
0:15:53 1929 comes the stock market collapse everything sort of changes so Foucault was born in the prosperity that just dramatic
0:16:00 prosperity right before the stock market crash of 29
0:16:04 He dies in 1984
0:16:07 so
0:16:09 See you kind of get the picture of what this guy lived through
0:16:12 Kind of a lot kind of a lot, you know the Second World War the Great Depression
0:16:17 And in all of the political change that happened in the 60s and 70s, really all the way up
0:16:23 to the modern era in the 80s, he's known as a political activist and a literary critic.
0:16:29 So let me just pause there for a second.
0:16:33 So with Michelle Foucault, we have a philosopher.
0:16:36 You guys know what I mean, the same kind of people we were talking about when we were
0:16:39 talking about play vote and Descartes and Heidegger and all these other people.
0:16:46 Foucault is going to consider himself one of these intellectuals that falls into this
0:16:50 tradition of people that are enlightening, are adding to this process of enlightening
0:16:56 the human race, the philosophers, the lovers of wisdom.
0:16:59 That's what philosophy means.
0:17:01 Fia Sophia, the love of wisdom.
0:17:03 That's who Foucault is supposed to be.
0:17:05 But he's remembered as a political activist and a literary critic.
0:17:11 That's interesting.
0:17:13 So when ever in human history have you had a philosopher, one of these deep thinkers
0:17:18 that's trying to bring truth to human experience, when have you ever known one of those people
0:17:27 to be remembered not for the ideas that he brought to the table, but for his influence
0:17:32 politically, his influence politically, you know?
0:17:38 There's all sorts of philosophers that were political philosophers, but we don't have
0:17:42 go down that road necessarily. But would you consider Foucault one of them? It's hard to answer
0:17:48 that question. He's also a literary critic and this is important because what the hell does that
0:17:53 mean? All right, so we're dealing with something right now in the United States critical race
0:17:58 theory. This is something that is coming up in the dialogue. We're seeing a lot of resistance to
0:18:03 that being introduced into schools. I happen to agree wholeheartedly with the resistance to the
0:18:08 idea, but this is where it goes back to. A literary critic is somebody who reads important
0:18:17 works of literature, important contributions to the culture, great books like Moby Dick
0:18:24 and Jane Eyre and Animal Farm and great books. They read those things and they pick them
0:18:32 apart and they point out where the there were assumptions that were wrong where
0:18:39 there were you know where there were misunderstandings that took us down the
0:18:46 wrong path they pick apart these great works for for many reasons first of all
0:18:53 it's to point out ways in which our culture was influenced that were wrong
0:18:58 that was an error it's like we have to go back to these great works that
0:19:01 influenced our culture and point out where we went wrong. So you've got these people in
0:19:05 retrospect with 2020 hindsight glasses going back into these great works of art and criticizing them.
0:19:14 And there's all sorts of reasons why they think this is a good idea and I'm trying to paint that
0:19:19 picture for you. It's like if we can find out where the culture is going wrong and why,
0:19:23 why were we influenced to believe this way? Where did this idea come from?
0:19:27 You know, the way that we get to the bottom of that, or one one way which we can, is by
0:19:33 critiquing them.
0:19:35 So we critique the Bible, so we critique Homer, so we critique, you know, the Western tradition,
0:19:40 so we critique our own language, we can critique all of that and try to figure out where all
0:19:45 the problems are there, that we can fix, that we can identify to get us on the right track
0:19:51 to help us moving in the right direction.
0:19:53 And what's interesting about that is you have to have an idea of what the right direction
0:19:57 direction is to do that kind of criticism, right? It's not blind. It's not objective
0:20:02 at all. You have to have an agenda to do that. You're going to go back into the Bible. You're
0:20:07 going to go back into these great works of culture, let's say. You're going to critique
0:20:11 them. How are you going to do that? You're going to do that from the cultural context
0:20:15 in which those books came. Are you going to go back to the time which they were written
0:20:19 and put yourself in the head in the cultural space of the people that lived there? No.
0:20:24 pretty goddamn impossible. But they're going to do that anyway. They're going to do that
0:20:28 in this forward thinking way, in this arrogant way. And I think this is where Jordan Peterson's
0:20:33 criticism comes in. You have to have something to critique. So what are you going in? What
0:20:40 are you going into, you know, the Iliad or the Odyssey looking to critique? And this
0:20:45 is what we see with critical race theory today. We're going in there and looking for racism,
0:20:51 wherever they can find it, to point it out,
0:20:54 and to swag its finger at the culture.
0:20:58 You know, it's the kind of thing I'm talking about.
0:21:02 So Foucault's a philosopher,
0:21:03 but a political activist and a literary critic.
0:21:06 And this is where he's focusing his great mental ability.
0:21:10 This is where he's focusing his interest
0:21:14 in contributing to the culture.
0:21:16 His interest is to make a political difference
0:21:19 and to tear apart the culture to find those components
0:21:25 of it that are wrong, that need to be fixed,
0:21:27 or those new opportunities that, let's say,
0:21:29 were hidden from us by, you know, by tradition,
0:21:33 something like that.
0:21:35 Shake things up, break walls down,
0:21:37 find ways of releasing potential,
0:21:40 find ways of opening doors and windows,
0:21:42 you know, find ways of creating something new,
0:21:46 where we were only finding brick walls and closed doors.
0:21:50 Something like that.
0:21:51 It's kind of like an inspiring philosophy.
0:21:56 There's a way of looking at postmodernism
0:21:58 that's like that.
0:21:59 And that's where so much of the appeal comes from.
0:22:03 And it's also where so much of the arrogance is.
0:22:07 And you'll see as we start reading it, what I mean.
0:22:12 All right, so there's a little bit here in Wikipedia
0:22:16 that I wanted to bring up because Wikipedia talks
0:22:18 about Foucault, I'll read you the quote.
0:22:21 It says Foucault's theories primarily address
0:22:23 the relationship between power and knowledge
0:22:26 and how they are used to form as a form of social control
0:22:30 through societal institutions.
0:22:33 So that's one way of summing up Foucault's brand
0:22:37 of postmodernism, it's a theory that addresses
0:22:42 addresses the relationship of power and knowledge.
0:22:48 So I know that's all as clear as mud right now, but we'll get there and how that's used
0:22:53 through societal institutions, that's through society at large, through our culture and
0:22:58 our society to control the citizens of the society.
0:23:05 I want to point out that it's not exactly clear.
0:23:10 When we're talking about government, maybe it's different, but when we're talking about
0:23:13 society. It's not exactly clear. Who's pulling the strings? So if society is
0:23:20 structured in a way that it's controlling the people, it's not exactly clear that
0:23:24 there's a dictator, that there's somebody who's the ruler of society. That's making
0:23:29 those decisions. Rather, it seems like it's a collective thing that
0:23:36 developed over a long time. So across all sorts of different people living
0:23:40 dead across all sorts of different cultures over a long stretch of time, that this is how
0:23:44 society developed, and the people pulling the strings aren't some in charge person,
0:23:50 or even any particular group.
0:23:52 It's the dynamics of all of those individual decisions that were made, and all of the individual
0:23:58 interactions with those people over generations.
0:24:02 That seems to be what's pulling the strings, not some power-hungry dictator.
0:24:06 But that's also how Foucault takes it, which I don't agree with.
0:24:12 Another thing that Wikipedia says about Foucault is that he was heavily influenced by Nietzsche.
0:24:18 So I have to point out, so was Jordan Peterson.
0:24:22 So was Carl Jung.
0:24:23 You know, there's so many, so many important thinkers that were influenced by Nietzsche,
0:24:27 where Nietzsche is kind of one of their, one of their most important influences.
0:24:33 You've got someone like Foucault, who is very much sensitive to communism and socialism
0:24:45 and group dynamics, very much sort of in favor of that type of thinking, and you've got somebody
0:24:55 like Jordan Peterson, who could not be any more different, who sees huge risks and concerns
0:25:01 with groupthink and group dynamics, who thinks that take robbing people of their individual
0:25:07 agency is kind of the greatest sin, like we need to be in, we need to be master of ourselves,
0:25:14 right?
0:25:15 You know, that's important to us and throwing us into a group and taking away our group
0:25:19 identity has all sorts of like red flags and danger signs and warning signs flashing off
0:25:24 over Jordan's head, where Foucault is more or less thinking that that that's good, that's nature.
0:25:32 So both men influenced heavily by Nietzsche coming out on very different sides of the spectrum,
0:25:39 and I point that out for the obvious reason. But also because there is, going back to my earlier
0:25:45 point, there is a connection between the way that Foucault talks about language and the way that
0:25:51 that Jordan and Young talk about reality, talk about God, you know, and Jordan's a little
0:25:58 bit more careful with doing that.
0:26:03 So this connection with Nietzsche I think comes from a description that Nietzsche made
0:26:08 and I can't remember what book this was in, but he makes a distinction between the God's
0:26:14 Apollo in ancient Greece, in Dionysus, and a way of being that he calls Apollonian, like
0:26:24 the way that Apollo represented, you could think of that as a way of being, as a way
0:26:32 of life.
0:26:33 And then you could think about Dionysus, that was, if you remember, Dionysus is, we talked
0:26:37 about it many times, but he's the God of the vine, he's the God of drunkenness and partying
0:26:42 and frivolity and chaos, that there's another way of being a human being that's
0:26:47 Dionysian. It's something like that. And so that there's this Apollonian and Dionysian
0:26:53 type of impulses that are going on in a human being all the time that are competing with each other.
0:26:59 And this is easy to explain. You already know what this means. Think about that part of yourself
0:27:04 that's always very rational, very cautious, that likes order, that likes things to be a certain way,
0:27:11 that likes to, you know, be able to rely on certain things, you know, like that the Sun is
0:27:15 going to rise in the morning, that they can rely on their friends and family, that stability and
0:27:19 order are important. There's that part of our psyche. That's, you might say, the higher order part.
0:27:26 That's the human part, maybe. And then you've got the Dionysian part. That's irrational. That's
0:27:33 the animal part of us. That's the part of us that's in tune with our instincts and desires and our
0:27:40 bodies. You know, again, Dionysius was the God of the vine drunkenness. It's the part of our body
0:27:47 that is, you know, that is attuned to the world around us and to our instincts. It's that sort of
0:27:54 thing. The part of you that can take over, you know, when you're lustful or angry, that part of you,
0:27:59 the part of you that subdues your rational part, Dionysus, this is the part that subdues Apollo.
0:28:05 But both of those things are going on at the same time, order and chaos, Apollo and Dionysus.
0:28:12 Both of those things going on in our psyches all the time, and they sort of struggle with
0:28:16 one another.
0:28:18 And you know that because it happens all the time, you know, I've been talking about fasting
0:28:23 and I was describing this to my mom just yesterday in exactly the same way.
0:28:28 She's like, why are you doing these long fasts, like three days with no food, are you going
0:28:31 48 hours in between meals, like on a regular basis, what are you doing that for?
0:28:35 what are you hoping to gain from that?" And I was like, you know, I hadn't really asked
0:28:39 myself that question, but I'm like, you know what, maybe what I'm doing is challenging myself
0:28:45 in a like an exercise of discipline. And what it is, is what it is, is trying to see if my Apollo
0:28:52 can defeat my Dionysus, right? If I'm not eating, what's more primal than that? When you're hungry,
0:28:58 wanting to eat, you know, what's more? What's more pressing than that?
0:29:02 So, there's like this animal part of me that I know is there that's always struggling
0:29:08 against the higher order part of myself that's trying to subdue those animal instincts.
0:29:15 And what I'm doing is putting myself in a situation where I'm starving literally.
0:29:19 My body wants to eat and I look at myself internally and I say, no, no.
0:29:26 I'm not doing that, you know, for any particular reason, I'm not, you know, it's not a psychological
0:29:32 condition, I'm not an anorexic. I'm doing that, you know, in a structured way on purpose,
0:29:38 you know, for that particular reason, so that I can, so that I can pit Apollo against Dionysus
0:29:44 within my own soul and see if I can come out on top. Something like that. And I am serious.
0:29:52 I think it's the same reason why people like Joe Rogan and all those crazy, all those crazy
0:30:00 the athletes that he's got on the podcast,
0:30:03 why they set themselves such difficult challenges.
0:30:06 I think it's something like that.
0:30:08 So we all have this battle going on,
0:30:10 and it is, you could say,
0:30:12 some kind of a power dynamic,
0:30:15 a struggle within our soul
0:30:19 for order over chaos,
0:30:20 or chaos over order all the time.
0:30:24 And it's interesting because Jordan Peterson talks
0:30:26 about that so much in maps of meaning,
0:30:27 chaos and order and the balance and the harmony
0:30:29 and why that's important in all those sorts of ways
0:30:33 I don't have to recap for you now.
0:30:37 So there is a way of seeing that,
0:30:38 that our lives are like that internally,
0:30:40 that there's some sort of a power struggle going on
0:30:42 like that.
0:30:43 Foucault read that from Nietzsche and he was like,
0:30:45 oh yeah, and that resonated with him.
0:30:47 He's like, that's exactly what my life is like.
0:30:50 And when you have that epiphany, that moment of epiphany,
0:30:54 which Foucault had when he was reading Nietzsche,
0:30:56 you,
0:30:58 you, it's hard to explain.
0:31:00 You are impressed with this truth, with this eureka moment,
0:31:06 this truth that comes out of nowhere
0:31:07 and punches you in the face.
0:31:09 But it's like it was always there.
0:31:11 It was always there.
0:31:12 And when you notice it, it's such a powerful feeling
0:31:16 that one of the things you wanna do,
0:31:17 and I have been guilty of this for sure,
0:31:19 one of the things you wanna do
0:31:20 is you wanna extend the power of that truth
0:31:23 as much as you possibly can.
0:31:25 You're like, oh, I have found this hard-earned piece
0:31:28 of knowledge and it makes so much sense, I wonder how far I can take it.
0:31:35 So you push the boundaries of it and to understand that you have this struggle in your own soul
0:31:40 between Apollo and Dionysus, between your rational and your irrational, like impulses,
0:31:46 let's say, when you realize that there's a struggle going on and then maybe you see
0:31:50 that in other ways, like you see that struggling struggle between individuals for one reason
0:31:56 or another, or you experience a war like the Second World War, like Foucault lived through,
0:32:04 and you see the power dynamics between nations.
0:32:07 Or remember Foucault lived through the Depression as well.
0:32:11 Maybe you see the power dynamics of the market, of the free market, and you see the worst possible
0:32:17 outcomes of that.
0:32:19 You start seeing those things that you know from Nietzsche are happening inside you.
0:32:23 start seeing them happen all around in all these dramatic ways. Somebody like Foucault
0:32:28 living through that part of Western history, you know, it's, you can understand why he
0:32:35 would bring this power struggle dynamic. He would impose that on the whole world. He
0:32:39 would see how far he can take it because he saw the truth a bit within himself. It resonated
0:32:44 with him in this powerful way. And he's seeing all this crazy shit happening in the world
0:32:49 that he thinks is also an illustration of the same kind
0:32:53 of conflict that he knows is happening in his own goddamn soul.
0:32:56 And he looks out and he sees it happening in the Second World
0:32:59 War.
0:33:00 I mean, you can understand, to a certain degree,
0:33:03 why Foucault would take this power dynamic idea to the extreme.
0:33:08 But what I want to point out here is
0:33:09 that Foucault sees power dynamics as a struggle,
0:33:12 as a life and death conflict.
0:33:16 So power dynamics are a life and death conflict.
0:33:19 Even this conflict within your soul
0:33:21 that Nietzsche points out between order and chaos.
0:33:24 And even that, one side has to win.
0:33:26 It's life or death.
0:33:27 One side has to win.
0:33:29 This is how Foucault sees it.
0:33:31 And hard to blame him for that.
0:33:33 Somebody had to win the Second World War, right?
0:33:38 Jordan Peterson, on the other hand,
0:33:39 does not see power dynamics as a life and death struggle
0:33:42 where one side has to win.
0:33:44 Jordan Peterson sees power dynamics as a dance, as a harmony and a balance that's struck
0:33:52 between these forces that are competing.
0:33:57 Something comes to my mind, I don't know if anybody shoots, if anybody goes to the range
0:34:01 and shoots or wants to learn how to shoot a pistol or whatever it is, but one of the
0:34:05 things I learned doing that, which is interesting, is when you're holding a pistol and you're
0:34:12 There's all sorts of things you have to be aware of and you have to fight against, including
0:34:17 the most obvious one is preparing for the recoil or preparing for the loud noise that
0:34:23 you know is coming.
0:34:24 So there's something that you're doing where you're almost pulling back.
0:34:28 You're almost expecting the recoil, you're anticipating what's going to happen and it
0:34:35 fucks up your aim.
0:34:37 So one of the things you have to do, or you can do, is you place your other hand against
0:34:44 your dominant hand that's holding the gun, and you pull back a little bit.
0:34:49 You pull your one hand in towards your body.
0:34:52 While at the same time you're trying to hold that gun straight out away from your body.
0:34:56 What happens is you've got these forces now that are competing.
0:34:59 You've got the force of one arm pointing the gun away from your body, the force of the
0:35:02 other hand, pulling the gun back towards your body ever so slightly, it doesn't take much.
0:35:07 And what happens is, for some reason, the balance of those two forces keeps your aim
0:35:18 true.
0:35:19 The balance of those forces will allow you to avoid some of those psychological things
0:35:23 that you're doing when you're shooting the gun that are causing you to shoot high and
0:35:29 right, that happens to me, or high and left, something like that.
0:35:33 You put a little bit of competing force there and suddenly your aim is true and this happened
0:35:37 to me.
0:35:38 It was amazing.
0:35:39 So here's the idea that Jordan is bringing up something more like that, like the Yin
0:35:43 and the Yang, the balance of competing forces and something about the harmony between the
0:35:49 forces is creating something significant.
0:35:53 The harmony itself is significant.
0:35:56 It's the thing that's valuable.
0:35:57 It's the thing we want the harmony between chaos and order.
0:36:02 We don't want all chaos.
0:36:03 We don't want all order.
0:36:04 That seems to be what Foucault wants.
0:36:07 And again, hard to blame him.
0:36:08 Hard to blame him when you're living through the Second World War.
0:36:10 Yes, you want one side to be victorious.
0:36:12 Yes, you want an end to this.
0:36:15 But there is no end to existence.
0:36:17 There is no end to being.
0:36:20 And it's not a winner-take-all situation.
0:36:24 It's a harmony.
0:36:25 It's more like a dance between two partners.
0:36:28 All right, so I think that's a good way of introducing postmodernism and Foucault.
0:36:37 And again, the best thing I can do to give you some counterpoints is probably Pepperin
0:36:41 some Jordan Peterson where I can.
0:36:45 So without further ado, let's get into it.
0:36:49 So the first section here I want to call power and knowledge.
0:36:53 So this has to do with going back to what Wiki said that Foucault's theories primarily address
0:36:57 the relationship between power and knowledge. So let's get into Foucault's words about
0:37:03 power and knowledge. Alright, Foucault says, the individual is a product of power. The
0:37:12 individual is a product of power. What does that mean? That means that your personality,
0:37:19 the thing that you call yourself, the thing that you've developed over all your life experiences
0:37:23 and your interactions with the world and with other people, they are individuality.
0:37:29 The thing you hold on to as you, the thing you recognize when somebody says your name,
0:37:36 the individual, that thing, is a product of power.
0:37:41 Do you believe that?
0:37:44 You were created somehow, the thing that you call yourself, that was created as a by-product
0:37:51 of this power struggle between groups, do you think that?
0:37:57 I mean, there's a way in which you can say,
0:37:58 if culture is this power struggle somehow,
0:38:02 in this abstract sort of way, then maybe yes.
0:38:06 So then maybe your individuality is sort of created
0:38:09 somehow through your experience of culture,
0:38:10 but not entirely.
0:38:13 It's not like we're all, I mean,
0:38:15 if that were the case, we kind of all be the same,
0:38:16 or at least much more similar,
0:38:18 We're all just getting spit out of the culture machine
0:38:22 in a uniform sort of way.
0:38:24 And that is what culture tries to do.
0:38:26 But how successful is it?
0:38:27 Do we all come out like cookie cutters?
0:38:29 Are we all exactly the same?
0:38:31 No.
0:38:31 There's something else going on here.
0:38:33 The individual is not strictly the product of power.
0:38:36 It can't be as far as I'm concerned.
0:38:38 But this is what Foucault is gonna lead with.
0:38:40 The individual is the product of power.
0:38:43 That's what made you power.
0:38:45 And it wasn't you that made you exactly.
0:38:47 It was this power struggle going on all around you.
0:38:49 That's what made you.
0:38:51 Is it, how does that, you know,
0:38:52 is that, does that rub you the right way?
0:38:54 You know, kind of,
0:38:55 you can see how your,
0:38:57 how Foucault's postmodernism is taking the power away from you
0:39:01 to even, to even create your own identity.
0:39:05 It's not even you that it's doing that.
0:39:09 Interesting, okay.
0:39:10 Foucault says,
0:39:12 it's my hypothesis that the individual
0:39:14 is not a pre-given entity,
0:39:16 which is seized on by the exercise of power.
0:39:19 The individual is the product of a relation of power,
0:39:22 exercised over bodies, movements, desires, forces.
0:39:28 The individual is a product of a relation of power,
0:39:32 exercised over bodies, movements, desires, forces.
0:39:35 So somehow, we can think about this culturally or socially,
0:39:43 you can see that there are restrictions
0:39:45 to what you can do with your body.
0:39:48 There are restrictions to where you can go.
0:39:50 There are restrictions to what you're allowed to want.
0:39:55 So when he says there's an exercise over desires,
0:39:58 that's kind of true.
0:39:59 Like if you have a desire, let's say as a kid,
0:40:03 to, you know, you want to be greedy,
0:40:05 you want everything for yourself, mine, mine, mine.
0:40:08 We all know that kid.
0:40:09 Can't play with my toy.
0:40:11 It's fucking mine, that kid.
0:40:13 You know, maybe we could all go through a stage like that.
0:40:15 let's say, but that desire is not okay.
0:40:19 The society says it's not okay.
0:40:20 So we limit that desire.
0:40:22 We don't allow a kid to go on saying mine, mine, mine.
0:40:25 And if we do, he kind of gets outcast.
0:40:28 By the time he's adult, nobody wants to be around him anymore.
0:40:30 So you can see there are restrictions
0:40:32 to what things like what we're allowed to want.
0:40:35 And those things don't come from us exactly,
0:40:38 but they do control who we become kind of.
0:40:41 So I'm not gonna be a greedy little dickhead
0:40:43 if the culture kind of beats out of me
0:40:45 the impulse that that's okay, right?
0:40:50 And that's what we do, right?
0:40:52 To a certain degree.
0:40:54 So there's some truth in this.
0:40:57 You can see it, but it's not cut and dry
0:41:00 that a relation of power is the whole story.
0:41:04 But to Foucault, it's the whole story, okay?
0:41:08 So he goes on, he says,
0:41:10 there is no escaping from power.
0:41:12 That is, excuse me, start over.
0:41:14 There is no escaping from power
0:41:16 that it is always already present,
0:41:19 constituting that very thing which one attempts
0:41:21 to counter with it.
0:41:23 So he's saying that this power dynamic is always there.
0:41:27 It's always there.
0:41:28 And he goes on to say,
0:41:30 where there is power, there is resistance.
0:41:34 And that's interesting.
0:41:36 That's interesting for a lot of reasons
0:41:37 because resistance to me seems to come from the individual.
0:41:43 Resistance doesn't come from the group.
0:41:46 Right, the group doesn't exactly make decisions, it's like a herd of animals, you know.
0:41:51 If one of the herd animals in the top of the pack senses danger to the right, he turns
0:41:57 to the left and everybody else follows him.
0:42:00 There's not exactly a decision being made there.
0:42:03 Where resistance happens is in the individual, it's not in the group.
0:42:07 And that's something that Foucault, as we go along, you'll see how he continues to discredit
0:42:14 and push that individuality to the side as much as possible.
0:42:18 But I think that's funny because to Foucault,
0:42:21 there has to be a power dynamic.
0:42:22 It's not like a power rises and it has no resistance to it
0:42:27 and it just takes over.
0:42:28 A power is always being balanced by some other power.
0:42:31 It's always struggling with some other power
0:42:32 so that there is a power and there's a resistance.
0:42:34 And so the picture that's being painted here
0:42:38 is much more like what Jordan Peterson brought up.
0:42:41 It's a dance.
0:42:42 It's a harmony.
0:42:43 a balance. That's what a power dynamic is. And this is what Foucault says when he says where
0:42:50 there is power, there is resistance. That's the power dynamic. It's power and resistance together.
0:42:58 All right, he goes on to say, my main concern will be to locate the forms of power,
0:43:03 the channels it takes, and the discourses it permeates in order to reach the most tenuous
0:43:08 and individual modes of behavior.
0:43:12 So here I have to point out again a little bit of a contradiction in Foucault.
0:43:19 So he's saying what his main concern is going to be, which thank you Foucault for being
0:43:23 plain about what you're doing here because not everyone's not everyone's so honest and
0:43:28 upfront.
0:43:29 He says my concern is going to be to locate forms of power.
0:43:33 channels that that power takes, the ideas that that that power generates and
0:43:38 permeates through the culture, because I want to, I want to identify all of those
0:43:44 areas so that I can make possible the most individual modes of behavior. Let me
0:43:51 say that again. He's going to identify power. He's going to point to it and say
0:43:56 this is, you know, undue influence. This is undue influence. This is undue
0:44:00 influence, these are all things that are making us less
0:44:03 individuals. These are all things that are limiting our
0:44:06 possibilities. I'm going to point them out so that people can
0:44:09 can realize, Oh, I can, I can be what I want to be. I can think
0:44:14 what I want to think. I can go in all these crazy directions. I
0:44:19 that's what he means when he says to bring about it, you know,
0:44:22 individual modes of behavior. So he's making it out like the
0:44:27 goal of postmodernism, the goal of challenging, of making
0:44:34 plain and challenging this power dynamic, the goal of it is
0:44:38 to allow people to be more individuals. This is coming from
0:44:43 the same person who for the rest of this dialogue is going
0:44:46 to talk about the group, the group, the group. So this is
0:44:50 where I think some of the contradiction is from such a
0:44:53 smart man is as Michelle Foucault to not understand that he's talking out both
0:45:00 sides of his mouth. I guess is what I mean. I'm not sure that Foucault ever
0:45:04 reconciled this. At least I didn't see where he did. So if anybody knows, let me
0:45:08 know. Alright, back to Foucault. He says, man, whom we are invited to free is
0:45:16 already in himself, the effect of a subjugation more profound than himself.
0:45:23 So that's just literally not even a complete sentence.
0:45:27 But wow, let me read it again.
0:45:30 Man whom we are invited to free.
0:45:32 So he's talking about here, the goal that he just referenced, the goal of his philosophical
0:45:37 exercise is to free the individual to be an individual and to not be bumping up against
0:45:44 All these phony fake walls that culture and society and power struggles have kind of boxed us into.
0:45:51 He's going to tear down those boxes as best he can so we can we can bloom and flourish and be individuals.
0:45:57 To be free to be weird and strange and taboo, that kind of thing.
0:46:01 To see what new things we can bring about.
0:46:05 Again, a very Peter Sonyan thing to say.
0:46:08 You know it in Jordan Peterson's mind the chaos is is the generative force its potential
0:46:15 Everything anything and everything can come from it and and seemingly our goal to Jordan Peterson
0:46:21 Are the meaning of our life is to see what we can bring from the chaos into reality?
0:46:26 This is exactly what Foucault is saying in a certain way
0:46:30 They're going about it in different ways, but the goals seem to line up a little bit here
0:46:35 And so when Foucault says that man whom we are invited to free, he's talking about again
0:46:40 wanting the individual to be freed from all of these arbitrary rules and barriers.
0:46:49 And he says that that person is already in himself the effect of a subjugation more profound
0:46:56 than himself.
0:46:57 So what does he mean by that?
0:46:58 He's saying that the person who we want to be free, the individual, that he is already
0:47:03 a slave to himself somehow and he calls that a subjugation more profound than
0:47:11 himself. Now I'm gonna keep reading because it'll get clearer. He says a soul
0:47:16 inhabits him and brings him to existence which is itself a factor in the mastery
0:47:22 that power exercises over the body. Oh my god, the soul is the effect and
0:47:29 an instrument of a political anatomy. The soul is the prison of the body. The soul is the prison
0:47:38 of the body. All right, so first of all, very strange here for somebody who's a proclaimed atheist
0:47:47 to talk about the soul, but also strange for him to paint this picture, because this is the mind
0:47:53 body problem. This is something that philosophers Foucault are very familiar with. The idea that we
0:47:57 have a body and that we have a mind or soul and it's to us it seems to be like
0:48:03 something connected to the world our body and something not our soul our
0:48:07 consciousness and we've always struggled to reconcile those two things and the
0:48:11 reality is that's how we are we're made up of this sort of unlikely mix of
0:48:16 spiritual and material and it's hard to understand and so philosophers have been
0:48:21 arguing about this for a long time and this is what Foucault brings up a soul
0:48:25 soul inhabits him and brings him to existence, okay? So you can see a soul inhabiting a body
0:48:32 and making that body alive or something like that, which is itself a factor in the mastery
0:48:38 that power exercises over the body. So now the soul is some form of power that's being
0:48:46 exercised over the body. The soul, if you can imagine your consciousness seems to be in
0:48:50 control of your body, almost like you're a little, like it's only certain people are
0:48:54 going to get this reference. It's almost like you're a mech, right? You're a mech warrior,
0:49:01 and you're driving, you're in that suit, you're sitting in the driver's seat, driving
0:49:05 this giant mech. For those people who don't know, it goes back to the 80s and Japanese
0:49:11 animation cartoons, but the idea is in the future we're going to fight in these giant
0:49:17 robot suits that drivers are like power rangers. You can think of that or a Voltron or something
0:49:24 right? The soldiers are driving these suits. That's what I imagine that that Foucault is describing
0:49:29 when he says that the soul is exercising power over the body. It's like you are the green ranger
0:49:35 driving the freaking dragon zord. The zord is your body and you're the soul. And that's how you
0:49:42 are the master over your body. You understand the point he's making? So there's a power dynamic
0:49:48 between your soul and your body. And that's already within you. Very, very, very similar to
0:49:55 what we were talking about before with Nietzsche, where you have Apollo and Dionysus in your body.
0:50:00 You know, there's that power dynamic all the time. This is how Foucault says it.
0:50:05 A soul inhabits him and brings him to existence, which is itself a factor in the mastery that power
0:50:11 exercises over the body. The soul is the effect and instrument of a political anatomy. The soul
0:50:18 is the prison of the body. What do you think of that? Amazing. I mean, it's an interesting idea,
0:50:26 but what he's saying here is that we are a slave to ourselves and experience a power
0:50:31 struggle within by virtue of our very existence, by virtue of being conscious, that we can't escape
0:50:38 it. We have this power dynamic going on inside of us. I want to point out something else coming
0:50:44 from an atheist. This sounds a lot like the notion of original sin to me. It's just painted up in a
0:50:52 philosophical costume. So if I have a soul and the soul commands the body, and that somehow is this
0:51:00 power struggle between body and soul, then somebody there in Foucault's mind is the good guy,
0:51:06 and somebody is the bad guy. You know, the body is sort of the slave of the soul, and so the body
0:51:12 should be liberated from that control. Again, that reminds me of this Judeo-Christian idea
0:51:23 that I'm born without any power of my own, without any agency of my own. I'm already
0:51:30 tainted by sin. I'm already tainted by this master-slave dynamic where my soul was the
0:51:35 master over my body. My body is a slave to it, right? So I'm born as a Jew or a Christian.
0:51:41 born already tainted by sin. That's what this sounds like to me. Also, he says
0:51:51 something weird here. He says that the soul is a political instrument. What the
0:51:55 heck does that mean? It seems to imply that the soul is wielded by something
0:52:01 towards some end. Like it's a tool. Like Foucault believes our soul or our
0:52:08 consciousness exists strictly for the purposes of manifesting a power struggle
0:52:13 go, between our body and our soul. If we didn't have, we weren't conscious, we wouldn't have
0:52:18 the soul, we'd just be the body, we'd just be an animal. We're running around obeying
0:52:23 our instincts. But because we have consciousness, suddenly we have this power dynamic. Why?
0:52:31 Why does Foucault want to, you know, why does he want to bring this up? He kind of at
0:52:36 the basis of his power struggle to point out that it's happening within us and that it's
0:52:40 unavoidable. Seemingly, because the power struggle is seen as generative somehow.
0:52:47 And what it generates is the purpose of existence. So the power struggle itself, it's what's happening.
0:52:55 It's the actions that are happening. Imagine existence is a theater.
0:53:01 What's happening on stage? What's happening? So we would have all sorts of answers to what's
0:53:07 happening. Foucault says what's happening is a power struggle, a power dynamic. That's
0:53:12 what's happening. Nothing else is happening. It looks like other things are happening,
0:53:18 but behind those perceptions, it's just a power struggle. You see how that's starting
0:53:23 to sound like that Terminator 2 substance behind our perceptions? Objective reality
0:53:28 is a power struggle? That's interesting. It's interesting for an atheist because it's starting
0:53:35 to sound pretty God damn spiritual. Let's keep going. Foucault says, let us say that
0:53:43 we are obliged to produce the truth by the power that demands truth and needs it in order
0:53:49 to function. We are forced to tell the truth. We are constrained. We are condemned to admit
0:53:56 the truth or to discover it. Interesting. So he says, I'm going to read this first bit
0:54:03 Again, he says, we are obliged to produce the truth
0:54:08 by the power that demands truth.
0:54:10 So you can see that what he's describing here
0:54:12 is something like, we don't have a choice in the matter,
0:54:15 but to generate truth.
0:54:17 And we're doing that in response to a power
0:54:19 that demands truth.
0:54:22 It's interesting because we don't really know
0:54:24 what he means by this.
0:54:25 What is the power that demands truth?
0:54:27 What is that?
0:54:28 So where my mind goes here is it's the language that he uses where he says we're obliged to produce the truth.
0:54:40 So that's another way of saying we're forced to tell the truth.
0:54:44 And then he talks about the power that demands the truth.
0:54:49 And again, he doesn't say what that power is exactly, but it implies that the truth is not a desirable thing.
0:54:58 Right?
0:54:59 If we're forced to tell it, it's like we wouldn't tell it if we weren't forced to
0:55:04 tell it.
0:55:05 So it sort of sounds like the truth is being pulled out of us against our will by whatever
0:55:10 the power is that's demanding it of us, and that kind of makes it sound like the truth,
0:55:14 whatever that means in this context, isn't something good?
0:55:18 Because if it were, it wouldn't need to be pulled from us by power.
0:55:20 We would just give it.
0:55:23 It's presented as if truth is foisted upon us and forced out of us by something against
0:55:30 our will.
0:55:32 But what is that thing?
0:55:34 Power, that's what Foucault says.
0:55:37 What in the Samhald does that mean Foucault?
0:55:40 Whose power?
0:55:42 Power is not a free-floating supernatural force.
0:55:45 Is it?
0:55:47 Power doesn't have intention or will, all by itself.
0:55:52 It is that is that what Foucault wants us to believe that power is this free-floating thing out there and it has a will
0:55:59 Like it wants to struggle and there's in it
0:56:01 No, this is something that it wants to do like something like that like now now power has an agency and an identity all by itself
0:56:08 apart from us is that is that what he's saying and
0:56:13 Power isn't necessarily wielded against others
0:56:17 Can't it be wielded for others, you know can't power be used for good
0:56:22 It's not like power is always something that's being used against somebody.
0:56:29 Can't power be used for good?
0:56:32 Isn't that right?
0:56:33 Foucault's supposed to be a political activist.
0:56:34 Isn't that what the government is supposed to be doing?
0:56:37 To wield power for good?
0:56:41 Come on.
0:56:42 Come on, Michelle.
0:56:43 Come on, buddy.
0:56:45 All right.
0:56:46 He goes on.
0:56:47 An actual fact.
0:56:48 as the manifold sexualities all form the correlates
0:56:52 of exact procedure of power.
0:56:56 So this was an interesting quote,
0:56:57 but I wanted to bring it up, you know,
0:56:58 he talks about, like there was a quote in here
0:57:00 about homosexuality and I didn't include it,
0:57:04 but I did read it.
0:57:05 And here he talks about sexuality again,
0:57:07 and I think it's important for a few reasons.
0:57:09 It's important to bring up because
0:57:10 with a postmodern connection to modern social justice
0:57:14 movements and the modern left,
0:57:16 he might say, progressive left.
0:57:18 Sexuality is a big part of it.
0:57:21 The transgender debate and gay and lesbian rights
0:57:24 and all the various letters and symbols
0:57:28 that keep continue to be added to the LGBTQ plus,
0:57:32 all that stuff, I'm sure I'm missing some.
0:57:34 That's all a part of it.
0:57:36 And sexuality is one of those things
0:57:39 that has a great deal of tradition
0:57:41 and taboo that surrounds it.
0:57:43 So if you were someone like Foucault
0:57:45 that wanted to tear down these arbitrary walls.
0:57:48 Doing it with sexuality, it's a prime target.
0:57:52 It's like there's lots of stigmas about sexuality.
0:57:54 Lots of things you can't do, lots of things you can't say.
0:57:57 That's the kind of stuff that Foucault was resisting.
0:58:00 It's like, who the fuck says I can't say?
0:58:01 What the fuck says we can't do?
0:58:05 He's wants to push back against that power dynamic
0:58:08 and so he brings this up, this sexuality.
0:58:13 he says, manifold sexuality. So that could be all the different things that you might think of.
0:58:19 You know, gay, straight, queer, you know, maybe all the stuff that we all the conversations we have
0:58:24 about gender today, gender roles and all that sort of thing. That is the type of critique
0:58:31 that comes from Foucault. It's like, let's go in here, let's start tearing apart all of these
0:58:35 ideas and concepts that have to do with sexuality so that we can point out the absurdity of them.
0:58:40 So, we don't have to obey them anymore so that new types of sexuality can be born.
0:58:45 New understandings can come out of it.
0:58:48 There's this emphasis in postmodernism on the novel, bringing things that are new into
0:58:54 reality or paving the way for new things to be born.
0:58:58 And I think that's also an area where someone like Jordan Peterson and Foucault would be
0:59:04 hand in hand.
0:59:05 They both seem to believe that.
0:59:06 I think with a little bit of a different color,
0:59:09 but they both seem to agree that creation,
0:59:12 that novelty and creation are absolutely key
0:59:16 to meaning and to purpose.
0:59:19 And I think that's interesting.
0:59:20 But anyway, he says here,
0:59:22 the manifold sexualities all form the correlates
0:59:25 of exact procedures of power.
0:59:27 So I don't know what this sentence even means.
0:59:29 And there's a lot of postmodernism that's like that,
0:59:31 very, very hard to understand.
0:59:33 But what he's saying here is that there's a connection
0:59:35 between sexuality and power.
0:59:38 And so here's my piece.
0:59:41 Is sexuality reducible to a power struggle
0:59:44 between the sexes?
0:59:47 Sexuality.
0:59:49 Is that what that is?
0:59:51 You think about romance and the birth of your first child
0:59:54 and adolescent periods of just lust and all the things
1:00:03 that go along with sexuality that have to do
1:00:05 you're forming your identity and you know forming your kind of moral compass which happens
1:00:10 which happens so much during puberty and you know the bloom of sexuality.
1:00:14 Imagine all of that stuff. Is all of that stuff reducible to a power struggle between the sexes
1:00:20 do you think? I wrote down a little note here my opinion hogwash that's what I wrote hogwash.
1:00:27 It's an oversimplification it's an oversimplification there's a lot of that happening in postmodernism
1:00:33 and it ignores basically all of the characteristics of sexuality that we actually care about.
1:00:40 I mean, there are power struggles and sexuality. There are things like rape. There are things like,
1:00:45 you know, people feeling diminished by gender roles, you know, that that's those are legitimate
1:00:50 conversations, but they're like marginal conversations. When you look at the topic of sexuality as a
1:00:57 We're going to get bogged down on that, tear everything down that we care about, you know,
1:01:04 to do with romance and sexuality and our identity, because we want to find if there's something
1:01:09 in these narratives that we tell about sexuality that is holding us back somehow.
1:01:16 Like, I wonder where the period of diminishing returns.
1:01:20 Where does that come in here?
1:01:21 Like, what do we have to tear down to find, you know, where's the limit here?
1:01:26 Where do we stop?
1:01:27 What do we have to tear down in our society and our culture to find all these bugs in
1:01:33 the system?
1:01:34 Like at some point, at some point, are we causing more harm than good?
1:01:40 I don't know that Foucault ever asked that question.
1:01:43 I certainly don't think that the progressives in the postmodernist today are asking that
1:01:46 question, but I digress.
1:01:51 Back to Foucault.
1:01:53 He says, this is where he first starts talking about language.
1:01:56 This is important.
1:01:57 When language arrives at its own edge,
1:02:00 what it finds is not a positivity that contradicts it,
1:02:04 but the void that will efface it.
1:02:07 Into that void it must go, consenting to come undone,
1:02:10 in a silence that is not the intimacy of a secret,
1:02:13 but a pure outside, where words endlessly unravel.
1:02:17 So when language arrives at its own edge,
1:02:22 so when we get to the point where we've used the language
1:02:27 to the highest level that we can. We've cracked it open. We've done everything we
1:02:32 possibly can with a language. Let's talk about this from the example of a
1:02:37 word because language is always changing and this is also a postmodern thing. This
1:02:41 is something you see from the left, the progressives today, all of the time. When
1:02:47 we've talked about this before, I don't want to berate this idea, but the idea
1:02:50 that you can create a word or that the meaning of words evolve and change over
1:02:56 sometimes that's intentional, sometimes it's not, sometimes it's natural, but what
1:03:01 that when you get to the end of the kind of usefulness of a word, that what
1:03:06 happens is Foucault says that it must go into the void, it must consent to come
1:03:11 undone. That word has to, the meaning of that word has to go into, has to get
1:03:15 sucked into the black hole from whence it came. He calls that, he calls that a pure
1:03:20 outside where words endlessly unravel. So this is an interesting picture that he's painting
1:03:27 of meaning and language, where the meaning of words is constantly transforming. And at
1:03:37 some point, the meaning of the words become exhausted. They no longer have meaning anymore.
1:03:42 And that when that happens, they just get recycled. They go back into the void where
1:03:46 they came. And so the implication is that we give, we create words and assign meaning
1:03:53 to them. And that that meaning is not, it was really hard to describe. Imagine that
1:04:00 term in the term in the term two substance again. So let's go back to this understanding,
1:04:03 this picture I tried to paint earlier, that Foucault believes the same thing Jordan does
1:04:09 about objective reality. That's maybe that's a stretch, but let me just say that. That
1:04:14 We have this infinite potential, whatever this is,
1:04:17 this thing that I call God that exists
1:04:19 behind all of our perceptions.
1:04:20 It's the ones and zeros in the matrix
1:04:23 that the computer program that these people are living in,
1:04:25 that's perception.
1:04:27 And the ones and zeros behind in the movie The Matrix,
1:04:30 that's what I'm talking about.
1:04:31 It's whatever that is, whatever's really there.
1:04:34 And Foucault is saying, that's what's really behind language.
1:04:38 It's infinite meaning.
1:04:41 So if I create a word and I assign some meaning
1:04:43 to it. What I'm doing is I'm arbitrarily coming up with a sound. I'm pretending
1:04:49 that some little bit of this infinite meaning I can attach to this sound, this
1:04:54 word. Have I really? Well not really. And what does that mean exactly? It means
1:05:01 that as long as we agree that that's what this word means, that we can kind of get
1:05:05 by with it. As long as we can get everybody on board. But the truth is
1:05:10 every word has infinite meaning and you can see that I mean you I wish I had a
1:05:14 good example to bring up to to bring up to illustrate this but but you can see
1:05:18 how words how words change their meaning over time you know I'm trying to think
1:05:24 of a maybe like a pop culture word or something you know like like oh geez I
1:05:31 don't know I'm such a freaking 90s kid just thinking about like like the word
1:05:35 bad. Like the word bad the way Michael Jackson would use it. I'm bad. I'm bad. That's a good
1:05:41 thing, man. That's a fucking good thing if you're Michael Jackson bad. But in modern,
1:05:46 you know, in the ordinary parlance, bad means exactly the opposite. So that's, that's, you know,
1:05:51 maybe it's a terrible example, but it's an example nonetheless how the meaning of a word is absolutely
1:05:57 flexible. And the only thing making it mean what it means is mutual agreement. And if
1:06:06 someone like Michael Jackson comes in and says, the word bad no longer means bad. It means
1:06:10 good. It means cool. You get enough people to agree because Michael Jackson is Michael
1:06:14 Jackson. Guess what? Bad means good now, buddy. Bad means good. That's what he's saying. That's
1:06:19 So Foucault is pointing out that language is like that.
1:06:25 I think that's absolutely interesting.
1:06:28 I have a hard time poking holes in that.
1:06:30 I think that there's something to that.
1:06:32 There's something to that.
1:06:35 And I wonder what Jordan Peterson would say about that.
1:06:37 I have a hard time thinking that Jordan would disagree
1:06:40 with what I'm saying.
1:06:43 OK, so the meaning of language is transitory.
1:06:45 It's always transforming, something like that.
1:06:48 So language is ultimately a tool of power
1:06:52 that we use against everyone else in Foucault's estimation.
1:06:56 Language is not real, and therefore it cannot,
1:06:58 and should, excuse me, it can and should change.
1:07:01 Language is not real, it can and should change,
1:07:04 and that's ultimately up to us.
1:07:07 We can change the meaning of language
1:07:09 so that it's a tool that's useful again for us,
1:07:12 for whatever we want to use it for.
1:07:16 And when it changes, the meaning is lost or transformed,
1:07:19 But something new and novel can emerge from its ghost.
1:07:23 And that seems to be the highest good for Foucault, novelty.
1:07:28 So if we suck this old word that doesn't
1:07:30 have any meaning anymore into the black hole,
1:07:33 then we can regurgitate whatever the pieces were back
1:07:36 into the world to create something new now.
1:07:40 And you can see that with a good and bad example.
1:07:42 The Michael Jackson example of bad.
1:07:45 Boy.
1:07:47 All right, so Foucault says, he says,
1:07:49 In a sense I'm a moralist, in so far as I believe that one of the tasks, one of the
1:07:54 meanings of human existence, is never to accept anything as definitive, untouchable, obvious
1:08:01 or immobile.
1:08:02 No aspect of reality should be allowed to become a definitive law for us.
1:08:07 We have to rise up against all forms of power, but not just power in the narrow sense of
1:08:12 the word, referring to the power of a government or of one's social group over another.
1:08:18 These are only a few particular instances of power.
1:08:21 Power is anything that tends to render immobile and untouchable.
1:08:25 Those things that are offered to us as real, as true, as good.
1:08:29 All right.
1:08:32 So this is an important quote for Foucault.
1:08:35 He talks about himself as a moralist, and then he's explaining what he means by that.
1:08:42 So he points out things that are untouchable, things that in our culture and in our society,
1:08:51 We want to remain permanent and unchanged.
1:08:56 Those are things like the law.
1:08:57 Those are things like, you know, in America, it's property rights.
1:09:01 It's, you know, it's protection under the law.
1:09:05 There's things like that that we want to remain the same.
1:09:09 We want to be able to rely on.
1:09:10 And like I said before from the Nietzsche example of Apollo, that their order is something that
1:09:15 we need.
1:09:16 Think about children.
1:09:17 Think about how important it is for them to have a bedtime.
1:09:20 important it is for them to have a schedule so that they know when they're
1:09:23 eating and they know when they're playing and they know when they're, you
1:09:25 know, when they're this and when they're that. How important order is, especially
1:09:29 when we're developing as children, you know, psychologically so important. So
1:09:36 there are things like that. There are things like that that that we would say
1:09:39 we want to be untouchable. We want to be permanent. But what Foucault focuses on
1:09:43 is that those are the things that get in the way. Those are the things that
1:09:47 become these arbitrary walls that we get so used to we don't even wouldn't even
1:09:52 know they're there anymore. That's the same logic that people use in the
1:09:56 social social justice movement let's say today when they talk about white
1:10:00 privilege. It's like oh it's invisible to you because you don't you don't see
1:10:05 it because you because you know you it's it's it's so ever-present that you get
1:10:11 you adapt to it you get used to it and becomes invisible to you. You don't see
1:10:14 it, but it's still there. That's the same type of argument. It's the same thing that comes up again
1:10:22 in social justice as in Michelle Foucault. And and to Foucault, it's tearing those things, pointing
1:10:31 those things out and tearing them down that leads to more opportunity that leads to greater
1:10:37 potential that leads to something new. And it's interesting that he points out the things that we
1:10:43 consider real, true, and good. That those are the ones we have to be the most
1:10:49 suspicious of. Because those are the ones that seem to be defending their
1:10:56 position. Those are the ones that the culture and the society is saying hold
1:11:00 the highest value. Those are the ones that we want to remain. We don't want to
1:11:04 deconstruct them. We don't want to critique them. We don't want them to go
1:11:07 away. We want the things that we consider real, true, and good. And Foucault is
1:11:13 saying those should not be untouchable. Those should be the things that we go after first.
1:11:18 We should be examining those things because the things that we consider real may not be real.
1:11:23 Things we consider true may not be true. The things we consider good may not be good.
1:11:28 And we only will know that if we pay attention, if we poke holes, if we get in there and root
1:11:33 around in there. And there's some truth in that. I mean, there's some truth in that. You can think
1:11:40 think of atrocities of Nazi Germany and the ideology there, and how the people believed
1:11:48 that they were real, true and good, and if nobody ever examined them, nobody would ever
1:11:56 point that out, and the Nazis would just keep doing what they're doing, something like that.
1:12:01 So you can see that there's something there, but you can also see the risk, and this is
1:12:05 something that Foucault I don't think ever acknowledges.
1:12:08 The risk is if you go in there and you start pulling the rug out
1:12:11 under the things that we consider real and true and good,
1:12:16 what happens if you accidentally undermine something that is actually real,
1:12:21 actually true, or actually good?
1:12:24 What happens if you undermine that?
1:12:26 What happens if you take that away?
1:12:29 The person who Foucault loved so much, Nietzsche,
1:12:33 specifically warned him against that
1:12:36 when he talked about the death of God.
1:12:39 What happens when that foundation gets pulled out?
1:12:41 When God is dead, then will there be enough water
1:12:45 to wash away that blood?
1:12:46 And then what will we do?
1:12:49 So Nietzsche tried to warn Foucault,
1:12:51 but Foucault must not must the fucking miss that sentence.
1:12:54 Nietzsche is not the easiest read.
1:12:57 I don't mean to be disrespectful of Foucault,
1:12:59 I think he was a very smart guy, but come on, man.
1:13:03 So to Foucault, it's like we should dissect
1:13:06 deconstruct those things that we hold as true, real and good, so that we can rise above the power,
1:13:13 the ideas and the concepts hold over us. So that's also important. It's like even the idea of true
1:13:20 or real or good, even those ideas all by themselves are like limits that we're putting on ourselves,
1:13:27 and that we actually have to disrupt that power, the power that those concepts have over us,
1:13:34 something like that. Think about that. But are ideas of real, true, and good? Are they legitimate?
1:13:44 Are those ideas even legitimate? If they are, why destroy them, Foucault? Why destroy them? Why claim
1:13:53 that they have undue power over us or any power over us at all? And why would destroying these be
1:14:00 arbitrarily good. See to Foucault, an idea or a concept being questioned or
1:14:06 undermined is always good. But why? Because it clears the way for something new to
1:14:13 arise. So why does the novel or the new equal good for Foucault? And why can't the
1:14:21 old coexist with the new? I think that is that the crux of the difference
1:14:28 between Foucault and Jordan Peterson.
1:14:31 Because Jordan talks about the dance, the harmony,
1:14:34 the synthesis of the chaos in order.
1:14:37 So to Jordan, if you have something that's old
1:14:39 that's corruptible, that it can always be recycled
1:14:43 and renewed and turned into something good again,
1:14:45 you don't have to get rid of the old
1:14:47 to have something new.
1:14:49 To Foucault, it sort of seems like you have to demolish
1:14:51 the old to have something new.
1:14:53 To Jordan, it's like, no, we can build on it.
1:14:56 we can synthesize it the old with the new.
1:14:58 And if you don't, that's the death of your father,
1:15:02 that the mythological death of your father,
1:15:04 that Jordan talks about.
1:15:05 He's like, look, if you demolish the old,
1:15:08 that you're losing your footing,
1:15:10 all of the work that all of the human beings
1:15:13 that came before you did
1:15:14 to make your life better than theirs was.
1:15:19 All of the culture that we've created
1:15:21 to help our future, our children,
1:15:25 that you're throwing all that under the bus
1:15:26 and starting anew.
1:15:28 And Jordan's like, there are risks with that.
1:15:31 There are very large risks with that.
1:15:33 That's what Nietzsche was pointing out with the death of God.
1:15:36 And that's something that Foucault seems to ignore.
1:15:41 All right, he goes on, he says,
1:15:42 the strategic adversary is fascism.
1:15:45 The fascism in us all, in our heads
1:15:48 and in our everyday behavior.
1:15:51 The fascism that causes us to love power,
1:15:53 to desire the very thing that dominates and exploits us.
1:15:57 So here Foucault is pointing out, again, this internal struggle.
1:16:01 He's saying that all of us are fascists in our soul.
1:16:04 Now, if you guys don't know what fascism means, and I don't blame you because it's
1:16:09 with things like antifa, antifascist, and with the modern understanding of fascism,
1:16:15 you know, compared to the historical understanding of fascism, it doesn't surprise me
1:16:19 that people don't really understand what fascism means.
1:16:21 But what it means, you can wiki this if you don't believe me, is a form of
1:16:26 authoritarian power that involves the suppression of opposition. So it's
1:16:32 authoritarian power that suppresses opposition. So you can see that with
1:16:38 the Nazis for sure they were fascists but every single communist system that's
1:16:42 ever existed has been fascist as well. You can see that anything that has a
1:16:45 dictator you know controlling power and anything that suppresses opposition
1:16:51 which is every dictator that's fascism. So you know that's what we're talking
1:16:56 about here. Foucault is saying that that exists in each one of us, that we all love power
1:17:02 and want power. And we all don't want, don't want to power exerted over us so that all
1:17:08 of us have this, have this instinct going on that both loves and hates power, something
1:17:15 like that. And he says it's the very desire that dominates and exploits us and that we
1:17:20 have to fight, we have to fight against the fascism in ourselves. So, you know, I don't
1:17:26 disagree with this, but I think we diverge 180 degrees at this point from where Foucault
1:17:32 began when he was talking about critiquing power dynamics. He's like, that's aimed to
1:17:37 reach, if you remember, to reach the most individual forms of behavior. That's what he said, to
1:17:42 reach the most individual forms of behavior. And yet here we see a rejection of the individual
1:17:48 as he's presented as fundamentally corrupted
1:17:50 by his instinctual desire to dominate and exploit.
1:17:54 So what is it Foucault?
1:17:56 Do we want to clear the way for the individual
1:18:00 to be an individual?
1:18:01 Or do we want to push down the individual
1:18:04 because that's the part of us, that's the fascist,
1:18:06 that's the part of us that loves power,
1:18:09 that wants to exploit and dominate?
1:18:10 It's the individual that wants to do that, right?
1:18:12 So we wanna subdue the individual?
1:18:16 Or do we want to clear the way for the individual to bloom?
1:18:19 To bloom?
1:18:20 What do we want to do here, Foucault?
1:18:21 Which one is it?
1:18:23 He goes on, he says, the real political task in a society is to criticize the workings
1:18:27 of institutions that appear to be both neutral and independent.
1:18:32 To criticize and attack them in such a manner that the political violence that has always
1:18:37 exercised itself obscurely through them will be unmasked so that one can fight against
1:18:43 them.
1:18:45 So this quote is extremely important to remember in reference to what's happening today.
1:18:53 So Foucault says that the real political task in society, this is the goal of politics,
1:19:00 is to criticize the workings of institutions that appear to be neutral and independent.
1:19:05 So we're going to criticize all of the institutions in the society that keep things running.
1:19:09 Those are things like schools, those are things like governments, those are things
1:19:13 like communities, those are things like the grand unifying narrative of our culture, you know,
1:19:19 like, you know, being proud to be an American for whatever reason that you might choose,
1:19:25 or even to hate being American, which seems to be awful popular these days. Whatever the
1:19:29 unifying narrative is, all of these things, he's saying that the job of politics is to criticize
1:19:38 all of those things. Why? Because if you criticize them all, then you can find,
1:19:46 he says, the political violence that has always exercised itself,
1:19:52 obscurely through them, through these institutions. Okay, let me just try to break this up a little
1:19:58 bit so we understand what the fuck he's saying. He's saying that the institutions that make up
1:20:03 our societies, like all the things I just said, that those things have always been
1:20:09 obscurely committing violence politically against certain groups, certain people.
1:20:17 He says obscurely because he wants to point out, you may not have noticed, you may not
1:20:20 have seen this.
1:20:21 This is, this may not be obvious to you.
1:20:23 Well, why?
1:20:24 Is that because it's fucking bullshit or is that because it's like secret and being
1:20:29 done, you know, in the shadows. Is that what you're saying? He kind of seems to be saying
1:20:34 that. He's saying that the institutions in our society are committing political violence
1:20:39 against us, and they're doing it in secret. So what we need to do is tear them apart so
1:20:45 we can find those areas of violence so that we can unmask them and bring them to light.
1:20:50 Then we can fight back against them, but only when we've done that. So to Foucault, it seems
1:20:55 like the only way that we can find the problems, that we can find the bug in the machine, is
1:21:01 to tear everything down, tear it all down to find the bug, then we can crush the bug.
1:21:07 Then what, Foucault? We've torn down all the institutions. Then what, Foucault? So this
1:21:14 is what the Communists would then step in and say, great, then we can bring about the
1:21:18 Communist Revolution. This is what Marx talked about when he said that there's
1:21:25 The phase is in the process of communism, and the phase that comes before the glorious
1:21:33 communist end game where the government doesn't have to exist anymore, this is the opportunity
1:21:42 that Foucault is describing for the final stage of communism, for the communist utopia.
1:21:49 So we're going to tear everything down so we can find that bug and squash it, and then
1:21:53 we're just going to end the ruins here.
1:21:55 We're going to bring about this communist revolution.
1:21:57 Foucault doesn't exactly say that, though.
1:22:00 And he doesn't say, what are we going to do then,
1:22:02 what all of our institutions are in pieces?
1:22:05 What are we going to do then?
1:22:06 Isn't that a risk?
1:22:08 Isn't that a dangerous thing?
1:22:10 Conservatives everywhere would be agree with me.
1:22:13 And liberals everywhere would say,
1:22:14 fucking burn it down, let's see what happens.
1:22:17 That's the Apollo and the Dionysus struggling.
1:22:25 All right.
1:22:26 So political violence being perpetrated covertly by institutions against society just seems
1:22:30 interesting to me.
1:22:31 It just seems like it just seems like a stretch.
1:22:36 What is that exactly?
1:22:37 You know, maybe in a communist or a centrally planned system, you could say that the government
1:22:42 imposes its will, you know, it imposes its power against its citizens because they don't
1:22:48 have a say in the matter.
1:22:51 in the capitalist system or in a free market, I don't see that. I don't see how that could
1:22:56 possibly be true. All right. So Foucault says, the work of an intellectual is not to mold
1:23:08 the political will of others. Let me just stop right there. This is a bigger, a bigger
1:23:12 piece here. But Foucault has just said in this, in this first sentence, this opening
1:23:16 sentence, exactly the opposite of what all of the people who follow postmodernism today
1:23:22 are doing. The political left, the progressives in particular, they want to mold the political
1:23:29 will of others. All you have to do is watch the news and see how they're talking to you
1:23:34 to understand that. They're berating you. They're making you out to be dumb if you don't agree
1:23:38 with them. And that has been happening for a very long time in media. That's the thing
1:23:45 that I brought up when I said that Rachel Maddow single-handedly turned to be against
1:23:50 the Democratic Party when I was trying to figure out
1:23:52 where I would land politically, that her arrogance
1:23:55 and talking about things like that,
1:23:58 like you're an absolute idiot if you don't agree with me,
1:24:00 like every single one of these absolute assholes
1:24:03 on social media that's yelling at people
1:24:05 who haven't got the vaccine, calling them, you know,
1:24:08 Pussy's are saying that they're afraid,
1:24:10 or whatever it is that they're saying,
1:24:13 it's shaming people into agreement with you.
1:24:18 you. And it's arrogant. And I don't want to, I don't want to beat this up. I just want
1:24:23 to say, Foucault says this, the work of an intellectual is not to mold the political
1:24:29 will of others. And the intellectuals in academia, in the, in the media are all trying to do
1:24:39 that today. And they've been doing that since the 60s, basically. And Foucault, who's their,
1:24:44 you know, who's their George Washington, you might say, is telling them that's not
1:24:48 not their place. So there's that. I'll keep reading. He says, it is to re-examine evidence
1:24:56 and assumptions to shake up habitual ways of working and thinking, to dissipate conventional
1:25:01 familiarities, to re-evaluate rules and institutions, and to participate in the formation of a political
1:25:07 will. So this is what he thinks the role of the intellectual is in the culture. It's
1:25:17 to re-examine poke holes and tear down all of those things that we wouldn't ordinarily
1:25:24 even look at, the things that are invisible to us, our assumptions, our habits, the things
1:25:29 that are conventional, traditional, familiar, that all of those things we should be tearing
1:25:35 down, that's what the work of the intellectual is, it's to question all of the things that
1:25:41 we don't question.
1:25:44 I kind of don't disagree with that. I think that is important. It's very important because
1:25:49 assumptions, I don't know if your mom or dad ever told you about assuming, but it will
1:25:53 make an ass out of you and me. It will indeed. Mom was right. I think the progressives and
1:26:04 the postmodernists need to fucking listen to my mom. It will indeed. Okay. So the role
1:26:11 All the intellectual is not to influence others' political opinions, but rather, he says to
1:26:15 participate in the forming of a political will.
1:26:20 That's interesting.
1:26:21 I'm not sure that those are different things, by the way.
1:26:24 To influence someone's political opinion, and to participate in forming a political
1:26:29 will, kind of seemed like the same thing, because a political will is being described
1:26:33 here like a free-floating thing, like politics is a spirit, and it has an intention.
1:26:38 will is to X, Y, and Z. That's kind of how he's painting this out. That citizens in a society can
1:26:45 work together to form a political will. And that will can work in the society all by itself.
1:26:51 Once we've created the spirit, this fucking political spirit, it'll just swim through our
1:26:55 culture and society and do the things we want it to do. Something like that. But again, I'm not
1:27:00 sure that forming a political will and convincing people to believe the same thing politically are
1:27:05 different. But Foucault seems to think so. By forming a political will, I wonder, is Foucault
1:27:11 referring to an emergent collective will of the people or of society, not of the people
1:27:17 exactly because they're made of individuals, but of society. Now, isn't this achieved
1:27:22 by creating a uniform kind of majority opinion by persuading others to your mind? I think
1:27:28 so. So I kind of think this Foucault, you know, making an arbitrary distinction here.
1:27:34 But this idea of a political will, like this emergent collective will, this is where we're starting to see Foucault
1:27:41 lean towards the idea that
1:27:44 the group can form a will and
1:27:48 that when it does that,
1:27:51 that the group kind of
1:27:54 the group kind of operates like its own entity, right? The group now has a will, like individuals have a will.
1:28:01 It has desires and goals. Like that's a weird thing to say about society, but that's what Foucault is saying here
1:28:08 And he's like once that's happened
1:28:11 He says that that's the role of every citizen to play to help form this political will
1:28:16 That now you have a group, you know
1:28:19 The the polis as the Greeks would say the who are the people that make up the political entity and that now this group is
1:28:26 More powerful and more important than the individual. That's that's gonna be what we're gonna start to see
1:28:31 Alright, so Foucault points out some interesting stuff here. He says, schools serve the same
1:28:39 social function as prisons and mental institutions to define, classify, control, and regulate
1:28:46 people. He also says, is it surprising that prisons resemble factories, schools, barracks,
1:28:54 Hospitals which all resemble prisons
1:28:57 So the point he's making here is all of the boxes and rules that we pain up for ourselves that we live in
1:29:06 All these arbitrary kind of conditions that we place on ourselves and limit ourselves
1:29:11 You know all of these things that we do and we kind of ingrain or even our children
1:29:16 We indoctrinate even them into the system that what what we're doing is we're putting ourselves in prisons
1:29:22 of some form
1:29:24 conceptual prisons." He says, schools are the same way, factories, hospitals. All of these things are
1:29:34 designed like prisons. Why is that, do you think? The implication seems to be because the power
1:29:41 dynamics that are working behind the scenes want us to be slaves, and that's what we have to fight
1:29:48 back against. Can't you see that the institutions and the institutions in society are making you
1:29:53 all slaves and prisoners? Can't you see that? That's what he's saying. Do you feel
1:30:00 like a prisoner? Maybe a little, I guess? I don't know. Not really. All right, he says,
1:30:08 a critique does not consist in saying that things aren't good the way they are.
1:30:13 It consists in seeing on just what types of assumptions, familiar notions of
1:30:18 established and unexamined ways of thinking, the accepted practices are
1:30:22 based. So this is Foucault's way of justifying the critique, the tearing
1:30:29 down of the institutions that postmodernism is designed to do. He's saying,
1:30:34 look, it's not about whether the institutions are good or bad the way
1:30:38 they are. It's about whether they can be better or whether they're
1:30:43 necessary. And if we can just question the assumptions that we never
1:30:47 question, maybe we can find those answers. And if we don't question them,
1:30:50 things will never change. And people don't like that idea. As much as people like security,
1:30:56 people don't like the idea that things will never change. Because nothing's ever good enough for us,
1:31:01 right? Nothing's ever good enough. We live in the most prosperous time and
1:31:09 it's the greatest time to be a human being ever. Even in the most terrible places on the planet,
1:31:14 it's better now to be a human being than it's ever been. It's easier to live,
1:31:17 you know, and it's never good enough. It's never good enough for us. So the idea that
1:31:24 things might be static and never change, that's a very scary thing. People don't like that
1:31:28 idea either. And that brings me to my next quote. Foucault says, knowledge is not for
1:31:35 knowing. Knowledge is for cutting. Knowledge is for cutting. Cutting what exactly, Foucault?
1:31:46 cutting up those institutions, cutting up those assumptions that we're blind to, cutting them
1:31:50 up. That's what knowledge is for. So the more we know, the more we know what we don't
1:31:56 know. The more we know, the more we know what's holding us back. So we go in and we get rid
1:32:01 of that stuff. That's the idea. Foucault says, under no circumstances, should one pay attention
1:32:08 to those who tell one, don't criticize, since you're not capable of carrying out a reform.
1:32:14 doesn't have to be the premise of a deduction that concludes, this then is what needs to
1:32:19 be done. It should be an instrument for those who fight, those who resist and refuse what
1:32:24 is. It isn't a stage to a programming. It is a challenge directed to what is. First
1:32:34 of all, that's a very nihilistic thing to say. To say that you want to challenge what
1:32:38 is. What is? This is a difficult conversation every time I bring it up, but I have to.
1:32:46 When somebody says, what are they referring to? What exists? It's the state of things. It's
1:32:55 what exists. It's everything that is and how it is. It's something I call being.
1:33:00 So somebody who has a challenge to being, that mythologically is the story of the devil,
1:33:08 The devil, Lucifer is the person who challenges being. Lucifer is the person who challenges God
1:33:13 and says, I could have done it better. Look at all these mistakes you made. Challenging what is
1:33:19 is, as Jordan Peterson would say, it's Cain from the Cain and the Abel story. You know,
1:33:25 it's somebody that's unwilling to see their own shortcomings and blames the world instead.
1:33:33 You know, somebody who wants to challenge what is is not happy with, with existence.
1:33:40 And that's a double edged sword, because as Foucault would say, you have to challenge
1:33:46 what is to make something new, to bring something new and better into the world.
1:33:49 And I agree.
1:33:50 You can't get that by not challenging things.
1:33:53 You're not going to get to the next scientific theory without challenging the existing ones.
1:33:57 You know, that makes perfect sense to me.
1:34:01 But also to challenge what is is also a very ungrateful thing to do.
1:34:05 It's very ungrateful because what is is beautiful and good in so many ways.
1:34:13 And to not acknowledge that, to not to not say that there's things in there worth preserving
1:34:17 or things in there that were hard-gained, hard-earned and worthwhile, that's a very arrogant thing
1:34:23 to say.
1:34:24 It's a very short-sighted thing to say.
1:34:26 And for somebody so smart as Foucault, it seems unlikely that that idea would not occur
1:34:31 to him. But he's saying that to critique is important for that reason and that reason only.
1:34:37 Even if you don't know what you would put in its place. And that is such a dumb thing to say
1:34:44 and such a dangerous thing to say. He says in the beginning here, he says, under no circumstances
1:34:51 as you listen to someone who tells you not to criticize, if you're not capable of carrying out
1:34:56 a reform, what he's saying here is, don't sit there and criticize the systems and say how bad
1:35:00 they are, unless you know something better, unless you can bring something better to the table."
1:35:06 He's saying, don't let that hold you back from criticizing. You should still criticize,
1:35:09 because that's very important, and it is important. But the idea here is if you criticize a system
1:35:18 and you tear it down, but you don't have something better to replace it with, then what?
1:35:24 and Foucault doesn't address that at all. In fact, he says, don't even listen to
1:35:31 that voice in your mind telling you that. Why should I tear down this
1:35:35 institution if I don't have something better to replace it with? Don't even
1:35:37 listen to that devil on your left shoulder. Just keep fighting the good
1:35:42 fight and doing the good work. Tear it down, tear it down. Don't let the
1:35:46 fact that you don't have a better idea of something to replace this with, hold
1:35:50 you back from tearing it down and that's what the left wants to do today. They want to tear things
1:35:56 down and they don't have anything better to replace it with and that's very scary. So to challenge
1:36:07 what is is to wish to transform being in my opinion. It's to wish the world away to make it
1:36:14 something that it's not. You wish that it was a different way to make things different from the
1:36:20 the way they are. Perhaps to believe arrogantly that you are capable of doing so. If you are
1:36:27 the postmodernist having this thought, you're going to tear it down without something to
1:36:32 replace it with. Why? Because you're positioned to tear it down. I just don't really know.
1:36:42 There's a hole here. There's a very goddamn big hole here. And it just seems arrogant
1:36:47 me. In short-sighted, you're not going to tear down important parts of the institution and the
1:36:54 culture. Things so important and ingrained that they're invisible to us. We rely on them so much
1:37:00 we don't even see them anymore. You're going to tear them down and replace them with nothing.
1:37:04 And then you're going to pat yourself on the back and applaud that you did something good.
1:37:09 I don't know about that. But to Foucault, it's just an unquestioned good
1:37:16 to tear these things down.
1:37:21 All right, the last quote on this piece,
1:37:22 he says, justice must always question itself.
1:37:26 Just as society can exist only by means of the work
1:37:29 it does on itself and on its institutions.
1:37:33 So I think this is an interesting quote to end on,
1:37:36 this piece because it's a warning.
1:37:38 It's a warning to the postmodernist today.
1:37:43 And he says, justice must always question itself.
1:37:47 He said, that's the only way things work.
1:37:51 The only way institutions can remain vibrant and not degrade and become counterproductive.
1:37:58 You always have to keep breaking them down, keep questioning them, keep finding the bugs
1:38:03 in the machine.
1:38:05 He says justice is the same.
1:38:07 You must always question justice.
1:38:11 You can imagine that's what people are doing when they're saying defund the police in Black
1:38:16 life matter, they're, they're trying to question justice, but they never question the justice
1:38:23 of their own cause. And I want to point that out here. When Foucault says justice must
1:38:28 always be questioned, you can definitely see defund the police people are questioning justice.
1:38:33 But are they ever once questioning themselves? Are you being just and what you're doing?
1:38:41 BLM, are you being just and what you're doing? Have you, have you questioned it? Have you asked
1:38:45 yourself. And you have to always do that. You have to continue to do that. As the movement
1:38:51 changes and goes on, you have to continue to always question. Is it just where are the
1:38:59 bugs in your machine? You have to have those eyes looking inwards. That's what Foucault
1:39:04 is saying. How many post monitors are doing that today? So I think it's a fair and a
1:39:12 prophetic warning from Foucault. Like I said, is social justice questioning itself? Is RBLM?
1:39:18 Is communist China? Is North Korea? No. They arrogantly believe that they're unquestionably
1:39:26 right and virtuous. To question them in today's society is to make yourself a target, a target for
1:39:33 that power that Foucault is warning us about. It's interesting. All right, so I want to turn a
1:39:44 a little bit now, we're going to talk about, we're going to talk about the self, the way
1:39:48 that Foucault thinks about individuals, because again, there's a, there's a dynamic here
1:39:53 between the group and the individual that's kind of key to this whole postmodernism's
1:39:57 debate. So what does Foucault have to say about that? All right, I'm going to open
1:40:02 it up this way. He says, the judges of normality are present everywhere. Excuse me, normality
1:40:09 are present everywhere. We are in we are in the society of the teacher judge, the doctor judge,
1:40:15 the educator judge, the social worker judge. It is on them that the universal reign of the
1:40:21 normative is based and each individual subject to its body, his gestures, his behaviors, his aptitudes,
1:40:28 his achievements. So this is interesting. This is Foucault pointing out this idea of normal
1:40:35 And he uses the word normative, and you will see that everywhere in the progressive language
1:40:41 today, normative, the idea that there is a normal or an average, that there is a mean
1:40:48 or a median, that there's some way for us to, that there is a measuring post or a measuring
1:40:54 stick that we can use, kind of middle of the road to compare people and their behaviors.
1:41:02 And that idea is something that postmodern philosophy doesn't like.
1:41:07 And there's lots of resistance to it.
1:41:10 I feel co is no exception.
1:41:12 And he's saying that in the society, there's everybody's a judge of what's normal.
1:41:17 Teachers, doctors, social workers, educators, everybody is telling you what's normal, how
1:41:24 to be and how not to be, how to speak and how not to speak.
1:41:29 And so that there's this weird, normative kind of standard that everybody's being forced
1:41:35 to comply with.
1:41:37 And you can see how you could imagine a power dynamic there.
1:41:42 That society is demanding some sort of normalcy from people.
1:41:46 And in order to get that, it has to chisel away at all the things that make you unique.
1:41:52 It has to impose its power against you somehow.
1:41:57 So the implication is that the normal is something imposed on us against our will by
1:42:02 society.
1:42:04 This is one way in which we are oppressed simply by forming the idea of normal.
1:42:11 The very existence of this idea, it pens the normies against the anti-normies, for lack
1:42:16 of a better word.
1:42:17 As soon as we come up with the idea, the concept of normal, here's where it gets interesting.
1:42:23 like the concept itself that exists, oppresses us so that there's a power in the idea of
1:42:34 normal that oppresses us for not conforming to it.
1:42:38 And nobody can conform to it perfectly, something like that.
1:42:44 And so the postmodern idea is that this is bad.
1:42:48 This is an example of those arbitrary borders and walls and things that are preventing us
1:42:53 from seeing paths of progress or moving forward, whatever that means. That's, again, not always
1:43:01 a good thing. Progress is not always a good thing, although that would be hard-pressed
1:43:06 to think otherwise when just hearing the word progressive seems pretty good, right?
1:43:11 Not always. Change is not always good. It's not always for the better.
1:43:14 All right, so Foucault says, if you were not like everybody else, then you were abnormal.
1:43:21 If you are abnormal, then you are sick, not being like everybody else, not being normal
1:43:26 and being sick are in fact very different, but have been reduced to the same thing.
1:43:32 So that's interesting.
1:43:33 You have this idea of normal, just having the idea as a concept is oppressing everyone
1:43:39 is the idea, that there's this power trying to make you normal and there's this resistance,
1:43:46 individuality you have that's resisting and that that's unavoidable.
1:43:55 The next quote here is, the individual is the product of power.
1:43:58 We already read that one, but I wanted to put it in here again.
1:44:00 So we're talking about this abnormal, normal thing, and then we can see this phrase, the
1:44:06 individual is the product of power, that maybe that makes a little bit more sense now.
1:44:11 The idea that the individual identity that you have is because of all of the circumstances
1:44:18 you find yourself in is being sort of pushed towards this, whatever normal is, this sort
1:44:23 of middle ground. And that that's happening against true well, basically. He says, it
1:44:30 is not that the beautiful totality of the individual is amputated, repressed, altered
1:44:37 by our social order. It is rather that the individual is carefully fabricated in it according
1:44:43 to a whole technique of forces and bodies. So the technique of forces and bodies is the
1:44:50 power dynamic that he's talking about.
1:44:52 So this is a better way, I think, of explaining what he means when he says that the individual
1:44:57 is fabricated.
1:44:59 He's, or the individual is a product of power.
1:45:02 He says it's not like the, like the individual is amputated by the social order.
1:45:07 It's not like we're being forced into being normal and we were once some crazy, you know,
1:45:13 chaotic pattern that's been trimmed down to this nice little, you know, perfect shape.
1:45:17 It's not like that.
1:45:19 It's rather that the individual is fabricated entirely.
1:45:26 The individual is carefully fabricated in it, in this power dynamic.
1:45:31 So the whole idea of yourself as an individual is made up, just like the idea of normal is
1:45:37 made up.
1:45:40 That's what Foucault is telling you.
1:45:42 The whole reason that you have an idea of yourself as an individual is because our society
1:45:49 and culture has created the conditions that let you believe that, that have fabricated
1:45:54 that idea.
1:45:56 And once it exists, just like the idea of normal, hard to get rid of.
1:46:02 So the individual was fake or false or ingenuine.
1:46:06 Due to the power dynamics he finds himself being born into, he finds himself in.
1:46:12 The individual was ingenuine and fake, this is kind of the idea.
1:46:16 And this is why novelty and bucking tradition is valued by Foucault, because it's taken
1:46:21 somehow as genuine.
1:46:23 It's like something new, something just born, something that couldn't have existed before,
1:46:28 but now exists.
1:46:30 That's something genuine, that it's an unencumbered form of being, that it's not constrained yet
1:46:37 by power, the power that works against your individuality.
1:46:43 So that's what we're going to continue to see.
1:46:44 It's interesting, but it's really hard to reconcile this idea of the group versus the individual.
1:46:51 Foucault says discipline makes individuals.
1:46:54 It is the specific technique of power that regards individuals both as objects and as instruments of its exercise.
1:47:02 So it's discipline that makes individuals.
1:47:06 So Jordan Peterson would say something like, you are what you repeatedly do.
1:47:12 So there's something there about discipline that matches up with what Jordan Peterson would say.
1:47:17 that your individuality is formed
1:47:20 by the things that you repeatedly do.
1:47:22 That's true, you are what you eat argument.
1:47:26 But Foucault is implying that power dynamics
1:47:28 are the discipline that molds you as an individual.
1:47:32 It's the power dynamics that are the discipline
1:47:35 he's talking about.
1:47:37 So you are an individual only
1:47:40 so that you can exercise power,
1:47:42 so that you can give power a form
1:47:45 so that it can act through you.
1:47:48 That is quite the religious statement, and one that I think Jordan Peterson would probably
1:47:55 agree with, at least largely, let me say that again.
1:48:01 So if when Foucault talks about the discipline being the thing that makes the individual,
1:48:08 he's talking about that as the power dynamic, because everything's about the power dynamic.
1:48:12 So that's the discipline that makes you an individual, it's the back and forth between
1:48:17 the power dynamic. So the fact that you're an individual is only the case. Like you have
1:48:24 this idea of yourself as an individual. That exists because of the power dynamic. Why?
1:48:31 Because you need an individual to exert power on some other individual. So power doesn't
1:48:37 just work all by itself. It's not this free-floating force out there that's just blowing against
1:48:42 The other power goes, it's not like that.
1:48:45 It has to be embodied in an individual.
1:48:49 That's how power can exist.
1:48:52 It doesn't exist like fucking Slimer,
1:48:55 like Slimer from Ghostbusters.
1:48:58 Doesn't work that way, right?
1:49:00 So what he's saying is that you are an individual only
1:49:06 so that you can exercise power,
1:49:08 so that power can take form,
1:49:10 So the power dynamic can be embodied and act in the world.
1:49:19 All right, so the pause here,
1:49:21 the silence that you're hearing from me,
1:49:23 is me putting two and two together here.
1:49:27 If the power dynamic is the thing that gets embodied
1:49:31 so that you can act out in the world this power dynamic,
1:49:35 that is very, very, very fucking close
1:49:39 to the idea that Jordan brings up about the logos.
1:49:43 a religious idea that consciousness needs to be embodied so that it can act in the world.
1:49:50 And that's what God is to Jordan Peterson, to me anyway, and that's the way I read Jordan Peterson.
1:49:57 So that consciousness needs to be embodied so that it can act in the world so that it can be
1:50:03 conscious. And what Foucault is saying is that the power dynamic needs to be embodied so that it
1:50:09 that it can act so that it can be the power dynamic in the world.
1:50:12 I know it's muddy, but what I want to point out here is that Foucault describes the power
1:50:18 dynamic in almost exactly the same way that Jordan Peterson and I describe God and consciousness.
1:50:29 I think Jordan Peterson and Foucault would actually maybe have an interesting conversation
1:50:32 here if Foucault were alive.
1:50:36 This is interesting, but it also makes me think that Foucault is not so much of an atheist
1:50:40 He thinks in this idea of a power dynamic, this disembodied, supernatural, driving force
1:50:46 of culture and individual, you know, identity and experience.
1:50:52 That is the thing I call God.
1:50:54 That is the thing Foucault calls the power dynamic.
1:50:58 So Foucault is not an atheist at all.
1:51:01 You might think he is, but he is not.
1:51:04 Now I would definitely think he's misled here in the idea that God is nothing but a driving
1:51:10 force of power, but you can definitely see this synthesis, this balance between chaos
1:51:19 in order that Jordan Peterson talks about in the image of the power dynamic.
1:51:22 You can absolutely see that.
1:51:24 All right, Foucault says, what strikes me is the fact that in our society, art has
1:51:30 become something which is related only to objects and not to individuals or to life.
1:51:35 But couldn't everyone's life become a work of art?
1:51:38 Why should the lamp or the house be an art object, but not your life?"
1:51:43 And then there's a related quote here.
1:51:45 He says, from the idea that the self is not given to us, I think there's only one practical
1:51:50 consequence.
1:51:52 We have to create ourselves as a work of art.
1:51:54 All right.
1:51:57 So when he says that the idea of the self is not given to us, what he means here is that
1:52:01 the idea of the self is actually created or fabricated by the power dynamics.
1:52:05 So it's a fake thing that we've attached ourselves to somehow.
1:52:10 This idea of a self, it's not real.
1:52:13 But we find ourselves in a self anyway, so what should we do with that fact?
1:52:18 We should create ourselves as a work of art.
1:52:20 We should take this thing that was given to us, that we didn't have control over this
1:52:24 identity, this self, and we should make it our own by making it something else, something
1:52:30 uniquely us.
1:52:33 And that's what he means by living our lives like a work of art, considering ourself like
1:52:37 a work of art.
1:52:39 Something that we can change and transform in any way we want to make it something new
1:52:43 and novel.
1:52:44 And that's something that we have done.
1:52:46 That's something genuine now.
1:52:47 It's not part of the power dynamic.
1:52:49 It's something that has emerged from the power dynamic.
1:52:54 Something like that.
1:52:55 And I think Jordan Peterson would probably not have much to say on that.
1:52:58 I think that largely lines up.
1:53:02 Foucault says, I don't feel that it is necessary to know exactly what I am.
1:53:08 The main interest in life and work is to become someone else, and I think this is connected
1:53:14 to what he said about living his life like a work of art and thinking that that's how
1:53:18 we should treat our individuality as a work of art, as something that we can change and
1:53:22 morph it any way we want.
1:53:25 And you can see shadows of this philosophy in the political landscape today.
1:53:31 Is your body something that is your work of art that you can create and morph and change
1:53:38 in any way you want?
1:53:40 Is that something like being born a man and wanting to become a woman, like the transgender
1:53:47 debate today, let's say?
1:53:49 Is that something like the transhumanist people who don't want to be a human so that
1:53:53 they cut their tongue so it looks like a lizard and they put the green pigment in their skin
1:53:59 and all, you know, all the scarification that people do to make themselves look like something
1:54:04 else. They want to be something else. Isn't that what, what you see here from Foucault?
1:54:12 The main interest in life and work is to become someone else, he says. Remember, to Foucault,
1:54:18 whether we're talking about society or whether we're talking about your own self, individual,
1:54:22 and individually, that the goal was to create something new, to create from yourself something
1:54:29 new and novel to create order from chaos. That's what Jordan Peterson would say. Amazing.
1:54:37 All right. So Foucault says, we must uncover our rituals for what they are completely arbitrary
1:54:44 things tied to our bourgeois way of life. It is good to transcend them in the manner
1:54:50 of play by means of games and irony. It is good to be dirty and bearded to have a long
1:54:56 hair and to look like a girl when one is a boy and vice versa. One must put in play,
1:55:02 show up, transform and reverse the systems which quietly order us about. So you couldn't
1:55:09 really get a better insight into Foucault than this. When he says we have to uncover
1:55:14 our rituals, these are our accepted standards, our unquestioned traditions. He said we have
1:55:19 to figure out what they are. And he says that they're completely arbitrary, which I mean
1:55:27 And there's this first mistake right there.
1:55:29 They aren't completely arbitrary.
1:55:30 The things that are accepted standards and are unquestioned traditions have survived
1:55:36 all this time and have been unquestioned all this time because they work, because they're
1:55:41 necessary for us for one reason or another to help us navigate the world, you know, for
1:55:46 whatever reason they survive.
1:55:49 It's not arbitrary that they survive.
1:55:51 It's not arbitrary that people to this day continue to believe in God.
1:55:56 And those science has transcended what every single thing that God served historically.
1:56:05 So there's a reason.
1:56:06 It's not arbitrary.
1:56:08 To dismiss it is to say that there isn't a reason.
1:56:10 To dismiss it is to say it's not worth looking for the reason.
1:56:13 It's not worth arguing the reason.
1:56:15 That's the arrogance that we see in today's politics.
1:56:18 And it seems to go right back to Foucault when he says our rituals are completely arbitrary
1:56:24 things, tied to our bourgeois way of life. Come on, man. I mean, and again, you can see
1:56:34 the Marxist language there. The Marxist language is there. He says, it is good to transcend
1:56:40 them in a manner of play by means of games and irony. And if, come on, games and irony
1:56:46 is about right. That about encapsulates my experience of watching the news today. Games
1:56:53 an irony. That's about what it feels like. And then this idea, he says, it's good to
1:56:58 be dirty and bearded and to have long hair and to look like a girl when you're a boy
1:57:02 and to look like a boy when you're a girl. Why? Because what it does is it throws yourself
1:57:09 up in the face of tradition as an example of something that's not going to comply. And
1:57:16 then you're going to see what happens when you throw that chaos into the system, when
1:57:20 throw that wrench into the gears. And anything that comes out of that will be new. And to
1:57:25 Foucault that means good. But that's not always the case. And that I think is strike number
1:57:32 two for Foucault, not necessarily for postmodernism, but for Foucault's brand of postmodernism.
1:57:41 He says, he makes the constraints of power play spontaneously upon himself. He inscribed
1:57:49 in himself the power relation in which he simultaneously plays both roles.
1:57:54 He becomes the principal of his own subjugation.
1:57:58 So that last sentence you might read, he becomes the master of his own slave.
1:58:05 So this is just another example of this power dynamic internally, this unavoidable internal
1:58:11 power dynamic where he says the individual makes the constraints of power play spontaneously
1:58:18 upon himself.
1:58:19 He inscribes in himself the power relation which he simultaneously plays both roles.
1:58:26 So within yourself, you're both sides of the power dynamic, the master and the slave.
1:58:31 He says he becomes the principal, that's the master, of his own subjugation, of his
1:58:36 own slavery, that's all happening in the individual.
1:58:42 So power is imposed, according to Foucault, even from one's self against one's self.
1:58:49 the slaves to the constraints, we allow to be imposed on us, whether that's socially,
1:58:56 politically, interpersonally, or even a blind respect for convention or tradition, according
1:59:02 to Foucault.
1:59:03 So any of that stuff that we allow to hold us back or to constrain us is allowing us
1:59:10 to become a slave to ourself.
1:59:13 We are the power that's imposing power against ourself.
1:59:17 Now he talks about that like it's a bad thing and that it's completely a bad thing in every
1:59:25 respect.
1:59:27 And then I have to go back in my mind to this example of a little angel on one shoulder
1:59:32 and a devil on the other shoulder.
1:59:33 We all found ourselves in those moral conundrums from time to time where we're asking ourselves
1:59:38 to choose the good or the bad and we have to make that determination for ourselves.
1:59:48 I was losing my train here, guys. Hold on.
1:59:54 Oh, well, shoot.
1:59:56 I guess what I guess the point I was trying to make here is that
1:59:59 if you've got an angel on one shoulder and a devil on the other shoulder,
2:00:02 and you're trying to make a decision, following the path of the angel
2:00:08 or the path of the devil,
2:00:10 it doesn't make you a slave to the devil or a slave to the angel.
2:00:14 So you're the master who's making the decision one way or the other.
2:00:18 And I think Foucault is kind of making the same point when he says
2:00:21 that you're choosing, that too many people are choosing to be the slave instead of the master.
2:00:26 We're going with the devil instead of the angel.
2:00:30 And I can't really disagree with that.
2:00:32 But I do disagree with the idea that I'm putting myself in the position of the slave.
2:00:38 Because I get to be the person who chooses.
2:00:41 So again, I know that that's kind of the same point that Foucault is making when he says that we make ourselves master and slave.
2:00:48 I just don't know that the logic flows the way he thinks it does, but it's just another
2:00:55 good example of him painting this picture of how we sort of enslave ourselves and the
2:01:00 power dynamic is unavoidable.
2:01:02 It's even there in our own hearts and God, guys, you have to see how this language sounds
2:01:07 religious.
2:01:08 You've got to see how this language sounds religious, that this philosophy sounds religious
2:01:13 And Foucault, it's funny the way it looks to me now is that Foucault has put all of these
2:01:21 religious impulses that he has under the constraints of this political lens.
2:01:28 I'm smiling right now while I'm talking, I'm saying this. Foucault, the person who says that
2:01:33 we shouldn't, we should be tearing down all of the, all of the lenses that we're looking through
2:01:37 so that we can see the truth. We should tear down all these arbitrary walls and borders and
2:01:42 constraints so that we can be perfectly free. And all these great things can flow from us.
2:01:50 And all of that stuff he views from the he views from the lens of a political and social
2:01:58 being. And I have to point out for Foucault telling you and I that we shouldn't do that
2:02:07 it's exactly what he's done. He's chosen to be the slave of this political lens.
2:02:12 He's the master and slave both, just like he said, but he's chosen and maybe he doesn't
2:02:18 see that, to argue this completely from this sociopolitical lens.
2:02:23 And that, sir, Michelle, is a constraint, that is a constraint that you've put yourself
2:02:31 in.
2:02:32 Interesting.
2:02:34 All right, he says, there is no need for arms, physical violence, material constraints,
2:02:40 a gaze, an introspecting gaze, a gaze that each individual under its weight will end
2:02:46 by internalizing to the point that they are their own overseer.
2:02:51 Each individual thus exercising surveillance over and against themselves."
2:02:57 So here he's talking about how power is exercised against yourself.
2:03:01 And he said, look, there's not even really a need for arms and physical violence.
2:03:06 Try telling that to the political activists today, by the way.
2:03:10 He says, all that's needed is a gaze.
2:03:11 He said, all that's needed is consciousness of the idea.
2:03:15 And what you will do is internalize that.
2:03:19 And you'll become your own overseer.
2:03:21 And this is a word we already know.
2:03:23 We call it conscious.
2:03:26 Conscience, like Jiminy fucking cricket,
2:03:28 where our own overseer, of course we are.
2:03:30 And he's saying that that's all that you need.
2:03:33 And you can see that internal power dynamic there.
2:03:38 He says, thought.
2:03:39 Listen to this.
2:03:40 Thought cannot help but liberate or enslave.
2:03:45 Even before prescribing, suggesting a future,
2:03:48 saying what must be done, thought at the level of its existence
2:03:52 is in itself an action, a perilous act.
2:03:57 All right, so your eye should be very wide right now.
2:04:01 You should be just waiting for me to read that again
2:04:04 because you want to make sure you caught it,
2:04:06 what the fuck did Foucault just say?
2:04:08 He said, thought cannot help but to liberate or enslave a thought is dangerous.
2:04:14 He says a thought in itself is an action and a perilous action.
2:04:19 So it's like a warning against thinking.
2:04:24 So that should be an interesting thing coming from postmodernist.
2:04:27 That should be an interesting warning sign because he says that a thought will enslave
2:04:32 or liberate.
2:04:33 It's going to do one of one of those two things or maybe both.
2:04:36 And you can kind of understand what we mean because we talked earlier about ideas and
2:04:40 the power of an idea, like the idea of normal, how all you have to have is an idea and suddenly
2:04:45 that idea has all kinds of power.
2:04:48 And so I think what he's saying here is along those same lines, he's saying a thought can
2:04:54 liberate or enslave.
2:04:55 So be careful with what you think.
2:04:57 It's like even before you put a thought into practice or into action that even at the level
2:05:04 of its existence, the thought is a dangerous act.
2:05:12 So there's all sorts of places we can go here.
2:05:14 I agree that a thought is a dangerous act, that a thought is like a powerful potential
2:05:20 thing, that it can be put into action and it can demonstrate that power in the world.
2:05:28 It is like that.
2:05:30 It's also interesting to say that a thought is a dangerous and perilous act because it
2:05:35 It also reminds me of what we were saying earlier about ideas, that Foucault seems to
2:05:41 think ideas are like the way Jordan Peterson thinks objective reality is, or the way I think
2:05:45 objective reality is, but it exists in this state of potential.
2:05:49 It's this undefined infinite potential, this thing that I call God.
2:05:53 And that's what ideas are.
2:05:55 They're also just a phony facade, a word that references this infinite pool of meaning
2:06:01 and potential.
2:06:03 And so any thought, any idea is a reference to that.
2:06:10 And that is dangerous, just like we said with the idea, if I pull out a word, a concept,
2:06:14 and I assume that this thing, I pull a little bit of this Terminator 2 substance, this infinite
2:06:21 potential, and I attach it to this word, that that is a dangerous act.
2:06:26 Because I have this thing that has infinite meaning, and I'm pretending that it means
2:06:31 this limited thing in reality, it's that it's potential. It's that
2:06:37 Terminator 2 substance. It's our objective reality. It's something
2:06:42 way more powerful than we think it is. It's more than it seems to be, as Jordan
2:06:49 Peterson would say. A thought is more than it seems to be. I just think that's
2:06:54 very interesting and it corresponds to this mystic idea of being that
2:07:01 Jordan and I and young and some others agree with and here we are right from
2:07:07 Foucault's mouth. All right so we're winding down here let me read a couple
2:07:11 more. He says people know what they do. Frequently they know why they do what
2:07:17 they do but what they don't know is what what they do does. Okay so this is
2:07:23 interesting. This is the idea of the individual's role in the group and remember
2:07:29 to postmodernist, the group and to Foucault, the group is the important piece. He's saying
2:07:35 here that people often they know what they're doing and they know why they're doing what
2:07:40 they're doing. But what they don't know is what all of that stuff they're doing is actually
2:07:44 doing. And the idea is they don't know what it's doing in the wider world. They don't
2:07:48 know what it's doing to the group. They don't know what it's doing to our future prospects
2:07:53 and what's going to happen. You know, what limits we put on ourselves today are going
2:07:58 to change the trajectory of the future. Something like that. It doesn't take much. We're not
2:08:05 going to let ourselves go any further right than this. We're not going to let ourselves
2:08:07 go any further left than this. And you can just project that path on into the future.
2:08:12 You can see how those limitations are going to change the trajectory of our path. So,
2:08:20 he's basically saying that we as individuals are going around living our lives, acting
2:08:25 in the world, and what's happening is on a macro level, the group is doing something
2:08:31 that we don't know.
2:08:33 It's like the human species is progressing in a certain direction, it's headed in a certain
2:08:40 to a certain goal, and we don't know what it is.
2:08:44 We're acting it out in the world, but we don't know really what this broader, higher-level
2:08:50 trajectory is.
2:08:52 It's like the cells in our body.
2:08:54 They don't really know what we are doing at this level.
2:08:57 They're just going around doing what a cell does.
2:09:00 Being conscious of that life, of that existence, of that experience.
2:09:03 They have no idea what the greater body is doing.
2:09:07 And that's the analogy here.
2:09:09 That there is a spiritual religious connotation that gets placed on the group.
2:09:17 the group is this, um, the individual is subordinate to this greater collective, you
2:09:28 know, and it's something that has an identity and a will, remember, he called it a political
2:09:33 will, all of, all in of its own that we participate in, but don't control. So this, this group,
2:09:40 you can kind of imagine this group, whatever that is, we can abstract that and make it
2:09:45 out like he said before, the power dynamic.
2:09:50 So to Foucault, you have the group.
2:09:52 And the group is this supernatural creature
2:09:54 made up of all the other individual things
2:09:56 that are just fabricated by the power dynamic anyway,
2:10:02 our individuality is fake, composed by the power dynamic.
2:10:05 The group is the important bit that the group is the colony
2:10:09 and we're the ants, that kind of a thing.
2:10:11 And so you get this idea, this abstracted idea
2:10:14 where the power dynamic really does start to look like God
2:10:17 behind the scenes.
2:10:19 I just can't help but point that out.
2:10:22 And again, I believe that thing we're calling God
2:10:27 as consciousness.
2:10:29 Consciousness is where thoughts and ideas come from.
2:10:32 And that's what Foucault is saying
2:10:34 are dangerous and powerful thoughts and ideas.
2:10:42 All right, so this whole quote here about people
2:10:45 knowing what they're doing or why they're doing it, but the group still kind of does its thing,
2:10:50 that this quote presumes that the individuals are doing something collectively, that they're
2:10:55 acting as a single organism somehow, and that we're completely blind to that. That's the will
2:11:01 of God. We don't know what that is, but His will be done, right? We don't know what that is.
2:11:05 It also implies that the meaning of our existence and the value of our actions and
2:11:09 accomplishments, they rest in our collective identity rather than in our individual ones.
2:11:15 Alright, so Foucault says, do you imagine that I would take so much trouble and make so
2:11:22 much pleasure in writing if I were not preparing a labyrinth into which I can move my discourse
2:11:28 in which I can lose myself and appear at last to eyes that I will never have to meet?
2:11:34 I am no doubt not the only one who writes in order to have no face.
2:11:39 Do not ask who I am.
2:11:41 Do not ask me to remain the same.
2:11:45 I'm going to read one more that goes along with this.
2:11:48 He says, I don't write a book so that it will be the final word.
2:11:52 I write a book so that other books are possible.
2:11:57 So these are the last two that I want to talk about as far as Foucault's conception of the
2:12:01 self or the individual because these two pieces are really interesting to me.
2:12:07 When he says, he says, look, do you know why I write?
2:12:11 Do you know why I enjoy writing so much?
2:12:13 He says, it's because I am preparing a labyrinth into which I can move my ideas.
2:12:19 It's like I'm creating this space, this hypothetical academic thought space with my ideas in it.
2:12:29 And every time someone picks up my book and reads my words, this is what's happening.
2:12:33 They're going to be existing in this place that I've created, that where people can tackle
2:12:39 my ideas and engage with these ideas.
2:12:42 And he says, in which I can lose myself and appear at last to eyes I will never have to
2:12:47 meet.
2:12:48 talking about speaking to you across time.
2:12:51 Foucault is dead.
2:12:53 He's doing that right now through me, right?
2:12:57 He says, I am no doubt the only,
2:12:59 not the only one who writes in order to have no face.
2:13:03 So he doesn't want this to be,
2:13:06 his ideas, he doesn't want this,
2:13:07 his ideas to be associated with him.
2:13:09 He wants his ideas to participate in the political will.
2:13:13 He wants to have no face.
2:13:14 It's not about the individual.
2:13:16 It's not about him.
2:13:17 That's what he wants you to know.
2:13:18 It's about his contribution to the political will.
2:13:23 And everybody who's still living
2:13:24 is participating in that political will.
2:13:26 And every time you read Foucault, you know,
2:13:28 he's contributed to this.
2:13:29 And he's given you this path of critique
2:13:33 and deconstruction to use, to continue that work.
2:13:37 He says, do not ask who I am,
2:13:39 and do not ask me to remain the same.
2:13:42 So he doesn't wanna get, he doesn't wanna get,
2:13:44 even with his own words.
2:13:45 Remember, to Foucault, the meaning of words
2:13:48 always changing and disappearing. He doesn't even want his words to be the end
2:13:53 all be all. He doesn't want his words and his concepts and his ideas to remain
2:13:57 static either. He doesn't want to remain the same. He wants people to pick up
2:14:02 this torch and to take it and to make it become something else. He wants you
2:14:07 to take postmodernism and make it the next thing. Maybe that's what I'm doing
2:14:11 right now. I don't know. Alright, here's a couple other bits that I want to talk
2:14:16 about. He has this, he talks about this desire to have no face. That reminds me of Game of Thrones,
2:14:22 by the way. For those of you who see that, his desire to have no face reminds me of the desire
2:14:29 for an ego death to have no face means to have no identity to not not to be an individual anymore.
2:14:37 And to Foucault, because the group is more is the is the important unit to have no face to not be
2:14:44 an individual to sink into the collective and become the group.
2:14:49 That's what he means.
2:14:50 That seems to be what he means here.
2:14:52 And that sounds like an ego death.
2:14:54 It sounds like a mystic experience.
2:14:56 It sounds like becoming one with the universe, only to Foucault's to become one with the
2:15:00 power dynamic, to become one with the political will.
2:15:04 That's what he wants.
2:15:06 That is a religious experience that Foucault is chasing, even though he doesn't know it.
2:15:11 Isn't that amazing?
2:15:13 Ah, man, does nobody ever notice that before?
2:15:17 His desire to have no face, to not exist as an individual, but to become part of the
2:15:22 collective?
2:15:23 Foucault sees his ideas as a disembodied force of influence on the collective consciousness
2:15:29 of society.
2:15:31 He plays a role and influences what the collective will become, but in a way, takes no credit.
2:15:38 Strange that he should think so when his faceless, quote, contribution to the collective can
2:15:42 easily be seen as a power that he is exerting for his own ends.
2:15:49 So there's a little bit of a self-contradiction there that Foucault wants to blend into the
2:15:57 collective and be a part of this political will, but he still wants his ideas there.
2:16:03 He wants to create this space for his ideas to exist and to be encountered.
2:16:09 That seems to be a little different from bleeding in and becoming one with a universe, becoming
2:16:14 one with the power dynamic.
2:16:16 All right.
2:16:19 So this bit he says about he writes books so that other books are possible.
2:16:24 This just reminds me again of the idea of about creating the new or the novel that that
2:16:29 that is to Foucault seems to be the goal of existence to plant the seed of something new
2:16:34 to arise in others in the future.
2:16:38 the contribution that each of us to the ideas that will emerge in the future. And the power
2:16:45 those ideas hold over us. But towards what exactly? Towards some new occurrence, some
2:16:52 new reality. And it is the newness, it's the novelty of what might be that constitutes
2:16:58 its desirability and its value according to Foucault. Now I think that's short-sighted.
2:17:06 I think that there's a lot of convergence here between what Jordan Peterson would say
2:17:11 and what Foucault was saying about the new and the novel, about participating in the
2:17:15 act of creation, about that being something that is a part of our essence as God, as the
2:17:23 creator, as a conscious creature.
2:17:26 That's what I would say.
2:17:27 That's the frame I would put it in.
2:17:29 That that is good to see what new can be born, what more can be brought forth from the logos,
2:17:35 more of this infinite potentiality can be made manifest, can be embodied in the world,
2:17:40 that I think is the purpose of life and in existence, and it is a religious one, and
2:17:45 it's lining up with what Foucault is saying.
2:17:49 I think that's interesting.
2:17:50 I think that's very interesting, but I do think it's short-sighted for Foucault to think
2:17:56 that something that is new is good.
2:18:00 I don't know that that's always true.
2:18:04 And he never seems to tackle that eventuality.
2:18:10 All right, just a couple of pieces on government
2:18:11 because there's actually precious little
2:18:15 that I think goes directly to politics for government
2:18:18 that comes out of Foucault's mouth,
2:18:20 which I was a little bit surprised by.
2:18:22 But I wanna read you just to wrap this up,
2:18:24 a couple of things that I did find.
2:18:27 First, firstly, he says,
2:18:30 a stupid despot may constrain his slaves with iron chains, but a true politician binds them
2:18:37 even more strongly by the chains of their own ideas. On the soft fibers of the brain
2:18:44 is founded at the unshakable base of the soundest empires. So this is interesting. This is saying
2:18:52 that, this is saying that if you want to rule people, if you want to be a politician and
2:18:59 rule the masses. If you want to embody the power dynamic and try to wield it for good,
2:19:06 he's saying that the dumb person does it with slaves and iron chains. The dumb person does it
2:19:14 overtly so that everybody can see out in the open. He says a true politician binds them ever
2:19:21 more strongly by the chains of their own ideas. So you make it sound like it's their idea. You
2:19:27 you make it sound like it's their identity.
2:19:29 You help them to attach themselves to those ideas
2:19:32 and you will be able to rule them
2:19:34 without them even realizing it.
2:19:37 Something like that.
2:19:38 So ideas are very powerful.
2:19:41 They're that powerful to Foucault.
2:19:43 And he's not wrong.
2:19:45 He's not wrong about that.
2:19:49 All right, he says in his next quote,
2:19:51 why am I so interested in politics?
2:19:54 Ooh, that's a great question.
2:19:55 I would like to know the same, Foucault.
2:19:57 Why are you so interested in politics?"
2:20:00 He says, but if I were to answer you very simply,
2:20:02 I would say this, why shouldn't I be interested?
2:20:06 That is to say, what blindness, what deafness,
2:20:09 what density of ideology would have to weigh me down
2:20:12 to prevent me from being interested
2:20:13 in what is probably the most crucial subject
2:20:16 of our existence.
2:20:17 That is to say, the society in which we live,
2:20:20 the economic relations within which we function,
2:20:23 and the system of power which defines
2:20:25 the regular forms, permissions, and prohibitions
2:20:27 of our conduct.
2:20:29 All right, there's a little bit more to this,
2:20:30 but hold the fucking horses, sir.
2:20:34 I want to read this again, this last sentence where he says,
2:20:38 he says, what blindness, deafness,
2:20:40 denseness of ideology would weigh me down
2:20:42 to prevent me from being interested in, quote,
2:20:44 what is probably the most crucial subject of our existence?
2:20:48 What is that crucial subject of our existence?
2:20:51 He says, the society in which we live,
2:20:54 the economic relations in which we function
2:20:55 and the system of power that defines our conduct.
2:20:59 Is that really the most crucial subject of our existence?
2:21:05 How we live?
2:21:07 What we're allowed to do in our time on earth?
2:21:10 What we permit from each other?
2:21:13 I mean, in the power that we exert against one another,
2:21:17 that's the most crucial subject of our existence.
2:21:21 I mean, Jesus Christ, ask somebody, ask somebody the meaning of their life, the most meaningful
2:21:28 things in their life, the most meaningful concerns they have about their existence.
2:21:34 How much of those have to do with power struggles between individuals or groups?
2:21:39 How much of that has to do with questioning what we're allowed to do or what we're not
2:21:43 allowed to do?
2:21:45 Very, very little, right?
2:21:47 It has to do with our interactions with each other.
2:21:49 has to do with, you know, the satisfaction we have that we get from our, from our day
2:21:53 to day, you know, our individual goals and things like that. It has nothing to do, very,
2:21:59 very precious little to do with society and culture at the highest levels. And Foucault
2:22:06 saying, that is, that is the most crucial subject to our existence. I'm not so sure,
2:22:11 Then he goes on to say this, the essence of our life consists, after all, of the political
2:22:19 functioning of the society in which we find ourselves.
2:22:25 What?
2:22:26 The essence of our life, do you think the essence of your life consists in the political functioning
2:22:33 of the society that you live?
2:22:35 I mean, fuck off, Foucault.
2:22:38 You could pick me up and drop me off
2:22:41 in a completely other society.
2:22:44 Or even better yet, you can pick me up
2:22:46 and put me on a desert island
2:22:47 with no other human beings alive.
2:22:49 There is no society, there's only me.
2:22:52 There is nobody giving me permission
2:22:54 or prohibiting what I can do.
2:22:57 It's only me there, right?
2:22:59 There's still that power dynamic
2:23:01 even within me that you described,
2:23:02 but I'm on a desert island now.
2:23:04 Is the essence of my life, then, the political functioning of the society I live in?
2:23:11 I think my life still has quite an important essence, even all by myself on a desert island
2:23:16 with no society or government, thank you very much.
2:23:20 That's the kind of short-sightedness that I'm talking about.
2:23:22 That's the constraint that Foucault has placed himself under.
2:23:27 That is the master to which Foucault is the slave, and he's been warning us not to do
2:23:33 this whole time. And this is what he's done. And it reminds me again of Anicha,
2:23:41 who's supposed to be such a big influence on Foucault. Anicha said,
2:23:45 Socrates is ugly to undermine all of Socrates's ideas about a world of
2:23:50 forms where appearances don't matter. Here's what I'm going to be doing the
2:23:56 same thing here. I'm going to take a cue from Anicha and I'm going to ask
2:23:59 Foucault. Again, he's not ugly exactly, not the same critique as Socrates, but he is telling
2:24:07 us to tear down the walls, to not listen to authority, to not to buck traditions, to find
2:24:13 our individuality in those places we've been told not to go. And then he very neatly pushes
2:24:22 all of that stuff into a little box, into this political and social box that he's operating
2:24:28 within. And that's exactly what he told us not to do. And I think it's what's keeping
2:24:34 him from seeing his own religious impulses in his own philosophy. Like all of this stuff
2:24:41 he's doing here, he's doing to answer a question, a religious question about his own instinct.
2:24:46 And he's so steeped and deep in this political and social, you know, web that he can't see
2:24:55 can't see the truth of it. I just want to read this last line again. The essence of
2:25:01 our life consists, after all, of the political functioning of the society in
2:25:04 which we find ourselves. And he says it like a matter of fact. Jesus, does anybody
2:25:10 believe that? And what would it mean if it were true that we yearn for an identity
2:25:16 greater than ourselves? I can go with that. That's a religious impulse. But is
2:25:22 Is that the entity, the society or government,
2:25:27 is that the entity that we wanna merge into?
2:25:29 Not a chance, not a chance, not a chance.
2:25:34 All right, so he's got a couple others here
2:25:38 that are interesting along the same lines.
2:25:39 He says this, the first task of the doctor is political.
2:25:44 Let me say that again.
2:25:46 And actually, I would shout out Dr. Fauci,
2:25:49 but he knows this already.
2:25:50 The first task of the doctor is political.
2:25:53 The struggle against disease must begin with a war against bad government.
2:25:58 Man will be totally and definitively cured only if he is first liberated.
2:26:04 So Foucault is made even the practice of medicine political.
2:26:07 What's the implication here?
2:26:10 What everybody's doing, whether they know it or not, even in their professions, even
2:26:15 their interpersonal relationships, everything you're doing is a political struggle. It should be a
2:26:21 political struggle. He also says, and the good ruler is precisely the one who exercises his power
2:26:28 as it ought to be exercised. That is, simultaneously exercising his power over himself. And it is
2:26:34 the power over oneself that thus regulates one power over others. Okay, this is one of those weird
2:26:41 flip-flop moments that I keep pointing to, where now the individual is coming into focus
2:26:47 as the important factor, no longer the group, no longer that desire to fade into the collective.
2:26:53 Now he's saying that the good ruler is one who exercises power over himself,
2:26:59 and it is that power that regulates his power over others. So I kind of like that idea. I think
2:27:07 as a ruler, you should be master over your instincts and impulses, and to the extent possible,
2:27:12 You should be rational and the master over yourself.
2:27:14 You shouldn't be making rash decisions.
2:27:16 You shouldn't be quick to anger.
2:27:17 You should be contemplative.
2:27:19 And that's all good qualities for a leader to have.
2:27:26 You should have to be able to regulate power over yourself
2:27:29 before you could be responsible for regulating
2:27:33 the power dynamic over society.
2:27:35 Absolutely.
2:27:37 Think about the leaders in the world that you know about today.
2:27:40 Think about the Justin Trudeau's, the Joe Biden's, the Kim Jong-un's.
2:27:44 Think about the political leaders today.
2:27:48 Do any of those people strike you as somebody that has power over themselves,
2:27:54 that has themselves contained, that regulates themselves?
2:27:59 Well, those are the leaders that Foucault's pointing to is bad.
2:28:06 They need to have the ability of self-control and self-discipline.
2:28:11 They need to be able to control the power dynamic within themselves to be trusted, to
2:28:16 do anything similar to that, you know, on the cultural level or the societal level.
2:28:21 I'm not sure we have any leaders like that right now.
2:28:25 Not sure.
2:28:26 I don't think Donald Trump is one of them either.
2:28:29 All right.
2:28:30 Lastly, in this vein, he says, because they claim to be concerned with the welfare of
2:28:34 whole societies, governments irrigate to themselves the right to pass off as mere abstract profit
2:28:41 or loss, the human unhappiness that their decisions provoke or their negligence permits.
2:28:47 It is a duty of an international citizenship to always bring the testimony of people suffering
2:28:52 to the eyes and ears of governments, sufferings for which it is untrue that they are not responsible.
2:28:59 The suffering of men must never be a mere silent residue of policy.
2:29:03 It grounds an absolute right to stand up and speak to those who hold power.
2:29:10 So there's things in this that I like and things in this that I don't and you probably
2:29:13 feel the same way.
2:29:15 You do think that people should be able to speak critically to power.
2:29:21 People should have a voice to speak up against the authority.
2:29:24 That is important and that's what that's what he says.
2:29:27 It grounds an absolute right to stand up and speak to those who hold power.
2:29:31 So I agree with that.
2:29:33 But there's some shit in here I do not agree with and you see how he let's slip under
2:29:38 the radar.
2:29:39 to you again. He says that governments can pass off as, as abstract profit or loss, the
2:29:48 their decisions that provoke or their excuse me, okay, excuse me. He's talking about human
2:29:56 happiness. He said, let me just start over because this is a mess. Governments arrogant
2:29:59 to themselves the right to pass off as mere abstract profit or loss. Human unhappiness
2:30:05 that their decisions provoke or their negligence permits.
2:30:10 So let me just stop here and say this differently.
2:30:14 What Foucault was saying is that human unhappiness
2:30:18 is caused by the decisions of the government.
2:30:24 And he says the government just writes it off
2:30:26 as abstract profit or loss,
2:30:28 but that human unhappiness that their decisions provoke
2:30:32 or their negligence permits.
2:30:34 So either they did something that made us unhappy,
2:30:37 or it's something that they should have done
2:30:38 and didn't do that's made us unhappy.
2:30:40 Ultimately, it's the society or the government's fault
2:30:44 that you as an individual are unhappy.
2:30:47 Bullshit, Foucault, I'm gonna say that.
2:30:51 Then he goes on, he says,
2:30:52 it is a duty of an international citizenship,
2:30:54 and an international citizenship is a lefty thing to say,
2:30:58 but there it is, to always bring the testimony
2:31:00 of people suffering to the eyes and ears of governments.
2:31:03 Okay, fine, you know, there's like some sort of catastrophe,
2:31:09 human rights violation going on in some other country.
2:31:11 Yes, people should bring that to everyone's attention.
2:31:14 It should be something that we,
2:31:15 that when there's something terrible happening,
2:31:18 that the society at large,
2:31:20 even the global society at large,
2:31:22 should have something to say about.
2:31:24 We can't sit idly by and let terrible shit happen.
2:31:26 I get that, but he says,
2:31:28 sufferings for which it's untrue
2:31:31 that they are not responsible.
2:31:34 Let me read this whole sentence again.
2:31:36 It is a duty of an international citizenship
2:31:38 to always bring the testimony of people
2:31:40 suffering to the eyes and ears of government,
2:31:43 suffering for which it's untrue they are not responsible.
2:31:46 So the end of that is yes,
2:31:48 we definitely wanna bring people suffering to light,
2:31:50 we wanna resolve it where we can,
2:31:52 we wanna shame people where we can
2:31:54 if they're doing something wrong,
2:31:55 that all makes sense that we have that impulse.
2:31:57 But then he's saying that it's untrue
2:31:59 the government is not responsible for them.
2:32:01 So again, he's saying, it's not just about, you know,
2:32:05 bringing the light travesties of justice.
2:32:08 It's also about holding the society
2:32:10 and government responsible for them, full stop.
2:32:15 Doesn't matter what the suffering is,
2:32:16 it's the government's fault.
2:32:19 And he said, we should never be silent about that.
2:32:22 What do you think?
2:32:23 Are things always the government's fault?
2:32:24 Are they always society's fault?
2:32:26 Is it systemic racism that's the problem?
2:32:28 Is it the system that's doing it?
2:32:29 or is it individuals?
2:32:31 Is it individuals?
2:32:35 So the achievement of our individual happiness
2:32:37 is the role of government, apparently, WTF,
2:32:39 that's what I have to say.
2:32:41 And I made a little note here.
2:32:42 And he thinks there are some holes
2:32:44 in the foundation of Foucault's philosophical bedrock.
2:32:47 Why would the individual be responsible
2:32:48 for creating themselves and their lives
2:32:51 as their own personal expression of art, as Foucault said?
2:32:54 But the individual offloads their happiness
2:32:56 and suffering to society.
2:32:59 So it doesn't that sound like a fucking contradiction.
2:33:01 It's my role to use my individuality
2:33:05 to create something new.
2:33:07 That's something I can do as an expression of individuality.
2:33:11 But if I'm unhappy or suffering,
2:33:13 that's not something I have to do with.
2:33:14 That's something I can just point fingers
2:33:16 at the society and the government.
2:33:22 That's what I have to say to you, Foucault.
2:33:24 All right, here's my conclusion.
2:33:26 There's a quote that I'll read in conclusion, two of them actually.
2:33:30 One of them says, as the archeology of our thought easily shows, man is an invention
2:33:35 of recent date and one perhaps nearing its end.
2:33:39 So that sounds a little creepy.
2:33:41 Man is one is an idea that's nearing its end.
2:33:44 He's not saying man is a species is nearing its end.
2:33:48 He's saying man is an idea, is an invention, is nearing its end.
2:33:54 And that should scare you.
2:33:55 It's not an apocalypse, but what he's saying here is that the individual is a concept.
2:34:01 It's getting sucked into that black hole we talked about.
2:34:04 That's an individual is a concept that's dangerous, whose meaning is beginning to fade,
2:34:11 that it has to be removed and replaced by something better, something like the group.
2:34:17 That should scare you.
2:34:19 Lastly, he says, curiosity evokes concern.
2:34:23 It evokes the care one takes for what exists and could exist, a readiness to find strange
2:34:28 and singular what surrounds us, a certain restlessness to break up our familiarities
2:34:34 and to regard others the same, a casualness in regard to the traditional hierarchies of
2:34:39 the importance and the essential of the important and the essential.
2:34:43 I dream of a new age of curiosity.
2:34:45 So this is good.
2:34:46 I dream of a new age of curiosity.
2:34:49 We have the technical means for it.
2:34:51 The desire is there.
2:34:52 things to be known or infinite. The people who can employ themselves at this task exist.
2:34:58 Why do we suffer? From too little. From the channels that are too narrow, skimpy, quasi-monopolistic,
2:35:05 insufficient. There is no point in adopting a protectionist attitude to prevent bad information
2:35:10 from invading and suffocating the good. Rather, we must multiply the paths and the possibilities
2:35:16 of comings and goings.
2:35:20 So this is similar to what he said before, you know, he's saying like I dream of a new
2:35:24 age of curiosity where all these new things are going to be able to come into existence.
2:35:28 Remember the novel, bringing in new things into being that have never existed before.
2:35:32 That's the ultimate goal for Foucault.
2:35:36 And he says there's no need to protect ourselves from the bad ideas, even though he made lots
2:35:41 of arguments earlier about how powerful and risky ideas are.
2:35:44 He says, there's no point in adopting a protectionist attitude to prevent bad information.
2:35:49 What we should do instead is multiply the paths of comings and goings.
2:35:53 He's like, what we should do is have new ideas.
2:35:56 We should facilitate them.
2:35:58 We should have all these new synthesis and cross paths with people that think differently,
2:36:03 and we should create all this newness from that.
2:36:09 And I ask you, in today's postmodern culture, is that what we're doing?
2:36:17 I mean efforts to prevent bad information.
2:36:21 That's what we see.
2:36:22 We see de-platforming, the word misinformation, fact-checking everywhere.
2:36:27 We're trying to shut down paths of coming and going, as Foucault would say.
2:36:31 We're trying to leave just one path.
2:36:38 And here, again, they're George Washington, Michelle Foucault, he's telling us that's
2:36:44 not what we should be doing.
2:36:47 So after reading Foucault, it seems to me that the communist and collectivist ideas that
2:36:51 that have become so tied to postmodernism
2:36:53 and its influence in the political realm,
2:36:56 they're a sort of bastardization of his philosophy.
2:37:00 It reminds me of the turn the other cheek
2:37:02 and love your enemy as yourself Christian,
2:37:04 who judges all of their acquaintances, friends,
2:37:07 and strangers as harshly as possible,
2:37:09 all the while holding themselves up as superior,
2:37:12 that kind of bastardization.
2:37:15 The same kind of thing we see with Muslim extremists
2:37:18 who pick and choose the passages from the Quran
2:37:20 that justify their hatred and violence
2:37:22 and ignore all of the others.
2:37:25 That kind of bastardization.
2:37:28 It seems to me that what Foucault wants more than anything
2:37:31 is to fulfill our collective instinct
2:37:33 to construct our identity
2:37:35 and to construct the world around us.
2:37:39 So Jordan Peterson spoke about this in maps of meaning
2:37:41 through the works of Jean Piaget
2:37:43 who described our our orienting reflex
2:37:46 and how it allows us through lived experience
2:37:49 to simultaneously construct ourself and the subjective world.
2:37:53 We literally build up our perceptions of ourself
2:37:56 and reality from the information we gain through experience.
2:38:01 And reality gets more and more complex
2:38:03 in concert with our own maturation.
2:38:06 The world becomes more complex as we become more complex.
2:38:11 Foucault wants to see just how much we can construct
2:38:15 and just how complex we in the world can become,
2:38:19 if we put our collective minds to it.
2:38:22 It's a noble and optimistic hope,
2:38:24 but it's also naive and arrogant.
2:38:28 It is noble in the sense that bringing something new
2:38:31 into the world is noble.
2:38:32 Order from chaos, as Jordan would say.
2:38:35 This is also a very obvious religious impulse
2:38:38 to participate in the act of creation, to be as God is.
2:38:43 It is noble to see just what we can create,
2:38:45 like the reference Foucault makes to our individual lives as an expression of art.
2:38:50 But it is naive in the presumption that bringing something new into the world is necessarily
2:38:55 good, and that you can make that determination all by yourself.
2:39:01 And then there's the emphasis on power, which isn't nearly as obvious and ubiquitous as
2:39:05 Foucault presumes, but even if we go with him on this, there is a contradiction in his
2:39:10 philosophy that remains unreconciled, and constitutes a critical flaw as far as I can
2:39:15 see it. You see Foucault puts the power dynamic within every individual. The
2:39:22 oppression of his soul or consciousness over his body and explains this as a
2:39:26 self-generating process. It's what creates your identity according to Foucault. So
2:39:31 the power struggle within gives birth to the individual who then continues the
2:39:36 power struggle with others. And just as the struggle within creates the
2:39:40 individual, the struggle between individuals creates the collective. It is
2:39:46 the collective that Foucault puts in the place of God and suggests that we
2:39:50 should lose ourselves within it. And doing so we lose our individuality but we
2:39:55 get to participate in something larger and more meaningful. The course of
2:40:00 history or the fate of the universe. The political will or the power dynamic as
2:40:06 as Foucault would say.
2:40:08 But if the power dynamic is the generative force, the force that turns out individuals
2:40:13 and moves within the collective, then why would Foucault wish to track down and destroy
2:40:19 it?
2:40:20 Didn't he say that to bring the novel into being is our purpose, to make ourselves
2:40:25 in the world forever new?
2:40:28 So why, oh why, would you wish to destroy the power dynamic?
2:40:33 If the power dynamic goes away, there is no more generative power.
2:40:38 Nothing moves, nothing changes, nothing new ever emerges.
2:40:43 Finally, I can just point out that the power dynamic, seen as a disembodied force that
2:40:49 permeates reality and controls its development, is identical to the idea of God.
2:40:57 You do see that, right?
2:40:59 to destroy the power dynamic is equivalent to the Nietzschean death of God, and Foucault
2:41:05 was a student of Nietzsche. Didn't he understand the point that Nietzsche was making? If the
2:41:13 modern proponents of postmodernism are the measure, I guess not.
2:41:33 It's hard and full of uncertainties, but I'm grateful for the company as we trek through this together.
2:41:40 Here's to hoping that the juice is worth the squeeze. See what I did there?
2:41:45 Let's find out together in the next episode.