The Two Tongues Podcast
S2E8 · Mar 2, 2022 · 98 min
YouTube: Coming soon
In this episode Chris introduces the ideas of Dr. Peter Sjostedt-Hughes of TEDx fame, who focuses on psychedelics, metaphysics and panpsychism. This one focuses heavily on the idea of panpsychism. What is it? What it is not? And an explanation of all the various 'isms' that come along with any philosophical problem.
Enjoy 🙂
Machine-generated transcript; names and terms may contain errors.
0:00:03 Welcome, everyone, to the Two Tungs Podcast.
0:00:08 Consider this your invitation to join Kyle and Chris
0:00:13 on a journey through our minds,
0:00:16 where we explore the questions that have fascinated us
0:00:22 for as long as we can remember.
0:00:24 Could anarchy actually work?
0:00:26 Does God exist?
0:00:28 And just how did the cosmos get here anyway?
0:00:32 Let me be the Virgil to your Dante, the Sacagawea to your Lewis and Clark.
0:00:39 Let's take the guided tour through the dark chambers of our unconscious,
0:00:44 seeking answers to the most important and unsettled questions of our shared existence.
0:00:51 Ready or not, here we go.
0:00:55 Here we go. Welcome. Welcome back to another episode of the Two Tungs Podcast.
0:01:08 Single tongue coming at you today. Once again, this is a Chris episode you guys.
0:01:13 Thanks for joining me this morning. What am I doing today?
0:01:18 Well, I've been doing David Chalmer's conscious mind.
0:01:22 That's been a little bit more difficult than I expected.
0:01:25 At least it's taken more time than I expected.
0:01:27 What I did was, I don't know, I got a little bored as people do.
0:01:32 I can't be the only one that's reading more than one book at once.
0:01:37 can't be the only person doing that.
0:01:39 It's very, very difficult to keep things cohesive
0:01:43 when you're doing that.
0:01:44 Yeah, oftentimes you think the passage came
0:01:47 from one book or the other.
0:01:49 You complicate that problem when both books
0:01:51 are about consciousness and that's what's happened here.
0:01:54 So I wanted to take a little break from David Chalmers
0:01:57 and bring to you modes of sentience.
0:02:01 So I talked about this a little bit before.
0:02:04 I struggled quite a lot to pronounce the author's name,
0:02:09 so I'll apologize for that right now.
0:02:13 What I did do was went online.
0:02:16 I knew this author did a TED talk,
0:02:18 so I took a look at that,
0:02:19 tried to find some interviews online so that I could hear
0:02:23 if anybody else pronounced the guy's name
0:02:25 so that I didn't have to guess
0:02:26 and wouldn't have to sound like a fool.
0:02:29 The best I could do was circle back
0:02:31 to where I originally heard about the guy
0:02:33 on the Mind Escape podcast.
0:02:36 Gentlemen's name is Dr. Peter Shursted Hughes.
0:02:42 Shursted Hughes.
0:02:43 That is the pronunciation from Mind Escape.
0:02:46 So Dr. Hughes, your last name is hyphenated.
0:02:49 It's probably not appropriate to call you Dr. Hughes.
0:02:52 But hopefully that is the correct pronunciation.
0:02:56 It's spelled Scandinavian-like or Germanic-like.
0:03:01 S.J. Umloud STEDT. Does that sound like sure said to you? Not to me, but I'm American.
0:03:09 So apologies. Peter sure said Hughes wrote this book modes of sentience and got a copy
0:03:16 of it. Start greeting it. And it's really good. It's really good. It's actually kind
0:03:22 of a breath of fresh air compared to Chalmers conscious mind, not because conscious mind
0:03:27 is particularly difficult, it is difficult, but because the arguments that are made in
0:03:32 modes of sentience are way more to the point, they're way more concise, and they talk about
0:03:39 more than just consciousness, talks about panpsychism, it talks about Dr. Shursted Hughes
0:03:47 metaphysics, you know, his own philosophy of the origins of things, and he touches on
0:03:53 psychedelics, and he does it in a subtle way, which we'll see today at some point, that
0:03:59 I find interesting.
0:04:00 It's more interesting than strictly hearing Chalmers argument about consciousness because
0:04:06 it's easier to read, and it includes more than just the topic of consciousness.
0:04:14 It includes those related topics that are of particular interest to me.
0:04:20 What I'm going to do is pivot from Chalmers today, talk to you about modes of sentience.
0:04:24 This, let me tell you really quickly about hearing about this on the Mind Escape podcast.
0:04:31 That podcast is largely about consciousness and psychedelics, so when I found out about
0:04:35 that, I was gravitated towards it, listening a little bit.
0:04:38 It's a good one.
0:04:39 They had a couple of conversations with the author, Sharest had Hughes.
0:04:43 I caught the latest one.
0:04:47 What they talked about in that podcast was pretty interesting.
0:04:50 The focus was on using the word sentience.
0:04:54 The book title is modes of sentience.
0:04:57 We all kind of think about sentience and consciousness to be synonyms, and it turns
0:05:02 out they're not really synonyms.
0:05:04 We'll hear this from the quotes that I'll read you from the book.
0:05:08 We'll hear the explanation here, but the idea is something like consciousness is a complicated
0:05:15 in sophisticated type of sentience, but there are other types of sentience.
0:05:20 And when we talk about things being conscious, especially when we start talking about particles,
0:05:27 you know, being conscious or energy being conscious or things that you wouldn't ordinarily
0:05:32 think are conscious and you could see the argument made pretty powerfully against it, like a
0:05:37 rock is not conscious, you know, clearly, that kind of thing, we can avoid those issues
0:05:43 if we don't use the word consciousness. So we're not thinking about consciousness like you and I have,
0:05:48 but we can talk about sentience and imagine that these things have some basic type of experience.
0:05:54 And that's what it boils down to. I've said this before, it's like,
0:05:58 do you imagine that, do you imagine that a star somehow experiences or feels the
0:06:08 pull of gravity that it exerts on the things around it? Do you think it feels the pull of
0:06:13 of gravity from other galaxies and stars pulling on it?
0:06:16 Do you think it has an experience of some kind
0:06:19 of the combustion of hydrogen and helium
0:06:21 that are going on inside of it?
0:06:24 That's a good question.
0:06:26 Do you think that an electron or some of these quantum
0:06:29 particles, do you think they have
0:06:31 an experience of their interaction with each other?
0:06:34 Do you think they have an experience of jumping
0:06:36 orbitals, having a quantum leap or bonding
0:06:40 with another particle or compound, you know, in a molecule, do you think that those types
0:06:47 of experiences, you know, they're doing something, right?
0:06:50 These quantum particles and, you know, even the combinations of those particles that make
0:06:58 up molecules and so forth, they're doing things, you know, they're doing things.
0:07:03 So is it possible that there's some experience that they're having of the things they're
0:07:08 doing, that is sentience. And that, I think, does help, you know, have these arguments.
0:07:15 It does help have these conversations and make things a little bit more clear. You know,
0:07:19 and I never really appreciated, because it's tedious and boring, never really appreciated
0:07:25 the specific, the amount of detail and attention and importance that philosophers put on being
0:07:35 precise in their language. Being a fan of Jordan Peterson, that's something that shouldn't
0:07:41 be a surprise. He says, be precise in your speech. And there's reason for that. Because
0:07:46 being precise in your speech is to be precise in your thoughts. And that's something that
0:07:51 I've been loosey-goosey with to date. But this whole idea of Cincians replacing consciousness
0:07:57 as a concept, I actually do quite like. And that's where I got introduced to Peter
0:08:03 sure said Hughes originally from my escape having that conversation then I
0:08:08 entered engage with him a little bit on Twitter and he's quite the nice fellow
0:08:11 he's responded and you know you know I'm you know I'm nobody for lack of a
0:08:19 better word and he's interacting with me online which is which is sweet you know
0:08:22 so you know shout out to Peter sure said Hughes we're gonna do we're gonna do
0:08:28 an episode today based on modes of sentience really chapter one because I
0:08:32 think it does a great job of answering the question, what is panpsychism? So this is
0:08:40 something that I've talked about a lot lately. Talk to Daniel Torden about it a
0:08:45 lot on the last interview we did. And even the first interview we did, just to
0:08:49 refresh your memory, panpsychism is one of these ideas that stems from mystic
0:08:55 intuition. So people that have a mystic religious experience or a psychedelic
0:08:59 mystic experience will often talk about feeling like they become one with the universe, feeling
0:09:05 an expansion of their consciousness, feeling like consciousness is in everything. And
0:09:11 that perhaps there's perhaps it's of paramount importance to everything that we consider
0:09:18 the material world, both objective and subjective. It's a very strange feeling. And there's
0:09:26 There's a whole branch of philosophy and a whole branch of religion, really, of many
0:09:31 branches.
0:09:32 And we're going to talk about some of that today, that circle around that.
0:09:35 The idea that consciousness or mind is somehow paramount or fundamental to everything.
0:09:42 And that has to be sort of fit into the scientific narrative and the fact that it hasn't been
0:09:47 is sort of a tragedy.
0:09:51 A lot of people talk about that.
0:09:52 David Chalmers talked about that.
0:09:53 We talked about that with the conscious mind episodes.
0:09:57 Jordan Peterson talked about that quite a lot.
0:09:59 That gentleman, W Stacy, that Princeton professor
0:10:02 that I quoted many times, he focused heavily on that.
0:10:05 And that goes back to the turn of the century.
0:10:06 So science needs to understand that it doesn't
0:10:11 have a complete explanation to offer
0:10:14 that it needs to fill some gaps.
0:10:17 Without further ado, let's get into it.
0:10:21 So we're going to answer that question today.
0:10:22 what is panpsychism? I'm not going to be the one to answer that for you. I am going to let
0:10:28 Dr. Schurst that Hughes do it. So I don't know how to intro the good doctor here, but I'll do my best
0:10:37 how to introduce him how to introduce him. Well, his Twitter bio says, says this, says,
0:10:43 Whitehead, Nietzsche, Spinoza, psilocybin. All right, all right, man, after my own
0:10:52 heart. Associate lecturer, TEDx talk. Okay, well, I like a good TEDx talk. I did
0:10:59 listen to Peter Schursted Hughes, TEDx talk. It was quite good, you know, it's
0:11:05 short and sweet. I encourage you guys to take a look. So I think this interest in
0:11:10 Alfred Whitehead, Friedrich Nietzsche, Baruch Spinoza, and then popping in
0:11:14 psilocybin as though that's the name of another philosopher of mind. Pretty
0:11:19 interesting. So you see the psychedelic stuff. You know, I'm a big fan of
0:11:22 Spinoza. We've talked about that. Haven't really had much of an opportunity to get
0:11:26 into Nietzsche or Whitehead so far in my life. That's probably it's a
0:11:30 disappointment. Turns out Whitehead is somebody that I'm gonna have to put on
0:11:33 the list after reading the beginning of this book. I cannot get away from that.
0:11:37 Alfred North Whitehead seems to be quite the character in terms of philosophy of
0:11:42 mind, consciousness studies and and psychedelics. So he experimented with
0:11:49 nitrous oxide himself. So I think that's a pretty good I mean just looking at his
0:11:53 Twitter bio sums up you know what we're gonna talk about in a nutshell what his
0:11:58 interests are but just so you know he's a lecturer at Trinity College London
0:12:03 that's a pretty prestigious thing. He also teaches philosophy of mind at the
0:12:08 University of Exeter. Personally Dr. Schurst that he has been pretty
0:12:15 approachable to me on Twitter like I said you know it's always nice to have
0:12:19 good interactions with people online and you know I don't know it came as a bit
0:12:25 of a surprise to me. He's also introduced me to such mind-blowing ideas as those
0:12:32 of Andre Bergson who we talked about on the last couple of podcasts that that's
0:12:36 gonna be that's gonna be something we'll talk about in the future and a guy
0:12:40 named Herbert Feigle F-E-I-G-L so just you know a good follow a good follow on
0:12:47 Twitter to be sure again thank you Dr. Shersted Hughes for introducing me to
0:12:53 Bergson and Feigle I'm gonna be doing some deeper dive on that so that maybe
0:12:58 that's a good introduction to the author. The next one is a quote from the book, but I think it
0:13:04 introduces panpsychism a little bit, so I'm just going to read this to you. He talks about the
0:13:11 history of panpsychism a little bit, and one of those quotes is this, panpsychism bears a proud
0:13:16 history of eminent thinkers, such as Thales and Heraclitus, through to the great Renaissance
0:13:23 figures such as Patrice and Bruno. To the mind, matter, cognizant of the modern era,
0:13:30 Spinoza, Leibniz, Chopinauer, William James, Alfred North Whitehead, and arguably Bertrand
0:13:37 Russell. So I don't know if you guys know any of those names, but it's quite the who's who of
0:13:43 philosophers. What he's saying here is that this idea of panpsychism goes back a long ways,
0:13:48 and he's providing evidence by using the names Thales and Heraclitus. Those are ancient Greek
0:13:54 pre-socratic philosophers. They go back way before Plato, and here you have big names in the history
0:14:02 of Western philosophy that he's saying were panpsychists or entertained those ideas. That's pretty cool.
0:14:09 And then he fast forwards to the Renaissance and talks about Patrice and Bruno.
0:14:14 I think Patrice, he said it was the person who coined the term panpsychism. Bruno,
0:14:19 And I may be misremembering that Bruno was a man that was burned at the stake for having
0:14:26 some panpsychist ideas during the Inquisition.
0:14:29 And then he goes on to talk about people like Spinoza, who we've talked about many times,
0:14:34 Leibniz, who invented calculus with Newton and is a huge, huge name in philosophy and
0:14:40 mathematics.
0:14:41 Chopinauer, who we talked about in the early days of the podcast, it's also somebody I
0:14:45 I need to get into more, but a huge name in philosophy,
0:14:49 William James, who we just recently did an episode on.
0:14:51 He wrote the book Varieties of Religious Experience
0:14:54 and had a huge impact.
0:14:58 Alfred North Whitehead, who I said,
0:15:00 we're gonna have to get into and you'll see why today.
0:15:04 And then Bertrand Russell, who's somebody that I admire,
0:15:07 he's got a relatively modern philosopher,
0:15:10 English philosopher, who wrote and said
0:15:13 some tremendously powerful things.
0:15:15 I was introduced to him from a book
0:15:17 that was like a summary,
0:15:19 history of Western philosophy, basically.
0:15:20 It's like philosophy for dummies.
0:15:23 If you wanna know what all the great philosophers said,
0:15:25 but you don't wanna go and read all of the shit,
0:15:28 then you just pick up a copy of Bertrand Russell's
0:15:30 history of Western philosophy.
0:15:31 It's a big book, but you can take it chunk by chunk
0:15:33 and get a pretty good idea
0:15:34 of what all the philosophers believed.
0:15:36 Point is, Bertrand Russell had quite the handle
0:15:39 on Western philosophy and contributed
0:15:42 in lots of interesting ways.
0:15:44 I resisted Bertrand Russell a little bit
0:15:46 because he was an atheist.
0:15:48 And clearly, I don't believe that.
0:15:52 But that's somebody who I'm gonna have to get into even more.
0:15:55 So thank you, Dr. Shursted Hughes,
0:15:58 for giving me a bunch of homework to do.
0:16:02 That being said, let's get into it.
0:16:07 All right, I'm gonna call this first section.
0:16:09 What is it?
0:16:10 Penpsychism, what is it?
0:16:12 The good doctor he answers this way, he says the word panpsychism is a Renaissance compound
0:16:18 of the ancient Greek pan, which means all, and psyche, which means mind or soul.
0:16:26 And then he gives this explanation really short and sweet, all of matter includes mind.
0:16:31 Okay, so we heard some of that from David Chalmers in the episodes we've done on him
0:16:37 lately. And we already knew, you know, we already talked about panpsychias and breaking down in the
0:16:43 in the Greek, you know, pan all and psyche mind. So everything is mind, everything is soul,
0:16:49 everything is consciousness, something like that. And then he clarifies by saying all of matter
0:16:55 includes consciousness. So we're going to have to flesh that out, we're going to have to figure
0:16:59 out exactly what he means by that. But that, that is the short and sweet answer to what is
0:17:04 panpsychism. It means that everything is consciousness. And what that means is
0:17:09 something like even the material world, the thing that's matter, you know, we
0:17:13 often think about mind and matter is separate. He's saying, oh no, all of matter
0:17:18 includes mind. So it's not clear whether that means that consciousness is has a
0:17:24 component to it, or excuse me, matter has a component to it. It's conscious, or matter
0:17:27 is consciousness, you know, it does not clear what that means, but we're gonna
0:17:31 If we're going to see that in just a bit, that is how he answers the question, what
0:17:36 is panpsychism?
0:17:37 All matter includes minds.
0:17:41 But he does this one better and he gives us a bit of what it's not.
0:17:46 So let's talk about what panpsychism isn't.
0:17:50 He says, it is unlike idealism and that it takes matter to be real rather than a mere
0:17:57 projection of the mind.
0:17:59 It is unlike dualism in that it does not take mind to be separate from matter, but rather
0:18:05 it takes mind to be intrinsic to matter.
0:18:08 And it is unlike physicalism as understood to imply that most matter is incensient.
0:18:13 All right, let's pump the brakes.
0:18:16 That's going to take some explanation.
0:18:18 All right, so whenever you dive into any philosophical idea, it could be a political one, it could
0:18:26 be, you know, in this case, a philosophy of mind, could be any topic you want, when you
0:18:30 jump into something that philosophers have talked about to any degree, what you're going
0:18:35 to find is a difference of opinion. And those difference of opinion, think about this like
0:18:40 religious denominations. The difference of opinion breaks up into factions. And this
0:18:45 is what philosophers love to do. They love to define things and put things in boxes,
0:18:50 because that's what helps you to understand them. That's what helps you to use them.
0:18:54 You know, that's what helps you to get to get by in the world.
0:18:58 You've got to put things in a box.
0:19:00 So whenever you have philosophers with differing opinion, what that means is you end up with
0:19:04 different philosophies, just like you end up with different religions with, you know,
0:19:08 variants and denominations and beliefs.
0:19:11 And you end up with lots of isms.
0:19:13 And this is my objection, my biggest objection to reading philosophy.
0:19:19 And again, this is probably related back to what I said earlier about having an appreciation
0:19:23 for the precision of language and words and what they mean, talking about the difference
0:19:27 between using the word consciousness and using the word sentience.
0:19:31 It does make a big difference.
0:19:32 So I'm a little bit on both sides of this argument.
0:19:35 I think that when you read philosophy and you have to, and you're reading all these
0:19:38 isms, like we just did, idealism, dualism, physicalism, it's like, wait a minute, man,
0:19:44 now I have to look those up, now I have to figure out what that means.
0:19:47 It just makes reading philosophy more difficult.
0:19:50 And I also object a lot to the idea that you can fit ideas into a box cleanly, because
0:19:58 you can't, because the edges are fuzzy.
0:20:01 And when you try to explain to somebody what idealism is or what dualism is, the truth
0:20:06 is, it's not that thing.
0:20:10 It includes those fuzzy edges that aren't exactly what you mean by idealism or dualism
0:20:14 or whatever.
0:20:15 There's no clear cut definitions as much as philosophers like to think there are.
0:20:20 So it just makes it challenging.
0:20:21 So that's what I'm going to try to help you with here.
0:20:25 Actually, I can let Dr. Schurst that
0:20:29 use explain it, which he's going to do in a little bit.
0:20:34 But I think it's good, because all of these ideas,
0:20:36 when we're talking about panpsychism,
0:20:39 we're talking about idealism, dualism, physicalism,
0:20:43 these are all different philosophical approaches
0:20:45 to the same thing, to understanding the mind, body,
0:20:48 problem? Mind and matter? What are they? Why are they different? Are they
0:20:52 different? What are the differences? How do they interact with each other? Do they
0:20:56 interact with each other? Just what in the same hell is going on? That's the
0:20:59 mind-matter problem. All of these isms that we're talking about are different
0:21:04 philosophers' opinions about how to solve that problem or how that problem
0:21:07 should be or could be solved. We're going to talk about idealism a little bit, but
0:21:12 it's something I'm a little bit sensitive to. Is that the right word sensitive? I like
0:21:19 the idea a little bit. It resonates with me a little bit. And that comes from the mystic
0:21:24 experience. Idealism is the idea that, again, like he says, matter is a projection of the
0:21:30 mind. Matter may not really exist, at least not the way we think it does. Matter, what
0:21:35 we call matter might actually be something like a projection of the mind, whatever that
0:21:41 That means, and again, when you have a mystic experience, especially that one with universe
0:21:51 experience that I was trying to describe a little earlier, that's something that does
0:21:56 resonate.
0:21:57 It's like, yeah, okay, when I had that mystic experience, what the thing I remember saying
0:22:02 was that everything is God's dream, right?
0:22:06 So what does that mean?
0:22:08 It's like, think about your dreams.
0:22:10 It's like nothing there is really material.
0:22:12 It all seems to be just like you're waking life,
0:22:14 but it's not real somehow.
0:22:16 And that's the kind of feeling you're left with
0:22:21 in mystic intuition, that even the real world,
0:22:23 even a matter itself is illusory somehow.
0:22:26 It's not what it seems to be.
0:22:28 So this is what I mean when I say I'm sympathetic.
0:22:33 That's the word I was looking for, to idealism.
0:22:36 Okay, so that's idealism in a nutshell.
0:22:39 Dualism is, we're all familiar with.
0:22:40 Dualism is like the difference between matter and mind
0:22:46 being cut and dry, there's no overlap between them,
0:22:50 there are two separate things.
0:22:52 If you come from the Western Christian background,
0:22:54 dualism makes perfect sense
0:22:55 because rather than talking about mind and matter,
0:22:57 you can just go back to talking about body and soul.
0:23:00 And that's something that religions talk about.
0:23:05 Christianity certainly talks about it, any kind of aesthetic religion, excuse me, not
0:23:10 aesthetic religion, any religion that values like the monk lifestyle, going out and a
0:23:24 minimalist lifestyle, you know, like Buddhism comes to mind for instance.
0:23:31 These are people that believe that there's a distinction between body and mind, and usually
0:23:37 If you think about the Gnostic Christians, for instance, usually they think about the
0:23:40 body as being bad, and the soul being good, and about you being able to, like the religious
0:23:46 process is something about purifying yourself to become more spiritual and less physical,
0:23:52 something like that.
0:23:54 That's possible to become more spirit than body.
0:23:58 You can think about like the Christian resistance, especially here in the United States coming
0:24:06 coming from our history here, the pilgrims and some religious groups that weren't, they
0:24:18 were awful buttoned up, so when you think about sex and taboo surrounding sex, and even in
0:24:24 this country, taboo surrounding language and curse words, like, man, you can't imagine,
0:24:29 you go over to the UK and you hear people using the word cunt constantly, and you can
0:24:33 And imagine that happening here in all of the eyebrows you would get if you called somebody
0:24:37 that, you know, Willie Billy, those are the kind of things that I'm pointing to when I
0:24:41 say we have considered the body in the physical world to be somehow sinful, somehow, you know,
0:24:50 something to avoid.
0:24:51 And that's that those are the ways in which you can see it in our own culture with these
0:24:55 taboos against the body, against sex, against identifying with, you know, just think about
0:25:02 intoxication and the taboos surrounding that.
0:25:04 These are all good explanations for trying
0:25:08 to understand this dualism that we separate mind and body.
0:25:13 And again, it fits right into this sort
0:25:15 of religious narrative that I describe.
0:25:20 Then there's this idea of physicalism,
0:25:22 which you guys will probably know as materialism.
0:25:24 Physicalism just means everything is physical.
0:25:27 Everything is governed by physical laws.
0:25:29 Everything is made of physical substances.
0:25:31 Physical, material, things are all that exist.
0:25:35 Okay, that's like the scientific paradigm
0:25:37 that we're in now.
0:25:38 There is no consciousness.
0:25:39 There is no spirit.
0:25:40 It's all physical.
0:25:41 It's all material, that kind of thing.
0:25:45 Okay, and so what I mean is he,
0:25:49 when I say that this is describing what panpsychism is not.
0:25:53 Again, he's just saying panpsychism is not idealism.
0:25:57 It doesn't believe that matter is a projection of the mind.
0:26:00 It's not dualism.
0:26:02 It doesn't believe that mind and matter are separate,
0:26:04 and it's not physicalism or materialism.
0:26:06 It doesn't believe that the physical or material
0:26:10 are all that exists.
0:26:11 There's more to existence than just the physical.
0:26:15 Okay, okay.
0:26:16 Well, that helps, that helps clarify,
0:26:18 but he's gonna do a bit more of that.
0:26:22 All right, this next segment,
0:26:24 I'm gonna call consciousness versus sentient.
0:26:26 So we talked a little bit about that already,
0:26:28 but I'm gonna give you Dr. Sote Hughes's explanation.
0:26:32 So here we go.
0:26:34 Panpsychism differentiates a vast variety
0:26:37 of states of sentience.
0:26:39 And it mostly attributes sentience
0:26:41 to self-systematic entities such as organisms and molecules
0:26:46 rather than to aggregates thereof,
0:26:48 such as rocks and radiators.
0:26:51 Okay, so that's pretty interesting.
0:26:53 So here he's making the, he's explaining
0:26:56 or making the distinction between consciousness
0:26:58 and sentience and he's saying that
0:27:00 panpsychism generally talks about cinchants
0:27:03 rather than consciousness.
0:27:04 And it attributes cinchants to self-systematic entities,
0:27:11 organisms and molecules he's talking about.
0:27:15 Panpsychism is not going to attribute cinchants
0:27:19 to aggregates of those things,
0:27:21 such as rocks and radiators.
0:27:23 So to me, that's pretty interesting.
0:27:25 And it's kind of hard to explain.
0:27:28 Like if you believe that an atom or a molecule has some level of experience, why wouldn't
0:27:35 a rock?
0:27:37 Why wouldn't a radiator?
0:27:40 He's going to explain that a little bit later when he's talking about a dead body.
0:27:44 He's like, look, at one point, a body is full of these things that he would call sentient.
0:27:52 The microorganisms in your belly, in your blood, on your skin.
0:27:58 even the cells, the molecules that make up those cells, that there's at least parts
0:28:04 of this larger system that are sentient already, all on their own.
0:28:09 But with a human being, it sort of aggregates and you have this larger sentience in control
0:28:14 of all of the others.
0:28:16 That's how you view yourself as a self, you know?
0:28:21 When that body dies, the organizing sentience, you know, with the thing that you call yourself,
0:28:26 That breaks down and is gone, but all of the other sentience going on inside your cells
0:28:32 and in the microorganisms in your body, they haven't gone away.
0:28:35 They're still there.
0:28:37 That's how he'll describe that in a little bit.
0:28:39 I find that interesting because if a rock is made of molecules and molecules he's going
0:28:44 to say are sentient, then why isn't a rock?
0:28:48 Maybe it's because the rock doesn't have experiences at the level of the rock.
0:28:53 all of the experiences that are being had are at the level of the molecules.
0:28:57 But I don't know that that's a satisfactory explanation.
0:28:59 I guess what I'm saying here is I don't know that I entirely go with this statement that
0:29:05 rocks and radiators aren't conscious or don't have sentience to some degree.
0:29:10 I kind of think they do and I think for the same reasons that he's saying they don't.
0:29:15 He's saying molecules have half sentience, but rocks don't.
0:29:17 I'm just going to say I'm going to put a question mark there.
0:29:20 I don't know that I entirely, I don't know that I would make the statement the same
0:29:24 way.
0:29:25 All right.
0:29:26 He goes on.
0:29:27 He says, in the hierarchy of states of mind, consciousness is an uncommon, complex crown
0:29:34 of sentience.
0:29:36 He says, all has mind, though not all has consciousness.
0:29:40 Okay.
0:29:41 So that's a pretty good explanation.
0:29:43 And I think this is what made sense to me.
0:29:45 He said, look, there's all different kinds of sentience.
0:29:48 thought, you know, there's this base consciousness, something you might call awareness or experience.
0:29:53 And then there's something more complex and sophisticated, and it's called consciousness.
0:29:58 And that's something that you and I display, or maybe we display something even higher,
0:30:02 something that I would call self-consciousness.
0:30:04 But there, you can see animals and maybe other things that clearly seem to be conscious in
0:30:09 the way that we are.
0:30:11 So that is something that he says is at the very top of this structure of sentience.
0:30:16 It's the most sophisticated thing that we know about on that continuum, but there are
0:30:20 lots of other types of sentience, and that's equally important.
0:30:25 Then he explains, he says, even Plato acknowledged such distinctions.
0:30:30 So Plato, he says, stated, the plant is without belief or reason or understanding, but has
0:30:37 appetite and a sense of pleasure and pain.
0:30:42 So he is deferring to Plato here.
0:30:46 By the way, I got an insert here.
0:30:48 I've used the quote many, many, many times on this podcast
0:30:51 that everything is a footnote to Plato,
0:30:53 and that's something that's been said a lot.
0:30:55 Now we're talking about Plato here.
0:30:57 It turns out Dr. So Hughes talks,
0:31:00 sure said Hughes, talks a bunch about Alfred North Whitehead,
0:31:04 and we're gonna talk about him today and more in the future.
0:31:07 He's the guy that quoted that, that was his quote,
0:31:11 that everything is, all of Western philosophy
0:31:13 is a series of footnotes to Plato.
0:31:15 So look, the connections you make, it's really funny.
0:31:20 So I've been using that quote many, many times.
0:31:22 Now I've discovered that through this book,
0:31:25 that it was actually Whitehead's quote.
0:31:28 So there you have it.
0:31:29 But here we go.
0:31:29 He's saying that Plato's describing that plants
0:31:33 seem to have some of the qualities
0:31:36 that we would call sentience or conscious.
0:31:38 And he talks about that being a sense of pleasure and pain
0:31:42 and even an appetite.
0:31:44 you can see a flower following the sun.
0:31:47 Why?
0:31:47 Because it's drinking that shit up.
0:31:49 Because it's using that light for photosynthesis.
0:31:53 That's feeding the plant, right?
0:31:55 So that shows that it has a will and it has an appetite.
0:31:59 That's amazing.
0:32:00 And it's true.
0:32:01 You can see that.
0:32:02 It's hard to write that off.
0:32:03 It's hard to say that a plant isn't conscious
0:32:06 when it's illustrating those sorts of characteristics.
0:32:12 All right, this section I'm going to call the mind body problem.
0:32:18 All right, so it goes like this.
0:32:21 The problem of understanding the relation
0:32:23 between mind and matter has brought human understanding
0:32:27 to an impasse.
0:32:29 The question is, how something describable
0:32:32 in physical spatial temporal terms, such as neuronal activity,
0:32:37 can relate to something that cannot be described
0:32:39 spatial temporal, such as melancholy or curiosity. We know that mind and matter can be correlated,
0:32:47 but we do not know the nature of that correlation. So this is the mind, body, problem in a nutshell.
0:32:54 It's like we know that the mind, that consciousness and the body, the physical part of ourselves,
0:32:59 they seem to be very different things. And it's hard. You can't explain one using the other or the
0:33:04 the other, you know, you can't. And so there's this, there's this strange dichotomy between
0:33:09 mind and body that we're struggling with. The way that, uh, the way that, uh, Dr. Sherse
0:33:14 that Hughes talks about it is saying you can't describe something like melancholy or curiosity,
0:33:21 something that's subjective, something that's part of our inner experience. You can't explain
0:33:26 that, uh, using anything physical or what he calls spatial temporal. That just means bound
0:33:32 by space and time. It's just like the reality that we exist in. You can't use anything from
0:33:39 that realm to describe or explain curiosity, this inner experience. That's what David
0:33:47 Chalmers calls qualia. You can't. So that's basically a summary of David Chalmers argument
0:33:54 right there. He says that they're correlated. We know that states of mind, that physical
0:34:00 states in the brain are correlated with these qualia like something like melancholy or curiosity.
0:34:06 We know that they're correlated but we just have no idea what the correlation is or what it means
0:34:10 or how it works. That's actually what the next bit of the David Chalmers episode is going to talk
0:34:16 about is exactly that the correlation and how that might be able to be used to come up with a new
0:34:21 theory of consciousness. I'm going to leave that for Chalmers but this is a good summary of the
0:34:26 mind body problem. He goes on, he says, a popular proposed solution is emergentism. We talked
0:34:36 about emergence before on this podcast. I'm going to let Dr. Hughes continue. He's defining
0:34:44 emergentism here. He says that mental states emerge from physical states. So this is what
0:34:50 the scientific paradigm would want you to believe,
0:34:54 or what have you believe,
0:34:56 that the qualia, the inner experience
0:34:59 that you can't explain by physical laws at all,
0:35:02 that they emerge, your consciousness emerges
0:35:05 from physical states, from something physical, okay?
0:35:09 So something non-physical emerges from something physical.
0:35:12 That is what the scientists want you to believe.
0:35:16 Dr. Schurst that you says, the problem here
0:35:19 is that there are no known bridge laws
0:35:22 that could describe how such emergence takes place.
0:35:28 So there's basically what David Chalmers calls
0:35:31 an explanatory gap.
0:35:34 There's nothing that takes you
0:35:36 from the non-physical to the physical or back.
0:35:39 There's no known laws of physics that can do that.
0:35:42 So there's something missing here.
0:35:43 Emergitism might seem like an interesting idea,
0:35:47 But in practice, we have the slightest idea
0:35:49 how it could be possible.
0:35:53 So that's a pretty critical flaw.
0:35:55 He says, there are other more extreme proposed solutions
0:36:00 to the mind matter problem, such as physicalist
0:36:04 limitivism.
0:36:06 So this is more isms that we have to talk about.
0:36:08 Physicalist limitivism, which denies the existence of mind
0:36:13 and its contrary, subjective idealism,
0:36:16 which denies the existence of matter.
0:36:19 Okay, so to me, this is like science versus mysticism.
0:36:24 And let me just talk about these isms a little bit.
0:36:27 So physicalist, a limit to wisdom, you know,
0:36:32 again, you're looking at the words physical
0:36:34 and, you know, to eliminate, right?
0:36:37 So the idea is that it denies the existence of mind.
0:36:42 Then you've got subjective idealism
0:36:44 which denies the existence of matter.
0:36:46 So we can potentially, we can get around the mind-body problem by saying only mind exists
0:36:54 or only matter exists.
0:36:56 And in that way we can eliminate this problem of thinking that there are two separate, distinct
0:37:01 things and yet, you know, interacting or emerging from one another, we can just go right around
0:37:06 that problem by saying either it's just really it's just mind and there is no matter or
0:37:13 It's just matter, and there is no mind.
0:37:17 And again, I think that that's science versus mysticism.
0:37:20 Science is the one that wants you to believe everything
0:37:23 is physical, because science can't
0:37:25 be used to describe the non-physical.
0:37:28 Then we just want to ignore it and say everything is physical.
0:37:32 And mysticism, like I talked about earlier
0:37:34 with my own mystic experience, having
0:37:36 one of these one with the universe experiences,
0:37:38 you want to believe that consciousness is all there is,
0:37:41 and that matter doesn't exist,
0:37:43 or it's just a part of consciousness somehow.
0:37:46 So I think that is a really good way
0:37:48 of understanding these other potential solutions.
0:37:51 It's also important to note that Dr. Shersted Hughes
0:37:53 says that there are more extreme proposals,
0:37:56 which presumably means that they're a little bit
0:38:00 more difficult to believe, and you can kind of see why.
0:38:05 Because if you're saying only matter exists
0:38:07 or only mind exists, you know deep down
0:38:10 that you're leaving something unexplained, and so there you have it.
0:38:16 So this is where he swoops in and says, from this background, panpsychism begins to be
0:38:21 seen as a potentially clear exit road, which may lead to a more comprehensive view of reality.
0:38:28 So it doesn't have to be, he's saying it doesn't have to be to solve this mind and
0:38:33 matter problem that we assume something, you know, out there, like only matter exists
0:38:39 or only mind exists, and there isn't, you know, everything else is an illusion, the
0:38:45 idea that there might be two separate things, that that's an illusion, panpsychism is coming
0:38:50 in to give us a third option. So what is that? Let's get into it. This next section, I'm
0:38:58 going to call the arguments. Let's make some arguments together, guys. All right, here
0:39:04 we go. He says, if one does not believe in panpsychism, then one believes that sentience
0:39:10 at one point in time, emerged from incentiate matter. Fair enough. If you don't believe
0:39:17 in panpsychism, he's basically saying you have to be somebody who believes in emergence.
0:39:23 Because if consciousness is not a part of matter always, then you have to explain it.
0:39:31 And to explain it, you're going to say at some point it popped into existence. And this
0:39:35 is an interesting kind of evolutionary thought experiment, because you can imagine a life
0:39:39 evolving from non-life, that's sort of an unexplained miracle, but that happens.
0:39:47 And then life becomes more and more sophisticated and evolves in different directions.
0:39:52 And at some point, they become sentient.
0:39:56 At some point, they become sentient.
0:39:58 Where is that point?
0:40:01 Did it happen before life emerged?
0:40:03 It happened when these really basic proteins and molecules were fusing together in the
0:40:10 primordial soup and eventually would become life.
0:40:13 Did it happen before that life barrier?
0:40:16 Did it happen after?
0:40:17 At what point did it emerge?
0:40:19 What ascension?
0:40:20 What and when?
0:40:22 These are all questions you have to ask.
0:40:23 If you don't believe in panpsychism, then you must believe that consciousness emerged
0:40:28 somehow at some point in time.
0:40:30 So when and why and how and all these questions come about
0:40:34 if you aren't a panpsychist.
0:40:36 So that's pretty interesting.
0:40:38 It's an interesting way of simplifying the argument
0:40:41 down to basically two choices, panpsychism or emergentism.
0:40:48 All right, he goes on, he says, by implication,
0:40:51 if one does believe in panpsychism,
0:40:53 one believes that sentience always existed with matter
0:40:57 and thus never emerged at a point in time.
0:41:01 Thus, if we reject emergentism,
0:41:03 we thereby advocate panpsychism, right?
0:41:09 Seems that way to me?
0:41:10 Pretty cut and dry argument.
0:41:12 And to me, it's what's obviously simpler and easier
0:41:16 to understand than what we talked about
0:41:18 when we were doing David Chalmers' conscious mind.
0:41:20 I mean, Chalmers goes into detail,
0:41:24 addressing every single other approach,
0:41:27 all these philosophical isms, and then talking about where their strengths and weaknesses
0:41:31 are, and demolishing them, undermining them.
0:41:34 And what Dr. Schurst that Hughes did was said, you know, well, you don't really have to go
0:41:38 to that level of analysis.
0:41:40 All you have to do is look at the problem this way.
0:41:43 Did the sentience, has sentience always existed?
0:41:46 Or did it emerge?
0:41:47 Did it come into existence at some point in time?
0:41:51 That's the question.
0:41:52 If you can answer that question, then the rest of those details aren't important.
0:41:58 And I think I agree, I think I agree.
0:42:01 And this is interesting too because there are parallels here.
0:42:04 When we're talking about consciousness, there are always parallels to ontology, to how the
0:42:11 universe was created.
0:42:14 And it has something to do with the fact that our consciousness seems, I don't know how
0:42:20 to put this.
0:42:21 It's like when we opened our eyes, when we were born, and we opened up our eyes, it's like the world began.
0:42:29 And, you know, you could take that even further and say that when you first started to have experiences as a fetus, let's say,
0:42:36 then the world started to unfold for you.
0:42:39 And when you die, the world kind of shuts off.
0:42:42 The world is born when you are born, and the world dies when you die.
0:42:46 That's our experience.
0:42:48 So there's this always a connection between consciousness and creation
0:42:53 between consciousness and stories of origins and religion.
0:42:56 There is always this parallel.
0:42:58 And one of the things that was mind-bendy for me,
0:43:04 and set me off into this whole other area of research,
0:43:09 was thinking about, as a teenager, really,
0:43:12 thinking about the question of the creation,
0:43:15 thinking about it from a theological perspective,
0:43:17 God created the cosmos, and thinking about it from a scientific perspective, like there
0:43:21 were conditions that caused the Big Bang, and because of physical laws and gravity and
0:43:25 so forth, everything sort of unfolded the way it did.
0:43:28 And thinking about both of those ideas, and this is what occurred to me, it's exactly
0:43:34 the argument that Dr. Schursted Hughes made about consciousness, either God always existed,
0:43:42 and the cosmos always existed, or God created the cosmos and it came into existence at
0:43:50 a certain point in time.
0:43:54 And that's the same argument he's making about consciousness.
0:43:57 Either consciousness always existed, or, and again I should be using the word sentience
0:44:02 rather than consciousness, forgive me, either sentience always existed or it came into existence
0:44:08 at some point in time.
0:44:10 So that's really the only way to look at either one of those questions.
0:44:15 And I think it's, I'm going to leave it to you to kind of unravel what I mean by that.
0:44:20 But I think it's particularly interesting that the argument about consciousness and
0:44:24 the argument about the creation of the world of the material reality, that those arguments
0:44:30 are basically the same arguments.
0:44:33 And you can simplify them down to this either or sit scenario.
0:44:37 All right.
0:44:38 Moving on.
0:44:39 He provides examples of emergence so that we can try to get our head around it.
0:44:44 He says this, he says,
0:44:46 a whirlpool emerges from water.
0:44:50 Water emerges from H2O molecules.
0:44:54 Then he says,
0:44:55 but the patterned movement of particles in the brain
0:44:58 makes emerge mental states that cannot be observed
0:45:02 is a claim that is not scientific.
0:45:05 So this is another jab at the idea of emergence.
0:45:08 It's like you can see how a whirlpool emerges from water.
0:45:13 You get this thing that's not exactly water.
0:45:15 It's a whirlpool.
0:45:16 It's something that's possible when you have water, but that it can emerge under the right
0:45:21 circumstances.
0:45:22 You get this new thing called a whirlpool from this other thing called water.
0:45:27 And he says the same thing about water, says you can take these hydrogen and oxygen molecules,
0:45:32 you put them together in a certain way, and water, this liquidy substance that we can
0:45:36 pick up with her hands and drip out of her fingers and put in a glass and drink, that
0:45:41 this thing emerges from H2O.
0:45:43 So you have one thing, these molecules, and they create this other thing.
0:45:49 And there's one way which we would say, no, water and H2O are the same thing.
0:45:54 But are they?
0:45:55 Are they?
0:45:56 If you have a couple of H2O molecules in the palm of your hand, you know, is that the
0:46:02 same thing as swimming in the ocean?
0:46:04 I don't know.
0:46:05 So there's this way of understanding emergence as something new coming from itself, and that's
0:46:13 an interesting and mystical thought, which I kind of like.
0:46:18 But when it comes to the brain, he's saying that when you look at the physical things
0:46:23 going on in the brain, the movement of particles within the brain, to try to think that from
0:46:29 those particles moving in the brain, you know, electroactivity in your neurons, let's say,
0:46:34 From that activity, mental states that can't be observed scientifically, that they emerge
0:46:39 from that, like water emerges from H2O, he's like, that is not a scientific claim.
0:46:49 Not only for the reason that those mental states can't be observed, and if they can't
0:46:53 be observed, they can't be tested scientifically, but because there is an explanatory gap between
0:47:00 the physical and the non-physical. There are no known bridge laws, as he said.
0:47:08 Alright, here he says, there are no known laws of nature that can render the emergence of
0:47:13 emotion from motion, of sentience from incentience. Furthermore, emergentism cannot accommodate
0:47:22 mental causation. And he explains that by saying that mental events such as desires
0:47:27 can have an effect upon the world. He says, as mentality is not an accepted force of nature.
0:47:34 So this is interesting. So imagine this. A scientist is going to say, everything is physical.
0:47:41 Everything can be explained by physical laws. So there is no role in mind as a cause and
0:47:47 effect situation in the world. Everything is physical. If you exert a force on an object,
0:47:55 object moves. There is nothing more going on than the physical. That's what the
0:47:59 modern scientific paradigm wants you to think. But he says, what about something
0:48:05 like desire? Is it not fair to say that your desire, which is this inner state
0:48:10 that can't be explained physically at all, that your desires causing you to go
0:48:15 and do something physical? Isn't it possible that something like that has a
0:48:19 causal role in the physical world? Well, he says, look, scientists are going to say
0:48:24 mentality, desire, is not an accepted force of nature. It's not gravity, it's not
0:48:30 the weak nuclear force or the strong nuclear force. It's none of these things
0:48:35 that scientists say drives the whole, you know, the whole physical system. It's
0:48:39 something else, so there's no place in the world for that. And so this is a
0:48:43 another fatal flaw of emergentism because it doesn't accommodate mental
0:48:48 causation. That's interesting. And this whole sentence here that the emergence of
0:48:54 emotion from motion, I just want to say, that's a beautifully crafted sentence. So emotion is
0:49:00 one of these internal states. It's not something that can be observed. It's not something that
0:49:05 any other human being can tap into and experience your experience. It's personal and subjective
0:49:12 in the way that only consciousness is. So he's like, you don't get that. You don't get emotion
0:49:19 from what, from motion, which is one of these physical, you know, laws, these physical qualities
0:49:25 of the world. You don't get emotion from motion. I love it. I love it. Now he's going to quote Isaac
0:49:32 Newton while we're talking about mental causation. And I think this is pretty interesting. He said,
0:49:37 even Isaac Newton allowed for the possibility of mental causation. And with it, the suggestion
0:49:43 of panpsychism. So here's the quote by Newton. We find in ourselves a power of moving our bodies
0:49:52 by our thoughts, but how this is done and by what laws we do not know. It appears that there are
0:49:59 other laws of motion, and this is enough to justify and encourage our search after them.
0:50:05 them. We cannot say that all of nature is not alive. Okay. That's beautiful. I did not
0:50:14 have never seen that Newton quote. That's amazing. So we all know that Newton, he coined
0:50:22 the laws of motion, you know, the laws of thermodynamics. I don't know. But he quoted
0:50:28 them. He figured them out. And one of those things is, you know, I can't quote them from
0:50:35 memory exactly, but one of those things is that, you know, when something's in motion,
0:50:40 it's going to continue to be in motion unless acted upon by another force. For every action,
0:50:44 there's an equal and opposite reaction. You guys remember, Newton figured these laws of
0:50:49 motion out to describe how all these physical things work in the world. He's the guy that
0:50:54 figured out the laws of motion. And what does he say here? He says, we find in ourselves
0:51:00 a power of moving our bodies by our thoughts. But how this is done, and by what laws we
0:51:06 don't know, here's the kicker. It appears that there are other laws of motion. Unbelievable.
0:51:13 So here you have Isaac Newton, who figured out the laws of motion. Coming up with this
0:51:18 statement that says, look, I haven't figured out all of the laws of motion because I can
0:51:23 admit that by my thoughts I move my fingers and my arms and my legs I walk
0:51:29 from here to there by my thoughts I move and that is unknown how I do it what the
0:51:37 laws are that govern that that is something that's missing from Newton's
0:51:41 laws of motion and he's coming out and saying that have you ever heard that
0:51:46 that's amazing that is amazing and then when he when he proposes that there must
0:51:52 be other laws that govern that type of thing. I have to say, going back to David Chalmers,
0:51:58 he actually talks about that in conscious mind. He says that there are laws that can
0:52:02 be discovered that govern the relationship between mind and matter. He calls them psychophysical
0:52:09 laws. So here we have Newton going way back saying there must be other laws of motion.
0:52:15 David Chalmers stepping in to say, you bet you're as there are, they're called psychophysical
0:52:20 laws. That's interesting. All right, another quote for you. He says, the founder of population
0:52:27 genetics, the evolutionists see wall right. He says this, the evolution of a new organ
0:52:35 involves nothing more mysterious than differential growth. Emergence of mind from no mind at
0:52:42 all is sheer magic.
0:52:46 Mind must already have been there when life arose, and indeed must be a universal aspect
0:52:52 of existence."
0:52:53 All right, so this is put in there, obviously, to bolster the argument about panpsychism.
0:52:58 Here you have an evolutionist, and a particularly noteworthy evolutionist.
0:53:05 He's saying that, look, if evolution drives the changing of biology, and it's no surprise,
0:53:10 There's nothing mysterious about how one organ evolves from another.
0:53:15 All it takes is differential growth.
0:53:17 All it takes is the organ growing and changing in a different way than another one.
0:53:23 And eventually it will become something new.
0:53:26 So he says, I got no problem with that.
0:53:27 That's evolution.
0:53:28 But how mind emerges from no mind.
0:53:32 How consciousness or sentience emerges from incensions.
0:53:36 He says, that is sheer magic.
0:53:39 I love that, because it fucking is, man, just like how the cosmos was born, if it was born,
0:53:46 or how it's always existed, if it's always existed.
0:53:50 Either one of the answers to those questions, magic, I have no freaking idea, that's the
0:53:56 phrase of last resort when we can't explain something, it's like magic.
0:54:01 He said it must have always existed, and not arose at some point, it must have always
0:54:07 existed as a universal aspect of existence.
0:54:10 Well, I can't argue with you, Dr. Shursted Hughes, that's what panpsychism is, and here
0:54:15 you have it from C. Walripe.
0:54:19 He says Wright points out that this alleged emergence would present the occurrence of
0:54:23 magic, not only during the course of evolution, but even during each pregnancy.
0:54:31 So there's another quote here, but I just gotta stop.
0:54:34 That's amazing.
0:54:35 Let me let me try to expound on that so he says that if sentience emerges at some
0:54:42 point in time that magic whatever that is that's caused that because again there
0:54:47 are no bridge laws there's an explanatory gap how that happened is
0:54:50 fucking magic it's anybody's guess so how that how that magic happened it
0:54:55 wasn't just one random event it didn't just happen when biological organisms
0:55:02 first became sentient, like it just happened. If you think that that was the case, you have
0:55:08 to also say that that same highly improbable magical event happens every single time a
0:55:17 baby is born, or every single time a baby is conceived. Because why? Because sentient
0:55:25 is there, how did it get there? It must have been this magic moment, like we're describing
0:55:29 happening in the prehistoric primordial past.
0:55:35 So here's the quote that goes along with it.
0:55:38 He says, the emergence of mind in the course of individual development from the fertilized
0:55:44 egg presents a similar problem and one that is in everyday occurrence instead of a single
0:55:50 event in the remote past.
0:55:52 It would appear that the mind of a human being must develop from something of the nature
0:55:57 of mind in the fertilized egg, in the separate germ cells, and in the nucleic acid molecules.
0:56:06 Buddy, hair is standing up on my arms.
0:56:10 So whatever it is that makes something sentient, he's calling that mind, but whatever it is
0:56:14 that makes you sentient, your consciousness, it must be there in the sperm, in the egg,
0:56:21 and even in the DNA.
0:56:26 So now we're taking consciousness and we're putting it in a molecule.
0:56:31 It's not even a living thing all by itself exactly.
0:56:35 That's interesting.
0:56:37 But the question that's being raised here I think is such a good one.
0:56:42 At least it's a Achilles heel situation for emergentism.
0:56:47 It seems to be because if you're calling it magic and you're saying it's unexplainable
0:56:51 and maybe one day it will be explainable but for now it's unexplainable.
0:56:56 And scientists will like to do that.
0:56:57 They like to say, listen, impossible things happen over enough time because of random
0:57:03 events.
0:57:05 Random events change your DNA, that drives evolution.
0:57:08 Random events like an asteroid hitting the earth change the environment.
0:57:12 These things happen one in a million, like how scientists might describe life coming
0:57:16 from no life, or the Big Bang, for instance, that these one in a million impossible situations
0:57:24 will happen randomly. They don't need a God. They don't need an explanation. They will
0:57:28 just happen given enough time, given enough time. Everything that can happen will happen.
0:57:35 That's the way they explain it. That might be a satisfactory explanation when you're
0:57:40 talking about the idea that the primordial soup in the ocean of the early earth somehow
0:57:50 created compounds and molecules and eventually life that that moment where
0:57:54 life sprang into being that Frankenstein moment that that might be this random
0:58:01 no explanation impossible one in a trillion event that happened and you
0:58:06 might be able to satisfy yourself with that but then to remember that every
0:58:11 time a sperm meets an egg you have another conscious creature born then you
0:58:18 You have to say that random one in a trillion magical event happens every day, thousands
0:58:25 of times a day, not just with human beings but with all creatures that are reproducing
0:58:30 but both sexually and asexually.
0:58:33 Think about that.
0:58:34 Think about a cell that splits into two.
0:58:39 If one cell is conscious, the other cell also must be conscious.
0:58:43 What happened there?
0:58:45 How did that, how did that cell split into two and its consciousness split into two?
0:58:50 How did that happen?
0:58:51 That's a magical miracle of unexplainableness.
0:58:55 That's what that is.
0:58:56 Oh boy, that's a good, that's a good bit, Dr. Shurston, he used a good bit.
0:59:01 All right, he says, if we reject the notion that mind emerged and that emerges from matter,
0:59:07 then we ipso facto accept that mind always existed with matter and that's panpsychism.
0:59:14 So if we can't go with emergence,
0:59:17 then we have to go with panpsychism.
0:59:19 There's no option C.
0:59:25 All right, this next section I'm gonna call,
0:59:27 what about material science?
0:59:29 Is there more to matter?
0:59:31 All right, let's get into that.
0:59:34 All right, the doctor says,
0:59:36 understanding matter structurally
0:59:38 is akin to understanding a scallop
0:59:41 as being merely its shell.
0:59:44 Panpsychism sees the inner life.
0:59:46 Okay, that's another great sentence to help understand this.
0:59:53 So when he says understanding matter structurally, what he means is looking at something material
0:59:59 and examining its structure, that's what he means.
1:00:02 What is it made of?
1:00:03 How does it interact?
1:00:04 What is its structure?
1:00:05 That's what science does.
1:00:07 And he says, understanding matter like that is understanding a scallop by only looking
1:00:12 at its shell.
1:00:13 looking at the outside, you're not looking at the inside. What does he mean by inside?
1:00:18 He means your subjective experience. What it's like to be you. What it's like to be
1:00:23 Chris. My experiences. Those things are more than the physical. They're things like the
1:00:31 quality that David Chalmers talks about. Like my emotional states. All this subjective
1:00:38 stuff about my experience. What color is like for me? What tastes are like for me?
1:00:43 sort of thing. There's something more there. There's something internal. There's an experience
1:00:48 happening inside that's different from what's happening outside. And understanding matter that
1:00:53 way only from the outside is like understanding a scallop only by its shell. You're missing something.
1:01:01 Great. All right. He goes on. He says, Descartes concept of matter was characterized by a single
1:01:09 property, extension. Okay, so now we're talking about Renee Descartes, the guy
1:01:15 that said I think therefore I am, I like Descartes. Dr. Sher said Hughes has some
1:01:22 objections to Descartes, especially given that the influence his ideas had on
1:01:27 modern materialist science. We'll talk about that a little bit, but when Descartes
1:01:33 talked about matter, what he was basically able to say about it, and he
1:01:37 He was a skeptic, so he was able to basically be skeptical about as much as he possibly could.
1:01:42 One of those things that he couldn't be skeptical about was that he thinks, therefore, he is.
1:01:48 Another thing he couldn't be skeptical about is that matter has a property called extension.
1:01:54 Matter extends into the world.
1:01:56 It fills space and time.
1:01:59 Matter has something called extension.
1:02:01 Again, this was a day and age before sophisticated technology.
1:02:05 He couldn't say more about what matter is, he could be skeptical about everything else,
1:02:10 but what he couldn't was that if matter exists, it has this property, it has extension.
1:02:16 That's one of those philosophical things, so let's keep going, let's plow through.
1:02:20 He says, as our knowledge advanced over time, further properties were attributed to matter,
1:02:27 such as nuclear force, mass, decay, spin, and so on.
1:02:33 So we realize that former conceptions of matter exclude properties which we now consider
1:02:38 essential to what matter is.
1:02:41 Yet, there is no reason to believe that we have reached a sufficiency in our understanding
1:02:46 of matter.
1:02:47 So what is he saying here?
1:02:49 He's saying that when Descartes said matter had this property called extension and we
1:02:53 could all agree is the case.
1:02:55 We later found out that matter also has other properties, not just extension, they don't
1:03:00 just fill a certain space and time.
1:03:02 They also have these forces associated with them.
1:03:05 Nuclear forces spin all these different things.
1:03:09 So there's more to it.
1:03:10 There's more to matter than just extension.
1:03:12 There's these other properties.
1:03:14 So that's interesting.
1:03:17 The point he's making is,
1:03:19 might there be other properties still?
1:03:22 Might we have extension, nuclear force,
1:03:25 mass decay spin, and sentience?
1:03:29 So, might there be something else missing
1:03:31 and might that be sentience?
1:03:34 And wouldn't it be arrogant of us to think that,
1:03:37 oh no, we used to think we had it penned
1:03:39 when we said extension.
1:03:40 Now we have it penned with extension,
1:03:42 master case, pen and so on.
1:03:44 No, that's the height of arrogance.
1:03:47 It's absolutely possible that there's things we don't,
1:03:49 still, things that we don't know about matter.
1:03:52 And might one of them be sentience?
1:03:55 Question mark.
1:03:58 All right, he says, physicalism,
1:04:00 Again, remember, that's just materialism, seeks to reduce mind to matter, idealism seeks
1:04:06 to reduce matter to mind, but panpsychism seeks to fuse Descartes division by placing
1:04:13 mind in matter.
1:04:18 So there it is, panpsychism places mind in matter.
1:04:22 So matter is sentient, period full stop.
1:04:28 He says, we perceive certain outer structural features
1:04:32 of the matter surrounding us, an object size, shape,
1:04:36 location, velocity, et cetera, and can speculate
1:04:39 whether matter has further intrinsic properties
1:04:42 to which we are not privy, and whether such properties
1:04:46 are sentient in nature.
1:04:48 That's exactly it.
1:04:49 Might there be other properties,
1:04:50 like when we're looking at the scallop?
1:04:53 Might there be other properties apart from its shell?
1:04:55 properties inside the scallop.
1:04:59 And by inside, in this case, he's talking about the mind.
1:05:02 Might there be other properties that we're not privy to?
1:05:06 Like cinchants, right?
1:05:10 You're not privy to that.
1:05:11 You look around at your family and your friends and strangers.
1:05:13 You think they're cinchant.
1:05:14 You assume they're cinchant like you are.
1:05:17 But how do you know?
1:05:18 You don't know.
1:05:19 You're not privy to what's going on inside.
1:05:21 And yet, you still have every reason
1:05:23 to believe there are things going on inside.
1:05:25 Why?
1:05:26 because there are things going on inside of you.
1:05:29 All right, he goes on, he says,
1:05:31 physicalist ideology only presents matter structure,
1:05:34 but not its content.
1:05:38 I think that's related to something Kyle
1:05:40 and I tried to talk about,
1:05:41 and I'm still baffled by this, by the way.
1:05:45 The question about what something does,
1:05:47 being the same as what it is.
1:05:50 Because this is what science tries to do.
1:05:52 It says that an electron has spin and charge
1:05:56 and velocity and momentum and all that stuff.
1:05:58 So when you ask a scientist what an electron is,
1:06:02 that's how they answer.
1:06:05 They tell you what it does.
1:06:07 It's structure, how it interacts with other things,
1:06:10 what it does, but not what it is.
1:06:13 It's not clear to me if they're the same or not.
1:06:15 And in this materialistic view,
1:06:18 it does seem to be the same.
1:06:21 And I think what's missing in that for me,
1:06:23 the gap between what something is and what something does
1:06:26 is this internal part that's not captured by what it does.
1:06:31 You know, what you are is consciousness.
1:06:34 You know, it's like your body and what you do
1:06:37 and how you're put together is part of it,
1:06:40 but I don't know how significant that part is.
1:06:45 You don't identify with your body
1:06:47 the same way you identify with your consciousness.
1:06:52 I mean, you can lose parts of your body.
1:06:54 You can lose your limbs, let's say.
1:06:57 Your appendix, let's say.
1:06:58 You're adenoids, let's say.
1:07:00 But your consciousness is still intact.
1:07:02 Can you imagine losing a piece of your consciousness?
1:07:05 You know, what would that even mean?
1:07:09 All right, he goes on, he says,
1:07:11 it would not be prudent to believe
1:07:13 that we have today finally reached
1:07:15 a complete concrete knowledge of what matter is.
1:07:18 It would be more imprudent still
1:07:20 to believe that we can explain Cincians
1:07:22 through this current understanding of matter, okay?
1:07:26 Absolutely.
1:07:26 He says, a full physical description of your body and behavior will not be a full description
1:07:33 of yourself.
1:07:34 It will omit your sentience.
1:07:37 And there it is.
1:07:38 There it is right there.
1:07:39 You can have a full description of your body and your behavior, but that's not what you
1:07:46 are.
1:07:47 It's leaving out something, your sentience, your consciousness, exactly.
1:07:52 Then he says, all of reality is alive.
1:07:57 It is our conceptualization that creates the illusion that most of nature is dead, that
1:08:02 the shell alone is the organism.
1:08:06 Even a corpse will contain a multiplicity of synciences, though no longer unified by
1:08:11 the higher deceased one.
1:08:14 The scientific method is here not sufficient, as it is based on the experience of structure,
1:08:20 not the experience of other experience.
1:08:23 That's great, man.
1:08:25 That is great.
1:08:26 It's exactly right.
1:08:27 The experience of experience, that is what's not described by science, by materialist science.
1:08:37 What is the experience of experience?
1:08:40 Sentience, self-consciousness, that's what that sounds like to me.
1:08:45 So this idea that all of reality is alive I think is interesting.
1:08:50 By that he means all of reality is sentient and the distinction between alive and sentient
1:08:56 is interesting.
1:08:57 And we're going to talk more about that actually in the next section, because what
1:09:02 is that?
1:09:03 What does it mean for something to be alive versus sentient?
1:09:06 Are they the same thing?
1:09:08 Or does sentience go back even below the level of alive?
1:09:12 All right, let's call this next section.
1:09:17 How do we draw the line?
1:09:18 All right, Dr. Shur said he says, we can but infer sentience in other organisms rather
1:09:29 than verify it, and people will differ in their guest inferences.
1:09:34 Some might stop sentience at the lobster limit.
1:09:38 Others might stop at the beetle border, but why stop at all?
1:09:42 If one demands a stop, the determining criterion must be established.
1:09:47 This is great.
1:09:49 This is that idea I brought up earlier about the borders being fuzzy.
1:09:53 So he says we can infer sentience.
1:09:56 What he means is that I can't go into your head and know what it's like to be you and
1:09:59 confirm, yep, you are sentient because I've been there and I've seen it.
1:10:02 We can't do that.
1:10:04 So we have to infer it.
1:10:05 We have to look at something and say, okay, they're probably conscious like I am, or they're
1:10:09 probably conscious in some way, and we have to infer it from the outside.
1:10:14 He says, people will differ in how they do that.
1:10:17 Some people will look at things and say, okay, I can go all the way down to the lobster, but
1:10:21 Anything simpler than that, like a scallop, let's say,
1:10:25 or a muscle, or a sea anemone or something,
1:10:28 maybe they're not sentient.
1:10:29 Maybe I don't think they are.
1:10:31 Others might go all the way down to a beetle
1:10:33 and say, okay, anything simpler than a beetle
1:10:35 is not conscious.
1:10:38 But why stop at all?
1:10:39 That's what he says.
1:10:40 Where do we draw the line?
1:10:41 And if you're gonna draw a line at certain types of animals
1:10:45 or plants or fungi or microorganisms
1:10:48 or even molecules,
1:10:50 You have to have a way of drawing that line.
1:10:55 That's the criterion, he says.
1:10:57 If you don't have that, then what's
1:10:59 keeping you from stopping?
1:11:01 Keep on going, all the way down.
1:11:03 And assume sentience, infer and sentience, all the way down.
1:11:08 Turtles all the way down, you guys.
1:11:12 All right, he goes on, he says, if one proposes the criterion
1:11:16 that a being can sense and adapt to its environment,
1:11:19 then one has almost become a panpsychist
1:11:22 by allowing for the sentience of plants.
1:11:24 Okay, so here he's saying,
1:11:26 people are gonna draw the line wherever they are
1:11:28 gonna draw the line.
1:11:29 But if you draw the line by saying,
1:11:31 okay, something is conscious or sentient,
1:11:33 if it can sense and adapt to its environment,
1:11:36 then you have to assume plants are in that category,
1:11:38 then plants are sentient.
1:11:40 He says, for instance,
1:11:42 biologist Daniel Chamowitz, he writes,
1:11:46 we now know that Arabidopsis,
1:11:49 That's the genus species name of a plant, so forgive me.
1:11:52 Aradodopsis has at least 11 different photoreceptors.
1:11:56 Some tell a plant when to germinate,
1:11:58 some tell it when to bend to the light,
1:12:01 some tell it when to flower,
1:12:03 and some let it know when it's night.
1:12:06 Some let the plant know that there's a lot of light hitting it,
1:12:10 some let it know that the light is dim,
1:12:12 and some help keep time.
1:12:17 So what's interesting to me here,
1:12:19 And I think the reason he brings this quote up
1:12:20 is because this biologist who's studying this plant,
1:12:25 he uses the word no.
1:12:28 And he talks about all these photoreceptors,
1:12:30 like the plant has more photoreceptors
1:12:32 than let's say a human being does.
1:12:34 So it's sensing the light in ways that human beings can't.
1:12:37 And the light is telling it what to do or what it can do.
1:12:43 So he actually uses the word no.
1:12:46 He says, some let the plant know
1:12:48 There's a lot of light hitting it.
1:12:50 Some let it know that it light is dim, right?
1:12:53 So to use the word no in reference to a plant,
1:12:57 that's a giveaway that you believe the plant
1:13:00 to be sentient somehow.
1:13:01 Because how can it know anything?
1:13:05 Knowledge is something that only consciousness has, right?
1:13:11 Then he goes on, he says,
1:13:12 plants do not have neurons,
1:13:14 but they have other parts by which they transmit information.
1:13:17 as do single celled organisms, viruses, molecules, and more.
1:13:23 The point is made by the distinguished mycologist Paul
1:13:26 Stamets.
1:13:27 All right, so here's a Paul Stamets quote.
1:13:29 For those of you who don't know Paul Stamets,
1:13:31 we talked about him on the podcast before,
1:13:33 where he's been on Rogan's podcast several times.
1:13:35 I highly, highly encourage you to check those out.
1:13:38 He's a mushroom scientist, and he is a fascinating guy.
1:13:42 Here's his quote.
1:13:43 He says, I see mycelium as an exposed, sentient membrane,
1:13:49 aware and responsive to changes in its environment.
1:13:53 As hikers, deer, or insects walk across these sensitive
1:13:57 filamentous nets, they leave impressions.
1:14:00 And mycelia sense and respond to these movements.
1:14:04 So mycelium is not the mushroom itself,
1:14:07 but the roots, the system of roots that
1:14:09 go down into the earth, some of them
1:14:10 go miles and miles and miles.
1:14:12 Those roots are where the mushrooms kind of sprout
1:14:16 from up above the surface of the earth.
1:14:18 So mycelium is really the organism.
1:14:21 The mushroom is just the fruiting body
1:14:22 that comes up out of the ground.
1:14:24 He's saying that the mycelium web under the ground
1:14:27 is a sentient membrane.
1:14:30 He says it senses and responds to the environment.
1:14:33 So here, you've got stammets.
1:14:36 He goes as far as to use the word sense and respond,
1:14:39 talking about fungi.
1:14:41 So now we have to include fungi.
1:14:43 We include plants, and now we have to include fungi.
1:14:48 All right, he goes on, he says,
1:14:49 a human brain may be necessary for human consciousness,
1:14:52 but it cannot be deemed necessary for consciousness,
1:14:55 let alone sentience.
1:14:58 This is another great way of illustrating this.
1:15:01 He says, while an orchestra is necessary for a symphony,
1:15:05 it is not necessary for music generally, let alone sound.
1:15:10 So that analogy is great, trying to understand why he uses the word sentience instead of
1:15:16 consciousness.
1:15:17 He's like, look, there are different types of sentience.
1:15:22 A symphony might be like describing consciousness, but there's other things to sound.
1:15:31 There's other types of music that are simpler, less grand, and then there's just sound all
1:15:35 by itself.
1:15:36 all of those are sentience. This is an analogy to different types of
1:15:41 sentience. I think it's great. Alright, he says, if we limit the inference to
1:15:48 behavior or sensation, we would have to include plants, fungi, viruses, and other
1:15:54 microbes as well. Thus, nearing panpsychism already, he says the
1:16:00 biologist HS Jennings in observing the behavior of an amoeba could hardly help
1:16:06 attributing to it consciousness. So another biologist looking at this single
1:16:10 cell organism, this amoeba going around under a microscope, watching it and
1:16:15 saying, look, this thing has some sentience. It knows what it's doing. It's
1:16:17 having experiences. So the point is, it's not clear where or how you can draw the
1:16:25 line between what is sentient and what is not. All right, let's call this next
1:16:32 section. Okay, so living things are conscious. What about the non-living? It's
1:16:37 Good question, man. What about the non-living? All right, he says this, it may be retorted that
1:16:43 though we may justifiably argue sentience to organisms, we do not have the justification to
1:16:49 include sentience within the inorganic. There is no delineation between what we call living and
1:16:56 the non-living. If we attribute sentience to organic molecules, then the continuation to other
1:17:02 types of molecules faces no natural barrier as we have no criterion by which we can stop
1:17:07 the inference, attributing sentience to creatures without brains, nor to the so-called inorganic.
1:17:13 The inference of sentience is extended all the way down through nature. Therefore, panpsychism.
1:17:22 I think that's interesting. We talked about it before, but it's a good point. The edges are fuzzy,
1:17:28 like I said, and there is no natural delineation between what we call living and what we call non-living.
1:17:34 Last time just came up on the podcast, we were talking about sixth-grade science and learning
1:17:38 about viruses and learning about there being a debate as to whether a virus is alive or not.
1:17:44 Scientists will say things like, for something to be alive, it has to be able to procreate,
1:17:48 it has to be able to have local motion, it has to be able to move, it has to be able to absorb
1:17:53 nutrients and excrete waste. There's these different things that they try to say have to be met
1:17:59 for something to be considered alive and viruses they satisfy some of them but
1:18:06 not all of them so they're like this in-between fuzzy case is it alive is it not
1:18:11 alive what about those prions we talked about the prions that cause mad cow
1:18:15 disease they're just proteins but they get in your body and they they wreak
1:18:19 havoc just like a bacteria or a virus might so is it alive it's hard to say
1:18:27 It's one of these fuzzy border situations.
1:18:30 There is no clear way for us to say, this is living and that is not living.
1:18:34 We don't know what the criteria are, the edges are fuzzy, this is a problem.
1:18:39 And if it is a problem and we recognize that, then we look at what's happening with these
1:18:43 molecules.
1:18:44 And we say they're made up of atoms and those atoms are moving around and they're interacting
1:18:52 with one another.
1:18:53 So they're having experiences.
1:18:56 So they must be sentient of some kind.
1:19:00 And if organic molecules are sentient,
1:19:02 why not inorganic molecules?
1:19:04 And if that's the case, everything is sentient.
1:19:07 Equals panpsychism.
1:19:09 That's the argument.
1:19:11 Beautiful.
1:19:13 All right, now we're nearing the end.
1:19:15 Dr. Schur said he was in this first chapter.
1:19:18 He wants to address not just what panpsychism is
1:19:22 and what it's not, but he also, at the end,
1:19:25 talks about why there's been resistance to this idea in philosophy and in physics.
1:19:31 Why has there been such a resistance to this idea? It's part of what he was getting at
1:19:36 when he started talking about Descartes. Philip Goff, who we talked about in terms of panpsychism
1:19:42 before, he wrote a book called Galileo's Error. He talks about the same thing in terms
1:19:46 of Galileo. He thinks it was Galileo's science that caused the cascade of sort of ill will
1:19:55 towards panpsychism and it sounds like they shared some, contributed some to that.
1:20:03 So why has there been resistance to panpsychism?
1:20:06 If it's been around, if it goes way back to Heraclitus and Thales, that's 400 BC or something
1:20:13 like that, if it goes way back then, why hasn't nobody ever heard of it?
1:20:20 Why is nobody talking about it?
1:20:21 Why has there been hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of years of silence on this topic?
1:20:27 Well he's going to try to give us an explanation, so I'm going to give it to you.
1:20:31 I'm not 100% sure I agree with it.
1:20:33 I'm going to tell you why, but let me just go into it.
1:20:38 Why is panpsychism spurned today?
1:20:40 Firstly, there are common misunderstandings about what panpsychism is, and therefore it
1:20:46 is often the victim of the straw man fallacy.
1:20:51 Ecism does not maintain that chairs, tables, gates, or stables are sentient as unified
1:20:57 entities.
1:20:59 There are no self-conscious sofas contemplating their contemptuous servile existence.
1:21:04 All right, so that's good.
1:21:06 I mean, you can see there's like an appeal to just logic and common sense that comes
1:21:12 here.
1:21:13 It's like, look, if you're saying that everything is conscious, doesn't that mean that you're
1:21:17 couches conscious. And the way he explains this is I think it's partly satisfying. He
1:21:24 says panpsychism does not maintain that chairs, tables, gates, or stables are
1:21:28 sentient as unified entities. So this goes back to that description of the dead
1:21:33 body. It's like the dead body's made up of these cells and viruses and bacteria.
1:21:37 And even though the person is dead, the organizing unity is dead. All those
1:21:43 sentient beings are still there, you know, they're probably dying too, but
1:21:47 They're still there.
1:21:51 So this is the explanation for why the molecules
1:21:54 that make up the table are sentient,
1:21:56 but the table itself isn't.
1:21:58 It's because it's not organized like a human being
1:22:02 is organized.
1:22:02 It's not organized like a multicellular organism
1:22:05 is organized.
1:22:08 That's what I mean by it's being partly satisfying.
1:22:11 It kind of makes sense.
1:22:12 I wish there was more explanation to it,
1:22:15 But I think it's still good.
1:22:17 It's like, look, you can still see that everything
1:22:21 that the world is composed of is sentient,
1:22:25 and that certain parts of it are organized
1:22:27 into higher sentiences.
1:22:29 And some of those are even what he calls
1:22:31 the crown of sentient, it's conscious, like you and I.
1:22:35 But not everything, right?
1:22:36 So some of these entities, like a table,
1:22:39 is sentient on the level of the molecules or atoms,
1:22:43 but not at the level of the table.
1:22:45 So it's not clear to me what makes the distinction.
1:22:48 I kind of feel like there's still an argument to be made
1:22:50 that at least in some way the table is conscious
1:22:53 or sentient rather.
1:22:54 But I think the operative word is sentient
1:22:58 as unified entities.
1:22:59 They're sentient but not as at the level of the table,
1:23:03 something like that.
1:23:04 That's the best I can do to make that clear.
1:23:08 Okay, so he just overcomes that idea by saying,
1:23:11 And look, it might seem illogical to think about a chair as conscious, but that's because
1:23:16 the chair isn't.
1:23:17 The molecules are the conscious thing, and it's possible for those consciousnesses to
1:23:22 aggregate and unify into a higher level consciousness, and that's something like URI.
1:23:28 All right, he also says this, a more rational reason for spurning panpsychism is recognition
1:23:35 of its inherent problematic issues, the most significant of which is the combination problem.
1:23:41 And this is exactly what I just talked about.
1:23:44 Combination problem is how is it possible for a multiplicity of sentences to combine to
1:23:49 form a unified sentence?
1:23:52 That's the idea.
1:23:53 If my, all the cells in my body are sentient, how do they form a crisp?
1:23:59 How do they, how do they merge into this higher level consciousness that I am?
1:24:04 How does that happen?
1:24:05 That's unexplainable.
1:24:06 That doesn't mean it's in Achilles' heel for panpsychism, it just means it hasn't
1:24:10 been explained yet.
1:24:12 It might still be possible to explain that, but that's one problem because it is unanswered
1:24:17 that people can point to.
1:24:20 I think Philip Goff talked about this in Galileo's error.
1:24:23 He talked about integrated information theory, and this is one of these cognitive scientific
1:24:29 areas that tries to do exactly that, to talk about how consciousness aggregates or how
1:24:39 information aggregates in systems. I think that that integrated information theory extends
1:24:44 into the realm of computing and stuff. But I haven't got into it that deeply. The point
1:24:49 is there are people working on it and trying to figure it out, even from a cognitive science
1:24:53 approach. All right, he goes on. He says, there are numerous proposed solutions to this
1:24:59 problem to the combination problem. But we can acknowledge the problem as one specifically
1:25:06 detrimental to panpsychism by highlighting the point that the combination problem is
1:25:10 also a problem for physicalism. He says, as David Chalmers writes, quote, how do micro
1:25:17 physical entities and properties come together to yield subjects? This challenge is presumably
1:25:23 at least as hard as the challenge to panpsychism. Okay, so all he's saying here is this combination
1:25:28 problem, you still have that problem with materialism.
1:25:34 So how do, you know, quantum particles and quantum laws come together to make you?
1:25:41 How does that happen?
1:25:43 That's still a mystery.
1:25:46 And it's the same sort of mystery that we're talking about with the combination problem.
1:25:53 Now I'll talk about this in the conclusion, but there's a couple places where Dr. Schurst
1:25:58 that Hughes does this, where he answers a problem like this
1:26:03 by pointing the finger back to the other direction.
1:26:06 And I just have to say, I resist that a little bit.
1:26:10 I'm not 100% satisfied with answers like that.
1:26:13 It just reminds me of political bickering.
1:26:18 He talked about the straw man fallacy earlier.
1:26:21 This, to me, kind of seems like an ad hominem.
1:26:24 It's like, that's an attack the man fallacy.
1:26:27 So it's like, I'm just going to point the finger back at you.
1:26:30 It just reminds me too much of political bickering,
1:26:33 to be 100% satisfying for me.
1:26:36 But I do think it's a way for him to at least say,
1:26:38 the problem is not unique to panpsychism.
1:26:40 So if you're a materialist, you got
1:26:44 to contend with the same problem.
1:26:45 You can't write off panpsychism and be a materialist
1:26:49 and avoid this problem.
1:26:55 He says, another more basic criticism of panpsychism
1:26:58 is that it is blatant anthropomorphism.
1:27:02 So for those people who don't know
1:27:04 what anthropomorphism means, it's often a critique,
1:27:06 but it just means to assume something
1:27:08 is like a human being.
1:27:09 Because you're a human being,
1:27:11 you oftentimes assume other things are like you.
1:27:15 And you see that kind of thing happen
1:27:16 in like creative writing all the time.
1:27:19 You know, we talk about, I don't know,
1:27:22 a tree standing or something.
1:27:24 Trees don't stand, human beings stand.
1:27:26 That's what's meant by anthropomorphism.
1:27:29 It's like the sky smiled.
1:27:30 No, it didn't, sir.
1:27:32 People's smile.
1:27:33 So this is what he says.
1:27:34 He's like, there's a more basic criticism of panpsychism
1:27:37 that is blatantly anthropomorphic.
1:27:40 Attributing human characteristics, by that he means
1:27:42 mentality to non-human entities.
1:27:47 He says, there are two simple reasons for this.
1:27:49 Firstly, to attribute to nature the characteristic of being
1:27:53 akin to that of man-made machines, like a mechanism,
1:27:56 is also anthropomorphic.
1:27:58 So the accusation cuts both ways.
1:28:01 Secondly, to charge panpsychism with anthropomorphism
1:28:04 is itself to commit anthropocentrism,
1:28:08 to believe that we are unique, special, and our sentience.
1:28:12 So to me, this is a mic drop moment,
1:28:14 but it's also just like the one before it.
1:28:16 It's a little bit finger pointy.
1:28:18 It's not exactly a defense.
1:28:20 It's more of a, hey, you don't solve this problem
1:28:25 by remaining a materialist.
1:28:27 So here's what he's talking about.
1:28:28 It's like people will say that you're reading into it,
1:28:31 because you're conscious, point to other things
1:28:34 and say they're conscious.
1:28:35 You're reading into it.
1:28:39 But the point he makes here is like, OK,
1:28:42 if I don't read into it like that,
1:28:44 if I don't assume that things are conscious or sentient,
1:28:47 then I have to assume the materialistic approach,
1:28:50 the scientific approach, that everything works like a machine,
1:28:53 that everything follows physical laws,
1:28:56 The whole cosmos follows physical laws.
1:28:58 And it's just like cogs and wheels in a machine doing exactly
1:29:01 what these laws say they should do.
1:29:03 There's no if ands or buts about it.
1:29:05 And what Dr. Schurst that Hughes is saying here is, well,
1:29:09 what you're describing is a machine.
1:29:11 And human beings make machines.
1:29:12 Nature doesn't make machines.
1:29:14 So if you're saying that we can't believe that the cosmos is
1:29:18 somehow sentient because it's just a mechanism that you are
1:29:24 Also, anthropomorphizing the problem,
1:29:27 because nature doesn't make machines, sir.
1:29:30 Human beings make machines.
1:29:32 So you're falling into the same problem
1:29:34 that you're claiming panpsychists are falling into.
1:29:37 See what I mean?
1:29:38 And he says, the accusation cuts both ways.
1:29:40 That's what he means.
1:29:42 But again, not entirely satisfying to me,
1:29:45 because it's kind of a finger pointy thing,
1:29:47 but I understand why he's doing it.
1:29:51 All right, almost done here, guys.
1:29:52 He says, panpsychism, as well as transgressing
1:29:55 general scientific paradigm, transgresses the Christian one, that the soul was distinct
1:30:01 to the material body.
1:30:03 Okay, so that's interesting.
1:30:05 Now he's bringing in religion into the mix.
1:30:08 He's saying panpsychism transgresses Christian theology.
1:30:13 What does he mean by that?
1:30:15 He goes on, he says, in panpsychism, mankind has no special status, distinct from other
1:30:20 organisms.
1:30:22 And as such is generally opposed to Christianity and other Abrahamic religions.
1:30:27 Panpsychism is more akin to the animistic pagan religions that worshiped nature.
1:30:33 Thus in Christendom, panpsychism has been contrary to both the religious and mechanistic ethos,
1:30:39 resulting in it being shunned, and even purposely suppressed.
1:30:43 This is the Roman Inquisition burned to the panpsychist Giordano Bruno on the stake in
1:30:49 1600. All right, so there's a couple things I'll say about this. I do think that Christianity
1:30:56 and Abrahamic religions are subject to the mind-body dualism. They think that mind and
1:31:01 soul are somehow separate. I don't think that that is doctrinal. I don't think that that
1:31:06 goes to the Bible. I think it's more of a philosophy. It's more of the way human beings
1:31:12 understand the concept of the soul that's presented in the scriptures. So I do think
1:31:18 think that the idea that there's a dualism, that there's a separation between body and
1:31:25 spirit is not biblical. So I think there's a whole in the argument there. It doesn't
1:31:31 transgress on Christian theology. It certainly does on the politics, you know, and religion
1:31:38 is obviously wrapped up in politics, controlling the narrative in order to control hearts and
1:31:44 minds, that kind of thing. And I definitely think that that's the case. You know, convincing
1:31:49 people they have an immortal soul and that they should sacrifice physical things because
1:31:54 it's the spiritual things that are important. You know, that's been used to manipulate people.
1:31:59 But I don't believe that that's critical to Christian belief. I think it's more of a political
1:32:06 item. Second thing he says is that panpsychism says that mankind has no special status distinct
1:32:13 from other organisms, by that he means that all things have a soul, all things are sentient,
1:32:19 and so human beings aren't special in that.
1:32:22 That I agree with, but I also want to point out earlier when he said consciousness is
1:32:28 the crown of sentience, and human beings have an unparalleled form of sentience.
1:32:35 So how can you tell me that that's not distinct from other organisms?
1:32:40 I still don't think that religion necessarily puts human beings at an apex position above
1:32:52 the rest of nature, but an argument might be made there.
1:32:55 I definitely think that there's a little bit of cognitive dissonance here, where in one
1:33:02 point he says human beings have the crown of sentience.
1:33:05 we have this, this, this pinnacle of, of what we call
1:33:08 cinciency, that's something that human beings call
1:33:10 consciousness. That's something that we don't share with
1:33:13 anybody else, any other organism. So are we special?
1:33:19 I kind of think he's saying we are and we aren't. All right,
1:33:23 he goes, it goes further, he says, the rejection of
1:33:26 panpsychism can be overcome by logical analysis, historical
1:33:31 cultural reflection, and perhaps even by chemical ingestion, so this is where at the
1:33:39 very end he references psychedelics.
1:33:42 And I'm very hopeful the rest of the book is going to talk more about that, but here
1:33:46 he's saying that psychedelic experience is a path to understanding the truth of panpsychism.
1:33:54 To that I couldn't agree more.
1:33:56 And lastly, he says, I believe that the greatest riches in the search for a satisfactory mind
1:34:01 matter theory will be unearthed with inspiration from the world of Alfred North Whitehead,
1:34:08 the most distinguished champion of panpsychism in the 20th century.
1:34:13 And that's a little bit of a foreshadowing because the next two chapters in the book
1:34:16 are about Alfred North Whitehead, so I will be bringing that to you soon as I finish those
1:34:23 chapters.
1:34:26 So it'll be interesting to hear what Alfred Northwhite had
1:34:28 to say on the matter and what's been convincing for Dr.
1:34:32 Schurst that he was.
1:34:34 So that'll be next.
1:34:36 That brings me to my conclusion monologue.
1:34:39 So let me go, let me read that to you.
1:34:42 It's somewhat disappointing that Dr. Hughes's response
1:34:45 to so many objections to panpsychism
1:34:47 is to point the finger at the opposing argument
1:34:50 and showing how the opposition shares the same objections.
1:34:54 It is fun to read and a legitimate point,
1:34:57 but still somewhat unsatisfying.
1:35:00 We saw this in the objection to anthropomorphism
1:35:03 and with a combination problem.
1:35:06 A similar unsatisfactory taste is left in the leap
1:35:09 from consciousness to living things,
1:35:11 or in living things, to the non-living.
1:35:14 The notion is posed that a molecule might be sentient,
1:35:17 and if so, then inorganic molecules should be no exception.
1:35:21 But I'd like to have more of a fleshed out explanation.
1:35:25 That said, I have never seen a better demolition
1:35:29 of the idea that sentience emerges from matter.
1:35:33 Remember, I talked about David Chalmers.
1:35:34 I talked about Philip Goff.
1:35:36 And yet, reading Dr. Schurst that Hughes,
1:35:38 I have never seen a better demolition of the idea
1:35:42 that sentience emerges from matter.
1:35:44 So there's a compliment for you.
1:35:47 To compare the idea of sentience evolving
1:35:50 at some point in our evolutionary history
1:35:53 to conception and birth was a brilliant move.
1:35:57 In this way, it is easy to see a sort of miracle
1:36:00 would be needed to have insentient matter
1:36:03 suddenly become sentient.
1:36:05 And then if we believe in emergence
1:36:07 that the same sort of miracle would be needed
1:36:10 not just once as a random, impossible,
1:36:13 one in a million event,
1:36:15 but countless times every single day
1:36:18 the conception of new life across all species everywhere.
1:36:24 Even in the division of a cell, you'd have to admit this miracle.
1:36:28 If one cell splits in two, both are now sentient.
1:36:33 The next brilliant move of logic follows directly from this.
1:36:38 Dr. Hughes states, if we reject the notion that mind emerged and emerges from matter,
1:36:43 then we ipso facto accept that mind always existed with matter, and therefore panpsychism.
1:36:51 And in one fell swoop, the complex argument between panpsychism and modern materialism
1:36:56 is reduced to this one single question.
1:37:01 If emergence is not real, panpsychism is our best explanation.
1:37:07 And that's Occam's Razor, my friends.
1:37:10 Occam's Razor, the simplest solution.
1:37:15 And the next chapter in this book focuses on the work of Alfred North Whitehead, a man
1:37:20 also referenced heavily by David Chalmers. It is a short chapter but I took a look and my god
1:37:26 it looks intimidating. I am looking forward to the rest of this book. Let's see what sense I can
1:37:32 make of it and I'll get back to you with part two of modes of sentience.
1:37:55 But I'm grateful for the company as we trek through this together.
1:37:59 Here's to hoping that the juice is worth the squeeze.
1:38:03 See what I did there?
1:38:05 Let's find out together in the next episode.