← All The Observer Effect episodes
The Observer Effect
S3E6 · Feb 22, 2023 · 71 min
This episode rounds out the "Nothing Matters" series, which began with Alan Watts. We delve into the mysterious world of quantum physics, the word of dark matter, dark energy and black holes. On this journey we are confronted with the "Nothingness" of the space-time vacuum with surprising results. As it turns out, "Nothingness" does not exist…or more correctly "Nothing" is "Something." Zero point energy, vacuum energy, something from nothing and the Big Bang. All this and more on this episode of the Two Tongues Podcast.
Enjoy 😉
Machine-generated transcript; names and terms may contain errors.
0:00:03 Welcome, everyone, to the Two Tungs Podcast.
0:00:09 Consider this your invitation to join Kyle and Chris
0:00:13 on a journey through our minds,
0:00:16 where we explore the questions that have fascinated us
0:00:22 for as long as we can remember.
0:00:24 Could anarchy actually work?
0:00:26 Does God exist?
0:00:28 And just how did the cosmos get here anyway?
0:00:32 Let me be the Virgil to your Dante, the Sacagawea to your Lewis and Clark.
0:00:39 Let's take the guided tour through the dark chambers of our unconscious,
0:00:45 seeking answers to the most important and unsettled questions of our shared existence.
0:00:52 Ready or not, here we go.
0:00:59 Here we go. Welcome back to everyone.
0:01:03 to another episode of the two tongues podcast. This is after all an experiment in conversation.
0:01:11 Today, it'll be a conversation with myself. We might call that a monologue. We're going to do
0:01:17 part two, which was an unexpected part two of an episode I did a few weeks back called
0:01:23 Nothing Matters with Alan Watts. So you guys remember that introduced to Alan Watts after Kyle
0:01:29 suggested that I listened to him many times over the past few years. Finally
0:01:34 did blew my mind. There's a lot of a lot of people that have done that to me
0:01:38 lately. Ian McGillchrist being one of them. Peter Schurst that used being
0:01:42 another. David Chalmers, I mean just the list goes on and on. And Alan Watts was
0:01:48 no exception. And it just to refresh your memory, what Alan wants, we've
0:01:54 basically listened to two different Watts lectures. And then we picked
0:01:59 from both lectures a whole bunch of stuff that he was talking about relating to
0:02:05 nothingness. What is nothingness? And Alan Watts argued that nothing is sort of a
0:02:14 misnomer. That word is something that we use and we think it means something like
0:02:18 non-existence. But the model is wrong. And in reality nothing happens to be
0:02:25 something, and it's something critical, something that we can't live without,
0:02:30 and there's all these examples about, for instance, right now as I'm speaking, the
0:02:36 words are something, and the silence in between the words you might call nothing.
0:02:41 At least it's not speech, but you see, you don't have speech without the no
0:02:46 speech in between that punctuates the words, otherwise everything I say blends
0:02:50 together. You can't make heads or tails of what I'm saying to you.
0:02:54 The same thing is true with music.
0:02:57 See, it's the silence in between the notes.
0:02:59 It's the timing and the spaces that make it music.
0:03:02 Without that, it's just deafening, buzzing,
0:03:04 you know, a conglomeration of noise.
0:03:07 You wouldn't call it music at all.
0:03:08 And so you see that there's something critically important
0:03:12 about the nothing that makes the something what it is.
0:03:16 And nothing and something are opposites.
0:03:19 And going back to Magilchris, which I mentioned a second ago,
0:03:22 Ian Magilchris made this beautiful
0:03:24 analogy about how opposites, he says that there is a coincidence of opposites, always
0:03:31 and only they occur together.
0:03:34 And because that's true, you don't have nothing without something.
0:03:37 You don't have light without dark, you don't have hot without cold.
0:03:41 Because you don't have one without the other, they are effectively one thing.
0:03:48 And this resonates with me so deeply.
0:03:50 resonates with this mystical intuition that I've developed.
0:03:54 And it goes back to the idea of the ouroboros,
0:03:56 which we talk about when we talk about mythology all
0:03:58 of the time, that the symbol that rests
0:04:01 at the heart of our mythological stories
0:04:03 about the creation of the cosmos, cross-culturally,
0:04:07 has to do with a symbol of the unity of opposites.
0:04:11 In and the yang brought together in a unity.
0:04:14 In the Sumerian myth that we talk about from time to time,
0:04:18 It's Tiamat and Epsu, the male and the female,
0:04:21 the goddess of salt water, the god of fresh water.
0:04:24 They're one thing, they're both god, they're both water,
0:04:27 but they're opposites, the salt and the fresh,
0:04:30 the feminine and the masculine,
0:04:31 and they have to come together
0:04:32 in this symbol, this orboros,
0:04:35 that shows us this generative,
0:04:38 generative union of opposites,
0:04:39 the thing from which creation emerges,
0:04:42 the thing from which something emerges.
0:04:45 Jordan Peterson calls that the chaos,
0:04:48 And the something that emerges is the order.
0:04:51 And the order is what we call, well, everything
0:04:53 that we call a thing has to, they're
0:04:57 tied to something like order, whether we're
0:04:59 talking about music, whether we're talking about language,
0:05:03 whether we're talking about culture.
0:05:06 And so this idea of coincidence of opposites and the opposites
0:05:11 being one thing has been really interesting.
0:05:13 And when I shortly after I finished those Alan Watts
0:05:18 lectures, and I told Kyle this, I had a bunch of Audible
0:05:21 credits.
0:05:22 So I went on Audible and I picked a book.
0:05:24 You can imagine why I picked a book.
0:05:26 It's called The God Equation.
0:05:28 I'll think it OK.
0:05:29 Yeah, I'm interested in God.
0:05:30 I'm interested in physics.
0:05:31 Let's see what's going on here.
0:05:32 This is a book published in 2021 by a gentleman most people
0:05:36 will probably recognize.
0:05:38 His name is Michio Kaku.
0:05:41 He's a physicist.
0:05:42 He's one of these popular culture physicists like Brian Green or Sean Carroll.
0:05:46 He talks about physics in documentaries and interviews and he makes it, makes sense to
0:05:53 the common man.
0:05:55 And I appreciate that.
0:05:56 You know, like a Neil DeGrasse type person.
0:05:59 But this book, The God Equation, it's also subtitled The Quest for the Theory of Everything.
0:06:11 It has bits that focus on nothingness.
0:06:14 the whole thing. But it has bits in the beginning and then a lot towards the end, especially
0:06:17 when he gets talking about Stephen Hawking and black holes. The vacuum becomes very important
0:06:22 and from the perspective of physics, from the perspective of cosmology space, the vacuum
0:06:31 of space is nothing. And I want to remind you before we jump into this that Alan Watts
0:06:37 had some interesting things to say about that also, about space, about the emptiness
0:06:42 of space. Alan Watts said that he made two analogies. He said, when you're writing something
0:06:48 down on a piece of paper, let's say it's white paper, black ink, you're writing something
0:06:52 down on the paper and you think to yourself, the writing is the thing. That's what Alan
0:06:57 Watts says. The letters, the words, that's the thing. That's where the information is.
0:07:02 That's what's important, right? We would agree. If I'm writing black words on a white
0:07:06 piece of paper, the words are the thing. And the thing is what we're interested in. But
0:07:12 then he points out that the paper, in this case the empty space, the behind the letters,
0:07:18 the thing that allows the letters to stand out, the contrast them, that the thing that
0:07:22 allows those letters to be there, the page, the empty page, that's the nothing that is
0:07:29 required for this something, in this case the letters and words, to be present. And
0:07:34 He makes the same analogy without our space.
0:07:37 He says, you look up at the night sky, you look up at the stars, and you think, ah, those
0:07:41 are the things, the planets and stars.
0:07:43 Those are the things that are out there amidst the nothingness.
0:07:45 I think we all pretty much agree with that.
0:07:48 But then he makes the same analogy.
0:07:50 But you see, the vacuum of space, the nothingness in between all of the stars and planets is
0:07:57 necessary.
0:07:59 Or else those things we think are important, the stars and planets out there don't exist.
0:08:03 There's no place for them to exist. So you need the empty page for the letters
0:08:08 You need the emptiness of space for the stars and planets to exist and we can't have one without the other
0:08:15 We need the nothing to have the something we need this something to have the nothing and so it's important to understand it
0:08:22 that something and nothing are
0:08:28 functionally one thing
0:08:30 Now, Michiukaku is going to use those exact same arguments, but he's going to do it empirically,
0:08:36 which I think is so great.
0:08:37 I think that Michiukaku's saying the things he said in this book, The God Equation, compliments
0:08:42 what Alan Watts said in those lectures that I covered in my Nothing Matters with Alan
0:08:48 Watts episode.
0:08:49 So, what we have here is for all those haters out there, for all those people who think Alan
0:08:55 Watson's eloquent speaker, but not somebody who you can put any sort of scientific confidence
0:09:03 and he's not somebody that you're going to look to for scientific or empirical fact or
0:09:10 truth.
0:09:11 No, you're going to look to look to him for poetry, you're going to look to him for,
0:09:14 you know, warm and fuzzy feelings, whatever.
0:09:17 And I think that's shortsighted.
0:09:19 I think that's a shame.
0:09:20 But there are people out there like that.
0:09:22 They just want the facts, sir, and nothing more very empirically minded people.
0:09:27 So meet you cock who being my can scarcely think of a better person to bring that perspective
0:09:32 to the table, he's going to do this.
0:09:36 So without further ado, I'm going to jump into it.
0:09:38 So how I want to maybe open this up is to say that this is going to be called nothing
0:09:43 matters with meet you cock.
0:09:44 So it was not intended to be a two parts series, but that's what it became serendipitously.
0:09:50 And I, you know, that's fine by me.
0:09:53 So this, you can call this one the follow up to nothing matters with Alan Watts, which
0:09:57 focused on philosophical, metaphysical, logical explanations of what nothingness means contrary
0:10:05 to our most basic intuition.
0:10:07 So all those things I just, I just mentioned that nothing is actually very important and
0:10:12 nothing serves very important purposes.
0:10:14 And without nothing, something cannot exist.
0:10:17 So nothing, we can use that word all day long if we want to, but the thing is nothing is
0:10:22 a thing, a very important thing.
0:10:25 Maybe the most important thing.
0:10:29 Now, Kaku's book takes a different approach.
0:10:33 It's a discussion of the discoveries that lead up to the notion of a theory of everything.
0:10:39 So if you guys don't know what that means, the idea from quantum physics is that you've
0:10:44 You've got general relativity that describes Einstein's theory of gravity, and then you've
0:10:51 got quantum mechanics which developed kind of alongside it.
0:10:55 So you've got rules that govern the largest scale, mathematics that govern the largest
0:11:01 scale of what we can measure in physics.
0:11:04 And then you've got mathematics that governs the very smallest scale.
0:11:08 And there's really not a way of reconciling them together.
0:11:11 So physicists have been trying to do that for a very long time.
0:11:15 String theory, we'll talk a little bit about that today.
0:11:17 That may be the most popular, it may be the most promising path towards a unified theory,
0:11:25 but really we're not anywhere close to that.
0:11:28 But this book is going to talk about leading up to developing this theory of everything,
0:11:34 going all the way to Stephen Hawking, and then all of the milestones that would progress
0:11:39 that we made over the years, so I'm not going to focus too much on that, but just know that
0:11:44 that's kind of the main theme of the book if you see it popping up here and there in the
0:11:49 quotes.
0:11:50 But in order for them to get to this exploration of the theory of everything, Michio Caku has
0:11:57 to delve into this idea of nothingness from the perspective of physics, and this is why
0:12:02 it's such a great compliment.
0:12:05 I think it serves as a terrific empirical complement
0:12:08 to the remarks of Watts on the same subject, nothingness.
0:12:13 It shows us how Watts' philosophical perspective
0:12:16 are reflected in the natural world
0:12:18 with the full backing of our most sophisticated scientific
0:12:21 models of reality.
0:12:23 So we can call this the math and the hard science that
0:12:28 backs up all of the flowery poetry
0:12:31 that we got from Alan Watts.
0:12:33 That brings me to the first section,
0:12:35 which I'm going to call infinity and the vacuum,
0:12:38 all and nothing.
0:12:41 So the first quote opens like this.
0:12:44 When scientists calculated the radiation emitted
0:12:47 from hot vibrating atoms,
0:12:49 the result defied expectations.
0:12:53 At high frequency, the energy of light
0:12:56 should eventually become infinite, which was ridiculous.
0:13:00 To a physicist, infinity is just a sign
0:13:03 that the equations aren't working,
0:13:05 that they don't understand what is happening.
0:13:09 Okay, so this is interesting.
0:13:10 So just to open this up,
0:13:11 what I want to try to explain here is that
0:13:15 when there were various times
0:13:17 through this progress towards the theory of everything
0:13:20 where the math, which I don't understand well,
0:13:24 so I'm gonna tip to around this as best I can,
0:13:27 the math supporting these ideas
0:13:30 included what scientists consider to be flaws where they were coming up with
0:13:36 infinity as a solution. And so, in physics, this is apparently a sign of a
0:13:43 problem. You know, all of the mathematics should work out, you know, should work
0:13:47 out to some finite resolution or multiple finite resolutions. Not
0:13:52 infinity, not infinite solutions. That's a strange thing. So, there's
0:13:58 something like this that they're dealing with and they found this result when
0:14:01 they were studying the vibration of atoms. They're studying kind of the most
0:14:07 fundamental, you know, physical properties. The math was turning up all kinds of
0:14:12 strange things. It was making it impossible for the physicists to go to
0:14:16 go further. And what the book explains is how they worked around this was they
0:14:21 they were able to offset the infinities with other infinities. So I don't
0:14:27 exactly understand that, but they were able to kind of make the formulas progress or move
0:14:31 forward by offsetting these infinities that they thought were problems. So I want to focus
0:14:38 a bit on infinity for a second because I think the word infinity gives us the opposite pole
0:14:50 to this idea of nothingness that we're going to talk about. Infinity depends on how you apply
0:14:57 the word, I guess, but infinity sort of represents the all, everything. It's infinite. It includes
0:15:03 everything. So infinity is like the everything. And you can see how the everything is opposite
0:15:09 of the nothing. That makes sense. So this is the framework that I want to try to move
0:15:16 forward with. This idea of infinity represents the all, the everything, in contrast to this
0:15:22 idea that we're trying to understand that, you know, nothingness. And we, when we understand
0:15:26 from what I said at the opening, that everything and nothing are opposites. And there's a coincidence
0:15:32 of opposites, they only exist together. So that's very important. They're basically one
0:15:38 thing. They're functionally one thing. How is it that everything and nothing are one thing?
0:15:45 So let's talk about this. So there's a coincidence of opposites, which implies a unity because
0:15:50 you can't have one without the other.
0:15:55 We can see the truth of this when we consider examples like, let's say, all the colors
0:16:00 that are possible.
0:16:01 If you take them all at once, if you take all the colors together all at once, what you
0:16:08 get is no color at all.
0:16:10 So how is it that all the colors taken together become no color?
0:16:15 Where did the color go?
0:16:16 You know, if I'm mixing colors of paint together, I'm going to mix and mix and mix until I end
0:16:20 up with black.
0:16:21 If I mix wavelengths of light together, all the different colors of light will blend together
0:16:28 to become white.
0:16:30 So in the case of paint black, in the case of white light, in either case, I'm left with
0:16:34 none of the colors I started with.
0:16:36 All of the colors are blended together in this white light or black pigment, whatever
0:16:40 it might be.
0:16:42 So you have no color and all colors having some sort of equivalency.
0:16:50 How about this?
0:16:51 to imagine all possible experiences and maybe start with all the experiences
0:16:57 you've ever had and then you expand that to all experiences anybody has ever had
0:17:01 living or dead and maybe you expand that to all the experiences that you know
0:17:05 plants and other animals are having or even that the atoms have if you think
0:17:09 they have experience which I think they probably do all of these layers of
0:17:13 experience for all of the history of time imagine all that if you can you
0:17:19 You can't, but, you know, try.
0:17:22 Imagine all those experiences now happening at once.
0:17:27 They would blend together to become no particular experience, and so there would be no experience
0:17:33 at all.
0:17:34 There would be unexperience, a bowl.
0:17:36 So all of the experiences taken together are no experience at all.
0:17:43 One more example.
0:17:45 Take a circle, imagine it.
0:17:48 definition. What is it? It's a couple definitions. It's a shape from which all the points are
0:17:57 equal distance from the center. It's a mathematical definition of a circle. But another one is
0:18:01 this. A circle is a shape that has an infinite number of sides. Hmm. Imagine that. Let's start
0:18:08 with a triangle and hold that triangle in your mind's eye and then shift that triangle, turn
0:18:15 into a square in your mind's eye. Now add more sides and turn it into a hexagon or a pentagon
0:18:23 or an octagon. Keep adding sides. Keep adding them. Continue, continue, continue as that shape
0:18:30 becomes ever closer to a circle. When it has infinite sides, it has no sides. Isn't that
0:18:38 interesting? A circle is a shape with an infinite number of sides and an infinite number of sides
0:18:45 means no sides at all. Everything and nothing are synonyms. They're functionally equivalent.
0:18:55 What do you think of that? It's a little mind-blowing, but this is going to be important as we move along.
0:19:03 Okay, quote number two, he says, Kaku says, experiments on electrons showed they vanished
0:19:10 and reappeared somewhere else, which is impossible in a Newtonian world.
0:19:14 So, this bit of the book is talking about quantum, the beginning of quantum physics
0:19:19 and the things that they were starting to encounter in their experiments that they couldn't explain
0:19:24 that were contrary to the laws of physics that they believed were true up to that point,
0:19:28 the Newtonian, Newtonian physics. And one of the things they noticed is that electrons appear
0:19:36 and vanish from nowhere. You have an electron appears in a system and disappears.
0:19:42 and like what in the world is going on? Physics is all about forces and motion and cause and
0:19:49 effect and angles and all this stuff, friction and all that. So what's going on here? There's
0:19:56 only one world. You can't have something from nothing. So what's going on here? And this is what
0:20:02 baffled people in the early days of quantum physics, what baffles people today. So in this
0:20:10 example where electrons pop into existence from and where they disappear
0:20:15 into. It's like one thing to say they they appear and reappear or vanish and
0:20:21 reappear. It's one thing to say that but it's another thing to ask where do they
0:20:25 go? Did they disappear into some place? Did they change their state of existence?
0:20:31 Did they move into another realm? It clearly they didn't just disappear
0:20:35 because they've reappeared, so did they just not have existence and suddenly
0:20:40 have existence or did they go somewhere else? And so the question is, when
0:20:47 an electron disappears into nothingness, is nothingness a place or if it
0:20:56 disappears into nothingness, is nothingness another state of being, another state of
0:21:01 existence. That's not what we commonly understand is this material, physical plane. Things don't
0:21:10 just disappear and reappear. They might move to some place or shift in some manner that
0:21:19 makes them undetectable. But does that mean that they were poof gone and poof here? Or
0:21:25 does it mean that what we're calling nothing is actually something, maybe a place, maybe
0:21:32 a different state of existence. And that brings us to our first piece about
0:21:40 Hawking. So, Kaku says, Hawking began to think the idea that nothing can escape a
0:21:46 black hole violated the quantum theory. So, now again, we're changing subjects, but
0:21:52 it's important here because Hawking was very concerned with black holes, very
0:21:56 interested in black holes, what they were, how they formed, you know, what they did.
0:22:02 They were mysterious objects. They're the only thing we've ever seen, which has gravity
0:22:08 so strong that light can't seem to escape. It sucks everything in, even light. And yet
0:22:15 a black hole is something synonymous to a vacuum, something synonymous to the vacuum of space.
0:22:23 It's not really a difference between the vacuum of space, the nothingness in between
0:22:27 the stars in a black hole, apart from the fact that the black hole has tremendous gravity,
0:22:33 all sort of isolated in one spot.
0:22:35 So we're talking about nothingness, and Hawking was very interested in that, the vacuum of
0:22:42 space, the black hole, nothingness.
0:22:45 And the more he thought about this, the more he thought, even though black holes seemed
0:22:50 to suck everything in, even light, there's something there that seems wrong, because
0:22:57 At the quantum level, there's this thing called quantum uncertainty.
0:23:00 It's like a rule that governs reality at the deepest level.
0:23:04 And quantum uncertainty doesn't seem to allow for a black hole to be perfectly black.
0:23:11 So it goes on, he says, in quantum mechanics, everything is uncertain.
0:23:16 A black hole looks perfectly black because it absorbs absolutely everything.
0:23:21 But perfect blackness violated the uncertainty principle.
0:23:26 Even blackness had to be uncertain.
0:23:30 Hawking came to the revolutionary conclusion
0:23:33 that black holes must necessarily
0:23:35 emit a very faint glow of quantum radiation.
0:23:40 He calculated this by realizing that the vacuum
0:23:43 was not just the state of nothingness,
0:23:46 but was actually bubbling with quantum activity.
0:23:51 In the quantum theory, even nothingness
0:23:53 is in a state of constant churning uncertainty,
0:23:57 where electrons and anti-electrons
0:23:59 could suddenly jump out of the vacuum,
0:24:01 then collide and disappear back into the vacuum.
0:24:07 So I want to hone in on a couple things here.
0:24:11 Hawking, according to Hawking,
0:24:14 the vacuum, Cacu says, was not just the state of nothingness,
0:24:18 but was actually bubbling with quantum activity.
0:24:22 So the thing that we call nothing
0:24:26 is bubbling with quantum activity.
0:24:28 How is that possible?
0:24:30 If nothing were nothing, as we generally
0:24:34 intuit the meaning, there wouldn't be activity.
0:24:37 There would be nothing, and yet there is.
0:24:40 So the vacuum of space, the nothingness out there,
0:24:44 isn't nothing at all.
0:24:46 It is something, something that is capable
0:24:50 of sustaining activity.
0:24:52 Activity in what?
0:24:54 In the nothing.
0:24:55 What does that mean?
0:24:56 Fuck if I know.
0:24:57 But there's activity happening in the nothing,
0:24:59 and that means the nothing is something,
0:25:02 something capable of action,
0:25:04 something capable of activity.
0:25:07 Then, he says, in quantum theory, in a state of nothingness, electrons and anti-electrons
0:25:14 pop out of the vacuum.
0:25:15 What does that mean?
0:25:16 They jump out of nothingness.
0:25:19 They collide and disappear back into nothingness.
0:25:24 So nothingness is full of quantum activity.
0:25:28 And it seems to be a place or a transitionary plane from which electrons, quantum particles,
0:25:35 emerge from nothing. Now this is something that we believe since the days of Aristotle,
0:25:42 if not before, that nothing can't, well, excuse me, something cannot come from nothing.
0:25:50 And what Hawking and Kaku were telling us is that that is not true. Classical philosophy tells us
0:25:58 you have to start with something, and that might change into something else, but you don't start
0:26:03 start with nothing and get something. It doesn't work that way. Like begets like, it's another
0:26:07 law from ancient philosophy. So how can nothing create something? According to quantum physics,
0:26:18 that's exactly what happens. So again, I want to point out that something from nothing is
0:26:27 a representation of opposites, something and nothing, opposites. And they only exist in
0:26:33 opposition to each other. They have this mutual dependence for their existence.
0:26:38 Now when these electrons and anti-electrons that pop out of the nothingness, when they unite,
0:26:43 they annihilate, they disappear back into the nothingness. And what that implies,
0:26:50 you've got these two particles with different charges that pop up together,
0:26:57 also opposites. Remember, electron and anti-electron, they're also opposites. They pop up together
0:27:02 out of the nothingness. They exist momentarily. And then when they recombined, they disappear
0:27:08 again. And that has implications, strange implications. That if you take nothing and
0:27:17 you split it in two, you get something. And you started with nothingness with the vacuum.
0:27:25 If you split that nothing in two and you have, you split it into opposites, you have an anti-electron
0:27:30 and an electron. It seems like by merit of the fact that they've been separated, they now exist.
0:27:39 And the moment they come back together, they don't exist anymore. Something about separation
0:27:45 that makes them real and then reunification makes them disappear. And it's strange because it reminds
0:27:53 me of, again, our earliest religious stories about the creation of the cosmos. If we just go to the
0:28:00 the Bible, for instance, we can see that everything in the Bible, in the creation story, is separated
0:28:05 from a wholeness. So you begin with something like the Ouroboros, something like God, and
0:28:12 you separate the heavens from the earth, you separate the waters, you separate the woman
0:28:20 from man, even with Eve being made from Adam. So all of the symbolism is of separation.
0:28:26 separate things into being, and then I get this idea, I get this image of God as being
0:28:33 the everything, the everything all at once, something that I call potentiality,
0:28:38 the thing from which all things can emerge, it's the potential, the source of potential,
0:28:47 and if it's infinite, if it's everything all at once, remember I talked about that example of
0:28:52 all experiences all at once, imagine something like that. You don't really have anything,
0:28:58 But the moment you start separating out pieces of that potential, you know, the moment you
0:29:04 start separating out individual experiences, then you have something, but it requires separation.
0:29:11 And this is exactly what we hear in our earliest myths, and it's exactly what we hear from
0:29:16 Stephen fucking Hawking when he describes electrons and anti-electrons, somehow making
0:29:22 their way from the nothingness, whatever that means, in crossing that plane from nothing
0:29:27 to something, this existing in the space and time, in our material world, in this divided
0:29:34 way, in this separated way. And when they come back together, they disappear. They go
0:29:40 back into the nothingness. And the last line from this quote is, so nothingness was actually
0:29:51 frothing with quantum activity. Nothingness is frothing with quantum activity. That tells
0:29:58 you that what we call nothingness is not nothing.
0:30:02 All right.
0:30:06 So we talk about uncertainty a little bit.
0:30:08 I want to point out that uncertainty has to do with this idea of a probability wave collapsing
0:30:15 into a particle.
0:30:17 So this is getting a little bit into the weeds.
0:30:19 But just so you know, when he's talking about uncertainty being something that's kind of
0:30:23 built into reality and, you know, it's unavoidable, this has to do with the idea that particles
0:30:29 at the quantum level exist as a wave. And quantum physicists and physicists of all kinds
0:30:35 will tell you that the most basic fundamental level of reality is something like quantum
0:30:42 waves. So reality at the deepest level is something like waves. And waves are strange.
0:30:50 It's hard to put any sort of point on a wave. Imagine you drop a pebble into a pond and
0:30:57 and you can see the waves rippling out.
0:30:59 It's hard to put any point on that wave
0:31:02 and think that you've isolated it,
0:31:07 that you've pointed it out,
0:31:08 that you've put a marker on it
0:31:10 that tells you anything about the wave
0:31:12 because it's just one little spot
0:31:13 on a wave that's continuously moving
0:31:15 and you've got new waves forming from the inside
0:31:18 all the time.
0:31:19 It's like, what are you pointing to exactly?
0:31:22 Are you pointing to the wave?
0:31:23 I mean, kind of yes, kind of no.
0:31:28 And then there's this idea that certainty in the world is the result of the wave itself
0:31:34 collapsing into some sort of certain reality.
0:31:37 So a wave becomes a particle, and that particle has reality in the way that we're sort of
0:31:43 accustomed to it.
0:31:44 It has a certain position, a certain momentum, it works the way that Newtonian physics would
0:31:50 have us believe.
0:31:51 So you've got some level of certainty, but the thing is you can't pull a particle from a wave,
0:31:58 or a wave from a particle. They're really one thing. Also, from the perspective of physics,
0:32:05 they're opposites. Waves and particles are opposites. And just like any set of opposites,
0:32:11 they're coincident. You can't have one without the other. So this is where
0:32:15 unquantum uncertainty comes in. It's like, how can I say a particle is here and moving
0:32:20 and this speed and this direction, when in reality it's a wave moving in all directions.
0:32:26 You see what I mean? All right, so this brings me to the last quote in this section which goes
0:32:37 like this. And I believe he's still continuing to talk about Hawking here. He says, he realized
0:32:44 that if the gravitational field was intense enough, electron and anti-electron pairs could be created
0:32:51 out of the vacuum. Okay, so again, now we're talking specifically about black holes and not
0:32:56 not just the vacuum of space, a particular type
0:32:58 where we have all this gravity.
0:33:00 But what I want to point out to you about this is
0:33:02 when Hawking says if the gravitational field
0:33:05 was intense enough, then you could have something
0:33:07 being created from nothing.
0:33:08 Then you could have electrons and anti-electrons
0:33:11 just jumping out of the nothingness.
0:33:13 So the energy required for this to happen
0:33:16 seems to be coming from gravity.
0:33:19 Now the black hole is something that's often
0:33:22 is called a singularity.
0:33:23 And it has a connection to the beginning of our cosmos because we call the Big Bang a singularity.
0:33:31 So there's this commonality between what's happening in a black hole and what kicked off
0:33:37 our creation of our universe.
0:33:40 And what I like to think of when I think about the Big Bang is the example that I've been
0:33:46 using throughout this so far is that you can imagine rolling back the clock of time and
0:33:51 everything kind of rewinding. And what happens is the expansion of the universe will slowly
0:33:57 come back together to that moment of the Big Bang. And what you end up with is all the matter
0:34:01 and energy of the cosmos condensed down into a singularity, condensed down into a unity.
0:34:09 And you can imagine if everything that exists, all space and time, energy and matter,
0:34:14 If all that stuff's been condensed down to a very, very minute spec, imagine the gravity,
0:34:22 imagine the mass, the energy, the gravity that's created from that singularity.
0:34:28 I mean, it's maybe it's infinite. I don't know. And from that singularity,
0:34:35 can emerge something out of nothing. Now, Hawking's saying that happens in a black hole,
0:34:42 And you can see that which we're going to get to, but Hawking radiation, radiation that we can now
0:34:48 detect, just bleeding off of black holes. They really are giving off energy, or giving off
0:34:56 something, even though we previously never thought that was possible. And that analogy holds true
0:35:02 for the Big Bang, for that singularity as well. So we got something from nothing. And what we mean
0:35:10 by nothing in this example, what we mean by this singularity, if we want to call it nothing,
0:35:15 is everything all at once, right? Everything that's unfolded in the cosmos rolled back
0:35:21 up into one thing. That nothing, that thing that we're calling nothing, is everything
0:35:26 all at once, the potential for everything that ever, ever will be or ever was. And so
0:35:33 you have this strange paradox where something and nothing are functionally equivalent. Okay,
0:35:41 brings me to dark energy and dark matter. And that's what I'm going to call this section,
0:35:47 dark energy and dark matter. I want to talk about this not because I think it necessarily
0:35:53 directly corresponds to this idea of the vacuum or the black hole, but it is a mystery. It was
0:35:59 covered in the book. And in my opinion, dark energy and dark matter. And you'll see as we go
0:36:06 through this, there's a reasonable reason or reasonable way of talking about these things as
0:36:13 Nothing, in the way that we've been talking about so far,
0:36:19 because nothing definitely doesn't seem to mean nothing.
0:36:23 It means something.
0:36:24 We don't quite know what that means,
0:36:26 but we know it means something.
0:36:30 One of the things it means is something that exists
0:36:35 in a way that's completely different
0:36:37 from our ordinary understanding of the physical cosmos.
0:36:42 It's not that it doesn't have existence, it does,
0:36:45 But that existence doesn't seem to be material,
0:36:47 doesn't seem to be subject to space and time
0:36:50 in the same way that everything else is.
0:36:52 It doesn't seem to be subject to the same laws of physics
0:36:55 as everything else.
0:36:58 And with the example of dark energy and dark matter,
0:37:01 you have something that's not visible,
0:37:05 so it's essentially undetectable,
0:37:07 that's not entirely true, but invisible, undetectable,
0:37:13 that doesn't interact with matter
0:37:15 in the physical world, and any way that we really understand.
0:37:19 I mean, we talk about, and we will talk about,
0:37:21 how dark energy and dark matter are responsible
0:37:23 for kind of the stasis of the cosmos,
0:37:25 the way that it's expanding and the way that it exists.
0:37:29 But those are like facts that we piecemeal out
0:37:34 from what we observe in nature.
0:37:37 We really have no great understanding
0:37:39 of what dark energy and dark matter is.
0:37:42 And because we can't give it reality,
0:37:45 We can't prove its reality in the same way we can
0:37:49 with the rest of the physical world.
0:37:52 There's a way in which we can look at dark energy
0:37:54 and dark matter in the same way we look at the vacuum.
0:37:58 It's nothing and yet it's something.
0:38:03 So let's talk about dark energy and dark matter
0:38:04 for a second.
0:38:06 Kaku reminds us, he says,
0:38:09 what might be driving the expansion of the universe
0:38:12 is the energy of the vacuum, now called dark energy.
0:38:18 Okay, so we know from the previous paragraphs
0:38:22 that the vacuum is bubbling and frothing
0:38:25 with quantum activity.
0:38:27 So then nothingness out there has got all this activity.
0:38:31 Now, what Kaku's telling us is that the force
0:38:36 that that creates is somehow responsible
0:38:38 for the expansion of the universe
0:38:40 and for those people who don't know,
0:38:42 science is determined using a red shift in tricks with light that the galaxies and stars
0:38:48 all around us are moving away from us all the time and they're moving faster and faster
0:38:52 the further they get they go. And so the universe is expanding like somebody blowing up a balloon
0:38:57 and we don't exactly know why. We don't exactly know if it will ever stop. You know, we don't
0:39:03 know. But the force causing that we call dark energy and this is the force of energy in
0:39:11 the vacuum in the nothingness.
0:39:16 Kaku says, the amount of dark energy in the universe
0:39:19 is enormous.
0:39:21 More than 68.3% of all energy in the universe
0:39:25 is in this mysterious form.
0:39:29 He says collectively, dark energy and dark matter
0:39:32 comprise most of the matter and energy.
0:39:35 This cannot be explained by any known theory.
0:39:39 There you go.
0:39:40 This cannot be explained by any known theory.
0:39:42 So, most of the energy and matter that make up the world is in this mysterious form that
0:39:49 we can't exactly prove.
0:39:50 We don't seem to know much about or anything at all about, to be frank.
0:39:56 And there's one thing I want to point out here that I think is interesting as well.
0:40:00 When he says more than 68.3% of the matter of the energy in the universe is dark energy.
0:40:06 I want you to understand that there's an asymmetry there.
0:40:09 68.3 is more than half, right?
0:40:13 So there's an asymmetry between energy and dark energy.
0:40:19 And this is something that's important because when you consider the opposites, you might
0:40:24 consider energy and dark energy to be opposites, let's say.
0:40:29 It's true that they're coincident, it's true that they only exist together like any set
0:40:32 of opposites.
0:40:33 But what people often don't consider is that those forces may not be symmetrical.
0:40:41 You might have one opposite greater than the other in some way.
0:40:48 And the way this pans out with physics in the creation of the universe is that when the
0:40:52 Big Bang happened, there was an asymmetry, a fundamental asymmetry, where some areas of
0:40:59 the cosmos expanded more quickly than others, some areas cooled off more quickly than others.
0:41:05 And so what you end up with is this sort of random pattern in the cosmos.
0:41:11 And you can see that in the microwave background radiation maps that they have.
0:41:18 You can see how it wasn't perfectly symmetrical as the energy expanded and everything.
0:41:23 It happened in this way that was irregular.
0:41:28 And the interesting thing about that is it's exactly the asymmetry.
0:41:32 It's exactly this irregularity that allowed for the cosmos and for life to develop.
0:41:38 Because if it hadn't been that way, if things would have been expanding in exactly the same
0:41:43 way in every direction, you wouldn't have time to allow these areas of space to cool
0:41:50 for the forces to balance out, for a stasis to be created that allows for planets and
0:41:55 stars and life.
0:41:57 You wouldn't have it at all without this asymmetry.
0:42:02 And there's something like that that Hawking will talk about, and we'll see this in a bit.
0:42:07 excuse me, when he talks about these electron and anti-electron pairs, he said, in some cases,
0:42:14 they will join together and disappear again, in most cases. But in some instances,
0:42:20 one of those pairs, the anti-electron or the electron, will escape. And so you have an asymmetry
0:42:29 then, right? Something hasn't gone back into the nothingness, but it's escaped, and now it's
0:42:35 sort of added to reality. And this is how reality forms. This is how you have something
0:42:40 instead of nothing, because you have this asymmetry. If we can speak philosophically about
0:42:47 it, we might say that God is a word I would like to use here. The thing I call potentiality.
0:42:54 Its opposite is actuality. Its opposite is the here and now, the physical material world.
0:42:59 And you can imagine if potentiality is God, and actuality is material being.
0:43:06 Clearly there's an asymmetry there.
0:43:08 There's always more potential than there is actual.
0:43:11 There's always, you know, if we consider God to be infinite, clearly there's an asymmetry
0:43:15 between an infinite God and the finite cosmos.
0:43:21 And Hawking and Kaku are pointing this out.
0:43:23 This asymmetry exists among opposites, and it's actually it's fundamentally important.
0:43:32 just to recap, we don't know what dark energy and matter is. They're undetectable. They
0:43:38 don't interact with matter in a way we understand. They have no charge. In the case of dark energy
0:43:44 no mass. They are for all intents and purposes nothing. They are the nothing in opposition
0:43:52 to the cosmos, which creates the stasis of being. So dark matter is said to hold everything
0:44:00 together, to hold the stars and planets and cosmos together, while dark energy pushes
0:44:05 it apart.
0:44:06 And this balancing act that we're talking about, this stasis, this force between opposites
0:44:12 is what gives us the time that we need to exist, is what gives us our moment, you know,
0:44:18 the moment where we make the cosmos conscious and living.
0:44:23 All right, he goes on, he says, most of the universe is hidden from us in the form of
0:44:31 dark matter and energy. He says, perhaps evidence for the theory of everything lies hidden in
0:44:38 this invisible universe. So when he says, most of the universe is hidden from us. And to me,
0:44:46 that sounds like most of the universe is nothingness. And perhaps the solution to the theory of
0:44:55 everything lies in the nothingness in the invisible universe. And this reminds me of a quote that
0:45:02 that Alan Watts said we covered in the Alan Watts episode.
0:45:06 He said, the secret to the whole thing
0:45:08 is to be found in nothingness.
0:45:12 Yeah, that's right.
0:45:13 The secret to the whole thing, you know,
0:45:15 the thing that reconciles gravity and quantum mechanics.
0:45:21 Isn't that amazing?
0:45:25 He says, dark matter is invisible
0:45:27 yet it holds the Milky Way galaxy together.
0:45:30 It has weight and no charge.
0:45:32 So you have to understand that charge.
0:45:36 Charge is how things interact with each other.
0:45:38 Charge is how magnets interact with each other.
0:45:39 It's how electrons interact with each other.
0:45:41 So no charge means no interaction.
0:45:44 And something that doesn't interact with matter.
0:45:47 It basically, that basically means it doesn't exist, right?
0:45:53 Something that doesn't interact.
0:45:54 As far as you're concerned, doesn't exist.
0:45:58 And that's a way for us to think about nothing and realize that we're immediately wrong
0:46:03 about that. The fact that it doesn't interact might mean that it doesn't have any causal
0:46:08 power. It doesn't mean that it isn't a thing that exists somehow. Call it nothing if you
0:46:14 want, but it's something. That brings me to my next section, which is called No Such
0:46:21 Thing is Nothing. All right. So cock who asks, where did everything come from? Why
0:46:31 is there something rather than nothing? Great questions. He says in the quantum theory,
0:46:39 There is no such thing as absolute nothing.
0:46:43 We have seen that absolute blackness does not exist.
0:46:47 Even black holes are really gray.
0:46:50 Similarly, when solving the quantum theory, we find the lowest energy is not zero.
0:46:57 For example, you cannot reach absolute zero, because atoms in their lowest quantum energy
0:47:02 state are still vibrating.
0:47:05 Similarly, you cannot reach a zero energy state quantum mechanically, because you still
0:47:11 have zero point energy.
0:47:13 That is the lowest quantum vibrations.
0:47:17 A state of zero vibration would violate the uncertainty principle, since zero energy is
0:47:22 a state of zero uncertainty, which is not allowed.
0:47:26 All right, so this idea of absolute zero, if you don't know, it's the coldest temperature
0:47:32 could possibly be. And the way that they define that is that heat is molecular motion. You
0:47:39 know that. You heat up your cup of water in the microwave. When you take it out, what's
0:47:43 changed? The molecule is moving around like crazy. You've added a bunch of energy to
0:47:46 that water, and we call that heat. So what happens if you quiet down all the quantum
0:47:52 vibrations? If you can get everything to just hold still for a goddamn second. If you could
0:47:57 To do that, we would be at absolute zero.
0:48:00 We'd have no molecular motion and no heat.
0:48:04 And what Kaku's telling us here is that state of absolute zero is not possible.
0:48:11 There's always fundamentally quantum vibrations.
0:48:15 You cannot get rid of that.
0:48:17 Even in a vacuum, there is no such thing as nothing.
0:48:23 There's no such thing as zero energy.
0:48:25 You're always going to have vacuum energy.
0:48:27 You're always going to have zero point energy.
0:48:29 You're always going to have something even when you think you've got nothing.
0:48:34 So the thing that you point to and say that is nothing, the vacuum, is not.
0:48:43 He says, so where did the big bang come from?
0:48:48 Most likely it was a quantum fluctuation in nothing.
0:48:53 I mean, what?
0:48:55 Where did the big bang come from?
0:48:57 It's likely it was a quantum fluctuation in nothing clearly with that sentence.
0:49:06 We cannot deny that what physics means by nothing is not nothing.
0:49:13 It's potentiality.
0:49:15 It's whatever it is that allows for something to come from nothing.
0:49:20 It's whatever it is that allows for material reality to come into being, for matter and
0:49:25 energy to exist in a space-time continuum,
0:49:30 in something like what we're familiar with.
0:49:33 Something from nothing.
0:49:36 So nothing is a thing that electron and anti-electron
0:49:40 pairs can pop out of.
0:49:42 Nothing is a thing that's frothing with quantum activity.
0:49:46 And also, nothing is a thing that's
0:49:48 capable of fluctuating such that it will create the cosmos,
0:49:53 that it will create the big bang.
0:49:56 So whatever nothing is, it has all of those properties.
0:50:00 Does it sound like nothing to you?
0:50:02 It sounds a little bit more like God to me.
0:50:09 I think that's very interesting.
0:50:11 Nothing this is a thing subject to quantum fluctuations and a thing containing the potential
0:50:16 for material reality.
0:50:18 Unbelievable.
0:50:19 That is not nothing.
0:50:20 All right.
0:50:24 So Kaku goes on.
0:50:25 He says, even nothing or a pure vacuum is frothing with matter and antimatter particles
0:50:30 continually jumping out of the vacuum and then collapsing back into the
0:50:34 vacuum. This is how something came from nothing. Man, this is how something came
0:50:40 from nothing. Kaku is overturning, you know, generations of Aristotelian
0:50:47 empirical science in philosophy by saying this is how something came from
0:50:54 nothing. Then he says Hawking called this the space-time foam. That is a foam of
0:51:02 tiny bubble universes, continually bubbling up and disappearing again back into the vacuum.
0:51:09 But once in a while, one of these bubbles does not disappear back into the vacuum,
0:51:13 but continues to expand until it inflates and creates an entire universe.
0:51:19 So why is there something rather than nothing? Because our universe originally came from quantum
0:51:25 fluctuations in nothing. That's something. That is something. What a statement. I mean,
0:51:34 the hair stands up on my arms. So just like the electron and anti-electron pairs can jump
0:51:43 out of the, out of the nothing, Hawking says entire universes can jump out of the nothing.
0:51:49 Most of the time, most of the time, they just joined together and disappear again. But every
0:51:53 And now then, a bubble floats away and becomes a self-standing universe that came from the
0:52:02 nothing.
0:52:05 And in the last bit in this category he says, the universe itself will eventually die.
0:52:12 According to the second law of thermodynamics, everything in a closed system must eventually
0:52:16 decay, rot, rust, or fall apart.
0:52:21 The natural order of things is to decline and eventually cease to exist.
0:52:27 Okay.
0:52:27 So it's a little bit, a little bit of a depressing thought, but, um,
0:52:34 it's talking about entropy.
0:52:35 I mean, I just took a sip of coffee.
0:52:37 I can tell you it's not as hot as it was when I first, when I first brought it back
0:52:40 down here.
0:52:41 The reason is that energy is constantly of, you know, uh, spreading out.
0:52:44 And the same thing happens with, um, you know, with heat and energy.
0:52:48 And so eventually all of the heat and energy is going to run out.
0:52:52 everything will die and fall apart, and where I want to grab a hold of this is where he says,
0:52:58 the natural order of things is to decline and eventually cease to exist.
0:53:03 So what I want to ask you is, what does that mean? What does cease to exist mean
0:53:12 given all of this conversation we're having about nothing and something?
0:53:17 Sees to exist seems to be ceasing to be something.
0:53:21 So, we might have said before we started this conversation that cease to exist means that
0:53:28 it's nothing.
0:53:29 Turned into nothing and it's inconsequential and it doesn't matter, it has no properties,
0:53:33 it has no existence, it's nothing.
0:53:37 But is it?
0:53:38 What does cease to exist mean if nothing is something?
0:53:45 It seems to me that to cease to exist means to revert back to the potentiality where you
0:53:51 came from.
0:53:52 ideal, a bit like reincarnation. The Hindus would say your atman returns to Brahman.
0:53:59 Something like that. Seast to exist means to revert back to what you were before you were born.
0:54:07 To revert back to the potentiality from what you came.
0:54:13 That doesn't seem like nothing. To cease to exist is not the same thing as nothingness.
0:54:19 And that brings me to the next section which we're going to call God and physics.
0:54:29 So Kaku says scientists are often reluctant to admit that there are some things outside
0:54:35 of the realm of science.
0:54:37 For example, it is impossible to disprove a negative.
0:54:42 These concepts are not testable and hence not decidable.
0:54:45 They're outside of the province of science.
0:54:47 Okay, so disprove a negative.
0:54:51 So you might have somebody who says, prove to me that God exists.
0:54:57 And then that person might say, prove to me He doesn't.
0:55:00 So prove to me He doesn't exist.
0:55:02 See, that's disproving a negative and it's impossible.
0:55:05 You can't do it.
0:55:07 You simply can't do it.
0:55:08 And so all Kaku's saying here is that there are certain questions that are beyond the
0:55:14 reach of science and that most scientists are uncomfortable with that.
0:55:18 They think that the answers will come with improvements in knowledge and improvements
0:55:25 in technology and all that sort of stuff, eventually we'll have all of the answers.
0:55:30 But you can't disprove a negative.
0:55:32 I think where that plays into this conversation here is that when we're saying that nothing
0:55:38 is something, that's not something that you can disprove either.
0:55:44 can't disprove that nothingness doesn't have some form of existence. And that's what I want to get
0:55:51 to. That's what I'm trying to get. It's what I'm aiming at. Nothingness seems to have some form
0:55:56 of existence because it's according to physics. It's that from which something can come, right?
0:56:04 Something comes from nothing. It's responsible for the Big Bang. It's responsible for holding the
0:56:09 cosmos together in a stasis that allows us our moment, our moment in the sun, nothing
0:56:14 this is hugely, hugely significant. It does seem to have a form of existence, but it's
0:56:20 not clear how. It's not clear that it's a physical, that it's governed by space and
0:56:25 time, that's a physical existence. So what does that mean? It seems to mean that there
0:56:31 is more to existence than what we can measure and model with physics and mathematics. There's
0:56:41 something more to existence than what's manifest materially and energetically. We can call
0:56:48 that nothing. We can call that God. You can call that whatever you want. That doesn't
0:56:53 take away its existence. It doesn't disprove that it has some form of existence.
0:57:04 So now Kaku is going to start changing, there's just kind of an interesting bit here where
0:57:09 he starts talking more about God in ways I didn't expect.
0:57:12 But he does say this, and I want to hone in on it, he's talking about the traditional
0:57:17 philosophical proofs of the existence of God.
0:57:20 And so many philosophers have talked about it, like here's different reasons why you
0:57:23 shouldn't believe that God exists.
0:57:26 And Thomas Aquinas is most famously put them together, and so there's a list of these proofs
0:57:31 of God.
0:57:32 One of them is called the ontological proof, and it was one that philosophers had a difficult
0:57:38 time picking holes in.
0:57:40 So let me just describe to you what this is, and I'll use cockoo's own words.
0:57:44 He says, God, by definition, is the most perfect being imaginable.
0:57:52 But one can imagine a God that does not exist.
0:57:56 But if God didn't exist, he would not be perfect, therefore he must exist.
0:58:02 So this is the ontological argument for the existence of God.
0:58:07 So God is the most perfect being imaginable.
0:58:11 So if God doesn't exist, he wouldn't be perfect.
0:58:15 So he has to exist.
0:58:17 That may not hold as much weight today as it did for most of human history, but it was
0:58:24 a really difficult argument to get around.
0:58:27 Now, I have my own problems with this, but I want to finish Kaku's thought.
0:58:31 says, it wasn't until the 19th century that Emmanuel Kant found a flaw in the ontological
0:58:37 proof. To be perfect does not necessarily imply that something must exist. All right,
0:58:46 so we'll get into this here. So something that doesn't necessarily exist, but it's perfect.
0:58:55 I mean, I can think of things like platonic forms, you know, so Plato will talk about
0:58:59 that, you know, even, even geometrical shapes as an example, platonic solids. So Plato would
0:59:06 talk about what shapes are possible and you know, he'll give you a certain, certain limited
0:59:10 number of three dimensional shapes that are, that are possible and perfect. And those things
0:59:16 don't exist anywhere in the world. That's why they're forms. Like there's, there's no
0:59:20 such thing in nature as a perfect, you know, three dimensional, whatever, polygon or whatever
0:59:25 that matches one of these forms. Everything in the real world is some imperfect version
0:59:31 of that. It goes right into the theory of essences that Plato talks about. It's like
0:59:38 the essence of a dog or the essence of a table or something is that which all dogs and tables
0:59:44 have in common. It's like this perfect idea of a dog or perfect idea of a table. You can
0:59:50 see in reality all different forms of dogs and tables, but what you don't see in reality
0:59:55 is the perfect form that you're comparing this to to say,
0:59:59 yeah, that's a dog.
1:00:00 Yeah, that's a table.
1:00:01 So these are perfect things.
1:00:05 They exist in a way.
1:00:06 They exist in Plato called what he calls
1:00:09 the world of forms, noose.
1:00:11 So they exist in a way.
1:00:13 So to be perfect doesn't necessarily mean
1:00:16 something exists physically in the here and now.
1:00:19 Mathematics is another example of this.
1:00:21 We can see, we can apply math.
1:00:24 and we can interpret math all around us all the time,
1:00:26 but math is this perfect thing that exists
1:00:28 in this ethereal place, this realm of our minds.
1:00:31 It doesn't exist in the real world.
1:00:35 But here's where I want to push back
1:00:36 on this flaw in the ontological proof.
1:00:41 I think it's probably true that to be perfect
1:00:43 doesn't necessarily imply that something exists.
1:00:47 But if God is supposed to be the most perfect being,
1:00:51 wouldn't the most perfect idea of God,
1:00:55 The most complete, be something that has existence and non-existence, but if God exists, or if
1:01:04 God doesn't exist, those things seem to be very different than saying God might exist
1:01:12 and not exist.
1:01:13 I know that sounds strange, but if God includes both existence and non-existence, don't you
1:01:20 think that's more complete than one or the other?
1:01:24 I think it is. I have, I have no doubt in my mind. It's more complete and so more perfect
1:01:31 by encompassing both it's more perfect. So what does it mean that God both exists and doesn't exist?
1:01:39 This idea of not existing is the idea of nothingness. God exists and doesn't exist.
1:01:49 And you might think that means that God is real and not real, but that's not what I'm saying.
1:01:54 I'm saying, God exists.
1:01:56 And whatever it is that nothingness is,
1:01:58 whatever it is that we're talking about,
1:01:59 hear when we're talking about nothingness,
1:02:01 God exists that way too.
1:02:05 It exists, it's something, and it's nothing.
1:02:11 And by nothing I don't mean
1:02:13 what we normally intuit nothing to mean.
1:02:15 I mean what physics is saying, it means.
1:02:17 What Kaku and Watts are saying, it means.
1:02:19 God is something and nothing.
1:02:21 Both. He exists and doesn't exist.
1:02:24 Both.
1:02:25 God's existence is in both realms.
1:02:28 I think Kaku says, as a child I was raised as a Presbyterian, but my parents were Buddhists.
1:02:38 These two great religions have in turn two diametrically opposed points of view concerning
1:02:43 the Creator.
1:02:44 In the Christian church, there was an instant of time when God created the world.
1:02:50 However, in Buddhism, there is no God.
1:02:54 The universe had no beginning or end.
1:02:56 There is only timeless nirvana.
1:03:00 So how can we reconcile these points of view?
1:03:03 The universe either had a beginning or didn't.
1:03:06 There is no middle ground.
1:03:09 But actually the multiverse theory gives a radical new way of viewing this contradiction.
1:03:15 Perhaps our universe did have a beginning, as mentioned in the Bible.
1:03:20 But perhaps big bangs are happening all the time.
1:03:24 these universes are expanding in a nirvana of hyperspace.
1:03:30 So our universe is a three-dimensional bubble, floating in a much larger space of eleven-dimensional
1:03:36 nirvana, out of which other universes continually arise.
1:03:42 Thus the multiverse idea allows one to combine the Christian mythology with the nirvana
1:03:49 of Buddhism in a single theory that is compatible with known physical laws.
1:03:58 So I think that's an interesting idea for him to tackle, an interesting thing even to
1:04:04 include in the book if I'm being frank.
1:04:06 But I think it's interesting.
1:04:08 Now, he does say that there is no God in Buddhism, which is something that I don't agree with.
1:04:12 His parents were Buddhist, mine were not.
1:04:14 So maybe we should defer to Kaku on this, but I disagree that there's no God in Buddhism.
1:04:19 In fact, when he says the universe had no beginning and no end, that there's only timeless
1:04:24 nirvana, then I would suggest that the timeless reality that you're describing, that it wasn't
1:04:31 born and doesn't die, that thing that you're calling nirvana, that's God.
1:04:36 There's just no two ways about it to me.
1:04:40 But I want to focus on something else.
1:04:42 I want to focus on this idea of nothingness and this idea of how nothingness has a form
1:04:48 of existence or a means of existence that's not like the material world. We call it nothing,
1:04:54 not because it doesn't exist, but because it doesn't exist like everything else. And
1:04:59 I think this little description gives us a way of maybe thinking about that. So the
1:05:06 eleven-dimensional Nirvana here, the reason it's eleven-dimensional by the way is because
1:05:10 string theory says that the math behind string theory says that reality is either ten or
1:05:17 11 dimensional. Now, we're, of course, we're familiar with four of those dimensions, the
1:05:22 three dimensions that we exist in and the fourth dimension is time. So we kind of understand
1:05:26 four of them. But according to string theory, there's 10 or 11. So Kaku says, so the 11 11
1:05:32 dimensional Nirvana here becomes the inaccessible unknowable ground of being. That's the way
1:05:37 it looks to me. The nothingness, the non being from which all things can arise. This is this
1:05:43 11-dimensional reality. Nothingness implies higher dimensionality. Maybe that's what
1:05:50 we're dealing with. Nothingness implies higher dimensionality, a source surrounding and containing
1:05:59 all of being. It is nothing only in the sense of being unexperienceable or inaccessible.
1:06:08 And a good way of understanding that is, imagine you drew a two-dimensional stick figure on a piece
1:06:13 a paper with a two-dimensional box that it lives in, imagine that that two-dimensional
1:06:17 creature comes alive and it can only move right and left up and down in your little
1:06:22 two-dimensional reality. It would have no way of experiencing you, the being standing
1:06:28 outside of it in the third and fourth dimensions. You would be inaccessible. You would be unexperience
1:06:34 bowl. You would be nothing. It doesn't mean that you're nothing, though, does it? So perhaps
1:06:42 we are this four-dimensional creature existing in this 11-dimensional reality,
1:06:47 and all of the things that we call potentiality, and God, and dark energy, and dark matter,
1:06:52 and everything that's unknowable, and all the mysteries, maybe those things exist, detached from
1:06:58 us in this way, and yet we're nested in it. We are one with this 11-dimensional reality,
1:07:05 and only believe ourselves to be separate from it. So at the same time, this 11-dimensional reality
1:07:14 is the full structure of which our 4D reality is merely one limited perspective.
1:07:22 And maybe that is what nothing is, and that brings me to my conclusion.
1:07:29 So Kaku is told us some pretty amazing things. He points out that spacetime is frothing with
1:07:35 quantum activity, always. Even when it's perfectly empty of matter, of gravity, of action or interaction,
1:07:42 He tells us that even with no energy to excite them, quantum waves always maintain a minimum
1:07:50 level of vibration, zero-point energy.
1:07:55 It is as though nature fights against nothingness, in nature of horrors of vacuum, as they say,
1:08:02 as though nothingness is simply not permitted by physics.
1:08:06 This is, of course, one way of looking at it.
1:08:10 might be that what we call nothing is simply not nothing after all. It's not that nothingness is
1:08:18 impossible. It's that nothingness is something. But what? Kaku gives us some hints at this. He
1:08:29 tells us that nothingness maintains the stasis of the universe, right? We have these invisible,
1:08:36 non-reactive forces called dark matter and energy. We do not know how they exist or why.
1:08:44 We have no concrete knowledge of them, and yet they push and pull the cosmos into the state we
1:08:49 find it. He also tells us that nothingness gives rise to pairs of particles directly from the vacuum.
1:08:58 So nothingness does something here, even if proof of its existence remains elusive.
1:09:04 But this isn't all nothingness does.
1:09:09 Kaku tells us that fluctuations in nothingness were the cause of the Big Bang.
1:09:14 What does this mean?
1:09:16 It means that nothingness, whatever it is, can fluctuate.
1:09:21 It's capable of dynamism.
1:09:24 It vibrates with a continual force of energy that cannot be destroyed.
1:09:29 And it holds the order of being together in a cosmic game of tug-of-war between dark energy and dark matter.
1:09:36 It bends gravity to its will in the form of black holes, and it creates something from
1:09:43 nothing.
1:09:45 From nothingness arises pairs of quantum particles, from the void, and from nothingness
1:09:50 arises an infinite stream of the universes.
1:09:55 All this to say that nothing is not nothing.
1:10:00 It is more true to say that nothing is everything.
1:10:03 It is the potential from which existence springs.
1:10:07 It is a very real something.
1:10:10 It is the counter pole to the material cosmos, its opposite, from which both somethingness
1:10:18 and nothingness derive their existence.
1:10:22 They are one thing after all.
1:10:24 And as with all opposites, we cannot have one without the other.
1:10:29 The positive and the negative have equal existence.
1:10:32 There can be no something, without nothing.
1:10:40 Well, there you have it.
1:10:43 That's one avenue to explore, but infinitely more still to go.
1:10:47 I hope you enjoyed thinking along with us.
1:10:50 I know I know, it's not easy work.
1:10:53 Thinking.
1:10:54 It's hard and full of uncertainties, but I'm grateful for the company as we trek through
1:11:00 this together.
1:11:01 Here's to hoping that the juice is worth the squeeze.
1:11:04 see what I did there. Let's find out together in the next episode.