The Two Tongues Podcast
S2E86 · Jan 4, 2023 · 91 min
YouTube: Coming soon
This was my favorite reading in Process and Reality to-date…hands down. Whitehead gets into the weeds on some of his most interesting concepts: God, the Creative Advance, Concresence and Satisfaction. He also introduces the idea of Mind, which muddies the waters up something awful. I take aim at some of the inconsistencies in his model, but make a great deal of headway in understanding how he sees 'God' and what it means to be 'real.'
Enjoy 😉
Machine-generated transcript; names and terms may contain errors.
0:00:00 Welcome, everyone, to the Two Tungs Podcast.
0:00:09 Consider this your invitation to join Kyle and Chris on a journey through our minds,
0:00:19 where we explore the questions that have fascinated us for as long as we can remember.
0:00:24 Could anarchy actually work?
0:00:27 Does God exist?
0:00:28 And just how did the cosmos get here anyway?
0:00:33 Let me be the Virgil to your Dante, the Sacagawea to your Lewis and Clark.
0:00:39 Let's take the guided tour through the dark chambers of our unconscious, seeking answers
0:00:46 to the most important and unsettled questions of our shared existence.
0:00:52 Ready or not, here we go.
0:01:00 Welcome back, one and all.
0:01:04 To another episode of the Two Tungs Podcast.
0:01:07 What's up everybody?
0:01:08 I want to apologize off the, off the rep here about last Wednesday's episode.
0:01:14 Audio, for some reason, was strange and came out sort of poorly.
0:01:20 So apologies for that.
0:01:22 Not sure why.
0:01:23 I'm really hoping that problem doesn't persist and this one sounds good.
0:01:27 What are we doing today?
0:01:28 We're going to keep digging into Whitehead.
0:01:31 All right guys, Alfred North Whitehead.
0:01:39 So we've been talking about him for some time and I think we have got a few episodes
0:01:42 left to talk about Whitehead. I started off kind of romantic about the whole thing. I thought
0:01:49 Whitehead's ideas were extremely interesting. I thought that I had a lot to learn from him,
0:01:55 and I have. I don't want to diminish that, but I'm finding that I have a lot more issues
0:02:03 with maybe his style of writing, maybe his lack of clarity, and it's strange because a lot of
0:02:10 philosophers, they speak really carefully, you know, they speak very precisely because
0:02:17 they want things to mean very precise things. And Whitehead does that. I mean, for sure,
0:02:23 he's inventing words to use for very specific reasons, because he wants to mean very specific
0:02:28 things. And I understand that. But it's not clear, even with these invented words, what
0:02:36 what he means. He's not being specific enough. He's not being illuminating enough. And I
0:02:41 have some issues with it. And I don't know whether I don't understand why it had well
0:02:46 enough. And that's why I'm confused and frustrated at times. Or if he wasn't clear enough, you
0:02:54 know, is it his fault? Is it my fault? Is a little bit of both? Maybe that's the case.
0:03:00 But just to give you a little bit of a refresher, in case you're jumping into this one without
0:03:05 listening to the other Whitehead episodes. Alfred North Whitehead was an interesting
0:03:09 philosopher and he was somebody who was adopted by theologians as much as philosophers in
0:03:15 terms of his philosophical model, what he calls process philosophy or the philosophy
0:03:21 of organism. And the philosophy of organism, that phrase really puts it into perspective
0:03:26 because what Whitehead says, and this is something he calls his ontological principle,
0:03:32 He says that all things, and by that he means experience, because to whitehead, all things
0:03:38 are experience.
0:03:39 And you can imagine, just from the way it is to be a human being, that's how our lives
0:03:44 are.
0:03:45 I mean, everything that we think we have, that we possess, whether it be ourselves or
0:03:50 our bodies, the world we inhabit, whatever it is, all that stuff we know through experience.
0:03:59 And that might sound strange, or you might wonder, like, how else could you have it.
0:04:03 But that's exactly the point, you know, that there may be some objective reality.
0:04:10 And we only have access to it through our experience.
0:04:14 So we really can't say whether anything exists outside of our experience, whether there is
0:04:18 even an objective reality, which I believe there is, I think Whitehead believes that
0:04:23 there is.
0:04:24 But to him, all things are experience.
0:04:28 And every experience exists within other experience.
0:04:34 So what you basically have is a web.
0:04:36 You have this sort of fractal network that comes to mind, where every object in it and
0:04:42 every subject in it for that matter is an experience that it's independent, it's living
0:04:50 all on its own, it's its own universe basically.
0:04:54 And they're all connected together to form larger, more complex experiences, experiences
0:04:59 that you might call a human being, experiences that you might call the cosmos.
0:05:03 So even material reality to Whitehead is an experience.
0:05:09 And so this ontological principle or this philosophy of organism, you can sort of imagine
0:05:13 this, and this is a simplistic way of doing it, but you can imagine this like those Russian
0:05:17 dolls.
0:05:18 I can't remember what they're called, but you know what I mean?
0:05:21 You open up the doll and there's a smaller doll inside of it and you open up that doll
0:05:25 and there's a smaller doll inside of it.
0:05:27 This is Whitehead's model of reality.
0:05:29 It's more complicated than that because it's not just like one experience becomes another.
0:05:35 That is true, but it's also the relationship among different experiences that are manifest
0:05:40 as actualities, things in the actual world.
0:05:43 So it's much more complex, this sort of fractal web of infinite connections and each set of
0:05:48 of connections, you know, represents something new, some new object, some new experience
0:05:53 in the world, something like that.
0:05:57 And this whole idea of process when we talk about process philosophy, what that is, is
0:06:04 the best I can explain it here in a simplified way, is that to white head you've got potentiality.
0:06:12 And I love that word.
0:06:13 I use it a lot.
0:06:14 not really clear. It's not obvious how to make that word clear. It's meaning clear.
0:06:20 But potentiality is whatever it is that's necessary for something to exist. Wherever
0:06:25 it comes from, whether that be the origin of experience or the origin of matter or whatever
0:06:31 it is, however you might think about that. But potentiality. And then, of course, the
0:06:36 opposite of potentiality is something that we might call actuality. So the potential
0:06:42 and the actual. And to Whitehead, the potential is constantly being transformed into the actual.
0:06:51 And what's unique about Whitehead is that he defines what actuality means. You know,
0:06:57 we all kind of imagine what that means. It means real. It means part of reality. It means something
0:07:03 like that. But to Whitehead, it means something else. To Whitehead, it means that it's being
0:07:09 experienced. So you have something like potentiality, whatever it is that's the potential for
0:07:15 experience, whatever it is that makes experience possible. And that exists not in a way that we
0:07:22 are familiar with, not in what we would call actuality or reality for lack of a better phrase.
0:07:30 It exists in something like the platonic world of forms or the Kantian numina or something like
0:07:36 Like that, it exists in this spiritual realm, and that's not a great way of explaining
0:07:41 it either.
0:07:42 But the point is it exists, but just not in, it's not real.
0:07:46 So we might just use that word.
0:07:49 Whitehead uses the word concresence to mean something starting as potential and becoming
0:07:55 actual.
0:07:58 Something from nothing, you know, it's sort of a magical phrase, but that's going to
0:08:03 give you some picture of this.
0:08:04 white-head actuality it means being experienced. And that's interesting. Because what that means is
0:08:12 whatever potentiality is becomes real by being experienced.
0:08:20 Well, that's kind of what our world is like. The things that we experience, those are the things
0:08:24 we think are real, right? And so it's something like that. It's like what it means to be real is
0:08:31 is to be experienced, okay?
0:08:35 And that's what makes potential real or gives it being.
0:08:41 He also talks about something he calls satisfaction
0:08:45 or feeling, you know?
0:08:46 It's like, when we talk about consciousness,
0:08:51 the idea of feeling is sort of inseparable from it.
0:08:54 But when you have an experience, you have a feeling,
0:08:56 that's associated with that.
0:08:58 Maybe those words are the same words,
0:08:59 feeling and experience.
0:09:02 And Whitehead uses the word satisfaction
0:09:04 when he's talking about that.
0:09:05 And it's like, what he means is that when things,
0:09:08 when potentiality becomes experienced,
0:09:11 and that of course makes it real,
0:09:12 or concrescent as he calls it,
0:09:14 that there's some feeling associated with that.
0:09:17 Maybe it's the feeling of experiencing something,
0:09:20 whatever that might be,
0:09:22 or the experience of being experienced yourself,
0:09:26 something like that.
0:09:27 But he frames that as satisfaction.
0:09:33 And I don't know what that word brings to your mind,
0:09:35 but it's like a good or an end desirable
0:09:42 in and of itself, satisfaction.
0:09:45 And the way he paints this is like having a feeling
0:09:49 or an experience, that is the aim of process.
0:09:54 And process by this, I just mean the model
0:09:57 the world that Whitehead brings to the table, but you might also say God, and he does say
0:10:01 God. So, satisfaction is the aim or goal or desire of God. And it's stranger than that,
0:10:10 because God, to Whitehead, is not God as I understand it. And I wouldn't even use that
0:10:14 word if it were me. I would use some other word to mean what he means when he says God.
0:10:19 But he also talks about this idea of the creative advance, or the creative advance of
0:10:23 universe, something that he says transcends God. So to me, God isn't God in
0:10:29 Whitehead's model. The creative advance is God in Whitehead's model. And so it's
0:10:34 not clear whether this satisfaction is something that God wants, or the
0:10:38 creative advance wants, or something like that. But it is connected to this
0:10:44 notion of what is fundamental, you know, what everything is composed of, where it
0:10:49 comes from. And those questions themselves might not even be good questions, because
0:10:54 Whitehead resists the idea of substance, what things are made of. And that's our strategy
0:11:01 in modern science. We think if we can figure out what something's made of, that explains
0:11:06 the whole thing. And Whitehead doesn't think that's the case. I certainly don't think
0:11:10 that's the case. Plato certainly didn't think that's the case. But what's fundamental to
0:11:15 Whitehead is something that's self-created. He's just never so clear as to what it is
0:11:23 that's self-created. Is it God? Is it process? Is it the creative advance? Are those different
0:11:32 things? It's very difficult to tell. So this is the mix that we're in with Whitehead today.
0:11:39 This episode is called Order and Chaos Whitehead Style. In the first section we're going to open
0:11:44 up with, I'm going to call order, concresence, satisfaction. Without further ado, let me give
0:11:52 you Whitehead's words, quote, for the organic doctrine, the problem of order assumes primary
0:11:59 importance. The correlative of order is disorder. There can be no peculiar meaning in the notion of
0:12:08 order, unless this contrast holds. Order must be a synonym for givenness. Okay, so now we're
0:12:16 going to get into this idea of chaos and order. And he's opening this up. It's simple. It's not
0:12:21 complicated. He's just saying that his philosophy hinges on the importance of order. And order is
0:12:27 contrast with its opposite, which you would call disorder. So there's nothing really much more in
0:12:33 there except for he says that order is a synonym for givenness. So when you imagine your experience,
0:12:40 all of the things in it are given for you. It's like you become conscious, you open up your eyes,
0:12:45 whether that be when you were a newborn baby or when you wake up from a good night's sleep,
0:12:49 the world turns back on for you and things are just given in your reality. So these are things
0:12:54 that are actualized. These are experiences that are actualized in the world. They're objects for
0:13:00 After you, according to Whitehead, that's the same thing as order.
0:13:06 So that might make, if actuality is order, that might make potentiality disorder or chaos.
0:13:14 And I think that's really not far off from the conversations about chaos and order we've
0:13:19 had in the past.
0:13:20 I always talk about Jordan Peterson and his framing of chaos and order and maps of meaning
0:13:26 and his talking about how those concepts show up in our religious stories, all of our religious
0:13:33 stories, from the very beginning, our creation stories, all across the world, but even our
0:13:39 oldest creation stories, the Anuma Alish from Sumeria and the ancient Egyptian versions
0:13:45 of that creation story, and even our biblical creation story.
0:13:49 And all of these things talk about this generative union of opposites, something that's together,
0:13:56 That's opposites that represent some unity, some wholeness.
0:14:00 Jordan calls that the Ouroboros.
0:14:03 Carl Jung called that the sisigi, which I mentioned a few times on our Carl Jung episodes, but
0:14:08 whether we call it Ouroboros or sisigi or what have you, really doesn't matter.
0:14:12 The idea is two opposite things that really are one thing, and it's hard to imagine how
0:14:17 order and disorder being opposites could in reality be one thing.
0:14:23 our mythological stories, if they are one thing, if they're brought into a unity, that's a creative
0:14:30 generative act. And it makes perfect sense when you think about the opposites, rather than talking
0:14:38 about chaos and order or potential and actual, if instead we talk about feminine and masculine,
0:14:45 right, because then you have this idea of a man and a woman, and it's not an exact, you know,
0:14:49 an exact or precise way of talking about it, but you know what I mean? If you bring the masculine
0:14:54 and the feminine together into one thing, that symbol to me is a sexual symbol. It's the beast
0:15:00 with two backs. That is a creative act. And in the creation stories, the union of opposites was like
0:15:06 that. You've got this cosmic egg in the beginning that's made up of these two primordial gods,
0:15:11 chaos and order. And while they're together, they're just in this sexual embrace. And what's
0:15:17 being created within them are all the other gods that exist that are going to come into being
0:15:22 and play a role in these religious stories, including the cosmos itself. All of that's wrapped up
0:15:28 inside. And if you go back to the biblical stories, you can see it very clearly because Genesis talks
0:15:33 about everything being separated, right? The day from the night, the waters from the land,
0:15:39 everything is separated. And that's what happens in even in our earliest creation stories in the
0:15:45 In the Anuma Leash, you've got the goddess Tiamant,
0:15:47 the goddess of saltwater, the goddess of chaos.
0:15:50 And you have absolute God of order,
0:15:52 a God of fresh water, and they're both water.
0:15:55 They're both the same thing.
0:15:56 They're together in this unity,
0:15:58 but they're separated from each other.
0:16:00 And that act of separation allows creation,
0:16:04 allows for reality to be born.
0:16:07 And so you've got this idea wrapped up
0:16:10 in this discussion of chaos and order.
0:16:12 And I find it interesting that Whitehead doesn't point that out.
0:16:17 He doesn't even connect this to his own idea of potential and actual and the process between
0:16:24 them.
0:16:26 That's the process and process philosophy, and he doesn't make that connection when
0:16:30 he's talking about order and disorder, so let me push on.
0:16:36 He says, there can only be specific order, not merely order in the vague.
0:16:42 So, I think he says this for a few reasons, but what does that mean?
0:16:48 There can only be specific order, not just this, you know, amorphous, not attached to
0:16:53 anything order.
0:16:54 Well, it kind of makes sense because order, just like any potentiality, has to have some
0:16:59 embodiment, has to have some representation in order to be real, in order to be actual.
0:17:06 But I also think he's telling us this because he wants us to avoid confusing order as something
0:17:13 fundamental or as some power or some causative part of this process.
0:17:23 Order he says is givenness.
0:17:24 It's the things that are ordered, the things that have come into existence because they're
0:17:28 ordered.
0:17:30 But there's no such thing as order in the vague.
0:17:32 So it's not like we don't want to confuse order with God, let's say.
0:17:37 Even though Whitehead is not great about not confusing God with other things like the creative
0:17:42 advance and all kinds of other ideas that we've talked about so far.
0:17:46 Then he says, satisfaction provides the individual element in the composition of the actual entity.
0:17:58 There's more to that, but this is going to take some explanation.
0:18:01 Remember by satisfaction, he means the feeling, the experience of something that's been brought
0:18:06 from potential into actuality.
0:18:08 Now that it exists, it's something that can be experienced, and that experience generates
0:18:13 a feeling.
0:18:14 That feeling he calls satisfaction.
0:18:16 That's the desire, the ultimate end.
0:18:19 That's what God wants.
0:18:20 That's what process is after.
0:18:23 Satisfaction.
0:18:24 I think that's kind of a strange thing to say, but we'll save that for a bit.
0:18:31 Satisfaction provides the individual element in the composition of the actual entity.
0:18:35 So the actual entity is the experience, any experience, including, let's say, the experience
0:18:39 that I am. So when I've been made materially real, when I've been
0:18:48 concrescent, that's the word he's going to use, that I become
0:18:52 something that can be experienced, that experience satisfies the
0:18:57 creative advance or God or process or whatever it is you want to
0:19:01 use here for the stand-in because he certainly doesn't make it
0:19:04 clear. He explains that what this means is that we have
0:19:10 something called a subjective aim, and you can imagine, if I'm something like
0:19:16 a potentiality, and potentiality is something like a stem cell, I like to use
0:19:20 this analogy, it's a cell that can become anything, but it's not yet any
0:19:24 particular thing, it's this amorphous can-be-anything thing, that's what
0:19:29 potential is, and so the potential for experience could become any experience,
0:19:35 including the experience that I am, let's say, and that potentiality has an aim
0:19:40 to become a particular experience. In fact, maybe infinite particular experiences.
0:19:47 And when it achieves that, when it brings into actuality a particular experience,
0:19:54 that is a particular type of satisfaction. I keep saying particular because this is what Whitehead says,
0:20:00 or what he means when he says, that the satisfaction provides the individual element
0:20:06 the composition of an actual entity. It's what makes an experience a particular
0:20:11 experience. And it has to be a particular experience in order to be
0:20:17 experienced. Otherwise it's a stem cell. It's no particular thing and it can't
0:20:22 be experienced. Have you ever experienced no particular thing? I don't think so.
0:20:27 All right then he goes on he says the satisfaction is the superject. So I'll
0:20:33 I'll come back to that in a second.
0:20:35 The satisfaction is the superject.
0:20:38 Satisfaction is the superject adding its character
0:20:41 to the creativity whereby there is a becoming of entities
0:20:45 superseding the one in question.
0:20:49 So what does Sam Hell doesn't mean by that?
0:20:51 All right, let's take this step by step.
0:20:53 He says the satisfaction is the superject.
0:20:56 Okay, the superject is the end result of concresence
0:21:01 when something becomes real and actualizes itself, it becomes what he calls a
0:21:07 superject. Now, this is one of those phrases, those concepts that's wishy
0:21:12 washy as far as I'm concerned. It's not clear to me what he really means by
0:21:16 this, but I'll tell you what I think he means. By superject he means, and this is
0:21:22 something that is similar to the word subject. You know, when I consider
0:21:26 myself a subject, that means that I'm not just an object, right? I am a
0:21:30 thinking, living, breathing, conscious being of my own. So it's something like that, that he means.
0:21:37 But he explains, and we've talked about this prior, that an experience is brought about by
0:21:44 the unity of other experiences, other actual entities as he calls them. So I'm kind of this
0:21:49 composite creature made up of a bunch of other experiences that have come before me, and that
0:21:56 constitute me in some real way. But taking on a subjective perspective, like I have,
0:22:05 you know, the way that I experience the world, the way I experience myself, that's unique
0:22:10 from everybody else, from everything else. And so you've got this, you've got this unity
0:22:17 of experience that takes on a perspective. And the world, as seen through my eyes, let's
0:22:24 say. To whitehead, that's a part of the experience that I am. And you can understand
0:22:30 that when you understand that nobody else is privy to that. Nobody else ever experiences
0:22:37 the experiences that I experience. They belong to me, including the way that I experience
0:22:44 the world. It belongs exclusively to me. It's mine. The world is mine, just like my body
0:22:52 his mind. So this is what I think he means by superject. I think he means the world as
0:22:59 a particular subject. And then when he says satisfaction is the superject adding its character
0:23:08 to the creativity whereby there is a becoming of entities superseding the one in question.
0:23:14 This just has to do with the fact that again every experience can come together with new
0:23:19 experiences to create something something new, right? You know, it can be like a composite
0:23:24 situation or a relationship situation where experiences come together to become something new.
0:23:31 And when something comes from potential into actual and this feeling arises, Whitehead sees this
0:23:39 new experience, the feeling of being Chris, let's say, that is new data, right? It's a new component
0:23:50 that can be included in the composition of other experiences and I've used this I've used this
0:23:58 before but I'll bring it back up so I had a friend years ago that a couple years older than me
0:24:03 and I have a brother a few years older than me they're on the same age and they treated me
0:24:09 very differently like my brother was very critical of me didn't want me hanging out with his friends
0:24:13 I was very annoying to him that kind of thing when we were kids but this other other dude Keith was
0:24:19 was his name. He was very, really open to having like the young kids hang out with him. And it was
0:24:25 very like, just meaningful to me just to have somebody older is willing to accept me. But he was
0:24:31 also very generous to me. He took me and, me and a friend out to a flea market where were kids,
0:24:36 which was a lot of fun when you're a kid. He gave his money from his own pocket. He stopped at
0:24:40 the gas station and got like, you know, donuts and stuff for us to have breakfast all on his own
0:24:44 dime. And you know, when I was a 12 year old kid or something, that wasn't something that a,
0:24:48 17-year-old kid did for a 12-year-old kid.
0:24:52 It just seemed like a generosity that I just wasn't expecting, and it kind of made an impact
0:25:00 on me.
0:25:02 I tell you that because it's something that inspired me to be generous myself and sort
0:25:06 of changed my character from that point on permanently.
0:25:11 That's an example as to how an experience, let's say, in this case, Keith, could rub
0:25:19 off on me and hold the whole separate experience, right, Chris, in a way that permanently changes
0:25:25 who I am.
0:25:26 And so you get some idea of this, how the experience of some person can become, let's
0:25:32 say, data or, you know, the composite pieces that are needed to build the personality that
0:25:39 I'm going to have, you know, something like that.
0:25:43 So each time you have a satisfaction, each time you have a new experience, it adds to
0:25:48 the character of what Whitehead calls creativity.
0:25:51 And this is the idea of the creative advance.
0:25:54 This is the thing that I think Whitehead means God when he says it, but he couldn't
0:25:59 use the word God because he already used it to mean something else.
0:26:02 And I think that was a big mistake.
0:26:04 And I think Whitehead admitted it was a mistake at some point historically.
0:26:08 But each satisfaction creates data, creates raw material for lack of a better word that
0:26:13 can be used to create new experiences, to be integrated into new experiences and make
0:26:18 new things going forward.
0:26:23 So if we're going to call potential, potentiality, God, which I certainly like to do, then we
0:26:30 can say every actual thing that gets brought into reality from that potential actually
0:26:35 add something to the infinity of God.
0:26:40 You know, every concresence adds something to God.
0:26:45 And it's almost, to me, it's almost like
0:26:47 that's what makes God eternal in the first place.
0:26:51 You know, if experience were to stop, let's say,
0:26:54 there wouldn't be anything new to it.
0:26:56 You know, maybe God dies in that situation,
0:26:58 whatever that means.
0:27:00 But because it doesn't stop,
0:27:01 because every experience creates new experience
0:27:04 and new possibilities of experience.
0:27:06 And that thing just keeps going and going and going.
0:27:09 That's what makes God eternal and infinite.
0:27:12 Something like that.
0:27:16 All right, then he says,
0:27:18 there are differences between the satisfactions
0:27:20 of different entities, including gradations of intensity.
0:27:25 The intensity of satisfaction is promoted by the order
0:27:29 from which concresence arises.
0:27:32 It is enfeebled by disorder, okay.
0:27:36 All right, so he's saying that there's
0:27:37 But they're differences in satisfaction, so you might have, you might have one, you might
0:27:42 have potential, let's say, becoming a particular actuality.
0:27:46 And that might be, let's say, a better one than the one that comes next or the one that
0:27:50 came before.
0:27:51 It's like, what does he mean by better here?
0:27:53 And he says, gradations of intensity, which is strange, but let me just get back to this.
0:28:00 Remember, when he talks about the whole point is, is to feel, you know, God, whatever it
0:28:04 is that makes experience possible.
0:28:07 to experience itself. It wants to feel. And so everything that it brings into reality,
0:28:13 that it can then experience, it can then feel, that's something that satisfies it. That's
0:28:18 what he calls it a satisfaction. And some things satisfy it more or better than other
0:28:24 things. It's kind of a strange thing to presume. And I don't know how Whitehead imagines that
0:28:31 that that's possible, I don't really know where he came up with this idea. But he does
0:28:37 attach it to this idea of order. And what it sounds like to me, and we'll get to this,
0:28:47 it's that when experiences come together, Whitehead says that they prehend each other.
0:28:56 So that just means that they come together, that they exist within one another. When
0:29:00 When that happens, the more completely this new experience can pre-end other things.
0:29:08 The greater the unity of prior experience that it brings into itself, the more intense
0:29:17 the satisfaction.
0:29:19 This is why he connects it to order.
0:29:22 The greater the order, the more intense the satisfaction.
0:29:29 He has this idea of negative prehensions, which I never understood really, but this puts it
0:29:32 in a perspective sort of.
0:29:35 The idea is that if a concresence doesn't pre-end certain things, that that might be
0:29:43 what he calls a negative pre-ension, that its satisfaction won't be as intense, it
0:29:48 won't be as good.
0:29:50 And here he's calling that the effect of disorder.
0:29:55 So we're coming back to order and disorder.
0:30:00 Here's my question, why is satisfaction
0:30:04 the presumed desire or goal of process or God
0:30:09 or whatever it is you wanna call it?
0:30:12 I don't know about you,
0:30:14 but it does seem to imply a kind of anthropomorphization,
0:30:18 you know, we're looking at God or process
0:30:21 like a human being, right?
0:30:22 We human beings are something that experience satisfaction
0:30:26 and I'm just not entirely sure what that means
0:30:29 in the context of the process of the world.
0:30:33 I just don't know.
0:30:36 It certainly implies a thing, you know, whatever that is,
0:30:40 with the capacity for feeling and satisfaction.
0:30:44 Maybe even the capacity for will,
0:30:46 since it seems to desire satisfaction
0:30:50 and will and feeling and satisfaction
0:30:54 are all things that are so closely tied to being human
0:30:57 that I don't really know if it's fair to abstract that
0:31:03 to the process of the world.
0:31:05 I don't know if we can,
0:31:07 and I don't know why Whitehead presumes it.
0:31:11 It sounds good, but it sounds so particularly human.
0:31:18 All right, let me push on.
0:31:20 He says, concresence is the building up of a satisfaction,
0:31:24 which constitutes the togetherness
0:31:26 of the discrete components.
0:31:29 The process of concresence terminates with satisfaction, and the creativity thereby
0:31:34 passes into the concresence of other actual entities. Completion is the perishing of immediacy.
0:31:43 It never really is. All right, so this is going to require some explanation.
0:31:49 So again, this idea of concresence or something potential becoming actual brings experiences
0:31:55 together into one unity. And that unity, that unity is something that can be experienced,
0:32:02 something that can be felt. And that's what he calls a satisfaction. So when Whitehead
0:32:07 says that's what constitutes the togetherness of the discrete components, that's what he
0:32:12 means, these discrete actual entities, these individual experiences that come together
0:32:17 to create this new experience. Then he says the process of concretence
0:32:23 terminates with satisfaction. So the process of becoming actual, becoming real from this
0:32:29 state of potential that it ends in a satisfaction. So you might think of that as being psychologists
0:32:37 might say that you're fully actualized, let's say as a human being. And I think it means
0:32:42 something like that, that when you fully come into your own to become what you are, that's
0:32:48 this satisfaction, that's the end of this process of becoming. And then he says,
0:32:54 end the creativity, thereby passes into the concresence of other actual entities.
0:32:59 So again, the experience that you are creates raw material, data, from which
0:33:06 other experiences can come or incorporate into these new experiences that will
0:33:10 come after. And then he says, completion is the perishing of immediacy. It never
0:33:18 really is. And that last part, it never really is, is a reference to Plato when he was talking
0:33:23 about the idea of becoming. That is a human being where we see ourselves as something
0:33:28 constantly becoming. You know, it's like we never, we never are exactly because we're
0:33:34 always transforming into something else into something new. And so every time you ask yourself,
0:33:39 you know, who you are, or where's the being in this process of becoming, you can point
0:33:44 to it. But what are you pointing to? You're pointing to something that came from something
0:33:48 else that came from something else. And if you go all the way back to the beginning and
0:33:53 you're saying, what is it that started becoming? And every time you, every time you ask yourself
0:33:59 that question, the answer is, it's becoming from something that it once was. And at the
0:34:05 very beginning of that process, you can't say what it is that's becoming. And so Plato
0:34:10 says, whatever it is that's becoming never really existed. It's only the process of becoming.
0:34:19 And so the satisfaction is the perishing of the thing, of its immediacy. So I then become
0:34:28 the raw material for some new experience that will come after me. And so I've perished, let's
0:34:34 say in my current form, but live on in the experience of others and in the future experience.
0:34:42 All right.
0:34:45 He says, no actual entity can be conscious of its own satisfaction.
0:34:50 For such knowledge would alter the satisfaction.
0:34:53 I don't know what you think of that doesn't exactly fit, but I wanted to keep it in here
0:34:59 because it reminds me of something interesting.
0:35:04 So why can no experience be conscious of its own satisfaction?
0:35:13 This is because if that were the case, it would alter the satisfaction.
0:35:18 So it's somehow unknowable.
0:35:20 But what that reminds me of, a couple of things, it reminds me of the observer effect
0:35:25 that we hear about from quantum physics.
0:35:28 This goes back to Niels Bohr and a lot of these early quantum physicists, and you've
0:35:33 heard me talk about this before, I'm sure you've heard this many times, but the idea
0:35:36 is that when you have quantum particles and you try to measure the particles, what you
0:35:48 find is that you can't measure a particle. What you instead measure is a wave. And so
0:35:53 you've got this duality where on the quantum level things exist as particles, but also
0:35:59 but as waves simultaneously.
0:36:02 And what collapses the wave function?
0:36:05 What turns this wave into a particular particle
0:36:09 with a specific momentum and a specific position
0:36:13 when these physicists are trying to measure something?
0:36:16 What does that seems to be the measurement?
0:36:20 It seems to be the observer.
0:36:23 So I as a scientist, when I measure the wave,
0:36:27 looking for the particle, I turn the wave into a particle, and it seems to be me taking
0:36:34 the measurement that's doing that. And so this is what comes to my mind when he says
0:36:41 no actual entity can be conscious of its own satisfaction because that would affect
0:36:46 its satisfaction. And the observer effect says that's the same thing, that we can never
0:36:51 know what's objectively out there, because we are part of the system, we are part of
0:36:56 this quantum system, and when we measure it, we've changed the system.
0:37:01 So the act of measuring it changes the results, and there's no way around that.
0:37:07 I think there's some interesting parallel there.
0:37:15 That brings me to the next section, which I'm going to call mind-feeling experience.
0:37:21 Whitehead says, the world is self-creative, and the actual entity as self-creating creature
0:37:29 passes into its immortal function of part creator of the transcendent world.
0:37:34 Oh, man. Oh, man. Okay. What a thing to say.
0:37:38 So what does he mean here? The world is self-creative.
0:37:41 That means it doesn't have an origin or it's its own origin, something like that.
0:37:46 Then he says, and the actual entity as self-creating creature
0:37:51 passes into its immortal function of part creator of the transcendent world.
0:37:56 What does that mean?
0:38:00 So I think we as experiences are part creator, and the Bible says we're made in the image
0:38:06 of God, and I think that has something to do with this idea of being a creator.
0:38:11 We're part creator of the transcendent world, why?
0:38:15 Because each actual entity, each experience that makes up us becomes constituent of the
0:38:23 the new and novel world of whatever experience comes next, and it remains so forever.
0:38:31 So we become this immortal thing, you know, when I cease to exist but become part of the
0:38:37 experience of some new experience in the world, I'm going to always exist as part of that
0:38:43 new experience, even though I'm gone, and I can think about this in terms of my children.
0:38:48 You know, I think about the lessons that I teach them and the memories that we make
0:38:52 together in things that will last longer than I will.
0:38:58 But more particularly, I think about sort of being a disciplinarian and trying to instill
0:39:04 discipline and hard work and certain values, you know, resiliency and things like that
0:39:11 into my children.
0:39:12 And I sort of imagine myself as like, you know, obviously I'm being an example of something
0:39:18 that they're going to take into themselves, they're going to, it's going to become part
0:39:22 their personality. And so I will be this abstract thing existing in their minds, you
0:39:28 know, that even when I'm dead and gone will be the thing that, you know, that
0:39:32 whispers in their ear, what's right and what's wrong, what they should do and
0:39:36 that they should face their fears and all these things that I want them to learn.
0:39:40 And in that way, even when I'm gone, I'm silly mortal in a way because that part
0:39:49 their personality that I am still exists within them and will be passed on to their children
0:39:56 and you know friends and people that they have interactions with and so forth. And it's more
0:40:00 than that. But that gives you one example of what this might mean. Alright, then he says,
0:40:09 in itself creation, the actual entity is guided by its ideal of itself as satisfaction and
0:40:17 as transcendent creator. So this is interesting. So, so to white head every experience is self
0:40:27 created, including you and I. So when he says in itself creation, that is guided by its ideal of
0:40:36 itself as a satisfaction. So this is this idea that the potentiality has all these infinite ways
0:40:43 in which it can become actual.
0:40:46 And it strives after particular ones or all of them.
0:40:53 I don't know.
0:40:54 It strives after them and manages to actualize one of them, let's say, and has this feeling
0:41:02 of satisfaction.
0:41:05 So our self-creation is guided by that, by this what we might be.
0:41:13 So you might call that creation and as transcendent creator.
0:41:19 So we're guided in our actuality by this idea of ourselves as creation and creator.
0:41:29 And something about that just rings true with my mystical experience.
0:41:35 It rings true with all sorts of religious traditions as well.
0:41:42 And then Whitehead says, the enjoyment of this ideal is the subjective aim.
0:41:47 The lower for feeling.
0:41:50 The lower for feeling.
0:41:54 So when he says enjoyment here, enjoyment of this ideal, again, that supposes a thing
0:42:00 with the capacity to feel or to enjoy.
0:42:05 And again, I mentioned that that might be kind of an anthropomorphic idea.
0:42:09 It's something that reminds us of a human being and maybe only a human being.
0:42:14 But it also reminds us of something with a mind.
0:42:17 So it may be it need not be a human being, but certainly something that you would say
0:42:21 has a mind.
0:42:22 What else has the capacity for enjoyment, for feeling?
0:42:28 Those aren't things that are physical.
0:42:30 They're not physical things in the material world.
0:42:33 They're conceptual, they're mental, they're emotional, they're feelings.
0:42:37 They exist in mind.
0:42:40 That's going to get interesting here.
0:42:45 Okay, so Whitehead says, this lore for feeling is the germ of mind.
0:42:51 I am using the term mind to mean the complex of mental operations involved in the constitution
0:42:57 of an actual entity.
0:43:01 Okay, the lure for feeling is the germ of mind.
0:43:06 So this is interesting to me because it kind of seems to put the cart before the horse,
0:43:09 like you need to have mind in order to feel.
0:43:13 He's saying that this temptation for feeling or this lure for feeling, trying to bring these
0:43:18 satisfactions about, trying to create experiences for the purpose of enjoying them, that has
0:43:26 to happen within a mind, that somehow, to whitehead, the lure for feeling is the germ
0:43:32 of mind as though it creates the mind.
0:43:36 So if you need mind for feeling, how is it that feeling creates mind?
0:43:41 you putting the cart before the horse. And then he says, I'm using the term mine to mean the complex
0:43:49 of mental operations involved in the constitution of an actual entity, which seems to say to me,
0:43:57 it seems to be an admission that actual entities or experience exist in mind. There has to be these
0:44:05 mental operations going on for an actual entity or for an experience to be possible. So how can
0:44:11 you have that before you have mind. You must have mind. And then he says, mental operations
0:44:21 do not necessarily involve consciousness. So he wants to introduce this idea that mind
0:44:26 is something that's more than the capacity for consciousness. So what might might mind
0:44:33 be then? Let's push on. He says, subjective ways of feeling, clothes dry bones with the
0:44:44 flesh of a real being. The miracle of creation is described in Ezekiel. And he quotes the
0:44:52 Bible here and the breath came into them and they lived and stood up upon their feet.
0:44:58 All right, so you can kind of see why the theologians like Whitehead because not many
0:45:04 philosophers, especially if his era are going to quote the Bible, but he has. So when he
0:45:09 says subjective ways of feeling, the ways of being experienced, let's say, clothed dry
0:45:16 bones with the flesh of a real being. So I don't know what he means by dry bones,
0:45:22 but I think what he means is the potential for experience. And this is
0:45:27 something that he's called actual entities. So his actual entities are
0:45:32 clothed with the flesh of a real being. And he uses to illustrate what this
0:45:41 means, he uses this quote from the Bible about breath coming into these forms
0:45:48 forms, and making them live. That's what he did in Genesis when he breathed life into
0:45:53 the clay forms of Adam, let's say. So you've got the potential for experience that's being
0:46:03 made real, just like Adam being made real by God in the Bible. Interesting, right? Then
0:46:14 he says, feeling has to be definite in respect to the eternal objects with which feeling
0:46:19 clothes itself. Eternal objects are potentials for feeling, a conceptual lure for feeling.
0:46:29 So you've got these what he calls dry bones, right? The actual entity, which is the potential
0:46:33 for experience. And it dresses itself up with the eternal objects, the eternal objects of experience.
0:46:40 These are the things that he's called qualia. Well, he didn't use the word qualia, but our sense
0:46:45 experience, the things that we that we feel, right, could be, you know, senses of taste
0:46:52 and touch and, you know, could be colors, it could be anything qualitative, the way it
0:46:56 feels to feel pain, the way it feels to fall in love, the way it feels to be a human being,
0:47:02 all of that stuff.
0:47:04 These are eternal objects that clothe, but the potential for experience and make it real,
0:47:11 like God breathing the breath of life into the clay form of Adam and he says order in
0:47:22 the actual world introduces a derivative order among eternal objects. I include this
0:47:29 just to say, what he's talking about here is eternal objects which are like platonic
0:47:33 forms. They don't exist in the world. They exist in the numinal realm. They exist in the
0:47:39 spiritual realm outside of reality and potential, whatever that means. But he says order in
0:47:45 The actual world introduces order in this ethereal world.
0:47:52 And they're connected, obviously, because the eternal objects become real, they become
0:47:56 experienceable by attaching themselves to the actual world.
0:48:03 And I think what he means by this is that creation affects the Creator, just as the Creator
0:48:10 affects creation.
0:48:13 You could say God creates the heavens of the earth, let's say.
0:48:17 But having created the heavens of the earth, that experience then changes God, right?
0:48:21 It creates some new thing that wasn't what you called God a moment ago.
0:48:27 It's something new.
0:48:29 And here, again, you have this image of a process, creation and creator affecting one
0:48:34 another back and forth in a continuous cycle.
0:48:38 as though they're one thing, just like the Ouroboros we talked about earlier with Tiamat
0:48:45 Napsu, the feminine and the masculine, the generative, you know, union of opposites,
0:48:51 being one thing. Then he says, feelings are vectors for they feel what is there and transform
0:49:03 it into what is here. This is a simple one, but it took a lot of thinking and I really
0:49:11 I really love it. I think it's beautiful. Feelings are vectors.
0:49:16 So he said, when you feel something, you take what is there and transform it into
0:49:22 what is here. When you feel something, you, you have an experience within yourself.
0:49:26 So that makes sense to bring something into yourself. When you, when you have an
0:49:30 experience, you do incorporate that into yourself, you feel it in your being.
0:49:37 But I also think it means something like this.
0:49:39 It says, for they feel what is there.
0:49:42 By there, I think he means what is in potential.
0:49:47 And you transform it into what is here, which is what is actual.
0:49:52 And this, I think, is what he means when he explains that the experience is what makes
0:49:57 something real.
0:49:58 And you take something potential.
0:50:03 And when you experience it, the process of experiencing it transforms it into something
0:50:08 actual, it makes it real. Then he says, the subjective aim at satisfaction constitutes
0:50:20 the final cause or lore whereby there is concresence. That satisfaction remains as
0:50:28 an element in the content of creative purpose. Satisfaction constitutes the final cause. That's
0:50:38 the end or the purpose of something. That's what he means by final cause. The final
0:50:45 cause of concresence, of becoming real. And he says, and that satisfaction remains as
0:50:52 an element in the content of creative purpose. So that feeling, again, it becomes data, it
0:50:57 becomes raw material that can be used or incorporated into experiences in the future,
0:51:02 to new experiences that couldn't have existed until the data, let's say that I am, came
0:51:08 onto the scene. Now it has more to use to become whatever it is going to become. That
0:51:26 That brings me to the next section, which is called actual entities, the world, and God.
0:51:34 So Whitehead says, an actual entity has a threefold character.
0:51:39 The character given for it by the past, the subjective character aimed at its concresence,
0:51:46 and the superject, which is its specific satisfaction, qualifying the transcendent creativity.
0:51:53 Okay, so every actual entity, every experience has a threefold character, and I'll make
0:51:59 this simple for you.
0:52:01 He says, the character given for it by the past, okay, so this is the past we're talking
0:52:06 about.
0:52:07 And what is that?
0:52:08 According to Whitehead, those are the actual entities from which you arose, right?
0:52:13 You are a new experience that came from prior experiences.
0:52:17 So the character from which you came, your past, that's all of those experiences that
0:52:22 that allowed you to exist.
0:52:25 The subjective character aimed at its concresence,
0:52:28 that's your present, that's the being,
0:52:31 that's the elusive being in this process of becoming.
0:52:34 It's the present, it's your present striving.
0:52:38 Whatever it is you're trying to be.
0:52:41 And the superject, which is its specific satisfaction,
0:52:45 qualifying with transcending creativity.
0:52:48 So once I've become a satisfaction and I've become
0:52:53 data for the rest of the world, let's say,
0:52:56 then you've got the novelty of future actualizations,
0:53:01 of something new that will exist in the future
0:53:03 or might exist in the future.
0:53:05 So these three components are past, present, and future.
0:53:13 And he says in the case of the primordial actual entity,
0:53:15 God, there is no past.
0:53:17 God differs from other actual entities. There is still, however, the same three-fold character,
0:53:25 the primordial nature of God, the concresence of a unity of feelings, the consequent nature of
0:53:34 God, the prehension of God, excuse me, the prehension by God of the universe, and the
0:53:40 superjective nature of God, his specific satisfaction qualifying the transcend creativity.
0:53:46 So you've got the same thing here, but there's a couple things that I would say.
0:53:52 So we hear where it says the primordial nature of God, the concresence of a unity of feelings.
0:53:59 What you have to ask feelings of what, right, if we're talking about God and God's supposed
0:54:05 to be the experience, the actual entity that kicks off this experiential process that all
0:54:12 All the other experiences come from.
0:54:14 He's the first.
0:54:15 God is the first.
0:54:17 So when it says that the primordial nature of God, the concresence of a unity of feelings
0:54:22 that I have to ask feelings of what, because nothing else exists, there are no experiences
0:54:30 beyond that of God.
0:54:32 So it seems to me that it's something like self-experience, feelings of what?
0:54:38 feelings of God. God's own feelings of itself, its self-experience. And then it says the
0:54:47 consequent nature of God, the pretension by God, manifesting itself within the universe
0:54:53 essentially. And then the superjective nature of God, you know, his specific satisfaction
0:55:00 qualifying the transcendent creativity, which remember, that means that it's acting upon
0:55:07 this transcendent creativity. That's the thing that I want to call God, even though
0:55:11 Whitehead doesn't mix this conversation extra confusing. But again, we see an
0:55:16 example here of the transcendent creativity being impacted by the
0:55:21 experience. And so you have this transforming of potentiality itself. And
0:55:28 you get this image again of a process. Creation acting upon creator, creator
0:55:34 acting upon creation. And that's something difficult for most kind of traditional religious
0:55:39 people to imagine. We imagine that God creates the universe and is far above it, or at least
0:55:46 in control of it. And Whitehead is saying something different. He's saying that creation,
0:55:52 the act of creation, impacts the creator in the same way that the creator impacts creation.
0:56:00 it's a back and forth between the two. And in fact, this process between the two, between
0:56:05 creator and creation, between the potential and the actual, that's actually one thing.
0:56:13 So it's the process in process philosophy. Okay, and then he says, God is the outcome
0:56:22 of creativity, the foundation of order, and the go towards novelty. Order and novelty
0:56:30 are instruments of his subjective aim.
0:56:33 Okay, so I think what we see here in particular in the beginning, God is the outcome of creativity.
0:56:41 So if God arises from creativity, then creativity is the real God, the real origin, the real
0:56:48 creator.
0:56:49 Is it not?
0:56:50 Is it just me?
0:56:51 Am I the only one that sees that?
0:56:56 God is the unmoved mover according to Aristotle, the uncreated creator.
0:57:00 If God's existence is dependent on creativity, then it's creativity that's God.
0:57:09 And whitehead has got everything topsy-turvy.
0:57:11 Then he says, every actual entity, including God, is something individual for its own sake
0:57:23 and transcends the rest of actuality.
0:57:27 God is a creature transcended by the creativity which it qualifies.
0:57:32 Then he says, God satisfies Spinoza's definition of substance, that it is cause-asue, self-caused.
0:57:43 So let's dig into this one.
0:57:45 So every actual entity, including God, is something individual for its own sake.
0:57:50 This is the idea that every experience is an experience, self-contained and self-created
0:57:57 and including the entire unity of things.
0:58:03 So experience is God, for lack of a better word, and the subjective perspective that
0:58:10 we assume, right, that this idea of myself as a subject or a superject, that gives reality
0:58:20 to the multiplicity of the world.
0:58:22 In reality, the world is just one thing, one experience, this creative advance, this one
0:58:27 process.
0:58:28 You know, it's a closed loop, self-contained and self-created.
0:58:31 And he says every experience is like that.
0:58:35 Every experience is a unique perspective that encapsulates all of existence.
0:58:43 And he says it transcends the rest of actuality.
0:58:46 That's the rest of it that we see as other than ourselves, the world at large.
0:58:51 I'm a subject and everything else is an object.
0:58:55 So he says that it transcends the rest of actuality, which seems to mean something like
0:59:02 the rest of actuality, which is all part of the oneness.
0:59:05 It's all part of me.
0:59:06 It's all part of my experience.
0:59:08 But it becomes an object for it, for the subject.
0:59:12 The world becomes objectified, as Whitehead will say.
0:59:18 And then he says,
0:59:19 God is a creature transcended by the creativity
0:59:22 which it qualifies.
0:59:25 And again, this is right along the same lines
0:59:29 as the quote we read before this.
0:59:30 God is the outcome of creativity.
0:59:32 God is transcended by creativity. So clearly, whatever the creative advance is,
0:59:39 whatever creativity means to Whitehead, that is God. That is the real creator.
0:59:45 That brings me to the next section, which I'm going to call God as feeler as
0:59:53 knower. Whitehead says, the philosophy of organism is the inversion of Kant's
1:00:01 The critique of pure reason describes subjective data passing into the appearance of an objective world.
1:00:10 The philosophy of organism describes objective data passing into subjective satisfaction.
1:00:18 For Kant, the world emerges from the subject.
1:00:22 For the philosophy of organism, the subject emerges from the world, a superject rather than a subject.
1:00:30 So, I think this is really interesting, you know, he's contrasting his philosophy to that
1:00:36 of Kant.
1:00:37 If you guys don't know Kant, the critique of pure reason is one of the landmark works
1:00:41 of Western philosophy.
1:00:42 It's considered one of the greatest works of philosophy even today.
1:00:46 And he sums it up by saying that Kant's perspective is that there's subjective data
1:00:52 that passes into the appearance of an objective world, which seems to say something like subjective
1:01:00 The data is somehow fundamental, somehow real, and the objective world that it creates is
1:01:08 just an appearance, almost like the objective world is illusory, you know, it's not real
1:01:15 exactly.
1:01:16 Then he says the philosophy of organism tips that on its head and says that no, no, there
1:01:22 isn't subjective data, there's objective data, and it doesn't pass into the appearance
1:01:28 of a world, it passes into the subjective satisfaction.
1:01:35 So again, for Kant, the world emerges from the subject, but for Whitehead, the subject
1:01:39 emerges from the world.
1:01:43 Now my take on this is a little different.
1:01:44 I was really struck by a quote from maps of meaning where Jordan Peterson's quoting John
1:01:52 Piaget was a developmental psychologist.
1:01:56 He studied children and their development.
1:01:59 He was apparently a brilliant man.
1:02:00 I haven't read his work myself, I probably should.
1:02:03 One of the quotes that really struck me though,
1:02:05 it stuck with me, is this.
1:02:08 Piaget says,
1:02:10 knowledge does not begin in the eye
1:02:12 and it does not begin in the object.
1:02:15 There is a reciprocal and simultaneous construction
1:02:19 of the subject on one hand
1:02:21 and the object on the other.
1:02:24 Man, still makes the hair stand up on my arms.
1:02:28 So knowledge does not begin with the subject
1:02:30 it does not begin with the object. There is a simultaneous construction of the subject and the
1:02:36 object together. Now he comes to this conclusion by looking at how children's conceptualization of
1:02:46 themselves and the world develop. And what he says is that they develop together. And that
1:02:53 makes a lot of sense. I mean, you can see what the world was like, what it seemed to you like.
1:02:58 Like if you think about your deepest memories, like what the world seemed to you when you
1:03:02 were four or five years old, is exactly what you would expect a four or five year old be
1:03:09 able to manage, a concept that they can wrap their head around.
1:03:13 But as you get mature and more sophisticated, what happens?
1:03:17 The world gets more mature and sophisticated, does it not?
1:03:22 So the birth of our understanding of our self as a self, and the birth of our understanding
1:03:29 the world, that those things are happening together as if they're one thing.
1:03:36 So here's what I want to propose.
1:03:39 When Kant says the world emerges from the subject, and Whitehead says the subject emerges
1:03:44 from the world, might we suggest that they're both wrong and right?
1:03:52 we take a Piagetian approach and say the world emerges from the subject and the subject emerges
1:03:58 from the world simultaneously? I think there's something to that. Whitehead says, the feeler
1:04:11 is the unity emergent from its own feelings. Okay, what in the fuck? Let me read that again.
1:04:19 The feeler is the unity emergent from its own feelings. So I sort of get what he's trying to
1:04:26 to say here, he's trying to paint the picture of something that's self-created, which he
1:04:31 says that experiences are. They're self-created. So the feeler is emergent from its own feelings.
1:04:39 It's something that's self-created. But we have to consider that feelings, in this case,
1:04:47 feelings create the subjective perspective of a feeler. It's like you as a subject or
1:04:53 self doesn't exist until there is experience. It's almost like those experiences don't
1:05:01 even take place within a feeler until you have an experience. And then that simultaneously
1:05:07 creates this idea of a feeler to contain them or that the feelings belong to. And then we
1:05:13 go back to something very Piagetian again, where the feeler and the feelings are maybe
1:05:18 mutually created, simultaneously created. Then he says order is applicable to the objectified
1:05:29 data for actual entities, to the relations among actual entities. So this is more along the lines
1:05:35 of order and satisfaction and intensities that we were talking about earlier. And he says that
1:05:42 order applies to objectified data. So you have to understand that to whitehead, when you take on
1:05:49 when you, when you are the world assuming a subjective perspective, you have yourself as a
1:05:55 subject, but everything else, all the other parts of you, you now see as objects, they become the
1:06:00 world around you. And that data, you know, that's the data we get from the world around us, that's
1:06:06 all the data we have access to. That's something like self-experience, by the way, it's data of
1:06:12 ourselves, whatever it is that we are. But it's that objectified data that becomes new
1:06:19 experiences. And he says this is what order applies to. Then he says chaotic disorder means
1:06:27 lack of definition in the satisfaction attained and consequent and feeblement of intensity.
1:06:36 means the lapse towards slider actuality. Then he says, society's harmoniously requiring
1:06:44 each other is the essential condition for depth of satisfaction. Okay, so earlier we
1:06:51 were talking about this. We said that the intensity of the feeling of the satisfaction
1:06:57 is greater, hypothetically, according to whitehead, when the satisfaction incorporates as much
1:07:04 as possible. So when it prehens and includes in its unity as much of what's of reality
1:07:11 as possible. The more it can do that, the more intense the satisfaction. The less it can
1:07:18 do that, he says it means the lapse towards slider actuality. And then he gives an example
1:07:26 of this. When he talks about societies, what he means are lots of experiences in association
1:07:34 or relation with one another that creates some greater, more complex experience or
1:07:39 entity. So that's a society to him. And he says, society's harmoniously requiring
1:07:46 one another is the essential condition for depth of satisfaction. And that kind of
1:07:51 illustrates this idea of a greater unity of, of preheinding more and more, the most
1:07:56 that you can incorporate into yourself to create whatever it is that you are, the
1:08:01 The more you can do that, the more powerful that satisfaction or intensity, the more God
1:08:07 likes it, whatever that means, exactly, and I'm not sure why he goes there in the first
1:08:13 place, but this is what he says.
1:08:15 The greater and more complete the unity or prehengean, the more intense or greater the
1:08:20 concrescent satisfaction, something like God enjoys that more.
1:08:24 And then he says, God is an actual entity imminent in the world, but transcending any
1:08:33 finite cosmic epic, a being at once actual, eternal, imminent, and transcendent.
1:08:41 The transcendence of God is not peculiar to him.
1:08:45 Every actual entity in virtue of its novelty transcends its universe.
1:08:51 God included.
1:08:52 I guess what I want to point out here is going back to this idea of chaos and order and recognizing
1:08:59 that Whitehead doesn't connect this idea of chaos and order to this generative union
1:09:06 of opposites, to this orboros idea which he still maintains when he talks about potential
1:09:12 becoming actual. That's the same exact thing. But here he says that God is imminent and
1:09:18 transcendent. Okay, imminent and transcendent. Those are two opposites again. They're orboric
1:09:25 opposites. The union of those things is just like the example he uses when he talks about
1:09:31 potentiality and actuality. But he never makes that connection and I find that
1:09:36 glaring. When he says, for Plato, the process of the actual world has been
1:09:44 conceived as an incoming of forms into potentiality, issuing into that
1:09:50 togetherness which is an actual thing. The creation of the world is the
1:09:56 incoming of a type of order. It is not the beginning, but one of infinite
1:10:01 beginnings. Okay, so when we take this platonic idea, which is something that's
1:10:09 part and parcel to Whitehead's philosophy, he says that the process of the world is
1:10:15 conceived as an incoming of forms into potentiality. So you can see
1:10:19 potentiality as this, well, as God, as this as this infinite stem cell of
1:10:25 experience can become anything, right, type of a thing. And that it's particular
1:10:30 incarnation, its particular manifestations are made possible by these forms, by some sort
1:10:41 of a limiting structure that makes it, rather than being all things or nothing, like the
1:10:47 stem cell, it becomes a particular type of thing.
1:10:52 And this is the role that actual entities serve with their incorporation of these eternal
1:10:57 objects of experience that we've been talking about in prior Whitehead lectures.
1:11:01 And then he says, the creation of the world is the incoming of a type of order.
1:11:07 So the important thing here is the last bit where he says, it's not the beginning, but
1:11:12 one of infinite beginnings.
1:11:15 So remember, as a superject, I'm the world with a particular subjective perspective.
1:11:22 I'm the world as a subject.
1:11:27 And every, every experience is like that, the world but a different type of subject that
1:11:32 sees the world and experiences the world in themselves in a different way.
1:11:36 So every world is the incoming of a type of order.
1:11:41 It's not the beginning, but one of infinite beginnings.
1:11:45 Every world, every perspective of the world is a kind of like a whole new world because
1:11:52 nobody else expresses or experiences the world in exactly the same way.
1:11:57 Then he says, the aptitions which constitute God's purpose, remember, this is his will
1:12:07 for concresence or his desire for this feeling, the satisfaction that we keep talking about.
1:12:12 That's the appetite of God, again, another sort of anthropomorphic thing to say.
1:12:17 But again, the aptitions which constitute God's purpose are seeking intensity and not preservation.
1:12:25 He and this primordial nature is unmoved by love for this particular or that particular.
1:12:32 For in this foundational process of creativity, there are no particulars.
1:12:37 Again, kind of a strange thing to say that God is unmoved or that God loves.
1:12:44 That's again, it's not uncommon for religious people to say things like that, but hard to
1:12:49 argue that it's sort of anthropomorphizing something that I don't know if it can be
1:12:53 anthropomorphized. You know, what human beings share in common with God seems to be mind.
1:13:02 And maybe all of these things, you know, will and desire and feeling and all of the stuff
1:13:08 we've been talking about, we can chalk up to something like mind. But Whitehead is going to be
1:13:15 characteristically confusing on that on that mark as well, which we'll see in just a second.
1:13:19 But this bit here where he says that God's purpose are seeking intensity and not preservation.
1:13:28 I guess that's basically pointing out something he's already said many times, is that actual
1:13:34 entities, experiences, they necessarily come and go.
1:13:39 In fact, they have to go in order to allow some new experience to come about that's
1:13:45 going to incorporate what the experience that once was.
1:13:49 So there's this necessity that experiences die, for lack of a better word.
1:13:56 And so what God is seeking are intensities.
1:13:58 He's seeking experience and not preservation, you know, to maintain an experience is neither
1:14:04 here nor there.
1:14:05 God doesn't love any particular thing.
1:14:10 Just the feelings of particular things.
1:14:16 Then Whitehead says, his aim is depth of satisfaction towards the fulfillment of his
1:14:20 own being. His tenderness is directed towards each actual occasion as it arises,
1:14:29 thus God's purpose in the creative advance is the evocation of intensities.
1:14:34 So it's all about feeling. It's all about evoking feelings that can be experienced.
1:14:40 And this, Whitehead says, is the fulfillment of God's own being. And I have to go back to
1:14:48 an earlier example where we talked about the primordial nature of God being the first experience
1:14:53 and what in the world is God experiencing?
1:14:55 If God is all that exists,
1:14:58 and the answer is itself,
1:15:02 experience of experience.
1:15:05 That's what we're talking about.
1:15:07 So if God is something like experience,
1:15:09 or the potential for experience,
1:15:11 fulfilling his own being is actualizing that potential
1:15:15 through experience.
1:15:18 It's amazing.
1:15:24 That brings me to, well, you know what?
1:15:25 Before I move on,
1:15:27 let me focus on this last bit here,
1:15:28 where he says, God's purpose in the creative advance
1:15:32 is the evocation of intensities.
1:15:34 So I know that we've been talking about intensity
1:15:37 strictly from the sense of feeling,
1:15:39 but I also have to bring up another,
1:15:41 maybe connection to physics here
1:15:43 where we're talking about quantum physics
1:15:45 a little bit earlier.
1:15:47 And one of the things that physicists will tell you
1:15:50 is that matter and energy boiled down
1:15:55 really essentially to one another,
1:15:56 And energy differentiates itself by,
1:16:00 well, you might say intensities here.
1:16:01 You might use that same word,
1:16:03 but it boils down to patterns of vibration.
1:16:06 So when you go down to the smallest level of matter
1:16:09 and energy and you look at things like quarks and gluons
1:16:12 and electrons and things like that,
1:16:13 that what distinguishes them from one another
1:16:16 is patterns of vibration.
1:16:18 And spin and charge and things like that,
1:16:20 but essentially patterns of vibration.
1:16:23 But everything is essentially some sort of cosmic music.
1:16:29 So when he says God's purpose in the creative advance is the evocation of intensities.
1:16:35 I also see this image in my head of like a guitar string vibrating and the different
1:16:39 patterns of vibration becoming, you know, it's an interesting word to use, but actualizing
1:16:44 maybe these building blocks, these material building blocks that will allow all of matter
1:16:50 to come about. That will constitute the force of causation and the laws of nature.
1:16:55 And all of that comes from these patterns of vibration or evocations of intensities.
1:17:01 I think there's an interesting parallel there. And that brings me to the last section here,
1:17:09 which is called mind and body. Whitehead says, each animal body harbors a living person or living
1:17:18 persons. Our own self-consciousness is direct awareness of ourselves as such persons.
1:17:25 There are limits to such unified control, which indicate dissociation of personality,
1:17:32 multiple personalities in successive alteration, and even multiple personalities in joint possession.
1:17:40 So here he's just talking about what it is like to be a human being in one of the ways
1:17:44 from the perspective of our personalities, and I've talked about young much, and young
1:17:52 does a good job of talking about this, how we're basically a body inhabited by many spirits.
1:17:57 And some of those spirits are more primordial and they're more visceral and they're attached
1:18:03 to our reptilian sections of our brain that go deep, deep into history and they're about
1:18:08 survival and they're about procreation.
1:18:11 We have this spirit like the Greeks would say, the god Ares, the god of war, and that
1:18:17 lives within us and it can be evoked from us, it can be brought out of us in the right
1:18:21 circumstances.
1:18:22 When you get angry and you lose yourself and you become, well, what do you become?
1:18:27 you become anger and you act out in ways that you regret.
1:18:31 It's because you weren't there anymore.
1:18:32 You were overshadowed by this other spirit
1:18:34 that lives within you.
1:18:36 And the spirit of lust, like the God Aerosis,
1:18:38 something much like that.
1:18:40 You make terrible decisions because of your impulses.
1:18:44 And when you come back to your senses,
1:18:46 you say, why did I do that?
1:18:48 Why?
1:18:49 Because you have other spirits occupying you.
1:18:52 And the unity of those spirits is something
1:18:55 that we call the self.
1:18:57 but it's not so clear, you know?
1:18:59 It's not so clear if they're in what way they're unified,
1:19:05 I guess I'll say.
1:19:07 And he says that our own self-consciousness
1:19:09 is direct awareness of ourselves as such persons.
1:19:13 It reminds me of a quote from the philosopher Hegel
1:19:16 that I love, real simple.
1:19:18 And he says, self-consciousness has before itself
1:19:22 another self-consciousness.
1:19:24 And that's certainly how we see ourselves.
1:19:28 It's something like viewing ourselves as a subject, but also as an object, you know?
1:19:35 We're an object just like any other object in our experience.
1:19:39 But we're also special in the sense that we have this subjective aspect as well.
1:19:44 So we see ourselves as both a subject and object, and that's what self-consciousness
1:19:48 is like.
1:19:51 But how we have unified control over these personalities
1:19:54 that exist within us or over ourselves as subject and object
1:19:59 is very difficult to understand.
1:20:04 And I think that this ties back to this idea
1:20:07 of actual entities existing as a unified experience
1:20:11 or building up into something greater
1:20:13 like what he calls a society, a new experience.
1:20:18 And there's order to that, there's a hierarchy to that.
1:20:26 The question is, who's at the top of the hierarchy?
1:20:29 And does that allow for some unity?
1:20:31 Does something hold it all together somehow?
1:20:37 And Whitehead says,
1:20:38 originality in the world is conditioned,
1:20:41 though not determined by a subjective aim,
1:20:44 supplied by the ground of all order and of all originality.
1:20:51 This is another one of those moments
1:20:52 where I have to stop and say,
1:20:54 why, why, oh, why, Whitehead, do you not explain this more?
1:20:57 How can you say something like the ground of all order without telling me what that is
1:21:01 or means?
1:21:03 What is that?
1:21:04 Is that the creative advance?
1:21:06 Is that God?
1:21:08 Is that mind like we've just introduced into this picture?
1:21:14 He goes on, he says, Cartesian philosophy is based upon the seeming fact of one body
1:21:20 and one mind, which are two substances and causal association.
1:21:28 For the philosophy of organism, the problem is transformed.
1:21:32 Each actuality is physical and mental.
1:21:36 The integration of the physical and mental sides into a unity of experience is a self-formation,
1:21:42 a process of concresence, which characterizes the creativity which transcends it.
1:21:51 Okay, so he's saying, according to Descartes, there's mind and body.
1:21:56 two separate things, but they're in causal association. They're linked, they're
1:22:00 associated, but they're two separate things. And he says, oh no, for the
1:22:05 philosophy of organism, it's not like that at all. There's only one thing. It
1:22:09 has a physical side and a mental side, but they're not two separate things. And
1:22:13 this is very important. He says the integration of the physical and mental
1:22:19 sides into a unity of experience is a self formation, a process of becoming
1:22:24 something like that. And here again, we see this, we see this illustration of creation
1:22:30 affecting creator and vice versa. Okay, says through mentality, excuse me, though mentality
1:22:39 is not non spatial, it is always a reaction from integration with physical experience,
1:22:46 which is spatial. Then he says something weird here, he says, we must not demand another
1:22:52 mentality, presiding over these actualities. So what does he mean by that? I think he means
1:23:04 something like a transcendent mind, a cosmic consciousness, something like that. But then
1:23:10 I ask, I don't know why he's telling us that we shouldn't demand this. It seems like it
1:23:17 should be on the table for consideration and he's telling us it shouldn't be. Then he's
1:23:21 not given me any reason why. And then I have to ask, if there isn't a transcendent mind,
1:23:27 what then is the primordial nature of God? I mean he told us before he said
1:23:35 something about the mental pole if you remember from a prior lecture and he
1:23:38 said basically that the actual world that what's been actualized creates a
1:23:43 mental pole or or contributes a mental pole to the potentiality so that if I'm
1:23:51 looking at the whole kit in kaboodle everything that exists it's the
1:23:53 potential and the actual and he's saying that it's in the actual where we have
1:23:58 something like mind, the mental pole. So the actual gives mind to potentiality. It gives
1:24:07 mind to God. It's the thing that allows God to have a mind, something like that. But if
1:24:14 mind only exists in individual experiences like you and I, and I can't demand a mentality
1:24:20 presiding over everything, I'm not sure how to make sense of that exactly. It's like
1:24:27 God only has a mind through its creatures, its creation that have a mind, something like that.
1:24:34 And parts of that I like, and parts of that I don't like. I'm not sure how to
1:24:38 come to terms with that yet. Then he says, all the life in the body is the life of individual
1:24:46 cells. There are thus millions upon millions of centers of life in each animal body.
1:24:53 So what needs to be explained is not dissociation of personality, but unifying control, by reason
1:25:01 of which we not only have unified behavior, but also consciousness of a unified experience.
1:25:09 So we are these cumulative, shared, united beings made up of a bunch of other living
1:25:15 independently living creatures, just like he says when he talks about his ontological
1:25:20 principle and actual entities, you know, existing within one another. It's very much like that
1:25:25 with a human body, all these individual cells that make up this greater reality that we call our
1:25:30 bodies. He's saying the mystery there is not that we exist in this cumulative way. The mystery is
1:25:38 how we have any kind of unified control of our body and how we have any sort of unified experience.
1:25:45 You know, I think we'd agree that if we knew what it was like to be a cell, that all of
1:25:53 the experiences of a cell, if we accumulate them all up, that does not equal the experience
1:25:59 of a human being.
1:26:00 There's something else going on, and then he adds, a heart can be made to go on beating
1:26:07 after it has been taken out of the body.
1:26:10 There are centers of reaction and control which cannot be identified with the center
1:26:14 of experience. So the question is, what causes the heart to beat on its own when not being
1:26:22 made to beat externally? What is that center of control? And that brings me to my conclusion.
1:26:32 Okay, this has been my favorite reading and process in reality to date. This has been
1:26:38 my favorite one. Whitehead really digs into those alluring concepts that he's been so
1:26:44 fragmentary about thus far, concresence, satisfaction, God, and creativity all take center stage.
1:26:53 Not just these, but a new concept enters the picture, one he alluded to before when he described
1:26:59 the world as furnishing the mental pole of reality. Today, for the first time, mind enters the picture.
1:27:10 In typical whitehead fashion, however, this concept is no more clearly defined
1:27:14 than that of God from the creative advance, and cannot be distinguished from them any
1:27:19 more than concresence and satisfaction, or feeling and experience. In all my frustration,
1:27:27 I continue to give the benefit of the doubt to Whitehead. I know as well as any that ontology
1:27:33 is rife with paradox, intuition, and the strain of communicating ideas that are irritatingly
1:27:41 ineffable. To that end, it is possible, even likely, that I have not yet understood his
1:27:49 ideas well enough. But I continue to strive. Whitehead began today speaking of chaos and
1:27:57 order. Concepts which the regular listener will be familiar with from my many rants
1:28:02 on the subject. I, of course, take the Peter Sony in perspective that chaos and order are
1:28:09 not only fundamental principles of reality, but also representative of the generative
1:28:14 union of opposites, the auroboros of our religious creation myths.
1:28:19 Interestingly, Whitehead speaks of the generative union of opposites with the ontological principle,
1:28:26 which rests at the foundation of his philosophy, the idea of potential for ever being made
1:28:31 actual.
1:28:34 And yet he does not make this connection here.
1:28:38 Instead he links the idea of order to the quality of a concrescent unity.
1:28:43 The more ordered it is, the more is brought into unity in the concresence, the greater
1:28:48 the satisfaction or intensity generated by the experience.
1:28:54 This Whitehead suggests is something like the desire of God, of process, or the creative
1:29:00 advance.
1:29:01 The evocation of feeling is the end and purpose of being.
1:29:08 brings us to mind. Whitehead says there is a lower for feeling. It's not particularly
1:29:15 clear what this means, but it is connected to the desire for feeling attributable to
1:29:20 God or the creative advance, which transcends God. It is this mind which Whitehead tells
1:29:28 us is the source of experience. So we could say, although Whitehead doesn't, that mind
1:29:34 is that which has the capacity for feeling,
1:29:37 and that which makes experience possible.
1:29:41 It's hard for me not to call this God.
1:29:45 Whitehead does not, nor does he explicitly link it
1:29:48 to the creative advance.
1:29:50 He even warns us without justification,
1:29:53 as far as I can tell, that we must demand,
1:29:56 that we mustn't demand another mentality
1:29:59 presiding over actualities.
1:30:02 Why, I wonder, what is he so afraid of here?
1:30:06 We aren't supposed to hypothesize a cosmic mind, a Brahma, a source consciousness from
1:30:12 which all actualities inherit their own mind.
1:30:15 Again, I say why?
1:30:19 To avoid the conclusion that mind is somehow fundamental, but this begs the question and
1:30:26 stands directly in the way of answering the question he leaves us with.
1:30:31 It asks how we can explain unifying control of behavior and a unified conscious experience
1:30:38 from entities that are merely composites of other independent living entities and personalities.
1:30:46 How can we ever hope to answer the question, what is the center of experience?
1:31:06 thinking it's hard and full of uncertainties but I'm grateful for the
1:31:12 company as we trek through this together here's to hoping that the juice is
1:31:16 worth the squeeze see what I did there let's find out together in the next
1:31:22 episode