Skip to main content

The Two Tongues Podcast

← All episodes

The Two Tongues Podcast

Last Days of a Philosopher Part 2 – Immortality

S2E24 · May 13, 2022 · 85 min

Watch

YouTube: Coming soon

Show notes

This episode picks up where we left off, right after Sir Humpry Davy tells us his crazy sci-fi revelation of traveling to space with a sun-being and observing the beings existing on other planets. Here we introduce a mysterious stranger who adds a scientific filter for Davys vision. They discuss sentience and matter, god and man, how they exist and in what relationship until bit by bit a theory of Panpsychism emerges.

Full transcript

Machine-generated transcript; names and terms may contain errors.

0:00:03 Welcome, everyone, to the Two Tungs Podcast.

0:00:09 Consider this your invitation to join Kyle and Chris

0:00:13 on a journey through our minds,

0:00:16 where we explore the questions that have fascinated us

0:00:21 for as long as we can remember.

0:00:24 Could anarchy actually work?

0:00:26 Does God exist?

0:00:28 And just how did the cosmos get here anyway?

0:00:32 Let me be the Virgil to your Dante, the Sacagawea to your Lewis and Clark.

0:00:39 Let's take the guided tour through the dark chambers of our unconscious,

0:00:44 seeking answers to the most important and unsettled questions of our shared existence.

0:00:51 Ready or not, here we go.

0:00:54 Here we go indeed.

0:01:01 Oh, welcome back.

0:01:03 one and all to another episode of the two-tongues podcast Chris coming at you

0:01:08 two days late and I guess two dollars short two dollars short this week I really

0:01:14 like to stick with a Wednesday release for these today is Friday so got really

0:01:19 busy man got really busy but here I am I'm nice I could have saved this one for

0:01:24 next week but we'll get something I'll see you next week today well you know

0:01:31 Before I tell you what we're going to talk about today, although you know because you already

0:01:36 clicked on the video and saw the podcast, rather than saw the title, we're talking about Sir

0:01:42 Humphrey Davie again, the book that he wrote before he died called The Last Days of a Philosopher.

0:01:49 If you remember, when we talked about that in the first part, I think we're going to end up with

0:01:54 one more of these, so it'll be a three-part series. But in the first part, we talked about

0:01:58 Humphrey Davy, the great scientist, the guy that invented the Davy lamp, the guy

0:02:04 that was the president of the Royal Society of England, had the same role as

0:02:08 Sir Isaac Newton. Oh, and by the way, Humphrey Davy was a knight as well, like

0:02:12 Sir Isaac Newton, and you might wonder if you're American, you might wonder what

0:02:17 kind of an honor that is, and you know, being a knight, being knighted by the

0:02:22 king or the queen. But it's only happened to two academics in the history of the

0:02:28 English monarchy. Once for Isaac Newton, we all know how important he was and once

0:02:35 for Sir Humphrey Davy. And this is the guy we're talking about. So this is a

0:02:39 well, well respected scientist. He has a tremendous amount of credentials and

0:02:48 contributions. And this is the guy that before he died wrote the craziest book I

0:02:54 I may have ever read. It reminded me reading the vision, the first chapter that we already talked

0:03:00 about, reminded me of reading the book of Revelation for the first time when I was a teenager,

0:03:04 like just completely incomprehensible, completely mysterious, completely powerful.

0:03:12 And that's what you get from Humphrey Davey. And you might, you definitely didn't expect it.

0:03:17 You know, if you'd read everything Humphrey Davey had published up to this last book,

0:03:21 you never would have expected it. So I won't take too much of my thunder away from the introduction.

0:03:29 I've prepared, but I do want to say one other thing, and that is the two-tongues podcast

0:03:36 officially has a website, the twotonguespodcast.com. Check it out. I'm pretty excited about it.

0:03:43 I don't know if Kyle has enough to ask him on Sunday, but I'm pretty excited about it.

0:03:47 It makes me feel like we're a little bit more legit now, got a spot on the old internet.

0:03:54 It's not like you couldn't find us there, but now we have a place where you can go.

0:03:58 All of the latest episodes will be there.

0:04:00 We'll have a blog there.

0:04:01 We'll have a place where you can message the podcast.

0:04:05 So if somebody wants to be a guest or there's something you want to ask or what have you,

0:04:09 there'll be a place where you can do that.

0:04:11 There is a place where you can do that.

0:04:13 You can go there right now.

0:04:14 All right, so with the highlights out of the way,

0:04:18 this is the last days of a philosopher part two.

0:04:22 I'm calling this one immortality.

0:04:27 All right, I'm just gonna jump into my prepared intro.

0:04:30 Here we go.

0:04:32 Where we left off was the vision from the Colosseum.

0:04:38 Davey recounts his tale of revelation,

0:04:40 how he traveled to the heavens,

0:04:42 accompanied by a higher being

0:04:44 who showed him the expanse of outer space,

0:04:48 the planets, stars, and comets.

0:04:52 He showed him the beings that exist on each planet

0:04:56 and explained how they were once earthlings too,

0:04:59 but have ascended spiritually

0:05:01 and been reborn on a higher plane of consciousness.

0:05:04 And that's the crazy part.

0:05:06 It's this higher plane of existence.

0:05:08 Davey sees as the other planets in our solar system

0:05:12 and beyond.

0:05:13 So there's this really obvious thread of like a reincarnation type of idea that is part

0:05:20 of Davey's vision.

0:05:21 It's a very important part of Davey's vision, but it's not just about the immortality of

0:05:27 the soul that it gets recycled, you know, that it never, it's not born and never dies.

0:05:32 It's also, it's also about, it's also about something more down to earth that, that when

0:05:42 you die and are reborn, it's not like the Buddhist supposes that if you live a good

0:05:48 life and you've built up good karma that you might be reborn as a rich man, or you

0:05:54 might be reborn as a God, you know, as something better than once than you once were on the

0:06:00 earth. No, no, no, Davey says it's possible for you to be reborn into something greater

0:06:05 or lesser, just like the Buddhist might say. But where you're reborn when you die is not

0:06:12 in the heavens and understood as some spiritual place,

0:06:16 but literally in the heavens.

0:06:18 You die on earth and you become reborn on Mars,

0:06:21 you become reborn on Jupiter, that kind of thing.

0:06:24 This is really strange, you know,

0:06:26 and I think about that, like,

0:06:28 going back to the days of Davy, you know,

0:06:32 this was a long time ago, you know, the 1800s.

0:06:35 So is it possible that with the limited knowledge

0:06:40 that we had of the cosmos at that time that people might have actually

0:06:44 supposed that other planets were other worlds in the sense that we might today

0:06:51 say like other dimensions or other realities like the place that that

0:06:55 somebody religious might say the place that where God exists or or supernatural

0:07:01 beings exist they're not they're not here on this earth and they're not even

0:07:05 really here in this physical plane, there's somewhere else, you know, somewhere like in

0:07:10 another dimension. And that's not what we get from Davy. It's like, look, Davy's telling

0:07:17 us the universe is all there is, this great creation, this infinite place, and it's filled

0:07:22 with places where you can be reborn. And something really interesting about that, something

0:07:27 really novel about that, that he's spiritualizing matter, you know, the material world is the

0:07:36 place where we can ascend spiritually, some other place in the material world, not in some

0:07:42 spiritual place, not in some ethereal place beyond the veil, but to hear now in space and time.

0:07:49 And I think that's super important because it's something that will relate to panpsychism,

0:07:54 this idea that everything is consciousness, that God is consciousness and so is the material cosmos,

0:07:59 that there's one substance that makes up reality, like Alfred North Whitehead would say.

0:08:07 So in this part of the book, David turns to dreams, his dreams, and he speaks of them as visions too,

0:08:17 their revelations, his dreams. So altered states of consciousness, it seems, hold

0:08:26 the key to understanding the deepest mysteries of being. And it's worth

0:08:31 noting again that everything you're about to hear, like the vision of the

0:08:36 Colosseum, were among Davey's very last words. He was literally dying when he

0:08:41 wrote this. These are the things he wanted the world to know. These are the

0:08:48 facts so important, so difficultly earned that Davey had to share them before he died.

0:08:57 Why? For the benefit of mankind. And the story we're talking about, the vision of going out

0:09:05 up into space and seeing all the crazy stuff that he showed us in the vision,

0:09:08 these are the kind of things that he thinks must be shared. Because something about them is so

0:09:13 important that if more human beings come to appreciate and understand what he's getting at,

0:09:19 that it will be a benefit to mankind, you know, like indoor plumbing, like running water,

0:09:27 like vaccines, you know, a benefit to mankind like that, maybe greater. All right, I just want

0:09:37 to remind the audience that the last days of a philosopher was written like a platonic dialogue.

0:09:42 If you guys ever read any of Plato's works, it's kind of like a play. There's different characters

0:09:46 involved, usually two primary back and forth speakers. And Davey wrote the story like that.

0:09:53 And he gave himself and his friends false names. So they're like characters in a play.

0:10:00 So I just want to point that out while we go through this. And the story itself is, well,

0:10:05 it's wrapped up in a story. So it's not just what he has to tell us, but it's put, it's set

0:10:11 like a play. So where this begins, the gang has left the

0:10:16 Colosseum. Remember where Davey had the vision. And now they're

0:10:19 going to Mount Vesuvius. So they're just traveling around

0:10:22 Italy, seeing all the ancient sites, all the stuff you might

0:10:24 want to see if you if you went there. And so they first went

0:10:28 to the Colosseum. Now they're going to Mount Vesuvius. And

0:10:33 the scene around them is this, you know, this this crater, you

0:10:38 the volcano crater and they're up towards the top somewhere looking down at the valley where they

0:10:43 can see ancient ruins and they can see the town in the distance and all that sort of thing.

0:10:49 And the scene of Vogue's discussion, the same as it did when they were at the Colosseum,

0:10:53 this time about human reason, about instincts and revelation. So they're trying to understand

0:11:01 And what human reason is, what instincts are, and what revelation are.

0:11:07 Are they the same?

0:11:08 Are they different?

0:11:09 Are they different?

0:11:10 Where do they come from?

0:11:11 But these are all faculties that human beings seem to have.

0:11:14 And they want to understand what they are in light of what Davy said he saw in the vision

0:11:19 of the Causseum.

0:11:23 So they discuss the progress of civilization and how religion and culture transform, both

0:11:30 rising and falling over time and across people from all over the world.

0:11:35 Then the discussion turns to Christianity and whether or not it constitutes the purest

0:11:40 form of religion, which I think was pretty interesting.

0:11:45 They go back and forth discussing the nature of God and man in the afterlife.

0:11:49 So this is sort of opening the scene.

0:11:53 That brings me to the first section here, which I'm going to call on dreams.

0:11:57 All right.

0:12:00 So not Davey here, but one of his buddies, he opens like this.

0:12:03 And again, I told you that Davey and his buddies were given fake names for theatrical

0:12:08 effect.

0:12:11 Philelthys is what they're calling Davey.

0:12:13 So I'm just telling you that because I'm about to read that name.

0:12:16 So one of his buddies says, this recalls to my recollection, an idea which Philelthys

0:12:21 started in the remarkable dream which occurred to him in the Colosseum, namely that no important

0:12:28 facts which can be useful to society are ever lost and that like these stones which they'll

0:12:35 covered with ashes are sure to be brought forward again and made use of in some new

0:12:40 form.

0:12:43 All right.

0:12:44 So his buddy here brings up the crazy vision from the Colosseum and something that was

0:12:48 said during that that we talked about in the first episode.

0:12:52 He said that no important facts which can be useful to society are ever lost.

0:12:57 And he says, he uses the analogy by saying, look at the ruins, the stones of all these

0:13:02 ruins you see around you, like they're not going to be, you know, garbage for lack of

0:13:07 a better word.

0:13:08 They're not going to be unused and sitting there in the way forever.

0:13:10 There used to be something, something great.

0:13:13 And one day they'll be reused for something else.

0:13:16 Maybe they'll be carved into a statue.

0:13:17 Maybe they'll be used for the foundations of a new building, but that those things are

0:13:21 are never gone, they just change and transform

0:13:24 and are reused for different applications.

0:13:27 And there's something about this that is,

0:13:31 it reminds me of something from psychology

0:13:35 that says, I'm just a quote that goes with this

0:13:38 that I can't quite remember, but something that said

0:13:40 in psychology that human beings spend a lot of brain power

0:13:46 and a lot of attention of their consciousness

0:13:49 learn things. And once you've mastered them, they become unconscious, meaning you don't

0:13:56 have to think about them anymore. You can just perform them. Like, for me, it's typing

0:14:00 on a keyboard. It was a good example. You know, I wasn't born able to do it. I learned

0:14:04 it, you know, it was very difficult. But now I can type really fast and really well. And

0:14:08 you know, that's what I mean. I no longer have to think about it the way I used to have

0:14:12 to when I first started learning. So there's something about that when he says that there

0:14:18 There are no important facts, which were ever lost, that they once earned, once gained,

0:14:26 that they become a part of us somehow.

0:14:32 How is a good question, but that they become part of us somehow, that they become part

0:14:36 of our unconscious, and we can then rely on them without having to think about them.

0:14:41 It's almost like they exist, and they don't exist all at once.

0:14:46 It's interesting.

0:14:47 It points to that paradox that we talked about with the sisagy in the Ouroboros before, the

0:14:52 way that God is conceptualized by the ancient people, like a union of opposites.

0:14:59 There's something there that is impossible to understand.

0:15:03 This recycling thing also reminds me of the reincarnation that Davey talked about on

0:15:08 his vision.

0:15:09 We're going to reuse the stones that used to be part of the ancient Roman buildings.

0:15:15 going to reuse them and for some new building. Just like whatever it is that

0:15:19 animates you, your soul, when you die will be reborn as something else. It'll be

0:15:23 reused. So it's pointing, I think, to these cycles in nature that there's no

0:15:29 beginning or end, but that it's an eternal process. You know, nature is an

0:15:35 eternal process. That's something that Spinoza and Whitehead would wholeheartedly

0:15:41 agree with. And this idea of souls being recycled back and forth, back and forth, that that is

0:15:48 an image of a cycle, you know? All right, he goes on, he says, I regard this vision or dream as a

0:15:57 mere web of his imagination in which he intended to catch us. Okay, so this is one of Davy's buddies

0:16:04 saying, I think he made up the vision, I think you're just trying to, you know, get one over on us.

0:16:10 And this is where David jumps in. He says,

0:16:13 I will acknowledge that the vision in the Colosseum is a fiction.

0:16:18 But the most important parts of it really occurred to me in sleep,

0:16:22 particularly in which I seemed to leave the earth

0:16:25 and launch into the infinity of space

0:16:28 under the guidance of a tutelary genius.

0:16:31 And the origin and progress of civil society

0:16:34 from likewise parts of another dream, which I had many years ago,

0:16:38 And it was in the reverie, which happened when you quitted me in the Colosseum, that I wove

0:16:44 all these together and gave them the form in which I narrated them to you.

0:16:49 Okay, so one of his friends calls him out on this, which is pretty funny, I think.

0:16:53 It's just, it's what a buddy would do, calls him out on his crazy, crazy, hippie nonsense.

0:16:59 And, and he, Davey admits, yes, um, I didn't really have that experience sitting there

0:17:04 at the Colosseum, what he did have is a memory of a crazy revelatory dream that was exactly

0:17:12 as he explained his vision.

0:17:15 What happened when he was sitting there at the Colosseum in this reverie of deep in thought

0:17:19 all by himself, you know, in this mysterious place in the night, in the ruins of the Colosseum,

0:17:25 is he brought back to mind that dream that popped back in his mind.

0:17:30 And then another dream he had popped back in his mind and it was like they were connected.

0:17:34 And suddenly he had this new experience of these two dreams kind of coming back to his

0:17:39 attention and full force in a new way, combined with one another.

0:17:44 And it struck him so powerfully.

0:17:47 It was like he had hints of this revelation in the past.

0:17:50 And while he was sitting at the calcium, it all came together for him.

0:17:55 And so he's admitting that it didn't happen quite like he said, which I think is interesting.

0:18:02 But that's how kind of it goes down.

0:18:05 And one of his friends says, of course, we may consider them as an accurate representation

0:18:09 of your waking thoughts.

0:18:11 So he's saying, well, do you really believe what you said when you described your vision?

0:18:20 Do you really believe that?

0:18:22 Do you believe in this reincarnation idea?

0:18:24 Do you believe in this progress of the soul that's possible and that there are manifestations

0:18:31 and bodyments of consciousness, just like you and I on Earth, that exist on other planets

0:18:37 even in our solar system?

0:18:39 Do you believe all that?

0:18:40 Do you really believe that, Davy?

0:18:43 He says, I do not say that they strictly are so, yet I have more than one instance in

0:18:49 the course of my life, a most extraordinary combinations occurring in dreams, which have

0:18:55 had considerable influence on my feelings, my imagination, and my health."

0:19:01 Okay, so Davey's saying, look, I can't say for sure that I wholeheartedly believe all

0:19:08 of this crazy stuff, but what I can tell you is that I've had these strange dreams in the

0:19:14 past at random times that have had deep, deep impacts on me. The vision of going into space

0:19:21 was one of them. And he said that there are times when those dreams have the considerable

0:19:27 influence on my feelings, my imagination and my health. So imagine, imagine a dream

0:19:34 being associated with your well-being, you know, how you feel. You have a dream and suddenly

0:19:46 you wake up and it changes your mood for the day or for the week. He says it changes his

0:19:51 imagination. So maybe it's altered the way he thinks and I can relate to that. You know,

0:19:56 I've said before, but when I had a mystic experience back in 2019, it changed the way

0:20:00 I think and I would definitely say the way that I imagine because while I'm thinking it's not like

0:20:07 it used to be. It's not like I'm thinking and by organizing, by supposing and organizing facts

0:20:13 or anything like that. I think in images now and that's more true when what I'm thinking about is

0:20:19 really difficult to understand but I think in images which I never did before and it's completely

0:20:25 completely baffling, by the way, and his health. So now he's saying here that his dreams

0:20:31 have had some impact on his well-being, but on his actual health. So there might be a connection

0:20:37 between the power of his mind, you know, what's happening to him and his dreams,

0:20:42 and a connection to physical reality, to the here and now, to the health of his body and mind,

0:20:48 you know, to the functioning of his psyche and his imagination, and his dreams have some real

0:20:52 impact on the physical world. So his buddy, his buddy jumps in and says, we shall perhaps

0:21:00 set you down by the side of Jacob, uh, beam or a manual Swedenborg. And in an earlier age,

0:21:07 you might have been a prophet, but pray, give us one of these instances in which such a marvelous

0:21:13 influence was produced by a dream. So you can see what his buddies are doing. His buddies are saying,

0:21:19 Yeah, yeah, yeah. Give us an example. You're telling me that your dreams are that vivid

0:21:24 and that powerful. Give me another example. And he's also related Davey to these two guys,

0:21:33 Jacob Beaman and Emmanuel Swedenborg. They're both mystics from the 17th century.

0:21:40 So if you read them, and I think we may have read some of this already on the podcast,

0:21:45 but if you read them you'll see what I mean. These are very mystical thinkers, so he's saying that

0:21:51 Davy is in the company of these types of people. I think it's important to note that those people

0:21:57 weren't entirely well received. Swedenborg was a scientist and changed to this sort of

0:22:06 hippie-dippy mysticism in his older age, you know, in his 50s. So it's important to mention that

0:22:14 Basically, his buddies are putting him into this category, and it's a little bit divisive.

0:22:18 It's a little bit like an insult.

0:22:20 Swedenborg actually claimed that he could travel to heaven and hell at will.

0:22:29 So in his later life, he claimed to be able to do that, which is sort of what happened

0:22:32 to Davey, right?

0:22:34 He got with this genius, this genius, this supernatural being who took him up into the

0:22:38 heavens.

0:22:39 is it in heaven? Just like Swedenborg said that he could do. And I think that's interesting.

0:22:46 I'll give you a little bit of Swedenborg here. He said this in one of his writings,

0:22:51 spirits appeared in front to the left who were said to be from the Earth Mars and who

0:22:56 declared themselves to be holy. So that's the kind of shit Swedenborg was saying. When

0:23:02 he says that they were from the Earth Mars, he just means the planet Mars, right? And

0:23:08 They declared themselves to be holy and isn't that exactly what happened to Davy when he

0:23:12 was taken up into heaven and seeing space in the planets and he was shown creatures that

0:23:18 exist on Mars, on Jupiter, on Saturn, right?

0:23:22 And they were more holy than him.

0:23:24 They were higher beings than those that exist on Earth.

0:23:28 I just think that's quite interesting that there's a precedent for that and it goes back

0:23:33 to Swedenborg who I guess I'm gonna have to read now. Alright so then we go back

0:23:42 to Davy who says, then I remember this is Davy telling about one of these

0:23:48 dreams, one of these other dreams that had a mystical impact on them. It goes

0:23:53 like this, almost a quarter of a century ago I contracted that terrible form of

0:23:59 typhus fever. My illness was severe and dangerous. As long as the fever

0:24:05 continued, my dreams were most oppressive. But when exhaustion came on, and when the

0:24:12 probability of death seemed greater than life, there was a change. I remained in

0:24:19 an apparently senseless state, but my mind was peculiarly active. There was

0:24:25 always before me the form of a beautiful woman, with whom I was engaged in the

0:24:29 most interesting and intellectual conversation.

0:24:34 Her figure for many days was so distinct as to form almost a visual image.

0:24:40 As I gained strength, the visits of my good angel became less frequent.

0:24:45 And when I was restored to health, they were all together, discontinued.

0:24:50 All right.

0:24:50 So this is the first bit.

0:24:52 Um, seems like Davey was a sickly guy.

0:24:54 So he's had, you know, these spouts of really, really bad, you know, uh,

0:24:59 sicknesses to the point of dying. When he wrote this book that we're reading now, he was on the

0:25:04 on the point of dying. So, you know, you know, bad luck, I suppose. But in any case, he says he's

0:25:12 sick. He's got these, you know, this fever hallucination where he sees this woman who he

0:25:17 knows she's not there, right? But he sees her and he talks to her and she speaks to him. And he has

0:25:22 this conversation with this invisible woman, you know, and what comes to my mind. And he refers

0:25:28 to her as an angel. But what comes to my mind is something like Carl Jung would call the anima.

0:25:34 You know, he describes how everybody has a part of ourselves, a part of our psyche that we're not

0:25:42 connected to. You know, that's something he calls the unconscious. It's part of ourselves,

0:25:46 but we don't have access to it. It's simultaneously part of us and not part of us.

0:25:52 And what happens really commonly in dreams, and you see it in mythology as well, is that the part

0:25:57 of us that we don't have access to, the unknown part of us. We project that in our dreams.

0:26:03 And if you're a man, it's almost always the projection of a woman, right? It's the opposite

0:26:08 of you. It's the part of you that you don't have access to. So if you're a man, it's almost always

0:26:13 depicted as a woman. If you're a woman, it's almost always depicted as a man. It's the enemos

0:26:18 or the enema. And so Davey being a man, of course, sees the vision of a woman. And I can't help but

0:26:26 imagine that it may be his anima, especially given the fact that he's sick and dying and maybe he's

0:26:32 closer to the spirits that dwell within him. He's closer to his unconscious because he's on the brink

0:26:38 of death, something like that. And then as he gets better, the vision of the woman gets less

0:26:46 frequent and goes away disappears like a ghost. And here's where it gets good. He says 20 years

0:26:53 after my first illness. I was exceedingly weak from a severe malady. So now he's sick again 20

0:27:00 years later. He says, which for many weeks threatened my life. And when my mind was almost in a

0:27:07 desponding state, I again met the person who was the representative of my visionary female.

0:27:14 And to her kindness and care, I believe I owe what remains to me of existence.

0:27:19 All right, pump the brakes.

0:27:23 What he's saying here is that 20 years after he had this vision of this angel woman, and

0:27:29 he spoke to her and she spoke back, you know, like his unconscious speaking to him, right?

0:27:33 After 20 years after, he has another terrible illness where he's almost dying.

0:27:39 This time, a real life woman is there.

0:27:44 He doesn't explain why.

0:27:45 Was she a nurse?

0:27:46 You know, he doesn't explain.

0:27:47 real life woman was there to help him through it. And when he saw her, he recognized in her the

0:27:53 exact same face as he saw in this angel woman from 20 years before. He describes her as a young

0:28:03 woman, which makes me think that 20 years ago, she likely wasn't even born. And he saw her face

0:28:10 and had a conversation with her. And then 20 years later, he met her. And he says he owes his life

0:28:16 to her. Amazing. So if that's, you know, not proof enough for his friends that his dreams are

0:28:26 powerful and real and have a real connection to the here and now, or maybe even showing him

0:28:33 visions of the future, I don't know what's going to convince them. And at this point,

0:28:41 at this point, the discussion between Davie and his buddies, it turns to religion. So it's like

0:28:46 the idea that they began talking about dreams then they start talking about

0:28:50 an apparition you know this woman this angel this ghost and so that that's the

0:28:56 bridge to get us to this conversation about religion and it starts with one of

0:29:01 Davey's buddies like this I suppose in the early state of man he imagined that

0:29:08 he enjoyed the actual presence of the divinity I take this to be the result

0:29:13 of religious instinct. In early times, I suppose these ideas were so vivid as to be

0:29:21 confounded with impressions. But as religious instinct became feebler, the

0:29:27 vividness of the impressions diminished, and they became visions or dreams, which

0:29:33 with the prophets seemed to have constituted inspiration. I do not suppose

0:29:38 that the supreme being ever made himself known to man by a real change in the

0:29:43 order of nature, but that the sensations of men were so modified by their instincts as

0:29:49 to induce the belief in his presence."

0:29:51 All right, there's a bunch packed into that, but this is interesting.

0:29:58 So what he's saying here is, in the early days, when man was living hand to mouth, cavemen

0:30:04 style as a savage, without all the benefits of civilization and culture, when man had

0:30:09 just be, be gone, that he might have imagined that he was in the presence of God, that he

0:30:16 spoke to God the way that Adam speaks to God in the Garden of Eden, that in that state

0:30:22 human beings would feel the presence of God all the time.

0:30:28 And if that sounds strange to you, I would just say, imagine living in a hunter-gatherer

0:30:33 lifestyle, where you're starving a lot of the time, where your, your, your happiness

0:30:40 and health is sort of at the whim of nature of mother nature. You have to hunt to survive

0:30:46 and every single day is dangerous to the point of death. You know, imagine that. Imagine how

0:30:52 careful you'd have to be, how significant everything would seem. What's around this

0:30:58 corner, what's in the bush, what's making that noise, you know, all of these things.

0:31:04 It would feel as though everything was significant, because you have to pay attention to them,

0:31:09 because if you don't, you might miss an opportunity, or even worse, you might miss danger.

0:31:15 And so everything would seem to be alive, everything would seem to be staring at you,

0:31:19 everything would seem to be simultaneously dangerous and potentially beneficial.

0:31:25 And that's the world you live in.

0:31:28 It's a very different world than we think of ourselves living in.

0:31:32 We've subdued all those dangers.

0:31:34 We've made predictable all those benefits.

0:31:37 The early man didn't have that.

0:31:39 So might that have felt like a deeper connection between man and the world?

0:31:46 Might that have felt like man was in the presence of God constantly?

0:31:53 You think about how these early religions, these animistic religions, like those that

0:31:58 you see depicted in Native America in Sub-Saharan Africa and Australia and places like that,

0:32:03 some of the Pacific Islanders and so forth, that they believed that the world was full

0:32:07 of spirits, that everything was alive, you know?

0:32:11 And that would be how you would imagine the world to be when things were always so dangerous

0:32:18 and your life was always hanging on by a thread and your connection to life and to the world

0:32:25 was so much more intimate than it is for us.

0:32:29 So I'd ask you to think about it that way.

0:32:32 Maybe it is true that in that type of a life,

0:32:35 human beings did feel like God was around them.

0:32:39 And then he says that as religious instincts

0:32:42 become feebler, right?

0:32:44 So it's like almost like we're growing out of it,

0:32:46 where we're getting used to it or something,

0:32:48 that the vividness of the impressions that we used to have

0:32:52 that made us believe that God was around us all the time,

0:32:55 that those things got marginalized and pushed

0:32:59 into these narrower and narrower experiences,

0:33:01 like visions or dreams.

0:33:03 So it wasn't just that you could encounter God

0:33:06 wherever you were.

0:33:08 It was that you could encounter God in sleep

0:33:11 or in extraordinary circumstances, like a vision.

0:33:18 And then he says this interesting thing at the end.

0:33:19 He says, I do not suppose that the Supreme Being

0:33:22 ever made himself known to man by a change in the order of nature.

0:33:27 So I think what he means there is like ancient people would think that there was a sign

0:33:33 from God, you know, like a meteor goes across the sky, meteor shower, that's a sign or

0:33:39 something like that or a volcano erupts and that's a sign from God.

0:33:43 I think what he's saying is that those sorts of things aren't God communicating to man.

0:33:49 And I think that we would mostly agree with that, right?

0:33:51 But then he says, but the sensations of men were so modified by their instincts as to

0:33:57 induce the belief in his presence.

0:34:00 Here he's saying that there's something about our perceptions, there's something about

0:34:03 our consciousness or our sentience that is like an instinct towards the belief in God.

0:34:10 And that's interesting.

0:34:14 So it's like just being conscious yourself.

0:34:18 instinctually gives rice to a belief in God, to recognize maybe God within, you know, the thing

0:34:26 that makes you alive, the thing that exists in your body, that you call yourself, that may be,

0:34:32 that may be something more like God. The same thing that the Native Americans believe,

0:34:37 the spirits that exist in everything all around, all around you, and within yourself,

0:34:41 that's kind of the image that comes out here. Then he goes on, he says,

0:34:47 Because I believe in the immortality of the sentient principle and man.

0:34:53 So I'm going to stop there for a second because the immortality of the soul, that's a really

0:34:58 common phrase in philosophy and in religion.

0:35:02 Because we generally believe that, that there's something in us that is undying and we in

0:35:08 a religious context we call that spirit or soul.

0:35:11 And he says the same thing, but he, instead of using the word spirit or soul, he uses

0:35:17 the word sentient principle and I just think that's interesting. It's like exactly what

0:35:23 Carl Jung would do decades later. He would replace this idea of spirit or soul with all

0:35:31 these religious connotations that people, you know, recoil from and he would call, he

0:35:37 would call it consciousness and it makes it more palatable especially to, you know, scientific

0:35:45 types, people that are ambivalent to the idea of spirituality or divinity.

0:35:51 And this is exactly what we see here in the book.

0:35:54 I believe in the immortality of the sentient principle and man.

0:35:58 This destruction of life is only a change of existence.

0:36:03 To the supreme intelligence, the death of a million human beings is the mere circumstance

0:36:09 of so many spiritual essences changing their habitations.

0:36:16 Man, so when he says destruction of life is only a change of existence, he's talking again

0:36:25 about the immortality of the soul and referencing this reincarnation idea from Davey's vision

0:36:30 that whatever it is that, you know, that animates you, whatever it is that's responsible for

0:36:34 your life, your consciousness, that that thing doesn't die, it just changes existence.

0:36:41 And then he uses this interesting example of if a million human beings died.

0:36:45 It's not a tragedy.

0:36:47 All it is is a whole bunch of people moving out of one apartment complex at the same time

0:36:55 and moving into a new one.

0:36:57 That's the analogy that he's bringing up.

0:36:58 It's just you're soul moving from one state of existence to another.

0:37:04 This idea of the immortality of the soul being maintained in this conversation I think is

0:37:10 interesting because we're not talking strictly in a religious context.

0:37:14 talking in a scientific and a religious context simultaneously.

0:37:18 All right, he goes on, he says, when Christianity took the place of Judaism, the ideas of the

0:37:26 supreme being became more pure and abstracted, and the visible attributes of Jehovah and

0:37:33 his angels appear to have been less frequently presented.

0:37:36 All right, that's interesting.

0:37:40 So it's important to note, obviously, Davy and his buddies were Christians.

0:37:44 You know, the Western world was, was dominantly Christian at this time.

0:37:49 Religion was far more acceptable and far more common back then.

0:37:53 So you got to, you got to put yourself in that, in that perspective

0:37:56 when you've got these scientists and philosophers talking about Christianity and Judaism

0:38:01 and whether the God of Christianity is somehow better than the God of Judaism.

0:38:05 It's kind of an interesting topic for scientists to talk about.

0:38:09 But what he says here is interesting.

0:38:11 That the way that Christians see the supreme being is more abstract than the Jewish idea.

0:38:19 And because it's more abstract, it's more pure.

0:38:22 So my question is, and probably yours too, is why is more abstract concept of God more

0:38:29 pure?

0:38:30 And the answer seems to be something like, because it is less associated with the material world

0:38:37 and more associated with the fundamental reality behind the material world,

0:38:42 behind the veil of perception. It also reminds me of

0:38:46 a phrase from the Bible that says, make ye no graven images.

0:38:50 And I have to remind Davey here that that

0:38:54 comes from the Old Testament, that's a Jewish idea, not to make an image of God.

0:38:58 So I think that the abstractness of the deity that

0:39:02 the Jews imagine is probably not any more abstract than the one the Christians

0:39:06 imagine,

0:39:06 So I'm not, you know, maybe I'll push back on him a little bit there, but I do think

0:39:13 it's interesting that to abstract the idea of God is to make it more and more generally

0:39:19 applicable.

0:39:22 So it's like the more abstract God becomes, the easier it is to see God in everything.

0:39:27 The more specific you are about God, the less you can, I mean, you're carving away possibilities

0:39:35 when you do that.

0:39:36 And what God is is something like possibilities, infinite potentiality, as I always say.

0:39:42 So the more specific you can be about God and the more confident you are making a picture

0:39:47 or an image of God, what you're doing is chipping away at all of what God is and leaving only

0:39:55 a small bit of it left, a small bit of it you can wrap your brain around.

0:40:00 And that's actually a bad idea in the search for truth.

0:40:05 It's a bad idea to do that

0:40:07 because you're not examining what God really is.

0:40:11 And not the extent of what God really is.

0:40:13 You're chipping off a little piece of them

0:40:15 and pretending that that's the thing.

0:40:16 It's not the thing.

0:40:18 And the Taoists in China are really good

0:40:20 about making that prohibition or making that warning.

0:40:25 And the Tao de Xing, they say things just like that.

0:40:28 that the Tao that can be seen is not the real Tao,

0:40:32 you know?

0:40:33 The Tao that can be spoken of is not the real Tao.

0:40:35 The moment you say anything about what Tao is,

0:40:38 you're off the mark, you're further away from the truth,

0:40:41 you know?

0:40:46 All right, this bit's interesting.

0:40:47 So, yeah, Davey's buddy says,

0:40:50 the infinite and eternal mind

0:40:52 fits the doctrines of religion

0:40:54 to the minds by which they are to be embraced.

0:40:58 I see no improbability in the idea

0:41:00 that a part of his essence animated of a human form.

0:41:05 There can be no doubt that this belief

0:41:06 has existed in the human mind

0:41:08 and the belief constitutes the vital part of religion.

0:41:13 All right, so there's a lot here, but this is great.

0:41:17 So when he says the infinite and eternal mind,

0:41:19 he's talking about God.

0:41:21 He says, God fits the doctrines of religion

0:41:25 to the minds by which they are to be embraced.

0:41:28 Okay, so what he means is my mind and your mind, right?

0:41:32 We're the ones that are supposed to embrace God

0:41:34 and embrace religion.

0:41:36 He's saying that that comes from the mind of God.

0:41:43 So the thing within us that seeks after God,

0:41:46 the thing within us that believes God is a possibility

0:41:49 that entertains the idea of eternity and the infinite

0:41:52 and all that sort of thing.

0:41:54 That we have those ideas within our own minds,

0:41:58 within our own sentience.

0:41:59 Because where that sentience comes from

0:42:02 is God himself, the infinite and eternal himself.

0:42:07 And then he says, I see no improbability in the idea

0:42:09 that a part of his essence animated a human form.

0:42:13 So while he's saying that the mind of God exists

0:42:18 in human beings, and that's why we get this notion of God

0:42:21 because it exists within us, that he says

0:42:23 that is the same very same thing that animates us,

0:42:27 that makes us alive.

0:42:29 I'll say that in another way.

0:42:30 He says,

0:42:31 sentience consciousness,

0:42:34 which is in this context,

0:42:36 another way of saying the spirit of God,

0:42:40 that exists within us

0:42:41 and is responsible for us being alive.

0:42:44 He also says that it constitutes

0:42:46 the vital part of religion.

0:42:47 So not only is it responsible for us being alive,

0:42:51 but it's responsible for us recognizing

0:42:53 that God, as a concept even, exists, or can exist, or might exist.

0:43:00 It's the same part of us that allows us to entertain and seek after

0:43:03 something that is beyond all of material reality.

0:43:07 Something that's not finite, like all of our experiences and everything we've ever known.

0:43:12 Something that's beyond that, eternal and infinite.

0:43:15 Amazing.

0:43:19 And this idea of the God within, you know, as being a vital part of religion, you know,

0:43:25 basically what that is, is identifying yourself, identifying with God.

0:43:30 And I've talked about that before, that that is part of the mystic experience,

0:43:33 is understanding all things to be one, understanding the thing that you think generally, that you

0:43:39 think God is, as something indistinguishable from yourself, and from everything else.

0:43:45 And that, my friends, is one of the earliest illustrations of panpsychism, that all is consciousness.

0:43:57 From the mouth of Humphrey Davy, amazing.

0:43:59 Alright, he goes on, to God, the infinite, little and great, are equal.

0:44:08 A creature of this earth, however humble and insignificant, may have the same weight with

0:44:13 millions of superior beings inhabiting higher systems.

0:44:19 So that's interesting.

0:44:20 Now that's obviously a callback to the vision where Daevi saw these higher spiritual beings

0:44:24 or higher material beings living on Jupiter and Saturn and on in the comets and all that

0:44:29 sort of thing.

0:44:32 And he says here that those superior beings who can do all this amazing stuff that human

0:44:37 beings can't do because they're greater than us and as Daevi described it, that all of

0:44:42 those creatures that we saw on the vision are no more significant than the human beings

0:44:47 on earth.

0:44:50 And so you have a paradox again, you have this conflict between David describing them

0:44:54 as higher beings with greater potential with higher forms of intellect and more pure and

0:45:02 true or understandings of God and reality, that those things are no different than the

0:45:08 lower things, like beings that exist on earth, like you and I. And I think that is a reference

0:45:17 to this fractal nature of reality that comes through in mystic intuition. It's that the

0:45:22 one that you can have the one in the many, and you can have the many in the one, the

0:45:28 oneness existing simultaneously with the diversity of the world, that is the paradox

0:45:34 that's being pointed out here.

0:45:36 And he says that one is worth the same as the other.

0:45:41 And that's another way of saying there is no difference.

0:45:44 There is only one.

0:45:46 And that is the message of the mystic experience.

0:45:51 And then he goes on, he says, my first principle

0:45:55 is that religion is an instinct intended to give to man

0:45:59 what he cannot obtain by use of his reason.

0:46:03 Now, that's interesting.

0:46:04 There's a guy named Kant who wrote a book called The Critique of Reason, The Critique

0:46:09 of Pure Reason, and there is reason to think that reason is not foolproof, that it's something

0:46:15 that can lead us astray, but it also is a great tool, reason, rationality.

0:46:20 It's also a great tool to find truth, you know, and when he says here that religion

0:46:27 is an instinct that's intended to give man what he can't obtain through reason, it sort

0:46:32 makes me think that reason is something that can be used to understand the material world,

0:46:38 you know, the things that you can hold and touch and experience. The things that you can't,

0:46:43 you know, those unconscious things, right, the other part of ourselves we don't have access to,

0:46:48 how do we understand that? We can't use reason to do that. We have to use something else.

0:46:55 and those are our religious instincts. I think that's right on.

0:47:04 Then Davey says, Revelation may be regarded as a constant principle belonging to the mind of man.

0:47:12 And that's something like saying that the mystic experience is always possible,

0:47:17 that the experience of God, like we started talking about, like Adam in the garden,

0:47:21 the direct experience of God is always a possibility.

0:47:26 right? It's always a potential latent within human beings. So if you've never had one,

0:47:33 you can have one. It is possible for you to have one. And I think that's true. And I think

0:47:40 that having that experience is important. In my life, it's maybe the single most important

0:47:46 experience period, at least spiritually. All right, so at this point in the story, we have

0:47:55 a little change here. The gang meets a mysterious stranger near the summit of Mount Vesuvius.

0:48:01 And they begin to speak with him. And the thing is, his intelligence is uncanny. They

0:48:07 even supernatural, actually. And they speak about the history of the earth. And this guy

0:48:12 is like a sage. And he never tells them his name. He's just called the stranger. And he

0:48:17 seems to know lots of stuff. Really, really high level, you know, scientific knowledge.

0:48:24 They speak of the layers of rock that make up the earth, and they speculate about how

0:48:29 and when they were formed, and of the fossils that are found or missing in each layer.

0:48:36 And this stranger basically lays out his impression of biological evolution based on this geological

0:48:42 evidence.

0:48:43 It's really kind of interesting, especially going back to when this book was written

0:48:46 1829, you know, that was decades before the origin of species. And then that brings us

0:48:56 here to the next bit, which I'm going to call back to the future. This next section is called

0:49:01 back to the future. All right, so the story shifts to the present day and reveals that the authors

0:49:10 recounting a story from many, many decades before when he was a young man. And now old and sickly,

0:49:17 he desires to return to his travels one last time, you know, he's reminiscing about going out with

0:49:24 his buddies, seeing different parts of the world when he was young. He yearns to do that again,

0:49:30 to have that adventure, you know, before he's not able to do that anymore. And he and one of his

0:49:35 friends, they leave for maybe their final adventure, and they go to the mountains of Illyria.

0:49:42 And after a near drowning incident, they find themselves serendipitously reunited with

0:49:51 the sage stranger from Davey's youth.

0:49:55 They bump into that same unnamed stranger that they talk to on the tip of Mount Vesuvius,

0:50:02 but this is years and years later.

0:50:06 And they start to discuss what life is.

0:50:09 tackle the hardest questions. Remember, they're always talking about, you know, the hardest

0:50:14 questions, the origins of God and religion and the afterlife and biological evolution

0:50:19 and all these things. They're talking about the most difficult and mysterious questions.

0:50:25 And so this should come as no surprise. They start talking about life, what it is,

0:50:31 what's necessary to create life. Can it be created? And one of the crews suggests

0:50:37 that life or consciousness depends upon error or breathing since, after all, when

0:50:44 one ceases breathing, one also ceases living, you know? And the stranger

0:50:50 responds, I think it probable that some subtle matter is derived from the

0:50:56 atmosphere connected with the functions of life, but nothing can be more remote

0:51:01 from my opinion than to suppose it the cause of vitality. So the stranger is

0:51:06 saying, no, I think it's more than just error, you know,

0:51:09 error may be necessary for sustaining life,

0:51:12 but it's not the cause of it, you know,

0:51:14 there's something more going on.

0:51:17 Then he says, I know there have been distinguished

0:51:20 physiologists who have imagined that sensibility,

0:51:24 and by that he means sentience, consciousness,

0:51:26 was a property belonging to some unknown combination

0:51:30 of ethereal elements, but such notions appear

0:51:33 to me unphilosophical.

0:51:35 I can never believe that any arrangement of the particles of matter can give them sensibility,

0:51:42 or that intelligence can result from combinations of brute atoms.

0:51:48 The materialists have quoted a passage of Locke in favor of their doctrine who seemed

0:51:52 to doubt, quote, whether it might not have pleased God to bestow a power of thinking

0:51:59 on matter.

0:52:00 All right, so the hair is thinning up my arms.

0:52:05 This bit is really interesting because, well, firstly, I'll just re-read to you that last

0:52:12 sentence where this is a quote from John Locke where he says, whether it might not have pleased

0:52:18 God to bestow a power of thinking on matter, what that means in a nutshell is did God create

0:52:27 the material world with consciousness,

0:52:30 that all matter has consciousness.

0:52:33 And again, that is almost verbatim,

0:52:36 what panpsychism is.

0:52:37 Here again, we see another summation of this idea

0:52:41 of panpsychism going way back to 1829.

0:52:45 But even better than that, the way it opens,

0:52:48 when he talks about physiologists having imagined

0:52:50 that sentient was a property,

0:52:52 belonging to some unknown combination

0:52:55 of ethereal elements or atoms.

0:52:58 Like what he's describing there

0:53:01 is something that we still talk about today.

0:53:03 Something that comes up with the hard problem

0:53:05 of consciousness as David Chalmers would say.

0:53:08 It's something called emergentism.

0:53:10 So most scientists today believe consciousness emerges

0:53:14 from the physical world.

0:53:16 That it didn't always exist,

0:53:18 the way that panpsychism says it does.

0:53:20 But that at some point in development popped into existence.

0:53:24 And all it took was the right prerequisite structure

0:53:28 once it was built, once it was evolved,

0:53:31 then suddenly consciousness.

0:53:35 And there's lots of problems with this idea of emergentism.

0:53:38 But I think it's interesting that Davey says

0:53:41 he doesn't think there's any combination of atoms

0:53:44 that would create consciousness.

0:53:47 Cincians doesn't just emerge like that.

0:53:49 So not only do you have in this one paragraph

0:53:53 Davey outlining this idea of what will become panpsychism today.

0:53:58 But he also acknowledges this problem of emergentism,

0:54:01 which we are still fighting about.

0:54:04 The greatest philosophers and physicists

0:54:07 are to this day still fighting about.

0:54:13 All right, then one of Davey's buddies says,

0:54:16 if a principle be supposed necessary to intelligence,

0:54:19 and by that he just means consciousness, sentience,

0:54:22 if a principle be supposed necessary to intelligence,

0:54:25 it must exist throughout animated nature.

0:54:31 So again, if there's some principle

0:54:34 that consciousness is based upon,

0:54:37 that thing has to exist in all of nature.

0:54:41 Because some parts of nature become conscious, right?

0:54:43 Some parts seem very obviously sentient.

0:54:45 There must be a seed there, already there,

0:54:48 that makes it possible.

0:54:49 That's interesting.

0:54:52 Then he says,

0:54:53 the elephant approaches nearer to man

0:54:54 intellectual power than the oyster does. In a link of sensitive nature may be traced from the

0:55:01 polypus to the philosopher. Now in the polypus the sentient principle is divisible and from one

0:55:08 polypus or one earthworm may be formed two or three, all of which become perfect animals

0:55:16 and have perception and volition. Therefore at least the sentient principle has the property

0:55:23 in common with matter. That it is divisible. And that is a hell of an insight. I never heard

0:55:32 the word polyposo before, but apparently it just means earthworm. And you guys know,

0:55:36 I assume you know, that if you take an earthworm and you cut it in half, you know, both sides of

0:55:42 that earthworm will continue to live. And this is what he's pointing to. And I think this is

0:55:48 brilliant. This is brilliant. He points to this miracle of sentience by noting that it's

0:55:57 divisible, just like an earthworm. It's something like we said before when we were talking about

0:56:02 fractals, that one can be many, you know? We're talking about consciousness, but we're talking

0:56:09 about an earthworm, right? If an earthworm is sentient and you can cut it in twos or threes

0:56:13 and all three pieces remain, remain sentient, then the consciousness is divisible and you have from

0:56:20 one consciousness, three conscious creatures from one can be many. And that's a reflection

0:56:25 of that fractal idea. It also reminds me of something I read in Dr. Schurst that uses

0:56:32 book modes of cinchians that we talked about, where he basically had the same argument.

0:56:38 He outlined the same argument being made. It goes something like this. If you believe

0:56:45 that consciousness emerges at some point in our evolutionary history, then what you're

0:56:49 describing is some kind of a miracle, some kind of a flip being switched, how that happens

0:56:54 still unknown, but something like that happens, you know, bewitched wiggles her nose, and

0:57:00 suddenly something that wasn't conscious is conscious. That's what immersion-tism means.

0:57:06 And the way scientists like to talk about this is that in this early, early Earth, what

0:57:12 they call the primordial soup, where the Earth is just a deep ocean just filled with proteins

0:57:18 and chemicals that are getting bubbled up

0:57:20 from the volcanic vents down under the ocean

0:57:22 and all these chemistries going on by random, right?

0:57:27 And it's completely random.

0:57:29 And some by some miracle, by some supreme accident,

0:57:34 that chemistry creates consciousness or life,

0:57:37 however you want to put it.

0:57:39 And so from that scientific perspective,

0:57:42 consciousness having been created from no consciousness

0:57:45 was it was a miracle. It was almost impossible. It was statistically impossible. It was a random

0:57:55 thing that happened. And it only could have happened because the earth has been around,

0:57:59 because the cosmos has been around for trillions of years or whatever, 16 billion years or whatever

0:58:04 it is, whatever the number is, I don't know, that they had plenty of time for this accident to happen.

0:58:10 And what Dr. Schurst that Hughes points out in his book is that if you make that argument,

0:58:16 if you're going to be convinced that that's how consciousness got here and not the pan-psychist

0:58:20 approach that it's always been here, it's been part of energy and part of matter this

0:58:25 whole time, then what you have to suggest here is that this crazy unrealistic, statistically

0:58:32 impossible miracle that caused something that wasn't conscious to become conscious,

0:58:39 But that thing happens, that miracle happens countless times every second.

0:58:48 And by that he means every time something is born, every time a cell divides, you know,

0:58:57 that those things are splitting consciousness.

0:59:00 And one cell becomes two and they're both conscious, remember just like the earthworm.

0:59:04 Or one human being gives birth to another human being and it's conscious too.

0:59:08 How did that happen?

0:59:09 How did the consciousness get there?

0:59:11 How did that happen?

0:59:13 This crazy, unrealistic, impossible miracle of emergentism happens not just once in our

0:59:20 primordial past.

0:59:21 It happens countless times every second.

0:59:25 How do you explain that?

0:59:26 I think that's the fact that that is in this book is amazing.

0:59:31 amazing. All right, so now we go back to the stranger. And he says physiologists prove that a

0:59:41 certain perfection of the machinery of the body is essential to the exercise of the powers of the

0:59:47 mind. But they do not prove that the machine is the mind. Fucking a man, that is, that is mind

0:59:57 matter dualism. That's the idea that we get from Descartes. But also an idea that you see in Plato

1:00:03 and that you see in Christianity, you know, the idea that the soul and the body are somehow

1:00:08 different. And you, again, you get that argument here. He says, he says that, you know, the body

1:00:16 is essential to, to, you know, consciousness. You have to have it has to be embodied somehow.

1:00:20 So you definitely need a body. And the more perfect the machinery is, like the more sophisticated

1:00:25 the brain is, the more sophisticated the consciousness seems to be. But the brain is not the same as

1:00:31 the consciousness. The mind is not the same. And he goes on, he says, without the eye,

1:00:38 there can be no sensations of vision. Without the brain, there could be no recollected ideas.

1:00:44 But neither the optic nerve nor the brain can be considered the recipient principle,

1:00:50 the conscious part, right? It's not the brain that's consciousness. Creatures without a brain

1:00:55 are still conscious, like an earthworm as an example. Then he says, they are but the instruments

1:01:01 of a power which has nothing in common with them, and that power is consciousness, and it has nothing

1:01:08 in common with the brain or the optic nerve. And yet somehow they work together. Then he says,

1:01:17 the external world is to us, nothing but a cluster of sensations. And in looking back our own,

1:01:24 our own being, we find one principle which may be called the monad or self, constantly present,

1:01:32 intimately associated with sensations, which we call our own body. That's interesting. So

1:01:41 when he says that the external world is to us nothing but a cluster of sensations,

1:01:46 that's an interesting way of looking at it. It's like we look out at the world and we see

1:01:50 see, we think we see things, we see space, we see objects, we see transformation going

1:01:56 on of all kinds, motion and action and cause and effect, we think we see all of that stuff.

1:02:03 But really, all we're all we're getting from our experience of the world are conscious

1:02:10 experiences, different sensations.

1:02:12 And so there's a way of looking at the world not as a geometrical structure of space and

1:02:18 time full of objects and forces but simply a cluster of sensations. He says, if we look

1:02:28 at ourselves, what we find is something he calls the monad or the self and it's associated

1:02:37 with our sensations. It's something like our body that we associate with the consciousness

1:02:42 that we seem to think is somehow in our body. And he calls it the monad, which is interesting

1:02:52 because that just means the one thing.

1:02:55 And you can think about yourself like in a young,

1:02:56 like a youngian sense, you can think about yourself

1:02:59 as the thing that's constant throughout time.

1:03:01 So your body changes, the world changes,

1:03:03 but the whole time you're on this ride we call life,

1:03:06 you still consider yourself this one unchanging part

1:03:10 that's been riding along in your transforming body

1:03:12 that's been riding along in the transforming earth,

1:03:15 that's been riding along in the transforming cosmos.

1:03:17 The one stable thing in your existence

1:03:21 is the monad. It's yourself. And because it's called a monad, the one thing, I just can't

1:03:28 help but point out that's what mystic experience tells you. God is one. Material reality is

1:03:36 one thing. And that one thing is the same thing that's responsible for your sentience.

1:03:44 He goes on, he says, we can fix no beginnings to its operations. We can place no limits

1:03:52 to them. We are conscious of an infinite variety of dreams, and there is a strong analogy for

1:03:59 believing in an infinity of past experiences. And human life may be regarded as a type of

1:04:06 infinite and immortal life. So now we're getting to the immortality bit. And there's

1:04:13 promises in religion about immortality. People are afraid of death. They're afraid of being

1:04:19 over. As much as we like to bitch about life, we seem to really don't want it to end.

1:04:24 with a rare, with a rare exception of the suicidal person or the crazy person,

1:04:28 as hard as it is, we don't want our experiences to end, and that's where the fear of death comes from.

1:04:34 And so religion oftentimes promises immortality.

1:04:38 You can see that in Gnosticism. You can see it in Christianity.

1:04:41 You can see it in Buddhism with Nirvana.

1:04:44 You know, this promise of immortality.

1:04:47 And it's funny because what Davey's doing here is he's saying,

1:04:51 if you consider the monad, if you consider the thing that really exists, the thing that you think

1:04:58 of as yourself, to be unchanging and eternal. And you put that in the perspective of Davey's vision

1:05:05 of this reincarnation, this process of reincarnation, where the soul is constantly transforming and

1:05:10 changing and re-existing again and again and again, that what you have is an image of immortal life.

1:05:17 life, its consciousness recycled and reused over and over and over, no beginning and no

1:05:23 end, that is immortal life. It's a different way of looking at it, right? Just like Davey

1:05:31 tried to show us a different way of looking at like the realm of the gods or the spiritual

1:05:37 realm, not as some place infinitely distant from us or some other dimension, but just

1:05:42 up there in space where you can look up and see, you know, oh look, you know, there's

1:05:45 Mars. That's, that's where this, this other place is. You know, it's a different way of looking at

1:05:51 spiritual ideas as in the here and now. And even this idea of immortal life has something existing

1:05:59 in you and I rather than in some spiritual place or some, you know, otherworldly place within God.

1:06:07 And all this stuff, very, very pan psychic leaning, you know, all right, he goes on, he says,

1:06:16 The whole history of intellect is a history of change, and we retain the memory only of those

1:06:22 changes which may be useful to us. The child forgets what happened to it in the womb.

1:06:28 The recollections of the infant likewise before two years are soon lost, yet many of the habits

1:06:35 acquired in that age are retained through life. So that is a better example of what I was trying

1:06:40 to explain before about functions becoming unconscious, you know? It's like you're never

1:06:45 going to lose them because they become part of yourself at this deepest level. Then he goes on,

1:06:52 the sentient principle gains thoughts by material sensations, excuse me, the sentient principle gains

1:07:00 thoughts by material instruments, and its sensations change as those instruments change.

1:07:06 And in old age, the mind falls asleep to awake to a new existence.

1:07:11 All right, so there's a lot there too.

1:07:14 When he says that the sentient principle gains thoughts by material instruments, what he

1:07:20 means by that is that sentience requires embodiment, right?

1:07:25 It has to be in a body in order to have sensations, in order to be conscious, right?

1:07:35 So it's something like saying to be embodied is a part of being conscious, and there's

1:07:40 an analogy there that says something like God is required for there to be material reality.

1:07:46 If God is the sentient component, if they're the one in the same thing, that is the way

1:07:53 of understanding the relationship between God and the material world.

1:07:56 You can't have one without the other.

1:08:00 And then when he says that its sensations change, as those instruments change, so imagine

1:08:05 God is in a human being and you're having experiences. And as you change, your experiences change.

1:08:12 And so God gets to experience through you all sorts of different experiences.

1:08:19 And it just reminds me of this idea of the being generator that I've talked about

1:08:23 from my own mystic experience where I had this sort of image that occurred to me of a process,

1:08:30 not unlike what we talked about with the Alfred North Whitehead, where God is consciousness.

1:08:36 And consciousness is experiencing itself, because experience is what consciousness does.

1:08:41 If God is the one thing that exists, like the mystic experience tells you, then what

1:08:45 it's experiencing is itself.

1:08:48 What Dave is saying is that that experience is going on in you and I and in the cosmos.

1:08:55 And as we change, we change God, you know, we change sentience.

1:09:01 And so there's this back and forth process of transformation between us and God back

1:09:06 and forth.

1:09:07 That's this unending process that I call the being generator.

1:09:13 But enough of that.

1:09:14 All right, he goes on, the intellect of man is naturally limited and imperfect, but this

1:09:20 This depends upon its material machinery, and in a higher form, it may be imagined to possess

1:09:27 infinitely higher powers.

1:09:30 This is basically saying here that consciousness is what it is.

1:09:36 If it exists in a plant versus in a human being, that the machinery of the embodiment,

1:09:43 the plant versus the human body, that's going to make a difference in how the consciousness

1:09:48 can express itself. And to go back to Davey's vision, if you compared a human being to one

1:09:54 of these alien creatures on Jupiter, that their material machinery is far higher and more refined

1:10:01 than ours. So their ability to be conscious is superior to ours. And we don't exactly know

1:10:10 what that means, but we can try to understand that by looking at the difference between our

1:10:15 consciousness and the consciousness of a flower. Imagine we encounter the creature as high above us

1:10:22 as we are above a flower in terms of our perception and consciousness. What might that be? We don't

1:10:30 even know. He says, from the infinite variety of perception, it seems extremely probable that

1:10:42 there must be in the brain and nerve matter a nature far more subtle than anything discovered

1:10:47 in them by observation. And that the immediate connection between the sentient

1:10:52 principle and the body may be established. Hmm, that's interesting. So he's saying

1:11:00 that there's something in matter itself that's more subtle than can be observed

1:11:05 by observation or by experiment. There's something already in matter that is the

1:11:10 connection between sentience and matter. And I don't know, I don't know, a better

1:11:16 way of describing panpsychism. So this is what we're getting from Davey over and over again here,

1:11:22 different formulations of this idea of panpsychism. He says, I sometimes imagine that many of those

1:11:30 powers which have been called instinctive belong to the more refined clothing of the spirit.

1:11:36 Conscious indeed seems to have some undefined source. That's funny, man. When he says undefined

1:11:43 source. It reminds me of the way I say and said earlier the unknown part of

1:11:48 ourselves, the undefined source. That's a part of us, but it's also not a

1:11:55 part of us at the same time. And that's something that I like to

1:12:00 imagine. I call it the unconscious. I like to use you a young's term. I think

1:12:04 that it's appropriate. And Carl Jung says that the unconscious is

1:12:11 where the archetypes exist.

1:12:13 And archetypes are exactly what Davy is calling here,

1:12:17 instinctive forces, instincts.

1:12:21 Davy and young are apples and apples here.

1:12:26 All right, he says,

1:12:27 a consciousness of good and evil

1:12:29 constantly belonging to the sentient principle in man.

1:12:32 So that's just a sort of part of a sentence,

1:12:34 but I wanted to bring it to you

1:12:35 because he's also saying,

1:12:37 he's also bringing this moral picture

1:12:39 in into this idea of sentience

1:12:41 And he says that a consciousness of good and evil is a part of being sentient, like being

1:12:48 aware of good and evil.

1:12:52 And to that, I can just say it sounds to me like another fractal picture, right?

1:13:01 It sounds to me like good and evil are opposites, you know, and just like we talked about before

1:13:06 with the ouroboros or the sisaji, when you take overarching concepts that are opposites,

1:13:12 but include all possibilities, like good and evil, there's nothing that can fall outside

1:13:18 of it.

1:13:19 You're going to capture everything if you look at that dichotomy, good and evil.

1:13:24 Another way of doing that is subject object.

1:13:27 Another way of doing that is being and non-being, we can go on and on, but you take any conceptualization

1:13:33 of opposites that encompass everything.

1:13:37 And you take those things together, and the symbol that you've got is what Jordan Peterson

1:13:41 calls the orboros, what Carl Jung calls the sisagy, which you have is the union of opposites,

1:13:47 the generative union of opposites.

1:13:49 That is the way that ancient people conceptualize God.

1:13:55 And what he's saying is this idea, this union of opposites, in particular, this good and

1:14:01 evil opposite union of opposites. It has this moral component, right? Because when we talk

1:14:06 about good and evil, that's what we mean. And that that's indistinguishable from, from

1:14:12 sentience that you can't remove that. It goes hand in hand with being conscious. It reminds

1:14:18 you of the story of the Garden of Eden, you know, Adam and Eve eat the fruit and they

1:14:23 become conscious. They become aware of good and evil. Okay. So now we go back to the

1:14:32 stranger who says, On my idea, conscious is the frame of mind fitted for its probation

1:14:39 and mortality. Obedience to its precepts not only prepares for a better state of existence

1:14:45 in another world, but is likewise calculated to make us happy here. We are constantly

1:14:51 taught to renounce selfish gratifications, to forget our body, to associate our pleasures

1:14:58 with mind, to fix our affections upon the one supreme being, and that we are capable

1:15:05 of forming to ourselves an imperfect idea of an infinite mind, is a strong presumption

1:15:11 of our own immortality, and of the distinct relation which our finite knowledge bears

1:15:17 to eternal wisdom."

1:15:19 Father, fucker, what a paragraph.

1:15:23 Okay.

1:15:24 So what is the stranger saying here?

1:15:26 He's saying he's saying that the fact that we can conceive of an infinite God

1:15:32 reflects some equally infinite capacity within ourselves

1:15:36 God the God within

1:15:38 If we were not ourselves infinite and eternal we could not conceive of either

1:15:46 That's something like that and then back to David. He says I am pleased with your views

1:15:53 They coincide with those I formed at the time my imagination was employed upon the vision of the Colosseum

1:15:59 The doctrine of the materialist was always, even in my youth, a cold heavy doll, an insupportable

1:16:07 doctrine to me, and necessarily tending to atheism.

1:16:13 So I'm going to stop there for a second just to point out, the materialist view is just

1:16:16 that everything's made of matter, everything's physical, that there is no spirit, there is

1:16:20 no God, there's nothing going on beyond the physical, everything can be explained by the

1:16:25 physical laws and the material that's in the cosmos end of story.

1:16:30 So you can imagine if you have that sort of way of thinking like most scientists do, most

1:16:36 modern western people do, there's not a lot of room in there for God.

1:16:41 It's just going to make you an atheist to think about things that way.

1:16:45 There's a question that can be asked that something like, if you limit your thinking

1:16:51 to just a material way of thinking, just a physical way of thinking, and you allow yourself

1:16:56 to be an atheist as a result, did you make a mistake? And are you missing something?

1:17:05 So then I'll pick up here where he says, I saw in all the powers of matter the instruments of the

1:17:11 deity, the sunbeams, the breath of the zephyr, awakened animation and forms prepared by divine

1:17:18 intelligence to receive it, the incension seed, the slumbering egg which were to be

1:17:25 Vivified, appeared like words of a divine mind.

1:17:30 I saw love as the creative principle in the material world,

1:17:34 and this love as a divine attribute.

1:17:38 Then I felt connected with new sensations

1:17:41 and indefinite hopes, a thirst for immortality.

1:17:48 So this is interesting.

1:17:50 It's one of the best quotes, and at least how it opens.

1:17:54 I saw in all the powers of matter the instruments

1:17:56 of the deity.

1:17:58 So when Davey says he's examining experimentally,

1:18:02 remember he was a scientist,

1:18:03 so he's examining matter experimentally

1:18:06 and trying to understand what it is.

1:18:08 And he saw in the workings of matter and energy

1:18:12 at the most basic level in the material world

1:18:15 the instrument of God.

1:18:19 So a panpsychist likes to put consciousness,

1:18:21 which again, I'll call God, I have no problem with that,

1:18:25 into matter, that matter and consciousness exists,

1:18:28 and she exists as one thing.

1:18:31 And they're not like Descartes told us two things,

1:18:33 but one thing, and they exist at the most basic level

1:18:36 of matter, not just in the creatures we call live,

1:18:39 but down even to the very atoms.

1:18:44 And so you've got God within even the atoms.

1:18:49 God within you as a human being,

1:18:50 and God within even the atoms.

1:18:52 And what they're doing, what the atoms are doing,

1:18:55 You know, all the things they do that make the physical world possible, that's the instrument

1:18:58 of God, he says.

1:19:04 And the God within it, he said, it's the incensient seed, the slumbering egg.

1:19:09 God goes in and makes it alive, and he says that they need to be vivified, that's what

1:19:14 he means.

1:19:15 You know, God goes in and makes it alive.

1:19:19 Then he says this bit at the end, I saw love as the creative principle in the material world.

1:19:26 And this love is a divine attribute.

1:19:29 And then I felt connected with new sensations and indefinite hopes of thirst for immortality.

1:19:34 Now, I can't help but point out that when you talk to somebody who's had a mystic experience

1:19:39 or a deeply psychedelic experience, they're going to tell you exactly those three things.

1:19:44 They're going to come away with three powerful takeaways.

1:19:49 Love, connection, and immortality.

1:19:55 exactly it. Connection, because all things are connected, right? You know, the mystic intuition

1:20:01 is that everything is one and that you're connected to all of it, you know? The immortality is exactly

1:20:08 that. That consciousness is not something that is born or dies, but it's the foundation of reality

1:20:14 itself. It's the only infinite and immortal thing. Might as well call that God. And that experience

1:20:23 is felt as a deep feeling of love, and that's exactly what we get from Davey.

1:20:33 And that brings me to my conclusion. Here we go. From Davey's vision of cosmic unity and

1:20:41 reincarnation, we move into dreams and altered states of consciousness which mirror the same

1:20:47 revelatory mystery. With Davey's last breath, he told the story of his vision, recognizing that

1:20:55 he could not die without sharing this great truth to which he'd reluctantly kept to himself

1:21:00 for a lifetime. In the same breath he tells of his dreams, and a glimpse of the future,

1:21:08 he received in the vision of a young woman. He'd first met in a fever dream before she was ever

1:21:14 even born. Davey emphasizes the unexplainable, the mysteries of existence that can be experienced,

1:21:22 but not explained or reasoned away. It was these uncanny occurrences that showed him the deepest

1:21:29 truth of being, that under it all, way down at the foundation of things, there is nothing but mystery.

1:21:38 The unknowable, the unconscious, the matrix of being itself. It is this gnosis, the secret

1:21:46 knowledge that Devi wished to share before he could no longer. He was desperate to, even at the

1:21:53 expense of his great scientific reputation, share the hard-won treasures of a lifetime of seeking.

1:22:03 Devi's treasure, it turns out, is a spiritual one. Perhaps spirit itself. He shines a light on

1:22:11 sentience as the force of vitality in the world, and as the instinct to religion.

1:22:18 Devi saw God as sentient as spirit in the religious sense.

1:22:24 He saw this same spirit within himself and all things, the animating force we call life.

1:22:32 And this was the key realization, God within.

1:22:37 Once Davie imagined the thing responsible for material reality is the same thing responsible

1:22:43 for his own consciousness.

1:22:45 He edges ever closer to formulating panpsychism.

1:22:51 Amazingly, he reasons through all the deepest and still unsolved problems of sentience.

1:22:58 Emergentism, the incompleteness of materialism, mind matter dualism, and the correlation

1:23:05 problem between brain states and consciousness.

1:23:08 All of these are addressed in turn, and the icing on the philosophical cake, the miracle

1:23:16 of sentience, is explained through the analogy of an earthworm.

1:23:22 Davey points to the earthworm who is cut into many pieces, which heal and exist as

1:23:27 independent beings.

1:23:29 But how did they achieve consciousness?

1:23:32 Which part of the worm carried it?

1:23:34 How did it share it with its pieces?

1:23:38 And Davey acknowledges that sentience is divisible, that one can be many and many one,

1:23:45 the great mystic insight.

1:23:48 And this cuts to the heart of the hard problem of consciousness, that we struggle with even

1:23:52 today.

1:23:55 If consciousness emerges from nature, how does it arise?

1:23:59 Where does it come from?

1:24:02 If it was a one in a Centillion accident of nature, how does this statistically impossible

1:24:08 accident occur countless times every second.

1:24:13 In every birth, in every cell division, in every severed earthworm, we bear witness to

1:24:19 a miracle, to an impossibility, to the immortality, sentience.

1:24:26 Well, there you have it.

1:24:31 That's one avenue explored, but infinitely more still to go.

1:24:36 I hope you enjoyed thinking along with us.

1:24:38 I know I know, it's not easy work.

1:24:41 Thinking, it's hard and full of uncertainties,

1:24:45 but I'm grateful for the company

1:24:47 as we trek through this together.

1:24:49 Here's to hoping that the juice is worth the squeeze.

1:24:53 See what I did there?

1:24:55 Let's find out together in the next episode.

All episodes